Credit is a social relationship, and as such, it helps explain the economic fortune of nations. In the last few decades, myriad research has highlighted the relevance of credit in past societies. Recent literature has cast doubt on the conventional chronology of financial development, the distinction between personal relationships and traditional financial structures in the preindustrial world, and the role of impersonal links under modern capitalism. Wasserman’s monograph on the history of credit in seventeenth-century Argentina contributes to the literature by showing how impersonal lending was already a common practice during the Old Regime, and what is more, it was a cornerstone of the economic and social configuration of a Spanish American society.
The book is divided into four key periods of the history of Old Regime Buenos Aires, which are also the four periods for which the author has samples of debt “declarations” (or statements)—collected from four hundred wills. As such, the four parts are: (1) the end of trade permissions with Brazil and the establishment of a temporary route between Andalusia and Buenos Aires (1619–1628); (2) the Atlantic trade crisis and the Portuguese secession (1635–1644); (3) the creation of a royal court of audience in the city and the renewal of trade restrictions by the Crown (1656–1665); and, (4) the emergence of a neighboring competitor, the Colônia do Sacramento (1676–1685).
Wasserman’s work provides an excellent account on how credit tools constituted, in the seventeenth century, the institutional and economic foundations upon which Buenos Aires would build its future. Throughout eight well-structured chapters, the author goes over wide range of economic headwinds that could have blown against the dawn and development of this emerging society located at the southernmost reaches of the Spanish empire. Initially thought as an Atlantic defense port of the Spanish Crown, Buenos Aires had to cope with legal restrictions on commerce, hazardous trade routes, an evanescent currency, and unstable population growth. Such a risky business environment could have hindered the development of trade and credit in this region. Yet, as the monograph explains, a variety of credit contracts and the use of networks of personal connections and notaries allowed economic agents to overcome such an adverse environment.
Thus, the book examines how the rise of key financial instruments allowed the inhabitants of Buenos Aires to evade all the trade and currency restrictions the Spanish Crown had imposed on them, often using credit contracts to convert illicit trade and smuggling operations into legal trades with hefty fees for the credit intermediaries. Debt statements, present in more than two-thirds of the analyzed probate records, illustrate how such state of affairs led Porteños to adapt using myriad forms of public and private credit agreements. For instance, the absence of silver in retail trades led dealers to resort to diverse credit practices that were essential for their economic transactions. Precious metals were less scarce in long-distance operations, but in this case credit tools turned out to be vital to face any repayment deadlines. This status quo eventually allowed for the allocation and redistribution of resources and facilitated the city’s capacity to articulate an economic and commercial network between the Atlantic and the Viceroyalty of Peru.
Payment obligations—known as obligaciones in Spanish, comprised the chief notarial instrument employed in credit operations in Buenos Aires. Such tools were mainly utilized to recognize values corresponding to the small-scaled redistribution of interregional and overseas trade shipments. The obligaciones’ main advantages were twofold: (1) since they allowed parties to officially formalize any transactions not conducted in cash, agents could also be offered legal guarantees when operating with frequent exchanges of prohibited imports or smuggled goods; and, (2) such instruments used to yield substantial interest rates that would have hovered around 10 to 35 percent per year.
Moreover, Wasserman shows how sometimes Porteño agents made use of their extensive social networks to intercede in their credit negotiations, while in other occasions, transactions required the mediation of a Notary—such as the Notaries of France described by Hoffman, Postel-Vinay, and Rosenthal (Priceless Markets: The Political Economy of Credit in Paris, 1660–1870. University of Chicago Press, 2000). Notaries were Crown officials and held a privileged position in a context of asymmetric information, and possessed the capacity to legitimate (legally) a universe of debt agreements based on trade operations of illicit origin. In this manner, trust in its different levels would have become the basis upon which economic activity rested in Old Regime Buenos Aires. In Wasserman’s words, “trust ended up replacing currency” and contributed to bring about an upward shift of the viable economic interactions curve. This turned the port of emerging Buenos Aires into a profitable hub for the Atlantic and interregional trade, and came to take part in the market integration of the area.
As such, Las Obligaciones Fundamentales is bound to become a seminal book on the early history of Buenos Aires. It will become a required reading for economic historians of the period and for students studying the economic roots of modern Argentina.
