The theatricality of ancient Greece and Rome have long been hot topics of investigation for classicists and theatre history scholars alike; even as their work has ranged widely across the stagings, dramatic techniques, festival contexts, and writers of the ancient world, however, there remain small but charged gaps in the research. One of these gaps has been costume, until now; enter Rosie Wyles's Costume in Greek Tragedy. Although Wyles's title suggests her volume solely concentrates on Greek tragedy, she dips occasionally into Greek comedy and Roman adaptations of Greek plays as well, presenting a more fluid discussion of ancient costuming than her title initially signals.
Wyles's work is the first comprehensive survey of the employment of costume in Ancient Greek tragedy in almost fifty years; it evaluates the usage, context, and meaning of theatrical costuming primarily in fifth-century Athens and does so from a perspective blending semiotics and metatheatricality with careful close readings, as well as with plenty of historical evidence culled from the plastic arts. Her book is divided into six digestible chapters, and Wyles guides her reader effortlessly—yet in a knowledgeable and sophisticated manner—through a wide-ranging discussion of ancient dramatic costume, in which, importantly, “costume is thought about in both material and symbolic terms” (3).
She opens the book with numerous images illustrating costumes in ancient Greece, via which she dispels the commonsense notion that ancient actors wore the equivalent of modern white bedsheets (5). Wyles's evidence stems primarily from pottery artifacts, including such works as the Choregoi and Pronomos vases, and she clearly analyzes the visual aspect of what classicists believe to be a contemporaneous artistic interpretation of ancient theatrical costume. This interpretation, or “melting” (8), is particularly significant and is theorized throughout the book. Melting describes the process of the classical sculptor or painter: after watching a performance, the artist would recreate a theatrical scene on a vase. However, the scene would include interpretations of two realities: the reality of the play (the “playworld” [8]) and the reality of the conditions of its performance. Therefore, the paintings that inform scholars about ancient production should be viewed through a dual lens, since they not only include elements that were most likely used in performance, but also elements of the real world beyond the performance that could have been implied in the playworld through the onstage use of a prop or symbol (8). Wyles's exploration of the theory of melting thus allows her discussion of costume directly to engage the role of metatheatre in ancient dramatic performances.
The examination of metatheatrical conventions in ancient Greek theatre is gaining traction in both performance studies and classical studies, and Wyles taps into this trend. Her intermittent discussion of metatheatricality culminates in a more sustained analysis in her penultimate (fifth) chapter, “Costume and Theatrical Discourse”; however, I would have found it beneficial had Wyles's sustained discussion of metatheatre appeared earlier in the volume. Since Wyles alludes to metatheatre frequently, but avoids a direct discussion of the theory of metatheatre until quite late, readers may at times feel her work is disconnected from the larger field in which it situates itself. An earlier introduction to this material would have been beneficial especially for students, and would have provided the reader with more confidence in the author's engagement with current scholarship on metatheatrical topics.
Her sustained analysis of metatheatre and costume in ancient Greek performance in that fifth chapter, however, is excellent. Wyles argues for costume as the predominant semiotic factor in the Greek theatre, one that allowed artists a space for broad metatheatrical commentary on the practice of performance and on fellow performance makers. She also contends that costumes functioned this way in both tragedy and comedy: in fact, she suggests that costumes as a vehicle for metatheatrical commentary were “more direct and transparent” in comedy, whereas tragic costumes remained “indirect and opaque” (99). Wyles draws on Euripides' Bacchae as one example of the political role played by costume, citing the scene in which Pentheus dresses up in the costume of a maenad and thus alludes directly to Aristophanes' comedic in-law scene in his Women at the Thesmophoria (98–9). In this scene, Wyles argues that Euripides' incorporation of the costume was meant as a retaliation “against Aristophanes' strategy for making the costuming process, and the creation of theatre, into something humorous, by showing that in fact putting on costume could be deadly serious” (99–100). Wyles contends that the ancient Greek audience would have been aware that putting on the costume ultimately signaled Pentheus' death.
One of Wyles's most important contributions to the history of Greek theatre, and the history of costume, appears in “Costume in Action,” her book's fourth and longest chapter. Here she explores the six major aspects of the “language of costume: identity, determinism, emotional manipulation, ethnicity, the historical dimension, and fabrication” (61), and thinks carefully about the semiotics of costume on ancient Greek stages. In each section of this chapter, Wyles musters plenty of evidence from the plays themselves, and highlights ways in which costume is incorporated into characters' actions to generate meaning for both actors and audiences in performance. Once again, however, I wondered about chapter placement: given the significance of the material here, which functions as a kind of climax, I wondered if this chapter ought not to have appeared later in the book, rather than closer to the middle.
Wyles's Costume in Greek Tragedy provides a comprehensive study of ancient costume for theatre historians, classicists, and modern theatre practitioners alike. Her writing style and tone suggest her intimate relationship with ancient drama, yet her glossary allows those not as familiar with Greek theatrical tradition to follow along easily, making Costume in Greek Tragedy a particularly valuable text for an introductory course on ancient drama.
