In telling the story of the Texas Railroad Commission (TRC), William Childs follows what he calls an analytical-narrative approach, using a traditional organizational history to examine larger patterns associated with the development of commission-style regulation in the United States. The TRC, well known for its role in regulating the extraction of oil in Texas, is a good subject for such an approach. Established in 1891 to resolve debates over rates and rules in the Texas railroad industry, the agency eventually gained responsibility for constructing and administering the rules governing three other economic activities in Texas: oil production, trucking, and the sale of natural gas. Given important differences in the dynamics of each market, Childs is able to provide four case examples for the price of one organizational history.
Drawing on a wide range of scholarship, Childs roots the formation of the TRC in a national context. In the mid-nineteenth century, as interstate railroads knitted small regional markets into a national economy, courts and legislators were forced to confront numerous concerns, including those associated with stock fraud, discriminatory rate-setting, and monopolistic pooling. After several decades of legal and legislative experimentation, regulatory commissions emerged as an effective way to establish rates and rules that railroads, shippers, and courts accepted as legitimate. Furthermore, the general strategy of using commissions appeared suitable for all common carriers and utilities whose heavy investment in infrastructure prevented easy entrance and exit from a market.
Childs then turns to Texas and the creation of its railroad commission, initially focusing on the leadership of John Reagan, a railroad reformer who resigned his seat in the U.S. Senate to become the first chair of the Texas agency. Childs then traces the transformation of the TRC into a mature Texas-style Progressive Era organization, capturing changes in the culture and logic of the commission as it wrestled with each new railway-related issue that arose. What emerges is the story of a small organization (still having fewer than 20 employees in 1920) led by pragmatic individuals struggling to promote state-level economic activity while balancing the economic interests of multiple actors. Overlaid on that story is the complicating factor of interstate commerce and an evolving federal relationship.
In the years after World War I, the agency inherited, partly out of convenience and partly due to its expertise in transportation-related activities, responsibility for regulating oil production (1917), natural gas utilities (1920), and motor carriers (1922). In covering the 1920s and 1930s, Childs drops any effort to fit the development of the TRC into tidy periods and focuses instead on the different challenges faced in each new industrial sector. The organization itself split into four separate divisions, each constructing its own regulatory model. The trucking industry, for example, consisted of many independent carriers; these carriers did not necessarily follow fixed routes or owe allegiance to large organizations that could be easily regulated. The natural gas industry, on the other hand, was dominated by common carriers with a heavy investment in infrastructure, but the relationships between producers and consumers differed substantially from those in the railroading. But, according to Childs, it was the TRC's venture into the regulation of oil production that eventually transformed the culture of the agency, placing it at the center of what Childs calls the “civil religion of Texas oil.”
Childs argues that the TRC's success in bringing order to oil production depended on a carefully constructed ideology that legitimized efforts to stabilize prices by rooting those efforts in the ideals of resource conservation. In the early 1920s, when the TRC had just taken on the challenge of regulating oil production, a handful of efficiency-minded advocates of resource conservation were lobbying to change the fundamental rules governing oil extraction. They argued that the rule of capture, which encouraged producers to extract oil as fast as possible, had to be scrapped. Otherwise, the industry would continually face reservoir-draining and price-depressing gluts caused by producers trying to extract more oil than their neighbors. The discovery of the giant East Texas field in the early 1930s rocked the oil industry and pushed the TRC onto the national stage. Under the leadership of Ernest O. Thompson, the agency soon transformed itself into organization capable of controlling oil production levels in Texas enough to stabilize prices. By 1939, the decisions of the TRC, which had grown to 560 employees, influenced the price of oil in national and international markets.
How does this study of the TRC help one to understand the development of commission-style regulation in the United States? Childs summarizes, in a succinct conclusion, the key points, most of which are threads pulled from the rest of the book. The gist, as I see it, is that the rules governing markets are constructed by a variety of interest groups, all struggling to shape the decisions of legislators and regulators in the face of constant technological change and innovative business practices. The TRC and similar regulatory commissions provided an arena for this process, facilitating the construction of rules and rates that promoted economic activity, with regulated companies often welcoming rules that brought order to a market. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the regulation of oil production, with the TRC's role—and conveniently mythical status—being pivotal to entire system.
In The Texas Railroad Commission, Child successfully illustrates how regulatory systems and markets co-evolve. Regulatory commissions, according to Childs, do not merely impose rates and rules on a resistant industry; indeed, among other things, they often codify actions that the private sector attempts to take on their own. I recommend this solid history of the well-known Texas agency to anybody who desires to enrich their understanding of regulatory systems.
