Memories, narratives and ideas of martyrdom were of great importance to the identity of the early Church. Indeed, martyrs arguably became even more important once imperial sponsored persecution had ceased, both as objects of competitive cult, and as weapons in intra-ecclesial conflict. This volume, arising out of a 2011 workshop at Göttingen, assembles a number of English and German essays on martyrologies of the fourth and fifth centuries a.d. Tellingly, the editors’ chronological limits for the study are variously stated as ‘300–450’ (in the book's title), ‘350–450’ (1) and ‘350–400’ (7); in fact, many of these essays range earlier than the fourth century, and some go well beyond the mid-fifth century (in particular Bumazhnov). This demonstrates the difficulties of trying to establish a cut-off point in late antique martyrology, and of trying to tame texts which are often hard to date and incorporate multiple layers of oral and written tradition.
The book falls into four sections: on general questions, Greek hagiography, Latin hagiography, and non-Roman martyrs and martyrologies. Barnes opens by foregrounding his long-held views that Tertullian can be used to control the picture of the persecuted Church provided by Eusebius, and that persecution ended not with Constantine, but with Gallienus in a.d. 260. Barnes is optimistic about the possibilities of recovering some kind of historical reality from early — that is, roughly contemporary — martyrology. He locates the invention of hagiographical fiction in the fourth century under Julian and finishes by showing how two Greek texts of the fourth and early fifth centuries reveal the spread of hagiographical literary features into other genres. Next in this section, Baumeister covers a lot of chronological ground in surveying Jewish, philosophical and other ideas of martyrdom, including a useful survey of Butterweck's work.
On Greek texts, Corke-Webster dates Eusebius’ Martyrs of Palestine before the Ecclesiastical History, and thus reads it as an early experiment in literary manipulation. Eusebius emphasizes the bestial rage and lack of self-control of persecuting state officials in the face of the calm endurance of the martyrs; Corke-Webster suggests that this reflects Roman models of paternal authority, although it also surely draws on Greek philosophical ideals and Jewish texts such as 2 and 4 Maccabees, as outlined by Baumeister. Corke-Webster finishes neatly by arguing that Eusebius is elevating educated, senior Christian martyrs over state officials as part of a bigger project to promote the clergy as the new bearers of the Roman right to rule. Gemeinhardt shows that the Life of Antony should be read as a martyrological text which encompasses features of the hagiographic passio and the philosophical, especially Neoplatonic, vita. He concludes that Athanasius is presenting Antony as a new kind of living martyr, itself a model for Athanasius’ self-presentation as a martyr for the Nicene cause. This reminds us of Barnes’ earlier discussion of the polemical post-mortem representation of John Chrysostom as a martyr; both examples demonstrate that martyrdom continued to be a live category long after the end of persecution, and was regularly appropriated by Christians during intra-ecclesial conflict. Finally, in this section, Mühlenberg productively compares and contrasts the homilies of Basil of Caesarea and Gregory of Nyssa on the forty martyrs of Sebaste.
On Latin texts, Kuhlmann expertly unpicks some of the semantic, intertextual and metrical features of Prudentius’ Peristephanon, suggesting that they show Prudentius appealing to the cultural and social values of the Roman élite. Dupont deftly deals with a big body of evidence in an essay on the theological significance of martyrdom in a selection of Augustine's sermons. He shows that in sermons against the Donatists, Augustine focused on his opponents’ lack of the right causa or motivation in dying, and in sermons against the Pelagians, he concentrated on Christians’ reliance on divine grace. However, in his sermons on martyrs, he deployed both his anti-Donatist distinction between causa and poena, and his anti-Pelagian emphasis on grace. Finally, Tamas examines the Passio of Pollio and concludes that it is a late fourth-century fabrication, rather than a contemporary record of Diocletian's great persecution in Pannonia, and that it was designed to act as a manual of Christian orthopraxis.
In the final section, Leemans characterizes the Passio of the late fourth-century Sabas the Goth as a hagiographic text promoting its exemplary subject, and locates it against the charged background of the development of his cult in Cappadocia. Bumazhnov examines a story told by Isaac of Nineveh about the dangerous consequences of exercising mercy, and shows that it ultimately derives from earlier Syriac discourse as visible in the Liber Graduum.
In terms of presentation, there are some infelicities in some of the non-Anglophone authors’ English essays, principally in non-idiomatic turns of phrase, sentence constructions, and uses of prepositions, as well as some typos (e.g. ‘hagiogra-phical’ and ‘Chris-tian’ (27)). Practices of citation and translation of ancient sources vary widely. On the plus side, footnotes throughout are full and helpful, and indices of scripture, ancient writers and modern authors are to be welcomed.
These essays generally have a narrow focus, examining one martyr, text, or set of texts in considerable depth. As such, the main value of this book is in the contribution of individual chapters to our understanding of particular corners of martyrological literature, some hitherto rather obscure. There are a variety of emphases, from readings which prioritize historical and contextual factors, to those which offer more theoretically informed literary analysis. Certain important topics appear repeatedly, such as the polemical appropriation of martyrdom by or for some individuals and denial of it to others, and the rhetorical construction of the martyr according to existing literary tropes. Overall, this volume usefully contributes to the growing body of literature on hagiography and martyrology.
