The history of textiles in South Asia, as traditionally told, has one grand narrative at its center: a flourishing industry, the envy of the world, was undermined by the colonial encounter. From being the world's major exporter of textiles, South Asia came to import cheap machine-produced cloth from Britain, and was “deindustrialized.” The appeal of this story lies at least partly in the simplicity with which it seems to clarify the destructive nature of colonialism. But this account has been challenged: indeed one of the editors of this volume (T. Roy. Traditional Industry in the Economy of Colonial India. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1999), among others, has pointed to ways in which traditional textile production survived and even thrived in the colonial setting. There is still energy in this long-standing debate, and several essays in the book under review offer valuable new evidence. Especially noteworthy is a chapter by Ian Wendt on South India, arguing that the deindustrialization debate has focused too much on weaving, which, though important, was only one part of the production process. Other elements such as spinning (which by itself was roughly 40 percent of the labor used) and cleaning were more affected by mechanization. Moreover, since female and agrarian labor were concentrated in these activities, Wendt suggests, the nineteenth century saw a process of “masculinization” and “urbanization.” In a similar vein, Prasannan Parthasarathi argues that deindustrialization becomes more visible if the starting point for comparison is the late eighteenth century rather than the early nineteenth, by which point traditional Indian producers had already lost significantly.
Another focus of this volume, one of its many strengths, is the emphasis on South Asian trade with regions other than Europe. On the issue of deindustrialization, Joseph Inikori's discussion of textile production in West Africa provides an interesting point of comparison with South Asia. The literature on South Asia usually defines (at least implicitly) deindustrialization in one of two ways: a decline in the number of workers in manufacturing, or a decline in the share of workers in manufacturing. Inikori uses a different metric, suggesting that the adverse effects of imports came at an earlier stage, even before manufacturing had the opportunity to flourish. Interregional trade and specialization were growing in West Africa, and left to itself, this process may have led to the development of “full-scale proto-industrial production of cotton cloth” (p. 108). Imports from South Asia and then Britain nipped this process in the bud. Pedro Machado, focusing on the substantial exports of cloth to East-Central and Southeast Africa by Gujarati merchants well into the nineteenth century, suggests that that the conception of Africans as “marginal” actors on the global stage needs be rethought; African “leverage” was reflected in Gujarati merchants' need to be responsive to trends in taste and fashion (pp. 8–9).
Several essays explore what we might call the “political economy of procurement.” European Companies, especially, faced (and created) many contractual problems. For instance, the East India Company (EIC) might advance capital to a weaver or to a merchant, to produce or acquire and deliver cloth. The weaver or merchant might divert the capital to some other use, or, more likely, sell the product to another buyer. As the EIC gained political power, it sought to minimize these problems by trying to monopolize procurement, by making contractual violations punishable under law, and by authorizing its agents to use force. Lakshmi Subramaniam argues that in Western India, in the late eighteenth century, the company's political power was too “fragmented and fractured” (p. 276) for this strategy. In contrast, Om Prakash argues that in late-eighteenth-century Bengal, where the company had consolidated political power, its procurement methods were primarily coercive; he suggests that this changed the distribution of surplus (to the weavers' detriment) without hurting output. Also focusing on Bengal in the same period, Bishnupriya Gupta suggests that the East India Company faced competitive pressures in international markets, forcing it to offer low prices, making procurement difficult.
The concluding chapters of the book discuss the evolution and construction of tastes, a subject usually not the preserve of economic historians. Beverly Lemire describes the growing popularity in the seventeenth century of a type of robe, originating in Japan but oddly enough labeled a banyan, the name used by European traders for their Indian counterparts. The banyan came to symbolize masculine accomplishment and refinement—Samuel Pepys borrowed one to pose in when his portrait was painted, in 1666! Maxine Berg argues that Indian products were marketed as “exotic” and ”secret” (p. 397) and of high quality. British manufacturers had to improve to match these quality standards. This discussion, and the material discussed above on the geographic scope of South Asian textile trade, are well-illustrated by reproductions of portraits and maps.
How India Clothed the World is an ambitious book which takes a comprehensive look at South Asian textiles from the minutiae of technology and procurement to the global movement of products and “invisible cargoes” (p. 8). There is much that informs and fascinates, but the sheer breadth of topics covered means that the nonspecialist, especially, needs guidance toward his/her specific interest. This is provided in an excellent overview/introductory chapter, making the volume accessible and valuable to a wide range of readers.
