Historical writing on colonial Mexico, and more specifically in ethnohistory, has for several decades demonstrated a notable promiscuity between historical, text-centred methods and anthropological, ethnography-centred methods. While this is true on both sides of the Mexico–United States border, where such studies have flourished, it is especially true of Mexican scholars. In research centres such as the Centro de Investigación y Estudios Superiores en Antropología Social (Centre for Research and Advanced Studies in Social Anthropology, CIESAS) or the Dirección de Estudios Históricas of the Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia (Historical Studies Department of the National Institute for Anthropology and History, INAH), it is often impossible to tell adepts of one discipline from those of the other. That salutary hybridity is very much in evidence in this book by Ethelia Ruiz Medrano, a historian who works much like an anthropologist. While the first several chapters are fairly typical of the anthropology-infused ethnohistory one sees these days, chapter 4 is based in large measure on the author's ethnographic fieldwork in communities in the states of Guerrero and Oaxaca, something that few historians actually do. This chapter is the most original and compelling part of a book which, while it makes excellent use throughout of archival sources and a vast array of secondary works, is nonetheless more confirmatory of what we already knew for the colonial period than path-breaking, and which does not deliver quite the punch for the still unexplored terrain of the nineteenth-century history of indigenous communities as one might have hoped. Still, this is a work well worth reading for its judicious basic summary of large tranches of colonial and modern Mexican history, its highly nuanced treatment of the ways in which indigenous communities documented their claims to land, and the practices of modern Indian pueblos in pressing those claims even today.
Using documentary evidence from codices to records of land litigation, and from títulos primordiales to personal observation, Ruiz Medrano looks at how indigenous communities in Oaxaca and central Mexico documented their claims to land from the sixteenth century to the present, and how these forms of documentation were accepted, rejected, or simply discounted by the colonial and national judicial system. Indian pueblos began using codices in legal cases as early as 1531, although the acceptance of these mixed text–pictorial accounts of pueblo histories and land claims had virtually disappeared by the end of the century. The author convincingly traces the ideas of Erasmian humanism in regard to the treatment of Indians as miserables (people of wretched condition) and the negative changes in legal conditions for them after the accession of King Philip II. She provides a detailed account of how these documents were read by colonial authorities, and of what their ‘truth-value’ was considered to be, making the interesting point that while documentary materials such as formal colonial-era titles were always admitted by the courts, evidence of traditional Indian usos y costumbres was not. Advancing in chapter 3 into the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, her discussion takes on the issues of how the citizenship of indigenous people within the new national framework at times widened, while at other times contracting, the avenues through which they pressed their claims. Here she provides useful accounts, for example, of Emperor Maximilian's pro-Indian policies in the wake of the disastrous (for indigenous communities) Ley Lerdo, the Liberal disentailment law of 1856. This chapter also contains a quite fascinating mini-history of a Puebla workshop in the latter part of the nineteenth century which actually forged dozens of sets of land titles to order for Indian pueblos lacking other documentation to support their claims in suits with other pueblos or non-indigenous landowners.
Ruiz Medrano's emphasis throughout, running through her two modern ethnographic accounts as well, is that pueblos have engaged in a ‘complex process of political negotiation’ (p. 6) to preserve their lands. In the face of an obvious shift in balance over time toward private, and even large-scale, landholdings and the ebbing of their land resources that such communities have therefore sustained, her conclusions about the efficacy of document-based defence efforts look a bit Whiggish. This arises from her concentration on the mechanisms developed to assert Indian claims to land, and upon the enchantments of collective memory, rather than on general economic processes at any given moment, which nearly always and everywhere trended in the direction of loss. Ruiz Medrano asserts that pueblos were able to survive in many places and retain control of land because they collectively possessed the necessary survival skills to do so, chief among them what she calls the ideological flexibility that underwrote negotiation in the political sphere and the courts. This seems to me tautological: pueblos survived because they had the skills to do so. Moreover, this putative flexibility can be turned upside down, to be seen as inflexibility in the face of changing forms of state power, and of the moral and legal standing of indigenous people and their communities. From this point of view their flexibility looks more like what Steve Stern has called ‘resistant adaptation’, and the pueblos' negotiation in the service of this inflexibility tactical rather than strategic. Despite these problems of argument, the book has much to offer in the way of carefully, even lovingly, deployed archival evidence and illuminating anecdote, a good account of the changing Mexican legal system as it bore upon indigenous people and their claims to village lands, and an articulate depiction of the broad continuity in their efforts to retain those lands through courts sometimes more sympathetic, sometimes less so.
