No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
We live in an age of clashing interpretations of world religions, not only by scholars but by the faithful themselves. This heated “intra-faith” dialogue has eclipsed the more ecumenical interfaith dialogue of the last century. The widely divergent interpretations of Christianity by evangelical fundamentalists, on the one hand, and the liberal-mainstream, on the other, provide a well-known example for Western observers. What is less recognized is the Islamic equivalent of this debate, which features similar adversaries: Islamists versus Islamic reformers. This crucial battle over the soul and the goal of Islam has raged in every Islamic society from Morocco to Indonesia for the past century. The debate continues, with added urgency, among Muslim immigrant communities in the West, whose opinions filter back to Islamic homelands with ease and speed. It is against this backdrop that the relevance of Abdolaziz Sachedina's new book can be evaluated. He is a proponent of Islamic reform, and as a widely traveled Muslim scholar and a polyglot he has had the opportunity to encounter alternative visions of Islam on four continents.
Sachedina's The Islamic Roots of Democratic Pluralism, a timely and meticulous meditation on the affinities of Islam with the values of our complex and diverse global society, unfolds in four chapters and an Epilogue. Establishing the compatibility of the “normative aspects of Islam” as a religion and as a historical and cultural reality with the “pluralistic world order of the twenty first century” (p. 11) is a daunting task, indeed, but the author is well versed in traditional Islamic lore and modern scholarship to face the challenge. Sachedina marshals carefully culled and judiciously assembled theological and historical evidence in defense of a tolerant pluralistic vision of Islam. He aptly characterizes this work as a contribution to an Islamic “theology of inclusiveness.” According to this thesis, the Qur

anic principles of the unity and equality of creation, divinely ordained “mystery” of diversity of religions, and forgiveness and compassion toward all humankind (pp. 23, 103, 109, 119) lead us to a tolerant, humanistic, and pluralistic horizon in Islam. Thus, throughout the book, Sachedina mines rich streaks of textual and historical evidence to articulate a “vocabulary of inter and intra religious understanding” and conduct in Islam (p. 41). The author hastens to remind the reader that his reading of Islam is not just an academic and theoretical extrapolation but an Islamic trait salient enough to have given rise to remarkable instances of pre-modern pluralistic tolerance, such as the “Millet system” of the Ottoman Empire (p. 101).
What of the historical and textual evidence to the contrary? Sachedina contends that instances of intolerance and suppression of human rights and freedoms in Islam are due to historical contingencies such as ethnic rivalries and the realpolitik of the Islamic empire rather than the inner logic or nature of the teachings of Islam. In Sachedina's words: “post Koranic” considerations have tended to eclipse the “Koranic provision for a civil society” based on freedom of conscience, tolerance, and acceptance of plurality of the communities of belief (p. 81).
Even those who would argue that the author has had limited success in proving that Islam is, indeed, a tolerant, pluralistic, and democratic religion would have to agree that Sachedina has succeeded in arguing that such an interpretation of Islam is possible—and, indeed, plausible. After all, this is a hermeneutical exercise reminiscent of similar endeavors in Judaism and Christianity that have led to dramatic revision of those religions in the course of the past three centuries. Sachedina and other reform-minded Muslims are attempting to launch a similar project in Islam. The answer to the rather scholastic question of what justifies a selective retrieval of tolerant, forgiving, and pluralistic strains in a sacred tradition in order to make it compatible with the modern world is that the harsh, intolerant representations of sacred traditions themselves are selective, local, and limited interpretations achieved at the expense of suppressing the forgiving and compassionate aspects of those traditions. Sachedina is keen to demonstrate such instances in the history of Islam (p. 90). On a broader historical and sociological level, the necessity of bold and earnest efforts to reinterpret Islam along democratic, pluralistic, and humanistic themes is beyond question. It is both necessary and desirable to meet the stream of tried and tested ideas of pluralism and democracy from without with innovative reinterpretation of the tradition from within.
From a stylistic point of view, the author's calm, deliberate, and earnest voice, which explicates fine points of Islamic jurisprudence with the same authority as the ideas of such Western thinkers as Georg Simmel, Martin Buber, and John Rawls, is reassuring to the scholarly reader. The general reader, however, may find the first half of the book tiring and difficult to navigate. Arguments appear as if from beyond a gossamer veil of abstraction and at once removed from the palpable realities the book addresses. This book is not, to use a popular expression, a “page turner.” The reader who perseveres will probably end up wishing that the first two chapters of the book were animated with the same lively and engaging prose that pervades the last two chapters.