The middle decades of the twentieth century left many Americans with the impression that the unelected Supreme Court exists to protect the rights of minorities, and with the belief that the Court has generally served this function. In the introduction to her ambitious book, Goldstein informs us that its goal is to interrogate this belief. In tackling this subject, Goldstein enters a crowded field. The political science literature on the Supreme Court and constitutional rights has long been occupied with the Supreme Court's relationship to minority groups in a system otherwise characterized by majoritarian politics. Much of this literature questions whether courts are likely to, or are even capable of, protecting vulnerable minorities. Scholars have expressed similar skepticism about whether constitutional rights themselves are workable as devices to promote equality and inclusion. Of course, this view also has many critics, whose scholarship highlights the important role that rights and courts have played in pushing the US government in the direction of racial justice.
Goldstein engages this debate through a compilation and examination of two centuries worth of Supreme Court rulings in cases about race. This is an encyclopedic work that moves well beyond a rehearsal of the standard canon, unearthing many obscure civil rights cases as important context for the famous ones. It is organized chronologically, with chapters devoted to the Marshall Court, Taney Court, the Civil War and Reconstruction, the period 1875–1910, the White Court, the Taft Court, a separate chapter on “Hispanic” rights, and a final chapter on 1930 through the late twentieth century. With the exception of its penultimate chapter, this work focuses on cases involving African Americans, Native Americans, and people of Asian descent. Each chapter compares the judicial doctrine it describes to the racial policies of the other two branches of the federal government.
The result resembles a cross between a casebook and a series of historical lectures. It offers short, frequently fascinating narratives about each period and each case within it, followed by an accounting of the general tendency of these rulings as compared with the policy commitments of the elected branches. This approach is a refreshing addition to a literature already crowded with grand theories. It avoids the temptation to generalize from a limited set of cases. Remaining firmly grounded in empirical data, it draws general conclusions about the Court's role only in the form of descriptions of its actual record.
So how does the Supreme Court fare when its civil rights record is compared against the other two branches of the federal government? Has it actually stood up for the rights of racial minorities when the elected branches attempted to trample them? Goldstein writes: “One can conclude that for most periods in the Court's first 200 years, the answer to my basic query, with important qualifications, is … ‘Yes’” (399). Despite this affirmative answer, the spirit of this work lies much more in the “important qualifications” mentioned in this sentence than in its “yes.” As Goldstein notes several pages earlier, the Court's stance “turns out to have varied according to historical period and particular personnel. And which minority would get judicial protection also varied across periods and across branches” (396). We learn, for instance, that the Marshall Court did less than Congress to check the practice of slavery, but more to recognize the rights of Native Americans. The post-Story Taney Court through the Fuller Court looked quite similar to the elected branches on questions of civil rights, but from 1930 to 1989, the Supreme Court seems to have been more egalitarian than either Congress or the executive. Even in describing these variations over time, Goldstein is quick to note cases that do not fit the general pattern.
The book's insistence on nuance is one of its great strengths. Another is Goldstein's decision to assess the Court's racial egalitarianism in comparison to the other branches of government. This framework mirrors the way the Court actually operates within America's constitutional system and allows us to identify rulings as relatively racially progressive, even in a system so deeply permeated by and committed to white supremacy. Another important insight that the book yields is its recognition that “minority rights” are not monolithic; even in the same period, doctrine has moved in different directions with respect to different groups. Some racial categories have received doctrinal protection at the same time that the Court denied it to others.
One feature of the book that is both a strength and a possible source of frustration is how little discussion of method it contains. On one hand, it renders the book highly readable and focused on substance. Yet readers may wonder about methodological questions like how these cases were selected, and relatedly, what kinds of cases were left out. In addition, some chapters talk a great deal about politics outside the Court, while others focus much more on the Court itself. Sometimes we get information about which justices were leading a particular charge, and in other places we do not. It is also not obvious (at least to this reader) why the discussion of “Hispanic” rights is contained in a separate chapter. Since it covers 1800–1992, it seems like this material could have been integrated into the chronology offered by the rest of the book. These may well all have been excellent authorial choices, but more information about how they were made might be welcome here.
The U.S. Supreme Court and Racial Minorities is a major scholarly enterprise. It offers an unusually comprehensive look at changes over time in the Supreme Court's understanding of civil rights and race. As a result, it can serve as a reference work, as an introduction to the long history of the Supreme Court's rulings on race, and as a valuable chronicle of law's political development.
