How does one write about the actions of a leader in such a way as to impress upon a reader that the leader is ‘bad’? Verena Schulz's book addresses this question by looking at the portrayals of Nero and Domitian (two quintessentially bad leaders from the well-stocked catalogue of bad Roman emperors) in the works of Tacitus, Suetonius and Cassius Dio. For S., the answer to this question can be found in analysing the ways in which these authors ‘deconstructed’ the (once positive) images of these two emperors and ‘re-coded’ their actions in a pejorative manner. All this may appear sound, even unexceptionable, and a sceptical reader may wonder why we need a book of nearly 400 pages to tell us this. Happily, this book, which is a ‘lightly adapted version’ of S.'s Habilitationsschrift, provides the reader with so much more.
S. takes the reader on a well-argued and often illuminating journey through the accounts of Tacitus, Dio and Suetonius. S.'s mastery of ancient rhetorical theory and the language of narratology is patent and she deploys these approaches judiciously. Structurally, S. has opted to treat her three authors separately, so the sections function as almost independent essays. Certainly, this provides the chance for S. to devote more attention to each author in his own right, rather than using two as foils for the third. Even so, reading through the book I was struck by the degree to which the analysis of one of the authors could be applied to the other two, which enhances its value.
What emerges from this book is three distinct portraits of the three authors. S.'s Tacitus is the author of studied ambiguity. By avoiding concrete resolutions, the text (principally the Annales) creates a sense of uncertainty. In this discussion, S. brings out the connections between critical historiography and panegyric. In S.'s reading, the tropes we find in historiographical texts, such as imperial transgressions into vicious behaviour, respond closely to the tropes of conventional panegyric where the crossing of boundaries or where actions are ‘bigger, better, more important than ever before’ are celebrated (97). As S. succinctly puts it, ‘panegyric presents emperors as superhuman, historiography renders them as less than human’ (83). As a way of showing Tacitus’ method of deconstruction, S. contrasts Tacitus’ portrayals with the idealised imperial portrayals found in contemporary sources such as Calpurnius Siculus, Martial and Statius.
As for Dio, S. begins, à la Fergus Millar, from the standpoint of reading the Roman History as a reaction to the author's own times, specifically the period from Marcus Aurelius to Septimius Severus. Yet S. develops this premise by incorporating scholarship on memory, specifically the idea of ‘hot memory’ (254, 256), arguing that Dio's portrayals of Nero and Domitian were fashioned to provide a critique of the emperors of the early third century. For S., ‘Dio creates a unity by explaining things from a contemporary point of view’. More than this, though, by subjecting Dio's account to a formal literary analysis, S. shows the reader just what a skilful author Dio can be — even when read in the Byzantine epitomes.
S.'s reading of Suetonius’ Lives of the Caesars has much to offer too. Just as S. places Dio in the political context of third-century Rome, so Suetonius is placed in the literary context of the turn of the second century, a world straddling the encyclopaedism of the first century (typified by the Elder Pliny) and the miscellany literature of the second (as represented by Aulus Gellius). S. discusses Suetonius’ use of rubrics in the context of recent scholarship, such as that by Jason König and Tim Whitmarsh, on the ways in which knowledge was ‘ordered’ during this period. S. is very good on the rhetorical aspects of Suetonius’ work, and demonstrates how the rubrics, around which the content of Lives is organised, are often presented with attention to amplification, both in terms of the ordering of the rubrics in each Vita and the ordering of the material within a rubric itself (314). This part of the analysis is certainly stimulating and takes Suetonius out of the shadow of Tacitus. More contentiously, for this reviewer at least, S. sees Suetonius’ Lives as an essentially non-political text, a work which represents ‘a highly rhetorical but non-political form of literary deconstruction of imperial representation’ (273). On this point, I was left wondering to what extent any work about emperors, or any political figure, can be non-political?
The book this most reminds me of is Paul Plass’ Wit and the Writing of History (1988). As with Plass’ work, S.'s monograph has much to offer the scholar of ancient historiography, biography and rhetoric. As a contribution to scholarship, S.'s work not only describes and deftly analyses the works of these three central authors, but points the way to new modes of interpretation.
