Incomes and inequality in select Ottoman regions
Incomes and inequality in the Ottoman Empire can be estimated from the information recorded in tax registers called tahrir defterleri, arguably the most prized, heavily used, but still underutilized sources of Ottoman history.Footnote 1 Although generations of prominent scholars have been fascinated by these registers and numerous historians have used them for a variety of regional and historical studies, their full potential has not been fully utilized in quantitative analysis of questions with a broader comparative dimension, wider geographic coverage, and larger historical significance.
Ottoman tax registers contain an enormous wealth of information about the tax systems, taxable resources, and expected tax revenues from a variety of productive activities. Based on this information, the table shows the preliminary results of a procedure that can be used to estimate how agricultural incomes and inequality varied over time and across regions of the empire. The regions chosen for this illustration represent the empire's geographic diversity in the late 16th century, consisting of Hüdavendigar province in western Anatolia in 1573; the Ajlun, Gazza, Hawran, Jerusalem, Lajjun, Nablus, and Safad districts of the Levant (province of al-Sham) in 1596; and the Hungarian districts of Budapest, Estergon, Gyula, and Novigrad in the 1560s. Because the information is not sufficiently detailed or consistent about towns and uninhabited resources, only rural inhabited settlements have been included in the calculations.
To estimate incomes from tax records, we need a procedure to trace back from taxes to taxable incomes. I calculated each village's income by multiplying the output-taxed items (such as grains) by the taxation factor (inverse of the tax rate) and the input-taxed items (such as land and trees) by eight (based on previous research).Footnote 2 I then subtracted all taxes and fees to determine net income. To facilitate regional and temporal comparisons of income, I converted the unit from the monetary currency of akçe to the more standard dry-volume measure of Istanbul kile (approximately 0.97 Winchester bushels), thereby eliminating the sensitivity of estimates to variations in the prices of products.Footnote 3
Preliminary estimates of income and inequality displayed in the table suggest that mean agricultural incomes were significantly higher in the villages of the Levant and the Hungarian districts than those in Hüdavendigar province in western Anatolia. The distribution of income was also more unequal in western Anatolia, as can be seen from the significantly higher Gini coefficient.
Before interpreting these preliminary estimates as evidence of significant regional disparities, researchers are encouraged to revise them with better data, improved procedure, and more reliable external information. Even though future research may adopt the same procedure and confirm these disparities, there is much work to do in estimating incomes and inequality in other periods and regions of the empire and in comparing them with other parts of the world.
