Economic Citizenship is a richly documented, theoretically sophisticated ethnography that involves participant observation, focus groups and interviews with low-income Israeli and Palestinian women over an important ten-year period. Based on research emerging from studies conducted for government and nongovernmental organizations, Israeli anthropologist Amalia Sa'ar gives us a textured scholarly as well as policy-oriented feminist analysis of Israel's “social economy” involving business leaders, public servants, local entrepreneurs, social workers and social justice advocates. The book is organized in three parts entitled “Paradoxes of the Pursuit of Solidarity amid Polarizing Social Inequalities,” “Women Making Sense of the Demand to Make Money,” and “Economic Citizenship—Between the Right to Work and the Obligation to Be Productive” and five chapters discussing the book's key themes on “Social Economy,” “Vulnerability,” “Empowerment,” “Entitlement,” and “Inclusion, Productivity, and Care.” Saʾar leads us through a discussion of “economic citizenship” including self-empowerment projects which “are replete with talk about individual self-sufficiency and open opportunities” that target low-income women, all of whom “come together in an effort to mitigate the rapacious effects of capitalism, yet without attempting to replace it altogether” (22).
Most remarkable about the work is Saʾar's attention to historical, sociodemographic, sociopolitical, and ethnographic detail. She carefully traces the currents that, from 1985 onwards, led to Israel's deregulated neoliberal and heavily militarized economy, which brought greater wealth to “a small, select group” while “placing Israel next to worst in the OECD club, above only Mexico” (33).
Saʾar makes abundantly clear just how important it is to understand the particularity of Israel's sociopolitical make up in order for readers to appreciate what is actually happening on the ground. For example, if one were simply to look from the outside in, one would see a fairly wide range of Israeli social agencies and state actors actively promoting empowerment and employment workshops for Palestinian citizens of Israel. However, Saʾar rightfully points out, this process
does not necessarily indicate a weakening of the hegemonic perception of Israel as the state of the Jewish people, or a shift towards the state-of-all-its-citizens position upheld by the non-Zionist left. Rather, it signifies a sense of urgency in the mainstream, secular Ashkenazi-Jewish elites to reduce social inequalities as a means of strengthening the democratic component of the state, which they perceive as complementary to its Jewish component. (55)
Remarkably, Saʾar is as attentive to the construction of class—women's “vulnerabilities” as well as their “overt and covert capacities” (71)—as she is to their identifications as citizen nationals within what is a surprisingly interesting milieu. She very carefully describes how self-empowerment projects and entrepreneurship workshops bring together an unusually diverse but engaged set of actors from “old-time Mizrahim, more recent Jewish immigrants from the former Soviet Union or Ethiopia, Palestinian-Israelis of various religions and lifestyles, and ultra-Orthodox Jewish women” (4, 50). In several respects, while economic citizenship can capture “subtle but meaningful dialogues” between and among a broad array of actors who often hold radically different social as well as ideological positions (222), the tendency is for most of the women to remain “apolitical” in their orientation and practice. As a matter of course, Saʾar repeatedly reminds readers that
activists using the concept of economic citizenship. . . to indicate minority women's right to inclusion rarely take into account the fact that the same concept is used simultaneously, with different implications, by neoconservatives or, in the case of Israel, by bearers of Zionist hegemony. Similarly, business philanthropists and development agents are rarely aware either of the more politicized significance of the concept as used at the grassroots level, or of its narrow utilitarian understandings by politicians and mainstream economists. (193-94)
She contends that this quality “represents its capacity to coopt critical perspectives and practices, while allowing space for meaningful engagements by the very victims of economic liberalization, and while compelling the sovereign—in this case the Zionist state and the dominant Ashkenazi class—to allocate economic and symbolic resources to the marginalized and the excluded” (194). Under these circumstances, Saʾar points to capitalism's forms of enchantment and charismatic deliverance though she is neither dismissive of women's expectations nor condescending in tone. For example, she writes about how they “experiment with a sophisticated emotional speech style that is generally the prerogative of a professional class and beyond the boundaries of their own habitus”(152). She also identifies a “deep ambivalence” that many of the women share about entering the formal economy: While well-disposed to the social aspects and independence they gain, they often also embraced what Saʾar (following other feminist scholars) refers to as “the gender contract,” placing women in the private/domestic sphere and men in the public/labor market. She goes so far as to tell us that some women “resent the idea of becoming primary breadwinners” (155). What the women hold in common is their low-income status and related vulnerabilities and an insistence on the value of sustaining their emotional capacities—to care for others as well as themselves. These capacities override their desire for individual wealth and explain their delight in participating in new entrepreneurial and related endeavors.
Informed by a deeply-held feminist ethos, Saʾar seamlessly incorporates her own experiences in the struggle for economic justice throughout the book, and writing in its final pages:
Throughout this research project I have swung between dismay at the gripping force with which capitalism co-opts even the most innovative attempts to create a more balanced, solidary, and just society, and awe at the vision and passion with which people leap into action, reach outside their comfort zones, and produce meaningful results for real-life women. (224)
I strongly recommend this work for upper-level undergraduate and graduate courses. Anthropologists will delight in the thick description offered and the richness of the mixed method approach, as will those in Women's Studies, Israel Studies, Peace Studies, Sociology, Social Work, Political Science, Cultural Geography, and Economic History.
