Following the French takeover of Algiers in 1830 and through its defeats at the Battle of Isly in 1844 and in the war against Spain fifteen years later, the Alawaite sultanate of Morocco came under growing political and economic pressure from Europe's leading powers. The “Moroccan Question,” what fate would await the Sharifian empire within the context of a rapidly partitioned African continent, became a constant feature in late 19th-century European diplomacy and was ultimately resolved in 1904 when Great Britain recognized the special interest of France in Morocco. Eight years and two international crises later, Morocco was forced to sign away its independence and accept a Franco–Spanish protectorate regime.
Great Britain's role in shaping Morocco's fate during the past eight decades of its precolonial existence, thus, is paramount. From the mid-1840s to the mid-1880s, Britain's interests in Morocco were in the hands of its representative in Tangier, Sir John Drummond-Hay. Single-handedly at times, this old-fashioned diplomat shaped not only his country's policies toward Morocco but those of other European powers as well. It is hardly surprising, therefore, that Drummond-Hay is placed at the center of the monograph under review.
A bit like his subject, Khalid Ben-Srhir is an old-fashioned diplomatic historian in the best sense of this title. Having spent a good portion of his life in the British Public Record Office, Ben-Srhir has a familiarity with the documentary record on Morocco probably second to none. His extensive archival work—including some hitherto untapped series and a significant array of printed sources in Arabic, English, and French—has enabled Ben-Srhir to present the most detailed, balanced account of bilateral relations between the two countries ever written. As Daniel Schroeter notes in his forward, no previous study has “succeeded in giving the Moroccan perspective on this relationship the way this book does” (p. xv).
Ben-Srhir opens his book with a brief history of Anglo–Moroccan relations before 1850, concluding with the appointment in 1845 of the twenty-nine-year-old Drummond-Hay to succeed his father, who had served as Britain's Consul-General in Tangier since 1829. In the first of the book's six chapters, Ben-Srhir delineates the negotiations that produced the 1856 Anglo–Moroccan Treaty that redefined commercial ties between the two countries and greatly facilitated European economic intrusion and the destabilization of Morocco's social and economic infrastructure.
Professing (and quite possibly genuinely believing) that free trade would best serve Morocco's long-term interest, Drummond-Hay pursued a vigorous opening of Moroccan markets for European importation. In the process, he bullied the sultan, Mawlay עAbd al-Rahman, and his representatives into compliance. In February 1856, for example, facing a critical deadline in the negotiations, Drummond-Hay “proposed that one of Her Majesty's ships of war should be sent by the Admiralty to Moroccan waters … to convince the Moroccan rulers that the British Government was prepared to resort to force to compel it to yield” (p. 44).
Similar tactics would reappear in the next stage of the relationship, during the brief Spanish–Morocco conflict of 1859–62 (Tetuan War) and the peace settlement brokered by Britain. Discussing the unfolding of the trilateral relationship, Ben-Srhir illustrates the clear ulterior motive behind the British mediation: pressure on the makhzan to pay heavy reparations to regain the occupied northern city of Tetuan. The money to cover those reparations came from a British loan, facilitated by Drummond-Hay, a move that “greatly increased his standings in Makhzan circles” and allowed “London financiers” to profit (p. 110).
In chapter 3, Ben-Srhir covers commercial transactions between Britain and Morocco in the two decades after the signing of the 1856 treaty. Drawing on numerous British reports on the volume of bilateral trade, he illustrates the impact of the treaty “to the irreversible opening of the Moroccan market” as well as to the “marked increase in the number of Europeans pouring into Morocco, the majority of whom were British” (p. 120). Makhzan attempts to halt the foreign intrusion and avoid the erosion of its authority over the indigenous society focused mostly on the growing practice of consular “protection” granted to native Moroccans, many among them Jews. In chapter 4, citing numerous incidents involving protégés, Ben-Srhir describes Drummond-Hay's rather halfhearted attempts to help the makhzan alleviate the problem all the way through the 1880 Madrid Conference. At that international gathering, Morocco found itself supported by Spain and Britain alone as the concluding resolution gave “further support and legitimacy to the principle of consular protection.” Thus, “[t]he Sultan's hopes had been dashed and Britain's policy regarding Morocco frustrated” (pp. 192–93).
Drummond-Hay was similarly frustrated in his frequent attempts to convince the sultan to implement structural reforms in Morocco's economy and agricultural production, the makhzan administrative system, and local governance—a matter covered in chapter 5. The consul was able to introduce a regular pay scale for port officials charged with Morocco's foreign trade (pp. 234–39); however, attempts to extend that principle to other functionaries of the state failed to carry the day. In assessing Drummond-Hay's motivation for implementing those measures, Ben-Srhir asserts that, although he “adopted a discourse of reforms, it was to serve the goal of bringing Morocco to serve European interests in general and British interests in particular” (p. 245). The same could be said of his involvement in the military reforms pursued by Mawlay al-Hasan during the 1870s.
Drummond-Hay was frustrated in his final diplomatic endeavor, an attempt to persuade the sultan to renew the 1856 bilateral agreement. Soon afterward, in August 1886, he was retired by the Foreign Office and replaced by a new representative. In the twenty-six years that would pass between Drummond-Hay's departure from Tangier and the end of Moroccan independence, London would be represented by several diplomats, none of whom would regain his stature. Meanwhile, the Anglo–French rapprochement and the signing of the Entente Cordiale in 1904 would mark a British departure from the policy exercised throughout the second half of the 1800s to protect and guarantee Morocco's sovereignty and independence vis-à-vis other European powers. To be sure, that policy was not derived from any altruistic motives. Rather, as Ben-Srhir asserts in his concluding remarks, “Britain was only interested in safeguarding its Mediterranean interests” (pp. 281–82). Be that as it may, the fact remained that, more than any other factor, Britain's policy toward Morocco delayed for several decades the demise of precolonial Morocco and its passing under direct European domination.
For anyone interested in the modern history of Morocco, Ben-Srhir's study, published originally in Arabic in Morocco, offers an invaluable contribution. Given the quality of this work, one should assume—and hope—that the author's follow-up study of the period between 1886 and 1904 will also be made available in English translation.
