The Anthropocene has become a familiar concept in recent years and has been eagerly adopted across the academic disciplines and by the media. But are all matters to do with the environment or sustainability now also about the Anthropocene? Even if they are, is the impact of this powerful concept being diminished by its ubiquity? These kinds of doubts haunt me whenever I find the word ‘Anthropocene’ in the title of a new publication, and Nicholas Kawa's new book Amazonia in the Anthropocene was no exception when I first came across it. Yet, as a specialist in the Amazon region, I was curious. At first sight it may not seem obvious that ethnography can contribute towards understanding the ecological importance of the Amazon region for the Earth system (maintaining hydrological cycles, carbon sequestration, etc.), but the book's title itself suggested a new and timely addition to the existing challenges to stereotypes of the region as a green hell or natural Eden – the kind of stereotypes to which the literature on the Anthropocene is not immune. The book turned out to answer my doubts above all by raising a further question: to what extent is mankind really at the centre of the Anthropocene? Kawa uses his ethnography to bring into focus the importance of post-humanist theoretical approaches to the Anthropocene while remaining deeply grounded in empirical data and in the materiality of the daily lives of real people in real places.
Kawa skilfully uses a personal ethnographic narrative to weave together different perspectives on human ecology. The book's subtitle, People, Soils, Plants, Forests, is true to its content and corresponds to the central chapter headings. It starts with an environmental history of rural Amazonians, including well-judged discussions of questions of identity (the nuanced meanings of the term ‘caboclo’) and the cultural legacy of the rubber boom, interspersed with rich descriptions of fishing techniques and encounters with the ‘barge economy’ of fluvial traders. The highly specific and localised descriptions are kept in the context of global economy and ecology: reflecting on the rubber boom, Kawa writes, ‘[i]f we accept modern industrial capitalism to be the engine of the Anthropocene, then we can affirm that contemporary Amazonia is populated by the descendants of people who were responsible for fueling that engine – or perhaps more accurately, supplying some of its most critical parts, including tires, machine belting, valves, and numerous other rubber components’ (p. 36). This may sound like a tenuous argument for the global significance of these descendants of rubber tappers, but that is not the point; the book's strength lies in the connections it makes between different perspectives, and the concept of the Anthropocene unifies the narrative, providing a global counterpoint to local histories. Descriptions of Amazonian lives support an argument that could be made for countless other peoples around the world: ‘Rather than viewing humanity as the ruler of the earth or its future conqueror, rural Amazonians typically acknowledge the agency of a wide number [sic] of nonhuman others that challenge human intentions and desires’ (p. 48).
This sets the tone for the following chapter on soils, which in itself is a useful primer on the fascinating subject of anthropogenic dark earths. A well-balanced literature review provides context for Kawa's own soil research and his conversations with Amazonian small-scale farmers about their use of dark earths, the crops they grow in them, their use of fertilisers, etc., all of which helps constructively to problematise some of the excitement that has arisen over the potential for dark earths to offer technological solutions for agricultural intensification and carbon sequestration. In a typically lucid reflection Kawa writes ‘the case of terra preta should remind us that while humans either knowingly or unknowingly altered Amazonian soils in ways that enriched them … it would be wrong to assume that the environment simply opens itself up to facile human manipulation and control’ (p. 70).
The theme of intentionality comes further to the centre in the following chapter, on plants, and in passages that offer genuine contributions to the ethnographic record on witchcraft and magic Kawa uses several examples to discuss plant agency from the perspective of scientific botany as well as from those of folk understandings: ‘Some magic plants found in Amazonian home gardens are actively cultivated by people and directly depend upon humans for their continued propagation. Others, like pião roxo, are opportunists that take advantage of people's company but also thrive independently of human management’ (p. 91). This chapter's focus on magical plants leaves little room for others, such as food plants, but it does help to advance the book's overall argument.
The chapter on forests brings the considerations of intentionality to bear upon critiques of the nature–culture dichotomy. Kawa gives another succinct primer on the ways in which historical ecology has shown that the preservation, the texture and even to an extent the biodiversity of many forest landscapes are the result of human activity. But closer examination, and revisiting the question through ethnography, leads him to argue that many authors are engaged in a futile attempt to draw distinctions between ‘anthropogenic’ and ‘natural’ forests. This leads them to reproduce the problematic nature–culture dichotomy, redrawing the line between nature and culture in a different place (even if the Amazon forest is not all ‘natural’, at least parts of it are). Discussing the forest as he walks through it with an old man, Kawa reflects: ‘Looking at the trees before me and thinking about their origins, I began to reconsider what it meant for a forest to be deemed “anthropogenic”, as such a designation can create simplifications of intertwining and complex histories. Was Nilo's plot of land the result of human management from only the past one hundred or one thousand years? Could we (or should we?) distinguish clumps of bacaba palms that were the result of indigenous management or subsistence activities from those that had resulted from the work of other animals or beings?’ (p. 101).
Kawa's central argument is that the Anthropocene is not simply all about mankind. The concept, he argues, places too much emphasis on human agency and does not leave enough room for the complex entanglements that exist between humans and other living beings. He advocates accepting uncertainty and a less central agentive role for humanity, and in the closing pages he offers some final considerations on the global ‘crisis in ecological thinking’: scientific progress has led much of humanity to fall victim ‘to the illusion that we can exert ultimate control over our surroundings. Instead the Anthropocene should teach us that science and technology have increased only our potential to alter life on the planet, not necessarily our dominion over it’ (p. 131).
This is a fitting conclusion for a book of great value for all of us who are engaged in the kind of interdisciplinary thinking that the Anthropocene requires.
