Rebecca LeMoine's Plato's Caves defends Plato's dialogues against the current misunderstanding and misuse that threatens Plato's tenure in both polite society and university classes. Offering new readings of the Republic, Laws, Phaedrus, and Menexenus, LeMoine demonstrates that Plato's works do not support walls between cultures. Instead, Plato's Caves concludes that Plato reveals the power of cultural diversity to uncover ignorance and thereby to facilitate the moderation and humility necessary to the search for truth. In other words, with Plato as her ally and cultural diversity as her thematic focus, LeMoine's book demonstrates what universities struggle to grasp: why Plato is important today (and always). In the process, she defies those who challenge the continued capacity of the Western canon to shed light on the human condition in its modern manifestation.
Plato's Caves “challenges the popular and scholarly narratives that Plato was hostile to cultural diversity” (4). The purveyors of the popular narrative that she challenges, LeMoine argues, include two opposing groups. The Far Left and the Far Right, although opposing one another, are united in their belief that Plato stands with the white supremacists and the nationalists. LeMoine argues that scholarly opinion associating Plato with hostility to cultural diversity may be attributed to earlier prior neglect of dramatic evidence and a consequent willingness to accept xenophobic statements within dialogues as indicative of Plato's position. Admitting that scholarly opinion on this question is both divided and nuanced, LeMoine claims to be responding in part to scholarly neglect of in-depth exploration of the question that drives her reading of Plato.
Making a case for a “pattern of valuing cultural diversity within Plato's thought” (33), LeMoine examines the role of foreigners and of foreign cultural elements—such as myths and historical references—in four dialogues. Ultimately, Plato's Caves offers an image of the foreigner as a kind of limited-capacity philosopher. In this reading, Plato represents interaction with foreigners as exposing “contradictions in the values that undergird one's political community” (5). Confronting contradictions forces the individual into the painful process of facing individual limitations, thus encouraging “a more self-reflective citizenship” (5). Reminding readers of Socrates's image of the philosopher as a gadfly that stings to awaken contemplation of oneself and encourage caring about virtue, LeMoine argues that Platonic dialogues repeatedly reveal that foreigners too can serve at least the initial, “stinging” function of the Socratic gadfly. This is not to claim that all foreigners are philosophers, but only to reveal that “foreigners, philosophical or not, can play the initial role of revealing a lack of knowledge” (5).
LeMoine defends her selection of the dialogues central to the book on several grounds. She conducted original-language foreign-word text searches, read the Platonic corpus for thematic relevance to cultural diversity, and considered prior scholarly focus in relationship to cultural diversity. The book is organized according to another criterion for selection. Part 1 focuses on two dialogues in which Athenians engage with foreigners in Athens, the Republic and Menexenus. Part 2 turns to dialogues in which an Athenian serves as a foreigner. In the Laws, the Athenian Stranger introduces his interlocutors to nontimocratic practices, and in the Phaedrus, Socrates—as a philosopher—presents himself as a foreigner.
LeMoine commences analysis of each dialogue by reviewing the evidence in favor of finding Plato hostile to cultural diversity. She then unearths the foreign elements of the dialogue and proceeds to detail how they illuminate the work as a whole. For example, the discussion of the Republic explores inferences arising from the dialogue's location in the Piraeus (where non-Athenians tend to reside), Socrates's attendance at the festival of a non-Greek goddess, and the diverse origins of the participants in the dialogue. All these elements come together, LeMoine argues, to create a portrait of Socrates as welcoming cultural diversity. Sensitivity to character motivations caused by cultural diversity—such as the need of the immigrant Cephalus to “fit in”—inform the reading. Similarly, the chapter traces both the background and effect of foreign historical and literary references. LeMoine concludes her analysis of the Republic by arguing that it both questions the justice of Athens to foreigners and encourages willingness to engage across cultural boundaries.
Plato's Caves makes the case for cultural diversity as beneficial, but the book's argument also explains why cultural diversity is often received with hostility and suspicion. The pain associated with the gadfly sting of cultural diversity is natural: “many feel aversion to foreigners because encounters with foreigners—like encounters with Socrates—often bring out tensions in one's most cherished cultural beliefs and thus in oneself, and facing these tensions is a painful experience” (230). Because the process is painful for the recipient of the sting, it follows that it is also potentially dangerous and difficult for the gadfly. LeMoine's account of the Laws focuses on this aspect of being foreign, chronicling the care and moderation with which the Athenian Stranger administers the sting to his timocratic interlocutors. Moreover, even expertly handled cultural diversity is unlikely to arrive at perfect solutions. Instead, experiencing cultural diversity helps the interlocutors “arrive a little closer” to justice, and in the process the Athenian Stranger has the opportunity to practice the virtue of moderation (193).
Moderation emerges, albeit somewhat slowly, as a major theme in Plato's Caves. The benefits to be expected from cultural diversity are moderate, practicing cultural diversity requires moderation, and—even apart from what develops as a result of practice—the process of engaging across cultures benefits us by creating a more humble and hence a more moderate outlook. Engagement with diversity creates a marketplace of ideas from which we can expect improved ideas, but benefits of the process itself (not the new ideas) are LeMoine's focus. The process forces one into moments of intellectual humility that help to “cultivate Socratic wisdom, defined in Plato's Apology as knowing the limits of one's knowledge” (243). This liberation from intellectual hubris—whether one proceeds on to philosophic heights or not—reminds us that we are not gods. LeMoine concludes that the Socratic wisdom thus won from cultural diversity acts “as a powerful antidote to the worst inclinations of democracy by provoking citizens to pause and reflect before presuming they know the best course of action” (246).
Plato's Caves offers careful, clear, and useful analysis while avoiding qualities that can make Platonic scholarship difficult to access for the nonspecialist. The book unobtrusively hefts an admirable scholarly apparatus, and the reader is not distracted by specialized terminology or interpretive genealogy. While remaining sensitive to the absence of perfect linguistic cognates (see, e.g., 39, 98, 134), LeMoine does not let semantic quibbles distract from the heart of the account. Hence, as readers we are spared the need to wade through a defense of the perennial nature of human dynamics; the book can get straight to the issue that is most evidently at hand (for Plato and for us).
For some readers of Plato's Caves the primary object will be to better understand Plato, and for others the primary object will be to better understand cultural diversity. In either case, there is much to be learned from this study.
