Published online by Cambridge University Press: 13 February 2006
Asian Americans are among the fastest-growing minority groups in theUnited States. In recent years, their impact on politics has beenthe focus of a growing number of scholars in the social sciences,which raises the definitional question: Who are Asian Americans? Theworking definition deployed here is that an Asian American is aperson who “resides in the United States on a permanent or long-termbasis, regardless of citizenship or other legal status” (Lien,Conway, and Wong 2004). However, the definition of who an Asian ishas undergone significant expansion over the last 150 years becauseof “shifts in the racial and ethnic makeup of the U.S. populationand changes in social attitudes and political concerns regardingracial and ethnic minorities” (Lien, Conway, and Wong 2004). Theseconcerns expressed themselves in various modes of politicalparticipation; referred to in the literature as the “Asian Americanmovement” (Wei 1993), these have ranged from litigation to theboycott activities of Asian Americans on a variety of issues.I would like to extend my gratitude toJane Junn of Rutgers University as well as to members of theAPSA Committee on the Status of Asian Pacific Americans in theProfession for encouragement and valuable feedback on thisarticle.
Asian Americans are among the fastest-growing minority groups in the United States. In recent years, their impact on politics has been the focus of a growing number of scholars in the social sciences, which raises the definitional question: Who are Asian Americans? The working definition deployed here is that an Asian American is a person who “resides in the United States on a permanent or long-term basis, regardless of citizenship or other legal status” (Lien, Conway, and Wong 2004). However, the definition of who an Asian is has undergone significant expansion over the last 150 years because of “shifts in the racial and ethnic makeup of the U.S. population and changes in social attitudes and political concerns regarding racial and ethnic minorities” (Lien, Conway, and Wong 2004). These concerns expressed themselves in various modes of political participation; referred to in the literature as the “Asian American movement” (Wei 1993), these have ranged from litigation to the boycott activities of Asian Americans on a variety of issues.
But if the accumulation of insights ought to characterize progress in social inquiry, we do need to pose the following questions. What generalizable propositions and mechanisms are true of Asian Americans as they seek to engage the U.S. political system? In what ways are Asian Americans distinct in their political preferences and their behavioral predilections? How do class and socio-economic status mediate politics in this community? Do these categories interact? Can their sub-component groups be disaggregated in terms of political preferences and if so, how? And if not, why not? While rich in empirical findings, there is a paucity of systematic, theoretically-informed, structured enquiry in the literature. I contend here that by deploying a variety of research methods the discipline can get traction on causal mechanisms to explain political participation at varied levels of analysis to enrich our understanding of Asian American politics.
Wendy K Tam Cho (1999) suggests that socio-economic theories, long a mainstay in studies of American politics, must be taken seriously, but with several caveats. One such caveat, according to Cho is that ethnic clustering impacts informational1
The informational cascade aspect of social networks has been modeled game-theoretically in a more international context by James Fearon and David Laitin (1996).
Yet if self-definition is a product not only of “primordial ties but also of social and political construction of concepts of race and ethnicity” (Lien, Conway, and Wong 2004), then pan-ethnic identity may also be seen as a strategic response to what Lien et al. call the “racially coercive forces imposed by governmental and social institutions.” But what exactly do studies of pan-ethnic identity seek to uncover?
Specifying the circumstances and the extent to which groups of diverse national originals come together as a new, enlarged pan-ethnic group is one such puzzle (Espiritu 1992). Espiritu draws upon but rejects the findings from the primordialist and instrumentalist literatures on ethnic boundaries. While the former views communities of culture as possessing cohesion, binding beliefs, worldviews and practices, economic and political inequalities are seen as “epiphenomenal”; for the latter branch of scholarship, ethnicity is treated as a strategic tool and populations remain ethnic when their ethnicity yields “greater returns than other statuses available to them.”
Espiritu's position is integrationist, yet it leans toward an instrumentalist explanation: pan-ethnicity is both an artifact of research, a “product of categorization,” but also as much a tool for insiders and a political resource inasmuch as it remains an imposed identity. Possibly unintentionally, her argument folds into a structuralist mode through her suggesting that in an institutionalized political system oriented toward numbers, political strength is thereby
derived from a united front rather than from the separate efforts of individual sub-groups. Thus pan-ethnicity is not only imposed from above but also constructed from below as a means of claiming resources inside and outside the community. (Espiritu 1992).
But if that is the theoretically plausible premise, the evidence unearthed by other scholars may well belie this neat story. As several other studies have indicated (Cain and Cho 2001; Kim and Lee 2001; Lien 1994; Lien 2003a; Lien et al. 2001; Lott 1998; Sanjeev Khagram 2001; Tam 1995; Tuan 1998), the diverse national origins of Asian Americans tend to be a significant barrier in generating a sense of pan-ethnic unity, even for political purposes. This is least palpable amongst Asian Americans from South Asia but is most salient amongst those of Korean and Japanese origin, which may be due to their longer presence in the United States (Lien, Conway, and Wong 2004). This is substantiated to some extent by Lien in her study of the micro-level processes of political adaptation of immigrants from different Asian backgrounds (Lien 2003a). Her survey analysis of the extent and level of political participation of Filipinos, Vietnamese, and Korean Asian Americans, shows that socio-economic variables worked most heavily against the Vietnamese in their levels of political participation (with 24% of the variance in this subgroup explained by socioeconomic factors) while the Koreans were least politically adapted. Filipinos were the most politically and socio-economically adapted and active in working within the U.S. political system. Regardless of national origin, though, such studies uncover the consistent finding that greater U.S. political participation is positively correlated with greater time spent in the country, gender, higher levels of socioeconomic status, greater acculturation, and higher social-structural integration.2
Lien (2003a) measures this in terms of the number of non-ethnic group friendships by survey respondents.
“The dilemma is how to maintain a kind of group political organization that accurately represents the actual communities and allows for protection of civil rights, on the one hand, while allowing individuals to create their own independent identities and avoid racial cycles that perpetuate imposed racial categories” (Youngberg and Lim 2001).
What are the contours of Asian-American participation in U.S. politics? Considering the strong role that socio-economic status plays in generating political participation, it is perhaps surprising that the voter registration levels of Asian Americans have been as low as 28% when compared to that of non-Hispanic Whites (67%) and African Americans (64%) (Lien 2001). Obstacles such as language, the lack of familiarity with the U.S. political system, ignorance, and concerns with mother-country policy issues are key factors that are linked to low registration levels and, in turn, low turnout.
Further, outside of Hawaii, Asian Americans do not vote en bloc (Espiritu 1992), being aligned neither with the Democrats nor the Republicans, although on the whole, their proclivity is toward the Democrats (Kitano and Daniels 2001) even though they are conservative on several issue-positions. Considering that Asian Americans are the second-most generous political donors after Jewish Americans, this low electoral participation rate is puzzling to scholars considering the close association between high group-level attainments in education and electoral participation.
Lien superbly disentangles this issue, suggesting that greater educational achievement in and of itself is associated with a lower likelihood of identification as Asian American. However, being connected to a social network through employment is associated with a “greater likelihood of identification with two of the American modes”4
It is not entirely clear what Lien means when she refers to “American mode,” but it probably refers to the probability of identifying oneself as an “American” and “Asian American” or “ethnic American” (Lien, Conway, and Wong 2004).
Nevertheless, Asian Americans continue to be predominant in exercising political power in Hawaii, especially through the Democratic Party. U.S. Senators Hiram L. Fong, Daniel K. Inouye, and Spark Matsunaga were active in representing the community's interests at the highest levels of power. Only in Hawaii do Asian Americans dominate; on the mainland their impact on national level politics has been rather limited (Kitano and Daniels 2001).
Lien also found that the sense of Asian-American identity is captured well by the concept of “linked fate” used for studying African-American identity.5
“Whatever happened to the Asian American community at large would somehow affect one's own life, but the percentage of those who believed that it should matter a great deal varied widely across groups” (Lien, Collet, Wong, and Ramakrishnan 2001).
“For example, citizens of Chinese ancestry are still estimated to register at lower rates and Korean Americans [are] less likely to turnout than other comparable Asians” (Lien, Collet, Wong, and Ramakrishnan 2001).
Buttressing this, Aoki and Nakanishi (2001) suggest in their study of Asian Pacific Americans (APAs), that such groups emphasize their ethnic (“Korean” or “Vietnamese”) rather than their pan-ethnic (“Asian”) identities. Both suggest that “there continue to be factors promoting a pan-APA identity.” Such assertions would require, however, additional empirical grounding in studies of a wider range of groups across time and space. More systematic, nation-wide studies are needed.
Aside from conceptual and theoretical work, the level of analysis needs to be more international instead of orientated exclusively toward American politics. International factors need to be incorporated systematically and it is in this vein that Watanabe (2001) highlights the role which “non-domestic” factors play in getting APAs politically engaged. His treatment is largely historical, recounting the involvement of APAs from the late 1800s in their efforts to influence U.S. foreign policy. These were resisted by the U.S. elites, consistent with the assertion that American elites view the involvement of ethnic groups in matters of external policy with “concern and suspicion.” But others temper this assessment. Chan (1991) suggests that taking the long view is germane since longitudinal analysis is necessary because the history of Asians in America can be fully understood “only if we regard them as both immigrants and members of nonwhite minority groups.”
In this vein, consider the notion of a “median” position in American society occupied by Asian Americans, referred to by Kim and Lee (2001) and Kim (1999), which serves to sustain the negative functions of the myth of the “model minority” vis-à-vis the African-American community and the dominant Whites in a model of racial triangulation (Kim 1999). This role of a “middleman minority” functions as a political buffer between the dominant and subordinate groups (Lien, Conway, and Wong 2004). But in a substantive sense, Asian Americans may well be the “typical” median voter. In studying the extent to which the structure of the Asian-American vote was based on perceptions of immigration, party identification, and ideologies, Cain and Cho (2001) found that Asian Americans' attitudes were located nearly “squarely between” that of Whites and other ethnic groups. Lacking a strong sense of party identification, Asian Americans came across as an unpredictable swing group. It is in this vein that the position of Asian Americans is characterized as “simultaneously superachievers, underachievers and strange outsiders” (Lien 2001).
Using data from the Pilot National Asian American Political Survey (PNAAPS), Pei-te Lien's (Lien, Conway, and Wong 2004) largely empirical analysis supports contentions by scholars cited above who allude to structural factors beyond the control of minorities—such as redistricting, the complexities of meeting eligibility requirements, and linguistic issues—as impacting potential political participation negatively. International factors do need to be considered in this context, too (Lien, Conway, and Wong 2004). This is rather reminiscent of the claims and hypotheses tested by Leighley in a more minority-group politics context (Leighley 2001).
This is corroborated by Lien, Collet, Wong, and Ramakrishnan (2001), who suggest that the act of voting is influenced more by contextual than individual factors. At the level of major metropolitan cities, they highlight Wong's (2000) study of the incorporation of Chinese-American immigrant political incorporation in New York and Los Angeles, which highlights the effects of a variety of organizations in integrating immigrant political participation.
But at the state level, APAs have been successful in campaigning and electing their own candidates despite the lack of a single Asian majority congressional district (Lai et al. 2001). The strategy, according to Lai et al., has been to galvanize voting by running as mainstream, crossover candidates. The assumption is that Asian Americans have in fact engaged in politics by other means but there is no systematic effort to study the link in relationships between “politically organized Asian Americans and external strategic political elites.” Lai et al. are silent on how such a study should be done, but ideational models of how elites change their beliefs and how these beliefs percolate through a political system in other subfields of political science7
Precisely how this operates has been explicated in recent works on the belief changes of Soviet elites and how that played a role in the collapse of the Soviet Union. A good example of this is Robert English's (2000) elite-identity framework.
But this is not necessarily to suggest a “linguistic turn” in the analysis of how Asian-American political elites do in fact think. Discursive analysis may potentially highlight how the ideational or cognitive maps of Asian-American elites in the U.S. do or do not shift. It may safely be asserted that the Asian community still does follow cues from its representative leaders. The methodological implication of this observation would be to engage in a textual analysis of communications at various fora to track changes in the belief systems of these elites. This may highlight the linkages between what elites think, how belief changes are absorbed or rejected, and how that, in turn, impacts the collective behavior of Asian Americans. But without multiple methodologies at multiple levels of analysis, it simply would not be possible to generate hypotheses, let alone test and verify or reject findings. Surveys are a superb baseline to build upon, but other methods of data gathering are imperative to get traction on micro-foundational as well as cultural and collective action outcomes.
Making progress in understanding Asian-American political participation requires wider theoretical grounding. The segregation of domestic from non-domestic factors is a less helpful distinction because it obscures the direct and feedback effects of variables influencing Asian-American political activity. Given the interplay of domestic and non-domestic factors, scholars working on transnationalism may pave a methodological way forward. Levitt (2003) disaggregates the “black box” of citizenship by making the case for dual loyalties as a factor to be taken both instrumentally and expressively.8
Levitt (2003) argues that attaining U.S. citizenship does not automatically cut off the affective umbilical cord that Asian Americans feel toward their home country, but rather that U.S. citizenship becomes an instrumental tool for larger objectives.
Nakanishi (2003) suggests using a combination of micro- and macro-political approaches by broadening the focus away from exclusively individuals as the level of analysis to include relations between countries and perhaps even systems. The operationalization of this requires far more specification but is a sensible suggestion, yet probably very difficult to achieve without a multi-level analysis—one of my central contentions. To combine approaches would require ethnography, cultural studies, and at least a certain level of bilateral/dual country institutional and cultural analysis. Another research possibility is to engage in “post-coding” data9
I claim no originality for this idea. This idea was proposed in another context by Ashutosh Varshney at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association in Washington, D.C., in August 2005.
The enterprise of mainstream political science is to begin with systematic, structured inquiry in order to generate facts that withstand contextual scrutiny. One way to begin would be by engaging with the public choice literature and importing the existing findings on top of those stylized filters to generate and test hypotheses. For sure, the lack of nation-wide data sets is a significant barrier to this enterprise, but a baseline is strongly required. Yet the data do exist, as studies here have highlighted.
But surveys require intellectual puzzles that need to be solved. So one way to begin would be to pose the question: Under what sorts of conditions do ethnic Asian Americans catalyze and overcome the problem of collective action? A plausible starting point would be take an Olsonian position and consider the role of selective incentives. If these are absent, the question becomes: In the absence of selective incentives, what were the factors that catalyzed collective action? Were these factors related to economic insecurity and/or racial discrimination? Why and under what conditions? Were the factors generating greater participation exogenous or endogenous to the community? If exogenous, at what levels of analysis can we classify and test them—the international? domestic? bilateral?
Similar iterations hold for factors that are endogenous to the community. If the factors are endogenous, posing the same question could require a cultural explanation. Thus, a multi-method approach could supplement community-specific ethnographies at a micro level with survey data on the topmost layer and perhaps case studies to fill in the gaps for specifying mechanisms to bridge the individual and collective levels of political participation. In posing the issue of how institutional arrangements do or do not feed into the community overcoming the collective action dilemma, textual analysis could come into play, given the role of leadership.
Thus, greater levels of structured, theoretically guided inquiry would enliven the scholarship linking Asian Americans to their political participation and even lead to cumulative findings. Given the welter of facts with which any social scientist will necessarily be confronted, some pre-empirical criteria of determination are required. This is where theory and data become crucial. Building an integrated edifice constitutes the single-most crucial challenge in the study of Asian Americans and political participation.
Anil G. Jacob is a graduate student at Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ.