During the summer of 2020, I intended to make my second visit to Iqaluit, Nunavut, to speak with people involved in performance and climate science practices, engage in “co-performative witnessing” (methodology after Dwight Conquergood), and work to make my doctoral research useful to communities in Nunavut.Footnote 1 Needless to say, that didn't happen. However, the limitations imposed by COVID-19 have also been opportunities for all of us in performance studies to renew our understandings of what it is we do. The pandemic has forced me to understand my dissertation project differently and to reassess the complex process of respectfully engaging communities to which I do not personally belong.
I am a Ph.D. candidate researching icescapes, which I define as practices that frame encounters between humans and ice and thereby stage potential ecological relationships. In studying contemporary icescapes based on the Canadian Arctic and Subarctic, I ask how climate change might be (re)imagined and negotiated, matters I approach through performance studies, settler colonial and Indigenous studies, biology and ecology, and feminist science studies. My interest in working with and for groups in Nunavut derives in part from how Inuit coalitions have been leaders in articulating global climate change as a human rights issue and otherwise innovating climate change communication (including within the UN and the academy).Footnote 2 I've learned the importance of these intersections (climate change, Indigenous theory, critical settler colonial studies, performances of art and protest) from environmental justice leaders, including the Nuluujaat Land Guardians who are opposing the expansion of an iron ore mine on Mary River in the Qikiqtaaluk region of Nunavut.Footnote 3 My work is rooted in the insights of scholars like Kyle Powys Whyte and Patricia Ybarra, who argue that ecological imbalances, including climate change, are constitutively intertwined with racial capitalism and settler colonialism. I also want to prioritize how climate change is seen and confronted by communities for whom it is a daily, insistent reality. It is urgently necessary to think beyond the terms of debate set by climate denialists and oil companies and to focus on moderating climate change and creating emotional and infrastructural adaptation in light of the changes already occurring. I hope my work can encourage others in academe and across the Americas to pay closer and more serious attention to the many Inuit voices that have long attested to the sensory experiences and lived challenges of climate change, and contribute to just, effective, collaborative adaptation across communities and disciplines.
The far north is experiencing particularly dramatic change from anthropogenic climate disturbances. February 2021 was the first February on record when ships were able to pass from China to Russia by the Northern Sea Route, previously impassable during winter months.Footnote 4 These developments are making Arctic lands and waters subject to intensified, but by no means new, international interest and speculation.Footnote 5 Within the territory of Nunavut, warming has complex consequences for government bodies, organizations, and individuals facing increasingly voracious interest from companies seeking access to natural resources and seaways (to which ice was a long-lived but fast-dissipating barrier). I am interested in how people in Nunavut are using creative practices (theatre and performance, broadly construed) to cope with and confront climate change as part of a longer lineage of settler colonialism, extractive capitalism, and Indigenous resilience.
I also believe that Inuit and Indigenous artists and scholars are producing some of the most exciting and urgent new creative works. In 1980, UCLA theatre professor Hanay Geiogamah (Member of the Kiowa Tribe of Oklahoma) became among the first published Native American playwrights.Footnote 6 Shortly before the pandemic, Professor Geiogamah explained to me his sense of a shift: how after centuries of oppression and acculturation, the contemporary moment in global Indigenous theatre is a new era of self-definition and self-expression, in which Native communities have greater means to speak for themselves. Unexpectedly, perhaps, the COVID-19 pandemic proved itself to be part of an important period for the public expression of Indigenous coalitions around the world and their audiences.
My primary encounter with this was the first UCLA TAPS (Theater and Performance Studies) Graduate Conference, in February 2021, which I coorganized alongside three other UCLA Ph.D. students and graduates.Footnote 7 Originally conceived pre-COVID as a small, California-focused event, the conference morphed into something more expansive once the pandemic forced events online. With travel and lodging no longer an object, we were able to accommodate distant speakers and more than seventy student participants. I embraced the opportunity to forefront the voices of Indigenous and allied innovators in artistic pedagogy and knowledge production, inviting three important scholars and curators of Canadian Indigenous Arts, who graciously obliged. This led to the participation of the GLAM (Galleries, Libraries, Archives, and Museums) Collective, comprising Dr. Heather Igloliorte (Inuk), Dr. Julie Nagam (Métis), and Dr. Carla Taunton (settler).Footnote 8 During the conference, GLAM modeled collaborative, intermedial practices informed by Indigenous feminisms and illustrated how they have employed creativity and pedagogy to produce lasting change, including using art incubators to catalyze self-perpetuating networks of Inuit, Métis, and First Nations arts leadership. Their commitment to enacting Indigenous feminist values of collaboration, innovation, and imagining otherwise through their own friendships, scholarship, and artistic knowledge production is inspiring. Although situated primarily in art history departments at three Canadian universities, GLAM also embodies aims of many performance studies scholars: to work across disciplines, unsettle oppressive categories, and advance theories of historiography and social justice through public creative praxes. Simultaneously, the GLAM collective stressed the importance of respecting limits to Indigenous studies research. For non-Indigenous settler scholars like myself, meaningful contribution often entails deliberate inaction and careful restraint, learning from mistakes, acceptance of and humility in our status as outsiders. Their advice on allyship echoed elements of the “Ally Bill of Responsibilities” offered by Anishinaabe professor Lynn Gehl: effective allies are supporters rather than leaders, doing what is asked of them and useful to Indigenous communities as a whole, and taking responsibility for educating themselves on the dynamic processes of being an effective ally.Footnote 9 As Linda Tuhiwai Smith summarizes in her foundational Decolonizing Methodologies, “indigenous research is a humble and humbling activity.”Footnote 10
In my doctoral research, I circulate around the conceptual/material entity of ice and mean to learn from more-than-human others, methodologies informed by Indigenous studies theories and ecology.Footnote 11 I follow Leanne Betasamosake Simpson's call to take seriously instruction from nonhuman beings.Footnote 12 Ice creates unique possibilities and nurtures life, including lifeforms that exist nowhere but the Arctic (think of narwhals); ice can also be an obstacle to movement, an impediment to growth (permafrost is the reason the Arctic is above the tree line: no large plants can root because of the frozen soil), or very dangerous. Audra Simpson's important essay “On Ethnographic Refusal” makes clear that there are times in Indigenous studies in particular when silence marks the intentional absence of information to which researchers must defer.Footnote 13 In such circumstances, inconclusion and nonknowing—lacunae shaped by personal and community boundaries and respect thereof—are essential parts of the most meaningful or useful academic findings. Relatedly, the COVID-19 pandemic has illustrated the power of community-minded inaction (we have not visited one another for a year because we care about each other). Silence can be a speech act and stillness efficacious. My personal objectives have changed as I've come to embrace the centrality of this caution, measure, and care—my impact on other people and communities is more important than any purely academic metrics of “success.” GLAM's community-oriented ethos to which I aspire emphasizes long-term dedication to projects and necessitates reciprocity and mutual trust that is earned, not simply taken (even by the well-intentioned).
Of course, the pandemic has also spurred action. There are consciously political Indigenous cultural resurgences occurring now, and coalitions are demanding redress of settler colonialism, including its impacts on health. This work relies on networks of intellectual, political, and spiritual labor, community support, and ongoing dialogue. To this end, The Internet and social media are a great boon to long-distance community building, including contemporary arts outreach. This emergent connectivity is by no means new but has been heightened by the COVID-19 pandemic, driving events online that might otherwise have been in-person and available only to proximate audiences. The GLAM Collective write about the importance of social media to physically remote communities (including towns in Nunavut) and to helping coalesce a stronger sense of pan-Inuit and pan-Indigenous identity.Footnote 14 Since the shutdown of in-person events, I have attended online events featuring art, lectures, storytelling, and fundraising, primarily via Facebook and related apps. Examples included the #NativeCOVIDAction Solstice fundraiser organized by Return to the Heart Foundation (22 June 2020) and “Rematriation and Indigenous Feminisms” hosted by Sogorea Te’ Land Trust (a celebration of International Women's Day on 8 March 2021). It is also through social media and heightened activism led by the Black Lives Matter movement and urgent public health needs (intensified within Navajo Nation and other tribal communities in my home state of Arizona) that I learned about mutual aid and supply drives from local Native organizers and allies.
It is clear that this level of involvement is not perfectly equivalent to being there and the “deep hanging out” at the center of much ethnographic methodology.Footnote 15 Dr. John M. H. Kelly (codirector of Carleton University's Centre for Indigenous Research) recommends that researchers interested in working with Canadian Indigenous communities “show up” to public community events, share meals, lend a hand, and “be there—telephone contact doesn't do it that well.”Footnote 16 Doubtless this is true. However, under these conditions (and other ecological upheavals yet to come), online participation has become its own distinctly dispersed yet still embodied, coperformative practice, creating affective support and material sustenance across necessary distance and through a global viral pandemic. Many Indigenous organizers included digital technologies as part of a diverse lineage of “tools of survival” and a means to enable long-distance gathering well before the COVID pandemic.Footnote 17 Recently, such virtual events have created opportunities to celebrate artists and their works, lend attention to community causes, and facilitate efficient donations to mutual aid funds. Certainly, my connections to these groups remain thin under these circumstances, and there are people without easy access to online spaces whose voices matter and whose presence is missed. Simultaneously, Sogorea Te’ Land Trust's “Rematriation” celebration was attended by an overflow audience far exceeding the organizers' expectations, and so had to be accommodated by multiple platforms (Eventbrite and Facebook Live). The event host, Fuifuilupe Niumeitolu, spoke about the relationship between “invisibilizing” forces of colonization and the high rate of suicides among Indigenous youths. She emphasized the importance of seeing Native women and recognizing the “pivotal and significant role that Indigenous feminist [relations] play” in rematriation. Niumeitolu and others describe rematriation as the restoration of relationships to heal the damage that colonialism has wrought globally through violence to the bodies of Native humans and sacred lands.Footnote 18 Throughout, the comment and reaction features of Facebook were filled with communications of thanks and affirmation for the all-femme speaker panel. This online community proved useful in generating life-sustaining visibility and camaraderie in a period of extreme isolation.
The ongoing global pandemic has seemed in some ways to be a rehearsal for intensifying repercussions of anthropogenic climate change: these universal crises manifest unevenly, exacting greater consequences on racialized and marginalized communities who have been systematically denied robust physical and public health infrastructure. Meanwhile, the pandemic has also forcefully insisted that non-Native people recognize that digital spaces are also Indigenous spaces, and that Indigenous scholars and creators may have a great deal to relay about resilience in facing a future of global pandemics and anthropogenic climate change—circumstances many would consider apocalyptic.
Clara Margaret Wilch is a doctoral candidate in UCLA's Department of Theater and Performance Studies. She researches icescapes and cultural negotiations of climate change based in and upon the Arctic.
