Pierre Manent begins with the questions of what it means to be modern, and from whence modernity came. These are big questions, no doubt, but even they barely grasp the scope, ambition, originality, and challenge of the book ahead.
In fact, only a minute after he introduces these questions in Metamorphoses of the City, Manent lays out some answers that muddy the category of modernity itself. Even, he says, as we are inclined to agree on some of the criteria of what it means to be modern—the religious Reformation, faith in science, and democratic political revolution—it is hard to say what primary intellectual or moral standpoint they share. Manent dismisses that widespread argument that says, “What these features of modernity share, and what underlies modernity as a whole, is the ambition to master nature, to transform the world through human construction.” That familiar assessment, he argues, mutes the obvious fact that human beings have always desired and endeavored to act in the world. Moreover, since the ancient Greek development of the city (and its concomitant politics), humans have been able to commonly deliberate and order our actions in the world. “Thus,” he writes, “if modernity is characterized first of all as a project of collective action, and if politics is the implementation and ordering of action, the modern project must in the first place be understood as a political project,” and “it must be situated anew in the history of European and Western political development” (p. 4).
For Manent, this means telling an evolutionary story—a story of what gets translated here as “movement”—about the history and dynamics of Western politics. That story begins in ancient Greece, with the author describing the ancient Greek city as a new form for ordering life that unleashed unprecedented quantities and qualities of human energy into the world. But the energy that animated the ancient city was also the energy that would destroy it. The energy of the ancient Greek city was so substantial that in the end, it consumed the city itself in the Peloponnesian War.
That story and that city have haunted the West ever since, and subsequent Western history might be seen as nothing more than a perpetual quest to find a political form that would harness the energies of the ancient Greek city while escaping its tragic fate. In the immediate aftermath of the city’s collapse, the Western empire emerged as a form that preserved and even exceeded all the energies of the ancient city—at times, Rome seemed close to encompassing the entirety of the known human race—but sacrificed its freedom. The prestige of that empire would endure, to some degree, but the empire would fail in part to deliver on the unity and peace that it promised. And so the Western empire, too, would collapse, leaving the specters of Caesar and Cato behind it.
The Western empire would be succeeded by the reign of the Christian Church, a form that understood politics and aspired to gather all human beings together into an association that is both intimate and universal. The church was in that way a harkening both to city and empire, an attempt to harness the energies of the prior political forms that had dominated Europe and to harness yet again more. Ultimately, though, like its predecessors, the church was fated to fall as a political form—in this case, because it was destined to disappoint, to fail to deliver on the promise of universal communion that it had made.
It is at this point in Manent’s story that modernity as we tend to recognize it reappears, in the moment when Europe struggled with this tripartite inheritance of city, empire, and church. Although the church emerged from empire, and empire emerged from the city, the three forms made for a confusing inheritance in combination. Sharing only an increasing thirst for energy and an increasing aspiration to unite humanity, the three forms provide divergent ideas and models for human life on virtually every front.
Out of this confusion emerged the modern state, which attempts to resolve the conflict among city, empire, and church by raising itself above all. The modern state thus thirsts for even more energy, and aspires to an even more unified humanity, than the previous forms that dominated Western politics. The hallmarks of its “solution” to the confusion it inherited are secularism and representative governance. But, says Manent, “this solution had neither the energetic simplicity of the civic form nor the ambitious exactitude of the ecclesial form, and the West would not cease to search for a ‘solution’ that would at last be complete and that would unite the energy of the civic operation and the exactitude of the religious proposition” (p. 10)—thus, the modern flirtation with totalitarian rule.
That brings Manent to the present moment, a moment in which, by his telling, civic life is almost invisible, and religious teaching is almost inaudible. “We are witnessing,” he argues, “a more and more profound divorce between the process of civilization and the political structure” (p. 12). Our moment is like the moment that preceded the birth of what we call modern politics, but if at that moment there were too many competing political models, at this moment there seem to be too few. For modern political science, the only legitimate regime is the democratic regime, and modern political science understands the nature of that regime poorly.
We are, Manent says, at a moment that seems to demand or foreshadow another metamorphosis of political form—something capable of harnessing new energies and nurturing great ambitions—but which lacks an effective political resource. The nation is being delegitimized without an apparent alternative emerging. The West can neither define nor defend itself. Ultimately, in trying to replicate or ratchet up the energy of the ancient city, the dynamics of the West have come close to eviscerating the political altogether. The idea of the city’s metamorphoses leaves him asking: What might we imagine now?
My recounting of Manent’s narrative up to this point has tried to capture its broad and provocative outlines—and broad and provocative they are, without question. But my recounting has missed that which takes up the bulk of the pages of Metamorphoses of the City, and that which makes this book most memorable: Manent’s inimitably profound interpretations of books that have been central to the history of Western political thought, interpretations that gather force from the sweep of the history as he tells it. Such interpretations appear throughout Metamorphoses, covering stories from that of Adam and Eve on, but the interpretations that he puts forth in the second section of the book, “The Enigma of Rome,” are especially powerful. His close reading of Roman ideas sets into relief how little contemporary political scientists think about Rome, and how much that neglect might impair contemporary political science.
In that section, as throughout the book, Manent takes us back and again to the idea that what we might imagine now may, in fact, depend on reimagining what has come before.
