To fight the symbolic annihilation of Asian Americans in Hollywood film and mainstream American histories, an Asian American independent documentary tradition emerged in the 1970s. These filmmakers sought to chronicle Asian American experiences, and to explore key issues that our communities face. Many of the earlier Asian American documentaries deal with weighty issues, such as traumas caused by national policies (e.g., the Japanese Internment, the Chinese/Asian Exclusion Act), racial discrimination and the harm caused by the model minority myth, the displacement of Asian Americans caused by gentrification, and the refugee experience. Aided in part by the founding of numerous Asian American film festivals beyond the West Coast and New York, over the past two decades Asian American filmmakers have explored an increasingly diversified range of topics and stories. In recent years, documentarians—some of whom are not of Asian descent—have created numerous films about Asian American musicians and the multi-directional movement of musical traditions across the Pacific. These films have made the lives, practices, struggles, and triumphs of Asian American musicians and Asians who regularly perform in the United States more accessible to researchers and to educators who want to make their courses more inclusive. Two recent contributions to this rich legacy are Far Western (directed by James D. Payne, 2016) and Bright Sun Mansion (directed by Haitao Guo, 2015).
Far Western tells the history of American country music and bluegrass in Japan primarily though the stories of Charlie Nagatani (b. 1936), a country bandleader based in the southern Japanese city of Kumamoto, as well as the Blueside of Lonesome, a bluegrass band based in the Greater Tokyo area. The film also includes informative and entertaining interviews with Yasushi and Hisashi Ozaki (two brothers who formed one of Japan's best bluegrass bands, the East Mountain Boys), Saburo Inoue (a member of Bluegrass 45, the first Japanese group to tour the United States), and renowned popular music scholar Toru Mitsui. Although the Ozaki brothers reveal that they secretly listened to American jazz and country music during World War II, Mitsui states that American country music and bluegrass became popular in Japan during the ensuing U.S. occupation. He argues that, for many young Japanese who came of age in the 1950s and early 1960s, these musical traditions became associated not only with the ideals of democracy and freedom that the occupation government was trying to teach, but also with the sense of adventure and danger evoked by the “Wild West.” Mitsui further maintains that because these enthusiasts had overly romanticized notions of these genres, they eventually became disillusioned, and the golden age of country and bluegrass in Japan did not last long.
Nonetheless, some musicians who caught the country and bluegrass “fever” in the 1950s and ’60s have continued to perform. Nagatani first heard country music at his twentieth birthday party, and formed his band the Cannonballs in 1961. In 1985, his international reputation led to an invitation from the Grand Ole Opry—where he has since performed twenty-seven times. In 1989, Nagatani founded Country Gold, an annual festival in Kumamoto dedicated to rekindling the popularity of country music in Japan. Nagatani's lifelong investment in country music stems partly from the fact that he has never lost the idealism that Mitsui discussed. Growing up near Nagasaki and Hiroshima, Nagatani sees continuing anti-American sentiments all around him, and views country music, which in the film he calls the “real American music culture,” as a form of cultural diplomacy.
Managed by designer and guitarist Masuo Sasabe, who has regularly attended bluegrass festivals in the United States since 1974, the Blueside of Lonesome is an “all-star” band whose members come from contrasting backgrounds. While Sasabe is the descendent of masters of Kiyari (a genre of Japanese work song), banjoist Ryukochi Hayakawa knows very little about Japanese traditional music—a fact about which he is somewhat uncomfortable. Meanwhile, Yoshie Sakamoto, their lead singer and the daughter of a Japanese country music star, listened primarily to rock music during her formative years. According to Hayakawa, the Blueside of Lonesome's strength comes from combining their members’ differing musical histories. The film concludes with Nagatani bringing thirty friends on a tour of the United States, culminating with his twenty-fifth appearance at the Grand Ole Opry, and the Blueside of Lonesome coming to perform at a festival and a bar in Oklahoma.
Directed by James Payne, who has produced and directed numerous documentaries on Oklahoman topics, Far Western is generally well paced—albeit a bit long—and features numerous excellent performances. Through the interviews, he broaches some of the most hotly debated issues in musicology and beyond. For educators, this film provides opportunities to open discussions on cultural appropriation, American cultural imperialism, and “glocalization.” They can also raise questions such as: “To what extent are Nagatani and the Blueside of Lonesome participating in a Japanese tradition?” and “Why do the Japanese performers appear to be unaware of the multiracial roots of country and bluegrass?”
Compared to Far Western, Bright Sun Mansion is a lesser film, but it brings to light the remarkable number of high-level traditional musicians who toil in low-paying jobs in the ethnic economies of the United States. According to this documentary, more than two hundred professional Peking Opera artists live in New York, and most of them work in nail salons. Directed by Haitao Guo and supported in part by a grant from the Sundance Institute, Bright Sun Mansion tells the story of Yulin Fang, an established Peking Opera performer in China who immigrated to New York in 2000 at the age of 53. A protégé of Jinkai Yuan and Huiliang Li, Fang began his training in 1960, which was then interrupted by the Cultural Revolution. In the early 1980s, he was a part of the traditional Peking Opera revival in China, and performed wusheng (acrobatic male warrior) roles throughout the country before his career eventually stalled.
After relocating to the United States, Fang hoped that he could find opportunities to perform professionally, but he soon realized that this dream was out of reach. Outside of a production of Butterfly Lovers at Lincoln Center in 2003, most of his performances have been in small community productions. Much of Bright Sun Mansion documents the difficulties he encountered preparing for an amateur production in 2012.
Bright Sun Mansion thus presents an engaging portrait of a high-level performer forced to work in a nail salon, but I wished the film had dug deeper into Fang's life, and also those of other Peking Opera artists in New York. In one segment of the film, Fang discusses how he misses his homeland, and says that he constantly wonders where he belongs. Unfortunately, director Haitao Guo does not really attempt to answer that question. That said, Bright Sun Mansion is useful for teaching purposes. It can serve as an introduction to both traditional Chinese opera in the late twentieth century and the concept of “micromusics.” Educators can also use the film to open discussions on ethnic economies and cultural preservation.
