Told that her ‘exhausted energies’ could be restored to ‘enable them to make a living after the jewels had given out’, novelist Gertrude Atherton extolled the benefits of endocrine rejuvenation in her 1923 novel Black Oxen. Her story illustrates the century-long romance between youth, vigour and sex hormones revealed in two excellent books that address complementary aspects of that romance. In The Most Secret Quintessence of Life, Chandak Sengoopta deals with scientific and medical developments in a work spiced with examples (like Atherton's) from literature. Using sources from England, Central Europe and America, Sengoopta shows how the ‘new’ hormonal physiology grew in cultural contexts hungry for physiological plasticity. Reversing the figure-ground, Judith Houck's Hot and Bothered concentrates on individual experience and American culture to frame the role of medicine in the co-construction of menopause. Houck presents older women not as pawns of patriarchal medicine but as part of the dynamic between lived experience and medical advice that shaped views of menopause between 1898 and 1990.
After about 1910, reproductive endocrinology challenged the rigid boundaries that had dominated previous decades between masculine and feminine. Neural ‘solidism’, which saw the gonads as ‘nodes in the immense network of nerves’ (Sengoopta, p. 21), gave way to fluid and malleable humouralism, as glandular research dethroned both the ovarian model of femininity (the ovary as a ‘node in the neural web’ (p. 21) thought to radiate from the pelvis) and neural control of the testicles. This change had a deeply cultural aspect. Before talk of hormones, normal ovaries were often excised to treat ‘conditions’ like nymphomania; the testes, by contrast, were not much tampered with, because sexuality was not considered the mainstay of male relevance. And whilst the images of youthfulness, beauty, vigour and normalcy that hormones offered were often framed by cultural stereotypes of masculinity and femininity, ageing and homosexuality became deficiency diseases, treatable with hormones to restore masculine and feminine bodies in decline.
Sengoopta's superb integration of sources from physiology, gynaecology and literary fiction illustrates how social and scientific temptations shaped endocrinology. As he shows, the work of reproductive endocrinologist Eugen Steinach was central. Steinach's experimental hermaphrodites and his procedure for rejuvenating the elderly appeared at about the same time that Serge Voronoff announced the invigorating impact of transplanted monkey gonads. The public, if not the entire scientific community, eagerly embraced the utopian possibilities. Summarizing studies of the ovarian cycle, Steinach's glandular transplants, and the later researches of Bernhard Zondek, Carl Moore and Steinach, Sengoopta recounts the rise and demise of the autonomy of sex glands. By 1935 hormonal ‘ambisexuality’, the power of the pituitary gland and the rise of biochemistry complicated any simple picture of the sex glands' impact. Sengoopta stresses the reciprocal interplay between lab-based endocrine physiology on animals and clinical treatment to explain why the promise of sex hormones persisted (they restored ovarian cyclicity in rodents) and the reasons why that promise went unfulfilled. Many outcomes depended not just on oestrogens, androgens and progestins, but on the pituitary and the thyroid. The artificial synthesis of hormones in the 1930s led to a de-emphasis on autonomous sex glands in favour of chemical balance within a multiglandular complex that eventually, again, included the brain. But into the 1950s, often with outmoded physiology, clinicians still used ‘sex’ hormones to treat a range of reproductive and non-reproductive disorders (such as homosexuality and cancer) in their effort to restore ‘normal’ heterosexual life.
Because women were seen as ‘the embodied sex’, their waning reproductive functions posed deep cultural issues about what womanhood is after reproductive potential has gone. Houck examines menopause as a threat that focused the problem of what women should be when childbearing becomes irrelevant. Drawing on the popular magazines and advice books aimed at middle-class white women, and making excellent use of the surveys through which women voiced their own experiences and preferences, Houck examines the early part of the twentieth century, when menopause was not regarded as a medical problem; the 1940s and 1950s, when rigid gender roles saw a judgemental medical community recommend that women silently grin, bear it, and get busy in gender-appropriate volunteer work; and the period after 1960, when Robert Wilson's Feminine Forever (1966) presented menopause as a debilitating woman's disease that could be ‘cured’ by lifelong oestrogen replacement. The first period saw older women through societies' ‘maternalist ideology’. Women were mothers, and when their reproductive functions waned hardly anyone noticed. Eventually, physicians saw menopause as a minor transition, but women were demonized for exacerbating it. Physicians assumed that women brought on their own surges of emotionality, depression and anxiety, as feminine superstition, gossip and too much idle time for bridge produced a psychological overreaction. The popular literature even warned that menopausal self-pity ‘poisoned’ marriage, leading husbands to seek sexual liaisons with younger women. By the 1970s, oestrogen treatment quadrupled, as Wilson and the drug companies that funded him tried to instil fear of the decrepit and valueless lives that menopause caused.
Houck's treatment is most original and convincing for the third period. Acknowledging that Wilson's approach was entirely sexist, she argues that earlier historical accounts overstate his impact on the medical community – there was no misogynistic medical consensus on the value of oestrogen therapy – and on women. Neither fully bought the value of lifelong oestrogen therapy or the disease concept. Instead, physicians challenged Wilson's alarmist rhetoric, raising genuine medical concerns about cancer and osteoporosis. Aided by the women's movement, many women chose their own course. Though some feminists condemned Wilson, others praised him because he motivated women to retain control of their bodies and helped challenge the patriarchy of the traditional doctor–woman relationship. Paradoxically, after the 1975 oestrogen cancer scares, debates about Wilson's views focused society on women's health and gave women options. Though her writing sometimes seems repetitive, Houck does an admirable job of presenting the diversity of – and interplay between – medical views, advice and the lived experiences of women. There was no single menopausal experience. The father-knows-best self-presentation of mid-century medicine masked the rumblings of enormous change that affected different women in different ways. Houck even speculates that the rise of oestrogen use in the 1960s had as much to do with America's emerging drug culture as with a plot to feed women oestrogen. She notes, for example, that many women were given oestrogen only when they demanded it after the Valium first prescribed by their physicians was ineffective.
Sengoopta also addresses menopause, revealing important cultural differences early in the century. Interestingly, however, only Sengoopta deals with male menopause. The condition was widely recognized in Europe and America between 1910 and 1950. But in the co-construction of gender and menopause, male menopause was not primarily an endocrine problem. Because a man's life was so much broader, male climacteric was often treated as nervous and mental in nature, more the province of psychiatry than of endocrinology. But as hormone therapy became widely available, clinicians gave testosterone (and oestrogen) to menopausal men, just as they gave oestrogen (and testosterone) to women. Sengoopta's account stops just before Wilson presented menopause as a uniquely female disease. Perhaps this, too, is part of Wilson's legacy. As they debated the disease issue in women, doctors and scientists deconstructed male menopause. Meanwhile, the shift to youth, beauty and sex allure over motherhood as criteria for women's ‘worth’ deepened a gender division that rendered the male climacteric obsolete.
