This volume consists of seventeen essays first presented at a 2004 conference at the University of Saskatchewan, the home of Canada's national facility for synchrotron light research (CLS). The opening of the enormously expensive CLS seemed an appropriate occasion to reflect on the complex and increasingly important relations between public science and democracy. (Although ‘public science’ is not defined, it is apparently meant to encompass issues – such as global warming, genetically modified organimsms and stem-cell research – that are subject to public deliberation.) Participants from Canada, Europe, the United States and Australia were invited to explore three broad questions: is it possible for science to maintain independence and objectivity in the face of increasing commercial and political pressures? Can a genuine public discourse exist when the views of experts are privileged? Can scientific knowledge and methodology be made compatible with the integration required by public discourse and policy formation and, if so, with what consequences for scientific objectivity?
These are indisputably significant questions. A trend towards greater public participation in scientific and technical policymaking has been evident in many parts of the world, prompting political theorists and others to focus on the mechanisms by which laypersons can effectively engage with the governance of science and technology. One result has been a lively debate on the normative justifications for and efficacy of competing approaches as well as concerns that many initiatives may constitute a form of marketing rather than genuine engagement. Given the considerable Canadian interest in developing concrete ways to democratize participation in science policymaking, the topic would seem a natural for a symposium on public science in liberal democracies. Unfortunately, it is a lost opportunity, as none of the essays seriously engage with either the theoretical debates or empirical findings in this literature.
Within the field of science studies, the trend towards wider participation has revitalized an old debate over the privileging of scientific experts and expertise in policy formation. Thus, in 2003, Harry Collins and Robert Evans, concerned that the pendulum had swung too far in the direction of populism, famously argued the need for a ‘third wave’ in science studies that would acknowledge the need for expertise. The diverse and sometimes passionate reactions to their proposal indicate that the controversy over the role of scientists in a democracy will not end any time soon – as is perhaps to be expected given that, in its more general form, the issue of expertise in a democratic polity stretches back to the Greeks. Alas, this volume contributes little to the existing discussion on the governance of science in liberal democracies. Indeed, it is not clear that either the editors (who make the astounding claim that the conference topic is ‘relatively unexplored’) or some of the authors are familiar with the work of Yaron Ezrahi, Sheila Jasanoff, Brian Wynne, Michel Callon, Bruno Latour or other historians and sociologists of science who write on the topic. At least, several essays are written as though that body of scholarship did not exist.
As is often the case with conference proceedings, there is great variation in the quality of individual essays. The volume does contain some nuggets. Steven Shapin has contributed a brief but engaging reflection on the science of dietetics, which asks why the views of academic experts carry so little weight with the public. Shapin suggests that credentialled experts are seen as interested parties and, in contrast to popular diet-book authors, both ignore the social and emotional meaning of food and frame their conclusions in terms of populations, whereas their readers are interested in themselves. The essay by Gordon McOuat takes a long view of debates over science and politics. He notes that science studies, whatever its other virtues, has been generally uninterested in the longue durée, and argues that as a consequence of its emphasis on the local, the field has missed important questions about the environment in which science operates. McOuat sketches an intriguing programme to use the tools of science studies to ask big questions – specifically, how the norms of scientists working in genetics/genomics laboratories are changing in response to changing forms of scientific funding and research. In one of the few essays with a comparative dimension, political scientists Grace Skogstad and Sarah Hartley discuss ‘the legitimation conundrum’ in Canada. Using the case of agri-foods, they show how the Canadian tradition of deference to authority (scientific and otherwise) has been destabilized by internal and external developments, such as the institutionalization of the precautionary principle in Europe, and they draw from the UK experience to suggest how the conundrum might be resolved.
But these and other individually interesting contributions do not add up to a coherent volume. The essays reflect disparate disciplinary and ideological perspectives, with some authors applauding the same policies or practices that others either explicitly or implicitly deplore. That diversity could have been a real plus had the authors engaged with each other or the editors made a serious effort to integrate the arguments. But as it is, to read the book through (which perhaps only a reviewer would) is to experience a kind of intellectual whiplash as assumptions taken for granted in one essay are implicitly repudiated in another. Thus authors variously assume that scientific expertise is fundamentally objective (and should count for more in policymaking) and that it is always informed by cultural and political values (and should count for less); that Mertonian norms are passé and that they must be defended; that the problem of climate change demands a radical response and that activists accountable to no one exaggerate the certainty of the scientific knowledge that legitimizes state action; that citizens are woefully ignorant of science and that the ‘deficit model’ is bunk – and so on. Making matters worse, the volume does not even include an index, so that only a reader with a photographic memory could actually compare claims in the various contributions. BJHS readers interested in any of the individual essays would do well to borrow this expensive hardcover book from a library.
