This book truly answers to its title. On the one hand it draws the reader into the vivid world of lucha libre, the Mexican version of professional wrestling – its history, its rules, its performances and its performers. The reader is not only placed ringside but also taken into the arduous training processes and learns what it takes to become and remain a luchador or luchadora. On the other hand, lucha libre is analysed as a signifying practice and a social phenomenon, a ‘master symbol of urban Mexican cultural authenticity’ containing ‘elements that could be read as a parody of the postrevolutionary political system’ (p. 220). Through her multifaceted explorations of lucha libre Levi addresses central aspects of Mexican national (and gendered) identities and politics, thus revealing the world of which lucha libre is a part and to which it also meaningfully speaks. Levi provides a historical reconstruction of lucha libre in Mexico City, tying its specific development into significant events and processes, both locally and internationally. Her argument is that lucha libre ‘makes sense because it is a performance genre that draws on and reproduces a series of contradictions that are broadly intelligible in the context of the shared historical and cultural background of its Mexican fans’ (p. xiii). Thus she emphasises the particular Mexican nature of lucha libre.
The ethnography, based on 15 months of fieldwork, is rich. It is also multi-sited, ranging from wrestling events, interviews and classes in wrestling to systematic perusal of written documents and examination of mass media and avant garde artists' appropriation of lucha libre. Levi makes good use of local events (such as the unveiling of Superbarrio, by the Asamblea de Barrios, as a presidential candidate in 1987) in order to read across contexts, making unusual and interesting connections. The strength of this book lies in Levi's ability to integrate this diverse material empirically as well as theoretically. Lucha libre is examined on three levels – as a performance, as a subculture and as a symbol – through six chapters, each addressing a different aspect or dimension of the phenomenon, and each carefully contextualised in an ongoing dialogue with the relevant literature.
To the uninitiated, lucha libre is indeed intriguing. Levi characterises it as sport in the mode of melodrama. The wrestlers enter the ring as morally encoded characters, as rudos or técnicos, with a very specific role to play. This feature is underscored by the name they choose and the costume they wear. Some wrestlers make use of masks, deliberately concealing their true identities. Perhaps the most striking feature of lucha libre, however, is that the matches are fixed. This is a public secret of wrestling, which nevertheless is not necessarily known by all.
Levi's presentation of the moral world of lucha libre provides both details and reflections which underpin her interpretations and analysis. She demonstrates the relations that hold this world together as well as the values that it articulates. In that regard, her analysis of the role of the mask and its interrelated effects is especially engaging. She not only relates her discussion of the mask to the use of masks in indigenous rituals, thereby linking her arguments to the ongoing discussion of ‘lo mexicano’; she also combines her ethnographic insights with her knowledge of Mexico in general to show how the mask and the act of unmasking, both central to lucha libre, are also emblematic – and indeed parodic – of central aspects of Mexican political culture (such as corruption, deception and disclosure). The mask, together with the practice of fixing matches, comes to represent a critique of power as something that essentially is found behind the scenes; secrecy appears to be an intrinsic aspect to the operation of power.
Levi argues that lucha libre provides a privileged vantage point for re-examining dominant understandings of gender relations in Mexico. Asking whether lucha libre is ‘centrally about hegemonic constructions of masculinity in Mexico’ (p. 138), she answers that there are a number of counter-discourses that ‘struggle with machismo for dominance in the ring’ (p. 139). In her broad review of the literature on gender in Mexico and Latin America more generally (including an article I have written), Levi suggests that lucha libre ‘casts doubt on the adequacy of this account’, insisting that ‘the story lucha libre tells about gender is more contradictory than the story told by many analysts of the Mexican gender system’ (p. 151). There is no doubt that the performance of lucha libre is open to multiple readings, and the good thing about bringing new ethnography to the table is that it provides stuff for scholarly debates. Levi uses the character of the exótico (a male luchador who wrestles in drag) and the female wrestler to argue her points. It seems to me that this ethnography lends itself well to a perspective that examines cross-sex and same-sex relations simultaneously, revealing the complexity of gender configurations. Moreover, it is to my mind significant that the luchadoras (both técnicas and rudas) identify as dedicated mothers, and use motherhood as a moral claim (p. 169). The claim to motherhood is precisely a claim for respect both within and outside of the ring, and perhaps speaks differently in the two contexts, but does not necessarily undermine a more general distinction of decent and not decent women. A critical point for further exploration (more generally) is the relationship between signifying practices of performance genres such as lucha libre and the reproduction of social relations.
There are many different threads that bind this work together, but power, both in terms of actual shifting power relations (as in the case of the relationship between lucha libre and mass media) and in terms of the signifying power of this spectacular performance (for grassroots politicians, artists or anthropologists), is a constant, albeit at times underlying, focus. There is one question of power that remains unanswered (and is perhaps unanswerable?), however, and that is the power to decide who is to win the game. How are the matches fixed, and what does it mean to a wrestler if he (or she) is always on the losing team? And in this world of secrecy and deception, what meanings does the notion of confianza, such a significant aspect of social relations in Mexico, carry?
This book is not just for those who have an explicit passion for wrestling. Anyone who is interested in Mexico – or the way a sport-cum-ritual can serve as an anchoring point for a more embracing socio-cultural analysis – will find much food for thought. Accepting that lucha libre ‘is indeed a story that Mexicans tell themselves about themselves’ (p. 151), there is much to be learned from this narrative.
