It remains to be seen if the study of Islam in South Asia is truly undergoing a ‘Shi‘a’ turn, but the contributions in the volume edited by Jones and Qasmi are welcome in a widening field of Shi‘a Studies in the region. This addresses the relative lack of scholarship on Shi‘ism outside Iraq, Iran and Lebanon, offering perspectives on a range of religious, political and social aspects of Shi‘ism in South Asia. This contribution challenges previous studies’ emphasis on viewing a Shi‘a historical legacy emerging from those regions rather than South Asia. The works outline historical dimensions of the formation of Shi‘i identities offering readers accounts of how religious convergences and divergences have shaped South Asian Shi‘i communities and their relationships in the wider Islamic world, while touching on themes of religious reform, revival, and development of Muslim publics.
Francis Robinson, in the volume's introduction, notes that scholarship on the Shi‘a in South Asia is lacking despite the community being a highly visible minority and having occupied an important place in South Asian history. Collectively, the works highlight ways that various Muslim groups – Sunni, Sufi, and distinct Shi‘i communities – British colonial power and nationalist mobilisations have contended with Shi‘i ideas, practice and political movements. The authors respond to two questions: how did various Shi‘i scholars and publics contend with Sunni and Sufi religious discourse in South Asia and what were the internal tensions that Shi‘i communities faced?
One thematic response to these questions highlights theological debates within the Shi‘i community and polemics between the Shi‘a and other Muslim groups. Three chapters are interested in prominent Shi‘i ulama and their roles advancing reform. A fourth, is interested in the nineteenth and twentieth century proliferation of sectarianism between Twelver Shi‘a and Chishtiya Sufi groups in Punjab. In Chapter One, Sajjad Rizvi highlights various aspects of Sayyid Dildar ‘Ali Nasirabadi's (1753-1820) theology and offers an intimate portrait of this leading figure of the khandan-i ijtihad. Rizvi details the development of usuli thought in South Asia through Nasirabadi's biography, highlighting his refutation of akhbariya, his theological attack on Sufis and his writings against contemporary anti-Shi‘a polemicists. In Chapter Four, Justin Jones focuses on Sayyid ‘Ali Naqi Naqvi's (1905-1988) mobilisation of the Karbala narrative and his oeuvre Shahid-i Insaniyat, as a “paradigm” for living. This is to demonstrate how biographies of Husain established popular conception of selfhood for Muslim publics. Jones also argues that the use of Urdu in an accessible language and print facilitated its resonance across Indian anti-colonial politics. Finally, Naqvi's position on the first three Caliphs is a robust non-polemic to bring Sunni and Shi‘i communities together. Simon Wolfgang Fuchs’ Chapter Eight takes interest in a contrasting mid-twentieth century figure, Sayyid ‘Arif Husain al-Husaini (1946-1988) and tracks the development of Shi‘a political engagements in Pakistan before 1979, through the Iranian revolution, and in the years of Shi‘a repression under the Islamisation policies of Zia ul-Haq. The chapter catalogues divisions between shaikhi scholars, the so-called Shi‘i Wahhabi, and al-Husaini's ‘third wave’ approach. In Chapter Seven, Tahir Kamran and Amir Khan Shahid trace Chishtiya Sufi relations with the Shi‘a, emphasizing modern developments of polemics between Neo-Sufism and Shi‘ism. The chapter offers a localised account of wider historical phenomena, tracing Shi‘a and Chishtiya revivalism to historicise discourses on wahdat al-wujud and the entrenchment of sectarian stances on shari‘a as a reliance on foundational texts and hadith grew.
Two chapters chart the theme of print culture and impacts of media on traditional networks and modes of authority. In chapter three, Muhammad Amir Ahmad Khan explores the Mahmudabad family and their contributions to religious and political discussions locally, nationally and transnationally. Khan highlights the absence of anti-Sunni polemics in the family's journals’ political and theological discussions. Khan argues that they made attempts to abrogate their minority status to engage the wider Muslim community in India and abroad more successfully. Shireen Mirza, in Chapter Six, examines how print and media cultures, are funded, produced and circulated locally and transnationally in two contemporary Twelver Shi‘a reformist groups in ways replicating traditional forms of knowledge production and dissemination to counter the commonly held idea that technology has primarily negatively effected traditional clerical authority.
Two chapters trace the theme of Shi‘a contentions with colonialism and decolonisation. In Chapter Two, Michel Boivin traces historical divisions in Isma‘ili and Twelver Khoja communities. Shifting colonial categorisation of the Khoja from caste to sect reshaped the Aga Khan's authority, communal theological debates and notions of self-identity. While community religious authority played a key role in emerging divisions, underlying caste forces and economic priorities incited new divisions. In Chapter Five, Soumen Mukherjee, explores the historical developments of universalising conceptions of service, identity formation and the replacement of religious ideals with “language of service” in the Isma‘ili community during decolonisation. The chapter is particularly interested in the creation of the Aga Khan Development Network and its role in promoting universalising ideals based in community service during the Imamates of Aga Khan III and IV.
This volume is a welcome addition alongside other recent contributions by Justin Jones in his book-length work and Andreas Rieck in The Shi‘a of Pakistan, offering historical and contemporary perspective on persistent debates in South Asia, Islamic and Shi‘a Studies. The work contributes to theorising the formation of religious publics, particularly ways that polemics shape publics. Further theoretical engagement would have been welcome to explore this link in the ways that scholarship has approached language and other religious movements’ relation to the development of publics in South Asia. The volume does succeed in highlighting a number of prominent religious figures, families, publications, movements and theological debates across the modern period. Themes link the chapters, yet the volume does not put forth cohesive arguments. The magnitude of the editors’ task in tackling such a major gap in scholarship reflects the lack of existing work on this subject, but also impeded uniting these chapters in their present scope. However, in attempting to redress this very paucity of sources, the volume adds several appealing and accessible readings to a growing field that will be useful for scholars and students alike.
