Philip Roth's lengthy career is characterized by abrupt shifts and about-turns in form and thematic focus. As David Gooblar notes in his engaging new monograph, Roth's “fiction has been defined by a refusal to commit himself to any one idea or position without taking up its opposite in turn” (154–55). Clearly, this presents a challenge to anyone attempting to encompass Roth's career within the confines of an academic study. Gooblar's solution – to group Roth's output into six phases, with a chapter arranged around each – runs certain risks but also provides the basis for some telling insights.
The first chapter examines Goodbye, Columbus in the context of the New York liberal intellectuals. In celebrating “complexity over simplicity, and ambiguity over certainty,” Gooblar maintains, Goodbye, Columbus “takes its place within the discourse of dissent, difficulty, and contradiction so in fashion among liberal intellectuals of the 1950s” (30). Gooblar also investigates the fairly well-trodden issue of the scandalized reception of some of the short stories, especially “Defender of the Faith,” among the American Jewish community. As such, the first chapter offers some insights, but is often heavy on context at the expense of analysis.
Chapter 2 focusses on the revolutionary approach adopted by Roth for Portnoy's Complaint and its gleeful rejection of a “seriousness” which dominated contemporary American Jewish intellectual life and which Roth had initially embraced. As Gooblar describes it, in Portnoy's Roth realizes and relishes the comedy to be had at the expense of those who seek to take themselves seriously. The conclusion here, that Roth learned from writing Portnoy's “that this sort of comedy can be very serious indeed,” is a little glib, but the freeing effect of the novel on Roth's future career is ably demonstrated. Chapter 3 explores this new freedom further, examining in detail the influence on Roth's subsequent writing of Anne Frank and Franz Kafka. For Gooblar, the incorporation of textual versions of these figures and connected ideas into Roth's work of the 1970s establishes an “interesting, apparent outward move in Roth's career” (59). This tension between inward and outward impulses epitomizes Roth's oeuvre for Gooblar, and much of this monograph usefully traces which trend, if either, is dominant at particular points in Roth's career.
Chapter 4 explores the influence of psychotherapy on Roth's work, in particular the way in which The Counterlife represents Roth's rejection of Freud's pessimistic conception of the self, instead favouring the human subject as conceived by narrative therapy. The Counterlife, Gooblar suggests, represents another liberating turning point in Roth's career, as postmodenist playfulness is combined with concepts from narrative therapy in order to develop “increasingly adventurous narrative strategies” (109) that go on to inform Roth's next few books. These autobiographically inflected books – The Facts, Deception, Patrimony, and Operation Shylock – form the basis for the following chapter. Gooblar acknowledges the interplay between Roth's fiction and autobiographical writing, and his sophisticated merging of the two, but is not interested in the precise ontology of these works, claiming that other recent critics have explored this question adequately. Instead, Gooblar sets out to challenge the “simplified reading that equates autobiographic reference with solipsism” (111), suggesting instead that these works represent, amongst other things, “evidence of a renewed concern with the responsibilities of writing about others” (112).
The final chapter comprises Gooblar's analysis of Roth's most celebrated work, the “American Trilogy” of American Pastoral, I Married a Communist, and The Human Stain. In these works, Gooblar perceives a return to Roth's earlier scepticism regarding conformity, but here expanded to encompass all of American society, rather than the earlier restricted focus on the Jewish community. Nevertheless, Gooblar disputes the consensus that the trilogy represents a new outward focus; rather it renews Roth's commitment to maintaining the balance between the inward and the outward. Gooblar thus perceives the trilogy as representing a culmination rather than a “new chapter in Roth's long and varied career” (132).
As this précis of Gooblar's study should suggest, while it offers some pertinent readings, the imposition of a narrative of “major phases” necessitates certain losses. One result is that works which do not fit into Gooblar's model are excluded; this is not especially problematic when minor early works such as Letting Go are omitted, but important texts such as Sabbath's Theatre and The Plot Against America also receive only perfunctory discussion. Likewise, the recent quartet of novellas which, as Gooblar acknowledges in his conclusion, seem bound to comprise another significant phase in Roth's career are barely discussed. Certain potentially reductive and exclusionary characteristics of his model are recognized by Gooblar, however, and he admits that this conception of Roth's career is only one amongst many. As such, Gooblar's study, despite these limitations, is absorbing and recommended for any scholar of Roth's work.
