Book reviews for The Journal of Pension Economics and Finance reflect reviewers' own views and in no way represent the views of the institution(s) with which they are affiliated.
Pension systems and reforms may be evaluated according to several benchmarks: economists typically refer to the concepts of financial sustainability, efficiency, and adequacy. Although these concepts are not easily transformed into clear-cut indicators, the empirical literature offers metrics – typically money's worth measures – which, properly interpreted, can provide a good assessment of the underlying characteristics of the systems, and a sound basis for cross-country comparisons. Internal rates of returns, net present value ratios, relative incomes and replacement rates are prominent examples.
This book offers a cross-national assessment of what may be the most elusive concept, namely adequacy of retirement provision. It is a difficult notion because it is very broad, involving individual behavior, institutional outcomes, and the market framework. Individual actions require the capacity to plan ahead, to understand the basics of finance, and to make reasonable decisions in terms of both saving and portfolio allocation, as described in traditional microeconomic life cycle theory, the reference model for assessing retirement saving adequacy. Yet even rational individuals can accumulate wealth poorly/inefficiently when they participate in ill-designed pension schemes or if they lack proper instruments and well-functioning markets. And well-structured pension institutions require diversified sources of retirement income including the public component, often financed on a pay-as-you-go basis, and the private one, which relies on financial accumulation and market returns. Going even further, the authors seek to compare retirement systems based on their effectiveness at (elderly) social inclusion which they define as receiving 40 percent of average income. The analysis is, however, limited, as it focuses only on simulating how private pensions can shape retirement outcomes of hypothetical persons characterized as “at risk” of inadequate or poor accumulations.
The research is based on a cross-country comparison of micro-simulated data. Nine stylized work careers or so-called “working biographies” are outlined, all deterministic, and varying according to qualifications, economic sector, family composition, and life cycle events such as unemployment spells, divorce, and remarriage. The authors formulate various typologies of “unsuccessful” male and female workers, for whom they compute pension benefits which they then compare to average income. The exercise is replicated for six countries they deem representative of different social security “models.” Rather than characterize them as Beveridgean or Bismarkian, these countries are instead classified as “veterans” (the Netherlands, the UK and Switzerland, all with a long tradition in private pensions) and newcomers (Germany, Italy and Poland, who have only recently introduced the multi-pillar system). Results are presented first for each country, and then compared in a final summary chapter. “Inclusiveness” as defined here is achieved in both the Netherlands and Switzerland; results are less certain for Germany and Britain; and definitely not in place for Italy and Poland where the first pillar is based on actuarial equivalence and the second pillar coverage is voluntary and (at present) very low.
Although addressing an important and interesting topic, the volume contains a mismatch between declared objective and outcomes. For instance, it is incomplete to measure elderly social inclusion by looking only at replacement rates or relative pension levels. Social inclusion does not depend solely on pensions, and further it need not depend on the relative income of the elderly with respect to the working population. Instead, a better indicator of elderly economic welfare would use a more comprehensive replacement ratio concept that nets out taxes and includes in-kind transfers such as health and care services, along with other benefits that capture the inclusiveness of welfare policies.
Furthermore, it is misleading to concentrate principally on the private component of pension systems. The authors use the concept of “passive privatization” to describe “an increased need for citizens to find alternative provisions in the face of reductions in the pension levels previously guaranteed by the state” (p. 223). But the existence of a private pillar more often responds to an efficiency rationale; that is, it enhances risk diversification and supports income insurance. While funded private pensions may not focus solely on solidarity principles and redistribution, most countries do not rely only on a single retirement income pillar. It could be argued that the goal of supporting the less fortunate members of society can best be pursued through progressive general taxation and not through proportional contributions levied on labor earnings. Thus benefiting the poor is certainly not the main rationale for introduction of private pensions.
The book also conveys the impression that it is always possible to increase benefits in the public system, so that budget constraints are unimportant. But this notion has produced very high levels of implicit system debt, burdening the young and future generations. Pre-reform systems also suffered from little transparency and excessive granting of privileges to the well off, instead of helping the poor.
In sum, it is essential to focus on elderly poverty, since this problem may be exacerbated in the future due to population aging, volatile labor markets, and the strengthening of individual correlations between pension benefits and contributions. But returning to the old retirement system model is both economically infeasible and politically unlikely.
