Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T12:45:27.979Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The persistence of large-scale circulation in Rayleigh–Bénard convection

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 August 2021

Ping Wei*
Affiliation:
School of Aerospace Engineering and Applied Mechanics, Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: ping.wei@tongji.edu.cn

Abstract

The time-averaged strength $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta$ of a convective cellular pattern and large-scale circulation (LSC) in the turbulence regime of turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection exhibits a sequence of sharp changes with the Rayleigh number $Ra$. Changes occur when $Ra$ reaches transition values between the conduction, convection, chaotic, transition, soft turbulence and hard turbulence regimes. Measurements were taken from two cylindrical cells with Plexiglas walls and nitrogen gas as the working fluid. The data cover the range $10^{3} \lesssim Ra \lesssim 10^{9}$ at $Pr = 0.72$, where $Pr$ is the Prandtl number and $\varGamma \equiv D/H=1.00$ is the aspect ratio (diameter over height). The cellular pattern strength $\delta$ grows continuously as $Ra$ exceeds the critical value $Ra_c=7300$ for the wall admittance $C=2.02$ in the convection regime. In the oscillation regime, the temperature power spectra at the sidewall show an oscillatory frequency peak. In the chaotic regime, δ is diminished as $Ra$ increases. In the transition regime, $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta$ continues to decrease, nearly to 0. Under soft turbulence where the LSC is formed, $\langle \delta \rangle$ grows with $Ra$ as a cellular pattern in the convection regime, suggesting that LSC reflects a cellular pattern. Under hard turbulence, the LSC flow strength decreases as $Ra$ increases. The Reynolds number $Re$ was also measured based on the LSC turnover time, and it was found that two power laws, $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta \times Ra/Pr = 0.007Re^{3.0}$ and $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta \times Ra/Pr = 15.4Re^{1.76}$, fit the data for $Re<400$ and $Re>400$, respectively.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.A diagram of an RBC cell. The various parts are explained in the text. The black circles on the top and bottom copper conducting plates represent the embedded thermistors. The green circle in the Plexiglas wall represents a thermistor embedded in a blind hole (without penetrating the wall).

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) A diagram of the gas pressure $P$ and temperature drop $\varDelta$ between two convection cells. (b) A diagram of $Pr$ vs. $Ra$. In (a,b), the open symbols represent convection cell A without thermistors disturbing the flow, while the solid symbols represent convection cell B with thermistors inside the fluid.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Examples of temperature profiles measured by sidewall thermistors on the mid-height plane. The measurements were taken at $Ra=6.4\times 10^6$ and $Pr=0.72$ in cell A with nitrogen as the working fluid. In (a), (b), (c) and (d) the dashed lines represent the fitting by the equation $T=T_{w}+\cos (m(\theta -\theta _0))$ with $m=1,2,3$ and $4$, respectively. The solid lines represent the fitting by (3.2).

Figure 3

Table 1.The total Fourier energy $E_{tot}$, and the ratio of Fourier energy and total energy $E_{m}/E_{tot}$ ($m=1,\ldots ,4$) for the examples in figure 3.

Figure 4

Figure 4.The time trace of various quantities for convection regime with $Ra=8.5\times 10^4$. (a) The four temperatures measured at mid-height. (b) The total Fourier energy $10^4E_{tot}/\varDelta ^2$. (c) The ratio of the first Fourier energy mode and total energy $E_1/E_{tot}$. (d) The ratio $E_{m}/E_{tot}$ with $m=2$, 3 and 4. (e) The flow strength $\delta$. (f) The LSC orientation $\theta$.

Figure 5

Figure 5.The time trace of various quantities for oscillation regime with $Ra=1.5\times 10^5$. (a) The four temperatures measured at mid-height. (b) The total Fourier energy $10^4E_{tot}/\varDelta ^2$. (c) The ratio of the first Fourier energy mode and total energy $E_1/E_{tot}$. (d) The ratio $E_{m}/E_{tot}$ with $m=2$, 3 and 4. (e) The flow strength $\delta$. (f) The LSC orientation $\theta$.

Figure 6

Figure 6.The time trace of various quantities for the chaotic regime with $Ra=4.7\times 10^5$. (a) The four temperatures measured at mid-height. (b) The total Fourier energy $10^4E_{tot}/\varDelta ^2$. (c) The ratio of the first Fourier energy mode and total energy $E_1/E_{tot}$. (d) The ratio $E_{m}/E_{tot}$ with $m=2$, 3 and 4. (e) The flow strength $\delta$. (f) The LSC orientation $\theta$.

Figure 7

Figure 7.The time trace of various quantities for the transition regime with $Ra=6.4\times 10^6$. (a) The four temperatures measured at mid-height. (b) The total Fourier energy $10^4E_{tot}/\varDelta ^2$. (c) The ratio of the first Fourier energy mode and total energy $E_1/E_{tot}$. (d) The ratio $E_{m}/E_{tot}$ with $m=2$, 3 and 4. (e) The flow strength $\delta$. (f) The LSC orientation $\theta$.

Figure 8

Figure 8.The time trace of various quantities for the soft turbulence regime with $Ra=1.4\times 10^7$. (a) The four temperatures measured at mid-height. (b) The total Fourier energy $10^4E_{tot}/\varDelta ^2$. (c) The ratio of the first Fourier energy mode and total energy $E_1/E_{tot}$. (d) The ratio $E_{m}/E_{tot}$ with $m=2$, 3 and 4. (e) The flow strength $\delta$. (f) The LSC orientation $\theta$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.The time trace of various quantities for the hard turbulence regime with $Ra=1.1\times 10^8$. (a) The four temperatures measured at mid-height. (b) The total Fourier energy $10^4E_{tot}/\varDelta ^2$. (c) The ratio of the first Fourier energy mode and total energy $E_1/E_{tot}$. (d) The ratio $E_{m}/E_{tot}$ with $m=2$, 3 and 4. (e) The flow strength $\delta$. (f) The LSC orientation $\theta$.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Plots of (a) the single-roll flow strength $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta$ and (b) $\sigma _\delta /\varDelta$ against $Ra$ for cell A. Six dynamical states are labelled. From left to right, they are (I) convection, (II) conduction, (III) chaotic, (IV) transition, (V) soft turbulence and (VI) hard turbulence. The dashed lines are logarithmic function fits to various segments of data serving as visual guides. The vertical lines from left to right are as follows: $Ra_c=7300$, ${Ra_{ch}=1.85\times 10^{5}}$, $Ra_{tr}=6.14\times 10^{5}$, $Ra_{s}=8.38\times 10^{6}$ and $Ra_{h}=9.18\times 10^{7}$. (Here, the oscillation regime between the corresponding $Ra_{o}=1.35\times 10^{5}$ and $Ra_{ch}$ is not shown.) The measurements were taken from cell A for $\varDelta = 4.00$ K (black circles) and $\varDelta = 10.00$ K (red squares).

Figure 11

Figure 11.The ratios of the $m$th mode of Fourier energy to the total Fourier energy $E_{m}/E_{tot}$ ($m=1,\ldots ,4$) against $Ra$. The vertical lines represent the transitions between different dynamic regimes. The measurements were taken from cell A for $\varDelta = 4.00\ \textrm {K}$ (black circles) and $\varDelta = 10.00\ \textrm {K}$ (red squares).

Figure 12

Figure 12.(a) The time-averaged orientation $\langle \theta \rangle$ and (b) the standard deviation $\sigma _\theta$ of the LSC against $Ra$. The vertical lines represent the transitions between different dynamic regimes. The measurements were taken from cell A for $\varDelta = 4.00\ \textrm {K}$ (black circles) and $\varDelta = 10.00\ \textrm {K}$ (red squares).

Figure 13

Figure 13.The p.d.f. distribution of the LSC orientation $\theta$ for various regimes. (a) Convection regime with $Ra=8.5\times 10^4$. (b) Oscillation regime with $Ra=1.5\times 10^5$. (c) Chaotic regime with $Ra=4.7\times 10^5$. (d) Transition regime with $Ra=6.4\times 10^6$. (e) Soft turbulence regime with $Ra=1.4\times 10^7$. (f) Hard turbulence regime with $Ra=1.1\times 10^8$. The vertical lines represent the azimuthal location $\theta =2.0$. The measurements were taken from cell A.

Figure 14

Figure 14.(a) The temperature power spectra located at $\xi =0.063$ and $z/L=0.51$ inside fluid of cell B for $Ra = 7.75\times 10^7$ (soft turbulence). (b) From bottom to top, the temperature power spectrum located at ${\rm \pi} /16$ in the sidewall of cell A for $Ra = 1.35\times 10^5$ with $\varDelta = 10$ K and for $Ra = 1.65\times 10^5$ with $\varDelta =4$ K; both $Ra$ are in the oscillation regime.

Figure 15

Figure 15.(a) Values of $Re$ multiplied by $Ra^{-4/9}Pr^{2/3}$. Squares, this work, cell B, $Pr=0.72$.; black triangles, from Bruno, run ‘C’ of Musilová et al. (2017), $Pr\sim 1$; orange triangles, from Brown et al. (2007), $Pr=3.32$; circles, from Brown et al. (2007), $Pr=4.38$; diamonds, from Brown et al. (2007), $Pr=5.55$. (b) $Re_{f_{0}}Ra^{-1/2}Pr^{0.62}$ against $Ra$.

Figure 16

Figure 16.The measured value of $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta \times Ra/Pr$ as a function of $Re$. Here, $Re_{f_0}$ is based on the peak frequency of the temperature spectra. Measurements are taken at $\xi =0.063, z/L=0.51$ in convection cell B. The dotted-dashed line is a power-law fit $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta \times Ra/Pr=0.007Re^{3.0\pm 0.6}$ to the data $Re<4.5\times 10^{3}$. The solid line is the fit of $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta \times Ra/Pr=15.4Re^{1.76\pm 0.06}$ to the data $Re>4.5\times 10^{3}$. The dashed line is the fit of $18{\rm \pi} Re^{3/2}$, the theoretical prediction from Brown & Ahlers (2008b). The dotted line is the fit of $159Re^{3/2}$ to the experimental data from figure 9 of Brown & Ahlers (2008b) for $Pr=3.3$, $4.4$ and $5.5$.

Figure 17

Figure 17.The experimental data of the LSC flow strength against $Ra$. Open squares, this work from cell A; solid squares, this work from cell B; inverted triangles, data from Brown & Ahlers (2007); triangles, data from Wei & Ahlers (2016); circles, data from He et al. (2016). The dotted line is $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta =0.0047$, which is the value in conduction regime. The dashed line is $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta = 0.20-0.0083\log {Ra}$; The solid line is $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta = 0.068-0.0024\log {Ra}$.

Figure 18

Figure 18.(a) The experimental data of the strength of the cellular pattern against $Ra/Ra_c-1$. Here, $Ra_c=7300$ was fitted from a logarithmic function for the data $Ra_c\leqslant Ra\leqslant 2Ra_c$, shown as dashed lines. The vertical line represents $Ra_c$. (b) The experimental data of the LSC flow strength against $Ra/Ra_s-1$. Here, the onset of soft turbulence $Ra_s=8.38\times 10^6$ was fitted from a logarithmic function for the data $Ra_s\leqslant Ra \leqslant 2.5Ra_s$, shown by the dashed line. In (a,b), the dotted line is the value of $0.0047$ measured in the conduction regime, which is also considered as the measurement error. The solid lines are fitted by equation ${\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta =k(Ra/\eta -1)^{1/2}}$, here $k=0.012$, $\eta =Ra_C$ for (a) and $k=0.010$, $\eta =Ra_S$ for (b).

Figure 19

Table 2.Time-averaged strength $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta$ as a function of $Ra$. Cell A, $\varDelta =4.00$ K and $Pr=0.72$ (circles, figure 10a).

Figure 20

Table 3.Time-averaged strength $\langle \delta \rangle /\varDelta$ as a function of $Ra$. Cell A, $\varDelta =10.00$ K and $Pr=0.72$ (circles, figure 10a).