In Intersecting Inequalities, Jelke Boesten sets out to better understand state–society relations in contemporary Peru through an analysis of three specific social policies that primarily affect women: poverty policy, reproductive health policy and family violence policy. Boesten's methods are multidisciplinary: she combines archival research in Peruvian feminist collections with interviews and other primary materials like local mothers' club logbooks and NGO evaluations. The result is an engaging bottom-up account of how social policies are understood by rural and urban poor women in Peru.
Boesten's study evaluates the above-named social policies with an eye to evaluating how they affected the quality of citizenship for poor women in Peru in the 1990s and early 2000s. She argues that the quality of women's citizenship is mediated by the pre-existing and intersecting inequalities of gender, race and class. Boesten highlights that there is often a disjuncture between a policy on paper and how it is implemented and understood on the ground, and this disjuncture stems from sexism, racism and classism present in both Peru's state institutions and society that prevent policies from taking hold in a straightforward manner. Her argument and her interdisciplinary approach speak most directly to gender and women's studies and development studies audiences, who will also appreciate her ethnographic detail.
The book is organised with an introduction, an historical chapter, three case studies on each of Boesten's social policies, and a conclusion. The historical chapter, starting in 1948 and extending to the year 2000, provides a broad overview of the history of state social policies directed at women, the maternalist gender discourses produced and disseminated by the state, and the history of women's grassroots organisations. It serves as a good starting point for the book, and for scholars that want an overview of these issues in Peru. I found some really interesting nuggets of information in this chapter, but it is primarily a broad-brush treatment of the major trends.
In chapter 3, ‘Food Aid, Motherhood and Women's Work’, Boesten presents her first case study, on anti-poverty policies centred on food distribution. These include Peru's ‘Glass of Milk’ programme, mothers’ clubs and community kitchens, all of which are primarily run by women in poor communities but financed in whole or part by the state. Boesten's focus is on how these food organisations became increasingly prone to clientelism and corruption in the 1990s. She traces how on the one hand, the state used a discourse of maternalism to recruit women volunteers, and how on the other, women also used this discourse as a ‘shield’ to defend their participation in these public activities against suspicious husbands or even suspicious members of the Sendero Luminoso (Shining Path, SL) guerrilla group. The most fascinating portion of this chapter is an account of how women members of a mothers’ club in Ayacucho used their club as a base from which to resist the violence of SL in the region. (I only wish that Boesten had further developed the link between the mothers’ clubs and resistance against violence based on these powerful examples, but the connection is not returned to in the conclusion or in the concluding portion of the chapter.) Boesten concludes that despite the potential of these grassroots food distribution organisations to empower, poor women who were recruited and depended upon by the state to distribute food aid in poor communities became increasingly enmeshed in the clientelistic hierarchies that evolved over the decade.
Chapter 4 focuses on population policies under the Fujimori government in the 1990s. Boesten recites the history of this difficult period in Peruvian family planning policy, in which President Fujimori spearheaded a state-sponsored policy that advocated the sterilisation of primarily poor, rural and indigenous women. Fujimori's motives were suspect; on the one hand he purported to be offering women a ‘choice’ of surgical sterilisation, while in reality many of these women did not have a full understanding of the operation to which they had agreed. Boesten's contribution in this chapter lies in her analysis of rural women's self-understandings of their sexual health and rights. She draws her analysis from a series of ‘self-diagnoses’ carried out by the Peruvian feminist NGO Manuela Ramos with rural women in the department of Huancavelica as part of its USAID-financed ReproSalud project. Boesten's analysis of the ‘diagnoses’ provides valuable insights into how rural Peruvian women understand menstruation, pregnancy and even family relations. While Boesten condemns the sexism, racism and classism of the Peruvian government as it carried out its population control policy, she also points to the positive effect of the ReproSalud project, which served to empower rural women in small-scale ways.
Boesten then turns to her final case study, on family violence policy. She outlines the emergence of the law against family violence and its evolution over time, including obstacles to quality implementation. The chapter focuses on the stories of a few women leaders of grassroots organisations who were also victims of domestic violence. The stories provide insight into the roots of domestic violence as well as the links between family violence and the broader history and context of violence in Peru. Interestingly, and supporting her overall focus on how women affect citizenship from the bottom up, Boesten cites a survey that shows that women engaged in community organisations are less likely to suffer from domestic violence.
In sum, this book will be of special interest to scholars of Peru and of gender and development, especially those who want to better understand policies through the eyes of those most affected.
