To the expanding corpus of studies on influential twentieth-century Middle Eastern personages we can add Yoav Alon's biography of the Jordanian tribal leader Mithqal al-Fayiz (c.1880–1967). As head of the influential Bani Sakhr tribal confederation in the second quarter of the twentieth century, Mithqal played an important role in the history of modern Jordan. Alon's biography of Mithqal provides useful insights into the transition of formerly nomadic communities to sedentarism, the study of which makes us reconsider some of the dominant tropes of modern Middle Eastern history.
Alon's biography tracks Mithqal's public life from his origins as a tribal commander on the margins of Ottoman authority who opposed British entry into Transjordan to his subsequent alignment with the British-installed Hashemite monarchy, a relationship that overcame its tenuous first decades to become a bedrock of the Jordanian state's strategy of governance. Mithqal's influence derived from his hereditary position as leader of the Bani Sakhr nomadic confederacy, but it also stemmed from his control over agricultural land. His story thus reveals important insights about the transformation of land use and ownership from the late-Ottoman imperial era to the modern Jordanian state.
In Mithqal's early biography we can observe how imperial politics were at least partially responsible for the sociological shift from nomadism to sedentarism. As Alon explains, Tanzimat land reforms led nomadic leaders to register previously collective grazing lands as private property and cultivate them for export, taxed by the Ottomans. This new policy marked a shift in the economic life of groups like the Bani Sakhr, beginning at the leadership level.
By 1922 Mithqal had become the biggest landowner in the country, since the Hashemite monarch Abdullah had gifted him lands to maintain his loyalty and support. Alon draws from the travelogues of Western visitors to Mithqal's estate to provide an intimate portrait of Mithqal's integration into sedentary life. This process was gradual but tangible and could be observed in his marriage to the daughter of Jordanian town elite, his immersion in land management practices, and other changes. Meanwhile, the economic downturn of the 1930s put Mithqal, like many other Transjordanians, into debt. His response was to cultivate new patrons, including Zionist, Palestinian, and Saudi leaders, who viewed him as a potentially useful ally.
Preserving the autonomy of Bani Sakhr was, according to Alon, Mithqal's greatest priority. Alon maintains, for instance, that Mithqal cultivated ties with Zionist leaders in Palestine in order to develop another independent patronage channel, and thus avoid exclusive reliance on British or other funding sources. During the Arab Revolt of 1936, the tribal leader reverted to the Arab nationalist cause, supporting the Palestinian position.
In the last decades of his life, Mithqal sustained his role as an important loyalist in King Hussein's court. By this point, the autonomy that Mithqal and his sons had long coveted was mostly eroded, replaced by ministerial appointments, salaries, and new forms of patronage including foreign development aid. Meanwhile, Bani Sakhr lands, including Mithqal's vast holdings, were placed under the regulatory authority of the state, with Mithqal forced to apportion some of his property to landless Bani Sakhr tribesmen.
Mithqal's ability to weave between Zionist, colonialist, and nationalist elite in Palestine, Jordan, Syria, Egypt, and Saudi Arabia in the 1930s and 1940s is a distinctive trait. Yet this fluid kind of politicking, Alon shows us, was tempered by the “immovability” of his key asset: Transjordanian farmland, rendering his interests, in the end, quite parochial. It is this interesting tension in the life of a formerly nomadic twentieth-century Arab elite that frames Alon's worthy book.
Mithqal's willingness to propose commercial exchange with the Zionist movement and to play the Palestinian leadership and Zionists against one another reveals him to be in some respects a pre-nationalist figure, as Alon suggests. Whether Mithqal was driven by crude opportunism for profits on the one hand, or by his moral compass as a Bedouin community leader determined to preserve his tribe's rapidly diminishing autonomy on the other, is a question worthy of debate. To contextualize Alon's sympathy for Mithqal's motivations, however, this study might be read alongside other studies that empathize with or otherwise elucidate the Bedouin position and worldview, including monographs by Andrew Shryock, Pascal Menoret, Saad Sowayan, and Lila Abu-Lughod.
Alon's granular study also provides scholars with new inputs for comparing the historical practices of tribal and kinship groups across the Middle East. Alon notes, for example, that during the Hashemite revolt of 1916, the Zaban, another Bani Sakhr subgroup who were rivals to the Fayiz, supported the Hashemites, whereas the Fayiz remained loyal to the Ottomans. Similar fissures divided the subclans of the Harb tribe in the Hijaz during the Ottoman-Saudi war in the early nineteenth century. This common historical pattern underscores the tribal confederation's identity as a loose and dynamic arrangement of non-exclusive kin-group interests.
Alon emphasizes the fact that late into the twentieth century, the Jordanian state maintained and even strengthened informal tribal legal and governance practices as a complement to codified state law. When Mithqal grew old, for example, he bequeathed his authority to his son ‘Akif, who rose to become both a prime minister under King Hussein, and, informally, the principle mediator on behalf of the Bani Sakhr with the government. Political scientists might fruitfully consider how the mechanisms and practices of tribal mediation in a non-oil state like Jordan compare or contrast with those in an oil state like Saudi Arabia, which in some respects adopted a similar policy toward tribal customary practices.
Deep histories of nomadism and of the transition of formerly nomadic communities to sedentary urban life can open up new narratives about modern Middle Eastern history. Alon's rigorously researched biography of Mithqal al-Fayiz succeeds admirably in this respect and is thus recommended for reading by advanced undergraduate and graduate students in history, anthropology, and Middle East Studies.
