The focus of this work is fourth- to sixth-century mosaic pavements from Israel and Jordan. These are divided into various iconographic categories, for instance Biblical scenes, depictions of rural life, Nilotic scenes, etc., each of which is considered in a separate chapter. Wider themes are then considered in four chapters: evidence for iconoclasm; a comparison of pavements in churches and synagogues; the identification of workshops; and a final consideration of iconography and meaning. Much of the book draws on Hachlili's numerous previous publications on the mosaics of the region.
One of the strengths of the book is its comparison of Jewish and Christian iconography, and H. successfully draws out the different attitudes to representation implicit in the mosaic schemes of church and synagogue. Scenes of everyday life found in church pavements are absent from their Jewish counterparts, which focus instead on the depiction of Jewish ritual objects, the wheel of the zodiac, and Biblical scenes. H. interprets this as an attempt to forge a distinctively Jewish identity for these buildings and the people who gathered in them. Mosaics in churches, meanwhile, would be perfectly at home in domestic and public buildings. The themes represented in the churches, and the zodiac scenes in the synagogues, sit comfortably within trends in mosaic decoration across the late antique world, and many motifs and scenes can be recognized from their preceding high-status renderings in, for instance, the mosaics of Piazza Armerina in Sicily, Santa Constanza in Rome, and the palace of Constantine in Istanbul. Yet in the synagogues, the human form only occurs in two contexts and appears limited to these alone: the representation of figures from the Bible, and personifications in the zodiac scenes. H. argues here for different attitudes to the representation of the human figure which has interesting implications for the later phenomenon of iconoclasm, which she also examines. Interestingly, she finds that the destruction of images in synagogues is far less prevalent than in churches, perhaps showing a more consistent attitude to images and what was considered appropriate in Jewish practice than the extremes of iconophilism and iconoclasm evident in the Byzantine Christian church. There are also other differences between Christian and Jewish representations, even where a common theme exists. H. makes the case, for instance, for different interpretation of similar themes by Jewish and Christian audiences. Biblical scenes, which for Jews represented the salvation of their people, were used by Christians to prefigure the salvation of individuals made possible by Christ. We see here the increasing divergence of the Christian religion from its Jewish origins by the fourth to sixth centuries a.d. It is a pity, therefore, that H. chooses to omit mosaics of the second and third centuries a.d., a crucial period of religious development. It seems an odd decision to include mosaics of the first century b.c. to first century a.d. instead; this short section at the beginning of the book does not add anything to our understanding of the later mosaics which are clearly the principal subject.
Definitive interpretations of the more generic iconographic themes found on mosaic pavements are clearly difficult. In many of the chapters, a common structure is evident: following on from admirably exhaustive descriptions and illustrations of the mosaics, the competing scholarly expositions of a particular mosaic subject are laid out by H. in heavily abbreviated summaries. Without, in my view, directly confronting these interpretations, H. then moves on to her ‘alternative’ idea, that many of the more popular mosaic themes have been chosen from pattern books and are thus devoid of symbolic content — a conclusion which does not necessarily follow in my view. Frequently, she draws a contrast between ‘decorative’ and ‘symbolic’ subject-matter, implying that anything ‘decorative’ has no actual meaning. This is too much of a simplification. It also conflicts with her recognition at other points in the text that meanings can be ascribed by viewers as well as intended by designers and commissioners. Given this, the potential surely remains for any hollowed-out ‘decorative’ scheme to be filled anew with meaning. In any case, as she notes elsewhere, even a design which has become devoid of its original significance can still evoke a reaction in the viewer — pleasure, consolation, the pride of ownership.
Some of the chapters diverge from the above formula to consider other notable aspects of the mosaic schemes. For instance, the chapter on inhabited scroll pavements, often found in churches, includes their symmetrical organization. Following earlier studies, H. observes that the motifs within each scroll compartment are chosen and orientated to deliberately emphasize the central strip of the mosaic, which leads towards the end of the room (and, in church buildings, the altar). This central strip tends to contain static motifs such as baskets of fruit, vessels, etc., which contrasts with the flanking motifs of animals which are directional: they look inwards, creating an axis of symmetry. This is nicely illustrated with drawings showing the directionality of the various motifs. Particularly in her chapters on the synagogue mosaics, H. considers the relationship of the mosaic pavements to the use of the buildings in which they are laid, and this could be taken further in relation to the Christian pavements discussed in this chapter.
Overall this is an impressive volume in many ways, very thorough in its compilation of information and scholarly opinion, and well-presented, with particularly useful and copious illustrations (though quite a large number of typographical errors were noted in the text). It will be a fruitful resource both for those interested in religious aspects of late antique art in general, and for mosaic specialists in particular.
