On the morning of Sunday, October 30, 2005, the five-piece Christian rock group known as David Crowder*Band (DC*B) found themselves on a golf course in sunny Orlando, Florida.Footnote 1 On any other Sunday morning, they would have been in Waco, Texas, providing music for the services at University Baptist Church (UBC)—a church of about six hundred members which was co-founded by DC*B front man, David Crowder. But on this particular Sunday morning, the band was in the middle of a thirty-three-city tour promoting their fourth full-length release, A Collision (or 3 + 4 = 7). Stylistically, the album represented a sharp departure from the band's prior output, which had consisted of three full-length records of tightly constructed, pop-styled “praise and worship” songs designed for use in congregational singing.Footnote 2 By contrast, A Collision is a sprawling and conceptually challenging record which takes its listeners through a remarkably diverse collection of cover songs, original compositions, and far-flung sampled sounds.
The album was released just a few days before the start of the tour to overwhelmingly positive reviews and would go on to garner the band's first and only Grammy nomination, as well as its first two Dove Awards from the Gospel Music Association. By all accounts, this was an exciting time for the band until their golf outing was suddenly interrupted by an urgent telephone call from Crowder's wife, Toni. Back at UBC, lead pastor and close friend of the band, Kyle Lake, was slated to perform a series of baptisms in front of a larger than usual crowd due to homecoming weekend at nearby Baylor University. As Lake waded into the baptismal waters in front of a crowd of nearly eight hundred parishioners, he reached out to adjust the microphone and was hit by a surge of electricity. Attempts to revive Lake were unsuccessful, and he was pronounced dead at the hospital less than an hour later. Unable to alter their tour schedule on such short notice, DC*B played their engagement that night in Orlando before returning to Waco for Lake's funeral on November 1.
As Crowder commented in an interview several months later, the events of that October morning irrevocably changed the band, not only because of their personal connections to Lake and to the community of people who witnessed his death but also because of the ways in which this tragic loss was already inscribed in their music. A Collision takes death as its central theme, designed in response to a number of parishioners at UBC who found themselves grieving the unexpected deaths of family and friends due to cancer. Having such an unexpected death interrupt a concert tour designed around the idea of death is strange enough, but what's more is that Lake had been crucial in DC*B's design for the album's overall scheme. Crowder observes that after Lake's passing “our church [was] left with a soundtrack of what we're going through—what we need. Yet he was the one that helped put it out there.”Footnote 3 In the minds of those most closely associated with UBC and DC*B, the coincidence between the content of the record and the conditions of its creation meant that A Collision came to represent a final divine message delivered by Lake to his congregation.
This intimate connection between the theme of death and Lake's passing also forged a new relationship among the diverse borrowed musical materials present throughout the album. In June 2006, the band released a “companion album” to A Collision entitled B Collision or (B is for Banjo), or (B Sides), or (Bill), or Perhaps More Accurately (…the Eschatology of Bluegrass). On this shorter EP release, the band reworked some of the songs from A Collision in a “bluegrass” style and added covers of tunes by Del McCoury and Loretta Lynn. Although the presence of bluegrass and southern gospel music on A Collision had been limited to just four of the twenty-one tracks (totaling just ten of seventy-three minutes), suddenly in retrospect, these became the interpretive centerpieces of the album. Just a few months after B Collision was released, Crowder and bandmate Mike Hogan published a book entitled Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven, but Nobody Wants to Die, or (the Eschatology of Bluegrass) in which they explicitly connect the difficulties of Lake's tragic death to what they see as the inherent spirituality of bluegrass music.Footnote 4 Their final record as a band, Give Us Rest Or (A Requiem Mass in C [The Happiest of All Keys]) released in January 2012, concludes with a fifteen-minute bluegrass-gospel medley, consisting of songs drawn from the Baptist Hymnal, the Gaither Vocal Band, and a new gospel composition entitled “Jesus, Lead Me to Your Healing Waters.”
In each of these instances, the band narrates a transformation of their relationship to bluegrass-gospel music during the ensuing seven years: from the omnivorous, “hipster” eclecticism on A Collision to a true “hillbilly” sense of musical religiosity on Give Us Rest. DC*B made a name for themselves as part of a wave of pop- and rock-styled “praise and worship” music that began to appear during the mid-1990s.Footnote 5 But even with the widespread adoption of “praise and worship” music in American churches, bluegrass-gospel musics still serve as potent musical signifiers, especially among the white southern evangelicals who are praise and worship's primary demographic. By drawing on Hank Williams, Loretta Lynn, and Bill Gaither, Crowder and his band mates use strategic musical references to establish their own sense of “hillbilly” religiosity but often deploy these references in ways that align them with a “hipster” community of young musicians and music fans. In the essay that follows, I hope to tease out some of the evolving relationships between DC*B and this musical sense of rural southern religiosity, culminating with the breakup of the band and David Crowder's first solo release in November 2012. In each of these instances, I demonstrate the ways that strategic references to bluegrass and gospel music allow DC*B to situate themselves within multiple discourses of evangelical authenticity. Finally, I explore how Crowder continues to hold these two impulses of “hipster” and “hillbilly” in tension through his account of bluegrass-gospel music's power to “re-narrate” past and present.
Bluegrass, the Gospel, and Bluegrass-Gospel
Throughout their book Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven, but Nobody Wants to Die, Crowder and Hogan argue that “bluegrass” is always and essentially a religious style of music. Starting from historian Neil Rosenberg's assertion that Bill Monroe almost always reserved time for hymn singing in his set lists because “it constituted an essential statement of values,”Footnote 6 Crowder and Hogan argue:
The religious element of music was one of the core things that Monroe adapted into his playing, thereby establishing it as one of the primary pieces of bluegrass. … It is most certain that God popped up in many of the old-time folk songs brought over from the British Isles by our Appalachian immigrants, as religion was one of the main reasons they came over in the first place. But the real influence for Monroe in this respect, and for all the bluegrass performers after him, was church music and the old spirituals.Footnote 7
Throughout their discussion, Crowder and Hogan tend to conflate many different strands of religious music-making from the rural American South using “bluegrass” as a blanket term and eventually even using it as a more abstract adjective to describe themselves—“we're bluegrass folks”—or to characterize particular ways of thinking and feeling—“there's nothing more bluegrass than Wikipedia!”Footnote 8 By the end of the book, the word “bluegrass” comes to indicate a kind of authentic being-in-the-world that is characterized by honest Christian engagement with the difficult questions surrounding loss and grief that were most obviously inspired by the traumatic events surrounding Lake's death at UBC. Throughout this essay, I use the term “bluegrass-gospel” to capture Crowder and Hogan's conflation of these myriad strands of southernness, working-class identity, rurality, authenticity, and evangelical religiosity, though I reproduce their uses of “bluegrass” in quotes from DC*B band members.
Of course, close associations between southernness, rurality, working-class identity, and evangelical religiosity are rife throughout popular culture and have been keenly observed by scholars of southern music and religion. Beginning with folklorist Bill Malone's so-called “southern thesis” of country music first laid out in 1968, scholars have interrogated the ways that the country music industry has incorporated Southern American identity markers into its strategies of market and genre development.Footnote 9 Given the ways that “some of its proponents see [bluegrass] as the only true, natural, authentic form of country music,” bluegrass is perhaps even more susceptible to consideration as a unique exemplar of Southern American music and identity.Footnote 10 Historian Robert Cantwell has carefully documented the processes by which bluegrass came to be understood as the “old Southern sound,”Footnote 11 and sociologist Richard A. Peterson has explored the ways that the construction of a bluegrass tradition relies on “the concept of Appalachia as pristine remnant of a bygone natural environment peopled by British American stock, unspoiled by the modernist thrust of urbanization and industrialization.”Footnote 12
This mythos of bluegrass music as the “old Southern sound” and the unspoiled splendor of an imagined Appalachia are precisely the ideas that undergird Crowder and Hogan's discussion of “bluegrass” throughout their book. And they leverage the narrative specificity of these tropes towards a kind of universal applicability that they assume to include the readers of their book.Footnote 13 In their introduction to Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven, Crowder and Hogan offer the following rhetorical vignette:
Have you ever sat quietly in a dark room with only the green glow of stereo lights cracking the black while Ralph Stanley's voice pours lonely from speakers, moving the molecules of air toward you? … Listen to Ralph's voice one night in the dark. You will feel the weight of mortal humanity in it. There is pain in that voice, and it moves fast. Have you heard the banjo of Earl Scruggs? It will quickly break your heart. I promise. Both are voices from a tradition that suffered communally.Footnote 14
For Crowder and Hogan, I think the function of moments like the one above is primarily to provide a sonic grounding for their most abstract theological musings. Their book is a winding and bizarre affair, mixing short fiction, memoir, scholarly nonfiction, and cut-and-paste bricolage—undoubtedly designed to signal a certain hipster omnivorousness to their fans (more below)—but moments like this seem to be designed to pierce the artifice and connect more directly with the reader. Crowder and Hogan connect bluegrass to eschatology in the title precisely because the imaginary spaces of “bluegrass” in the book are the closest analogy to the tensions between this world and the next that they can muster: “Bluegrass is a shaking, shimmering echo of this—our reality.”Footnote 15 It is almost as though the trauma of Lake's death was so large that only the imaginary landscape of “bluegrass” could adequately expand to hold it all. The embeddedness of bluegrass-gospel music in a massive complex of religious and cultural identity formation makes it an ideal choice for quickly and easily indexing a wide range of concepts for their white evangelical audience.Footnote 16
Eclecticism and Mediation on DC*B's A Collision
Over the course of A Collision’s seventy-three minutes, DC*B casts a wide sonic net, drawing on African American spirituals, southern gospel, country-western, contemporary “indie rock,” electronica, and Western classical music, in addition to the pop-styled worship music for which they are known. But not only does the album display a fascination with a diverse range of musical sources, it also evinces a concern with presenting each of these musical resources precisely as a historically bounded, genre-specific event. Drastic changes in musical style are often accompanied by sonic gestures which remind the listener of the constructed nature of these sounds, whether through the static-filled hum of an old 78-rpm record player, a strong sense of “the room” as a place-specific recording environment, or jarring jump cuts from one sonic space to another. In the performances on A Collision, DC*B presents each of the musical resources they draw from as something they encountered through careful study rather than through an organic or necessary relationship with their lived experience as musicians. DC*B front man and native Texan David Crowder explained on his blog that the band only decided to undertake a “bluegrass tune” after a particularly forceful suggestion from one of the band member's grandfathers. Even then, he admits to settling on Hank Williams Sr.’s gospel classic “I Saw the Light” by engaging in “hours and hours of my pouring over bluegrass lyrics and tracing historical threads of song origins and authors and stories surrounding the songs,” and only then after seeing a performance of the song by Johnny Cash on television in 2004.Footnote 17 In short, it seems that the diversity of musical materials on A Collision was fashioned with a cultural “omnivorousness” associated with a hipster subculture of popular music.Footnote 18 Here I use the word “hipster” primarily to describe two characteristics of DC*B's musical approach: (1) a studied sense of eclecticism with respect to cultural products such as music, movies, print media, and television, and (2) a conscious acknowledgement of the conditions by which these cultural products are mediated into our lives, namely the media in which these cultural products are inscribed and the social networks which predicate their consumption.Footnote 19
Right in the middle of A Collision, one finds a fairly self-contained set of five songs that are framed by two tracks, labeled “A Quiet Interlude” and “B Quiet Interlude,” respectively. This five-song set begins with the title track of the record, “A Beautiful Collision,” which is a mid-tempo rock song very much in the style of DC*B's previous “praise and worship” output.Footnote 20 This songs ends abruptly with a sudden and unexpected jump cut to the sound of a creaking rocking chair and the far off tinkling of wind chimes. The needle drops on a record player and the warm, vinyl fuzz gives way to a 1968 recording of “Soon I Will Be Done with the Troubles of the World” by the Howard Roberts Chorale. As soon as the first chorus is completed, the basses descend to a low E-flat and suddenly we hear the sounds of someone scratching the record to sustain this low note as a pedal tone, over which the introduction of “Be Lifted or Hope Rising,” another Crowder original, emerges seamlessly. Following the second time through the chorus, the instrumental texture thins considerably as violinist Mike Hogan begins playing strains of Ralph Vaughn Williams's 1914 composition “The Lark Ascending” over the continued chord changes of the electric guitar. At the midpoint of the song, the instrumentation stalls completely and falls into what sounds like a skip on the record. This rhythmic skipping effect continues for exactly four bars, followed by a sudden chord break on the downbeat and the entrance of DC*B guitarist Jack Parker playing a Scruggs-style banjo lick. What follows is about a minute and a half of lively bluegrass instrumentals with ecstatic vocal flourishes from Crowder and a backing gospel choir providing four-part harmonies and congregational handclaps. As soon as the final note sounds, there begins a recording of Ralph Stanley speaking at a concert in Tokyo in May 1971. Stanley comments on their ongoing Japanese tour saying,
I appreciate your applause. It seems like during our visit here in Japan, we have met a wonderful group of people everywhere that we've been and it seems like most everywhere that we've played, people enjoy the old-time hymns. We'd like to do one for you now, one that we've had a lot of requests for all over Japan. One called “I Saw the Light.”Footnote 21
With Stanley's introduction serving as their own, DC*B suddenly enters a totally new sonic space. One that is characterized not only by banjo, mandolin, and fiddle but also by the enthusiastic handclaps, cheers, and singing voices of a live audience. The eruption of applause at the end of the track is slowly crossfaded and then eventually cut as a slow, acoustic version of “I Saw the Light” featuring Crowder alone is faded in. Just as Crowder's solo version seems to build to a climax, another sudden jump cut drops the listener into the piano introduction of “O God Where Are You Now (In Pickerel Lake? Pigeon? Marquette? Mackinaw?),” a track written and originally recorded by Sufjan Stevens for his 2003 album, Greetings from Michigan. After nearly five minutes, this track finally dissolves into the wind chimes, which appeared briefly before “Soon I Will Be Done with the Troubles of the World,” although now they are accompanied by thunder.
The startling conglomeration of sounds and styles in this eighteen-minute segment of A Collision is central to understanding this record in light of its utilization of bluegrass-gospel music. In the five minutes leading up to the performance of “I Saw the Light”—which Crowder called “a really special moment on the record”Footnote 22—the listener is guided through a series of sound samples and hard-edged genre shifts, all of which are emphasized by a foregrounding of the media techniques needed to effect them. The sound of a needle against vinyl, a record's rhythmic skipping, and sudden aural cuts are all used to construct a self-conscious eclecticism into the sounds of the record itself. “I Saw the Light” itself was recorded in Crowder's converted barn recording studio in Waco with many of his friends and relatives in attendance to provide the “hoe down” atmosphere with live participants, but even this track ends with a sharp reminder of its own constructedness within the context, as the crowd noise flickers and suddenly disappears beneath Crowder's disembodied voice. In each of these transitions, DC*B demonstrates that they are relating not simply a series of sounds but also the logistical and physical processes that went into creating those sounds. DC*B performs an omnivorous hipster persona through its demonstration of a studied knowledge of a wide variety of musical materials as well as its self-conscious acknowledgement of the pastiche quality of such knowledge.
B Collision and the Beginnings of Re-narration
On B Collision, DC*B places this specific stretch of A Collision—particularly the pairing of “Be Lifted or Hope Rising” with “I Saw the Light”—at center stage. The album opens with two half-heartedly “bluegrass” versions of praise and worship songs from A Collision, which incorporate surface-level sonic signifiers of the genre, like a banjo doing Scruggs-style rolled arpeggios, without actually rethinking either of the songs’ structures or overall presentations. Following these opening tracks, DC*B presents cover versions of Loretta Lynn's “Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven” and Del McCoury's “I Can Hear the Angels Singing,” neither of which appears in its entirety on A Collision.Footnote 23 Although these cover songs come from canonical bluegrass-gospel artists and include sonic markers of the style such as banjo and out-of-tune “honky-tonk” piano, they display DC*B's continued commitment to a hipster “omnivorousness” through their use of hip-hop sampling techniques and bizarre instrumentation including a circuit-bent Speak & Spell toy which serves as Crowder's duet partner on “I Can Hear the Angels Singing.”Footnote 24 But this half-hour EP is anchored by the back half, which contains nearly fifteen minutes of live audio footage from the final concert of the A Collision tour, presented at MidAmerica Nazarene University in Olathe, Kansas, less than three weeks after Kyle Lake's death. Two solid minutes of applause and chants of “one more song!” are finally followed by an eruption of applause as DC*B and their tour mates, Shane & Shane and the Robbie Seay Band, step back onto the stage for an encore performance. Mike Hogan quietly begins to play “The Lark Ascending” as the rest of the band takes their positions. After several minutes, the song recognizably becomes “Be Lifted or Hope Rising” and David Crowder begins to sing. Again, at the midpoint of the song, the instrumental texture dissolves completely with only a halting electronic hum persisting for nearly thirty seconds. Finally, four clicks of the drumsticks by DC*B drummer Jeremy “B-Wack” Bush and a whooping “Wee-haw!” from Crowder launches the ensemble into a series of lively bluegrass riffs for the second half of the tune.
But before continuing on to “I Saw the Light” as they do on A Collision, the following conversation unfolds on stage between David Crowder and Shane & Shane frontman Shane Barnard.

In this extended spoken introduction, Crowder demonstrates the ways in which DC*B's live shows articulate a different relationship to their borrowed musical materials than was present on A Collision, even in this performance that was recorded less than two months after the album's release. Despite the fact that Crowder still emphasizes the boundedness of bluegrass as a genre-specific experience—through evoking particular bodily experiences of the genre or by calling out the names of bluegrass-associated instruments prior to their featured solo passages in “I Saw the Light”—he also seems to suggest that the music is available in a more direct way and suitable for evangelical religious experience through “group singing.” This shifting relationship to southern music in DC*B's public presentation is negotiated through a set of three interrelated modes of authentication which I outline below.
Authentication in the Middle Voice
Before I begin to work with such a complex and fraught concept as “authenticity,” some preliminary comments are in order. I understand that “authenticity” is one of the most oft-contested and easily deconstructed tropes in the popular music repertoire.Footnote 25 In his work on country music, Richard Peterson has done a particularly compelling job of teasing out some of the half-dozen different meanings that often operate under the umbrella of “authenticity” as well as compellingly describing the ways in which authenticity is a “renewable resource” connected to an ongoing naturalization of the term by a genre community.Footnote 26 But although scholars and fans alike ascribe authenticity as a trait of specific artists, genres, and performances, they struggle to specify how it actually consists in these entities in any meaningful way. Here, I am not concerned with what authenticity is—or even if authenticity “is,” in any real sense of the word—but rather with what authenticity does in particular musical communities. For this reason, I follow musicologist Allan Moore in his use of the verb “authentication” as a term that refers to the processes by which authenticity is constructed or conferred upon a particular artist, genre, or performance.Footnote 27 By reconceptualizing authentication as a process of meaning making in which “authenticity” is ascribed to, rather than inscribed in, a particular performance, we are forced to recognize all the ways that “‘authenticity’ is a matter of interpretation which is established and contested from within a bounded historical and cultural position.Footnote 28 In this model, performances would not be labelled as “authentic”—meaning that they would possess some attribute that can be identified and scrutinized—but rather as “authenticated”—meaning that they have undergone the processes of performance and reception that ultimately lead to the ascription of “authenticity” to a particular musical moment by a particular community of listeners. I believe that this productively shifts the conversation around authenticity from an ontological conversation—that is, a conversation about how musical texts and artists actually are in themselves—to a phenomenological conversation—that is, a conversation about the ways in which they come to be experienced within particular communities.Footnote 29
Moore, however, takes the central question of “authentication” to be a question of person, stating clearly that his system “offers a tri-partite typology dependent on asking who, rather than what, is being authenticated.”Footnote 30 His typology of “first-, second-, and third-person authenticity” attempts to specify “whether it is the performer herself, the performer's audience, or an (absent) other who is being authenticated” in a particular performance.Footnote 31 But Moore's “who” question is implicated in the same ontological trap that plagues the “what” question he rejects, namely the need for a fixed entity that clearly contains or receives something called “authenticity.” Changing this fixed entity from a “what” to a “who” is simply not radical enough. For my purposes, I believe it would be a more fruitful endeavor to ask “how?”—that is, how do objects, performances, genres, and artists come to be labeled as “authentic”? Rather than attempting to identify the objects of the process of authentication, I assume that the objects being authenticated are necessarily fluid and that the authentication of a particular performance can be shared or transferred with another performance, artist, or object. Instead, I seek to identify the relationships through which these processes of authentication take place, identifying the means by which the processes of authentication actually accomplish “authenticity” as a result.
My approach to authentication in this essay is productively illuminated by appeal to Derrida's concept of the “middle voice.” Throughout his writings, Derrida observes that in many ancient grammars—most prominently including Greek and Sanskrit—there existed a grammatical position between the modern binary of “active” and “passive” voices.Footnote 32 In a recent book on Derrida and Sartre, critical theorist Steve Martinot describes how, in this so-called “middle voice,”
the agent is both actor and acted upon, act and enacted, subject and object of an action at once. A power or dynamic other than the subject's own autonomy or intention is at work on the subject while at the same time “performed” through that subject. … The active voice says the subject effects something, the passive voice says the subject is affected by something. The middle form might say the subject effects something and in so doing is affected, or that a subject acted (was not passive) upon itself but was itself not a wholly autonomous agent in the action.Footnote 33
In his later works, Derrida used this concept of the middle voice to illuminate the ways that words like “justice” and “democracy” are able to promise or solicit certain effects without the help of any actually existing entity which might guarantee their efficacy.Footnote 34
In scholarly approaches to authenticity, a similar intervention seems to be necessary. Moore's model of authentication adopts a passive-voiced approach by continually inquiring about the direct object of the processes he is describing. My approach is not simply a grammatical correction from the passive to the active voice—and thus from object to subject—but rather a grammatological correction to the middle voice. I contend that divisions between agent and patient in the process of authentication obscure the ways in which the process is always being effected by the same objects and subjects that it ultimately affects. I understand my analysis of authentication to take place in the middle voice between activity and passivity, between agent and patient. Authenticity is not something that gets done by a specific subject or done to a specific object but rather something that “gets itself done” in the performance and reception of DC*B's music, often in ways that defy clear and permanent fixation of agency or intent.
As an example of this middle-voice process of authentication, I would like to closely examine David Crowder's introduction to “I Saw the Light” reproduced above as an example of discourse that engages in authentication. In his statements about “bluegrass” music, I identify three different modes of authentication which are accomplished at three distinct sites.
(1) “Seriously, don't panic. We're all from Texas.”
(2) “Bluegrass is based upon a very complex rhythm structure known as the ‘boom-chuck, boom-chuck.’”
(3) “Alright, so here we go, one more chance for a little group singing with Shane and Shane and the Robbie Seay Band.”
In the first statement above, we see the first mode of authentication, which I call biography. In this instance, DC*B, Shane & Shane, and the Robbie Seay Band can more authentically engage in this type of bluegrass-gospel music-making because of the public construction of a biography which shows them to be Texans. Crowder further emphasizes this mode of authentication through his thick Texas drawl, his plaid shirt and western-cut jeans, and his “folksy” demeanor with his bandmates and the audience. Audience members invest the state of Texas with meaning as a cultural source of bluegrass-gospel music—despite the lack of clear historical sense this may or may not actually make—and the musicians with authority about the musical traditions of their home state. This is perhaps the most well-worn trope of authenticity, in which the creative production of an artist is intimately and necessarily tied to lived experiences. The music becomes authenticated in and through the personal identity of the performing musicians, though not exclusively by the performing musicians.
In the second statement, we see the second mode of authentication, which I call proficiency. This meritocratic system of authentication is rooted in the notion that anyone capable of demonstrating proficiency in the specifics of a particular style of music can authentically perform within the genre. Although the second statement is obviously delivered in jest, it demonstrates that Crowder understands bluegrass to be a self-contained genre with a distinctive sonic signature. He goes on to assert that the genre also demands a certain mode of bodily engagement from the audience, which includes foot stomping and hand clapping in appropriate places. Authentication through proficiency generally draws its power from the two interlocking subprocesses of musical ability and discursive fluency. DC*B demonstrates the first of these through the Scruggs-style banjo, bluegrass fiddle, and four-part vocal harmonies in their performance of “I Saw the Light.” Crowder's discursive fluency can be seen in his joking analysis of the rhythmic characteristics of the genre but also in his ability to identify and faithfully perform a song important to those familiar with its repertory and to demonstrate his knowledge of specific artists and recordings—in this case, Hank Williams and Ralph Stanley—that have meaning within the genre.
In the third statement above, we see the third mode of authentication, which I call rituality. Although the word may instantly carry the sacramental connotations of organized religion for some, I want to use the term here in the most generous possible sense to describe the use of music to accompany or facilitate an experience of community practice. Although this particular mode is perhaps less commonly discussed in popular music, one can clearly see this mode of authentication in the case of the hip-hop DJ, for whom success is often measured by his or her ability to create an environment in which a community of dancers feels like dancing.Footnote 35 In short, the function of a successful DJ is to transform a group of people into a community of dancers. Like the mode of proficiency that I discussed above, I see that the function of rituality hinges on two sub-processes: in this case, the creation of an environment conducive to activity (whether dancing, political activism, worship, etc.) and the creation of an experience of community (whether real, imagined, or imaginary).
Even in the case of individual practitioners connected through media networks, audio and video recordings have the ability to create an experience of community for the listener. Ethnomusicologist Monique Ingalls has noted the ways that music at the Passion Conference invokes two interrelated communities that expand beyond the boundaries of the events themselves.Footnote 36 She uses Benedict Anderson's notion of an imagined community to describe the ways in which the Passion crowd can be expanded to include geographically disparate believers connected through the power of Passion's media network.Footnote 37 But in addition to this imagined community, there is also an “imaginary” community of all believers: past, present, and future. The addition of Wegner's ideas stresses the importance of utopian, eschatological considerations as well.Footnote 38 For evangelicals, this means that the “imagined community” of a worldwide body of believers is constantly being informed by (and informing) an “imaginary community” of heavenly host which praise God at the end of time. In this context, the community one experiences might be real (i.e., the Kansas audience on the recording or a local church community from which one learned the song), imagined (a worldwide community of DC*B fans or bluegrass-gospel devotees), or imaginary (the eschatological community of Christian believers throughout the whole of space and time). These various types of community can be evoked to varying degrees and in tandem with one another depending on the particular artist and listener.
This ritual mode of authentication, in which one is judged by one's ability to curate a particular experience for an audience, is also deeply embedded in the Christian tradition of pietism. Notions of evangelical piety which situate authenticity within the emotional and bodily response of the worshipper can be traced back at least as far as Schleiermacher's concept of “religion gefühl” from the beginning of the nineteenth century.Footnote 39 Here, it is clear that bluegrass-gospel music represents a specific type of Christian piety which provides sufficient conditions for group singing and dancing, even in a present-day evangelical context. This suggests that bluegrass-gospel provides a common or shared musical ground on which all three bands and the audience can encounter one another as participants.
Even though the religious connection is perhaps the most obvious, I would suggest that this “felt experience” of authentication through the practice of rituality is equally common in mainstream popular music of nearly all styles. Sociologist Sarah Thornton argues that authenticity in popular music is always a matter of feeling and experience, especially in our media-saturated culture where reproductions and simulacra are constantly available for access.
Authenticity is arguably the most important value ascribed to popular music. … Music is perceived as authentic when it rings true or feels real, when it has credibility and comes across as genuine. In an age of endless representations and global mediation, the experience of musical authenticity is perceived as a cure both for alienation (because it offers feelings of community) and dissimulation (because it extends a sense of the really “real”). As such it is valued as a balm for media fatigue and as an antidote to commercial hype.Footnote 40
Although there may be concrete aspects of a performance or artist to which one appeals in a justification of “authenticity,” authenticity itself is grounded in a felt reality. In the case of DC*B, that felt reality will often be one of divine presence through the act of worship, although in the case of “I Saw the Light,” it might simply be an experience of evoking an authentically southern musical community.
Particularly in this final mode of authentication, artists such as DC*B must strike a delicate balance. Ingalls has observed that within evangelical communities, “performance” and “worship” are often diametrically opposed, with the first term implying a degree of artifice and showmanship that is incompatible with the second.Footnote 41 This means that in order for DC*B's music to be ritually authenticated as “worship,” it must not be experienced as primarily “performative” by the gathered community. The pastiche techniques which permeate the presentations of music on A Collision are inherently performative and led many critics and interviewers to question whether or not Crowder had actually conceived the album as conducive to corporate worship. They felt the lofty artifice of the album actually prevented DC*B from properly facilitating the worship of an authentic community of Christian practitioners. For instance, see the following exchange from an interview with Russ Breimeier from Christianity Today:

Authenticating this album as something that could properly facilitate corporate worship is a crucial part of DC*B's appeal to its fans. But as Crowder's final comments about Pearl Jam suggest, DC*B must also strive to authenticate themselves as thoughtful recording artists, which, on many of their albums, involves the ritual construction of a community of knowledgeable and experienced listeners—the kind who would pick up on subtle references to an obscure Ralph Stanley album, for instance. Crowder and others in the praise and worship subculture must use both of these as carefully crafted strategies of authentication which help them to negotiate the complicated relationships between their roles as recording artists, concert performers, and evangelical worship leaders.
Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven
In their book, Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven, but Nobody Wants to Die, or (the Eschatology of Bluegrass), David Crowder and his DC*B band mate Mike Hogan continue the processes of authentication that began on B Collision. First of all, the book represents the first attempt by anyone from the band to articulate an explicit connection between their use of southern music and their associations with Lake's death. At the end of the book's introduction, the authors provide the following concise statement of the book's core premise:
Everybody wants to go to heaven, but nobody wants to die. And heaven, if we're to believe what was proposed by a man two thousand years ago, is a kingdom coming and a kingdom here and now; something for the present not reserved entirely for the ever after. Right now we exist somewhere between here and there, and bluegrass carries the high lonesome sound of our in-between condition in the rise and fall of its lyrics and its melody lines that reach and plummet like the slopes of the Appalachians.Footnote 43
In addition to providing further reasons to privilege the bluegrass-gospel tracks as central to A Collision's interpretation, this also affords the band members an opportunity to make deeper biographical attachments to the music. Throughout the book, both Crowder and Hogan include personal conversations, emails, and anecdotes related to Lake's death which are interlaced with their particular experiences of bluegrass-gospel music, usually with reference to specific recordings or reflection on particular moments in their lives where the music had a special effect on them. In contrast to the ironic distance that the omnivorous consumption on A Collision seemed to suggest, Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven presents DC*B as practitioners of southern music who are authenticated biographically by their engagement.
In addition to these positive personal affirmations of the music, the authors also describe the less authentic relationships that many of their younger listeners seem to have with these same musical repertories. They note with mocking irony the “newly born hipster cred” associated with Johnny Cash, claiming that young listeners “who are now claiming allegiance to the house of Cash never really listened to him before his death—and even more telling, before his movie biopic,” while simultaneously decrying those “attempting to project instinctive coolness by denying country music” by taking their “cowboy hats off to the ones who are keeping it real.”Footnote 44 Furthermore, the book continues to establish the band's authority on the subject of bluegrass music, effecting an authentication of their proficiency in the both the history and practice of the genre. The book is woven around a seven-part “history of bluegrass” which not only traces a lineage of the music from its Scotch-Irish heritage to the developments of Earl Scruggs but also engages with several secondary sources that help to footnote this account. The book also contains several appendices which provide an introductory playlist for those interested in learning more about bluegrass music and a description of the “evolution of form” in southern music.Footnote 45
In the years following the publication of Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven, “I Saw the Light” became an indispensable concert staple for DC*B and a fan favorite. But despite the popularity of the tune, much of the congregational engagement with it was still under the guise of “performance” rather than “worship.” An examination of any number of the dozen or so DC*B performances of “I Saw the Light” on YouTube shows that audience members tended to engage with the music through physical caricatures of southern musicality—such as knee-slapping, do-si-doing, and spirited hand clapping—rather than gestures which would typically accompany corporate worship. According to this evidence, it would seem that “I Saw the Light” is not ritually authenticated as worship for most participants, serving instead as an opportunity for performing tropes of southernness associated with bluegrass-gospel. This music, even in a live concert setting, still carries the performative connotations that were established on A Collision.
“Oh My God, I'm Going Home”
Their final record as a band, Give Us Rest Or (A Requiem Mass in C [The Happiest of All Keys]), is DC*B's only recording to outdo A Collision in terms of scale and scope.Footnote 46 This 121-minute behemoth takes as its blueprint the Roman Catholic requiem mass but expands the form in nearly all directions. There are several southern-styled tracks throughout the album, but of particular interest is the way that the record ends. Four tracks from the end, Crowder begins singing an original tune titled “Oh, My God I'm Coming Home,” accompanied only by his acoustic guitar. The simple song—which largely consists of repetitions of the title—slowly unfolds as the stereo field gradually narrows to a single point. At the same time, ambient noise is introduced which leads to an experience for the listener that she is exiting the virtual world of the record and suddenly listening to the record on a stereo in a car in which the listener is in the driver's seat. With about twenty seconds left in the track, the driver turns the car off, ending the music, and we hear her get out of the car and begin walking. As the next track begins, we hear our protagonist throw open a set of doors, and a bluegrass rendition of the gospel hymn “Leaning on the Everlasting Arms” pours out of the space, lead by banjo, mandolin, and fiddle.
What follows is a four-song medley which consists of two nineteenth-century gospel hymns, “Leaning on the Everlasting Arms” and “’Tis So Sweet to Trust in Jesus,” an original DC*B tune in a southern-gospel style called “Jesus, Lead Me To Your Healing Waters,” and finally the song “Because He Lives,” composed by Bill and Gloria Gaither in 1971. This medley of songs offers an interesting contrast to the “medley” presented in the middle of A Collision. If the songs on A Collision were strung together in such as way as to emphasize their radical constructedness, the songs here on Give Us Rest create a fiction of organic spontaneity. The songs move gently from one to another and are united not only by the consistent instrumentation and sonic character of the band but also by the voices of the congregation singing along. In concert, as evidenced by footage from their final tour—and their final performance at the Passion Conference in January 2012—these songs elicited enthusiastic participation from the audience and were received in stereotypically worshipful ways, including the raising of hands, the closing of eyes, and enthusiastic, full-throated singing.
If we are to assume that David Crowder is the protagonist of the record and the driver of the car in the previous track, then the album as a whole provides an even more richly textured narrative of southern music as authenticated congregational worship. The first track begins with a similar soundscape of someone walking into a church setting, although in this instance he walks into a church in which someone is reciting the requiem mass in Latin. These recitations kick off the first disc of the album, which consists largely of contemporary re-imaginings of the mass parts, culminating in a nearly seventeen-minute setting of the Dies Irae that spans the final seven tracks of the first disc. The second disc begins with a reprise of the opening tune, continuing through a variety of different styles before arriving at this final medley. In addition to the obvious significance of DC*B choosing to end their career as a band with a collection of bluegrass-gospel performances, I think the importance of the journey from death into gospel music is incredibly important for Crowder's purposes. Crowder does not eschew the music's previous associations with death in order to achieve a more worshipful liturgical effect. Rather, he deepens the associations with death to cosmic levels, pairing the second disc's bluegrass ramblings with the wrath of the Dies Irae. The album ends with Crowder leading the congregation in a final stanza saying, “And life is worth the living, just because He lives.” For DC*B, it would seem, this is the home for which they have been searching since the opening strains of A Collision, finally affirmed by a singing congregation in an old, country church.
Conclusion: Crowder Beyond DC*B
This collection of performances represents the apotheosis of bluegrass-gospel in DC*B's output, where the critical pastiche of the hipster is replaced by the earthy liturgy of the hillbilly. However, in interviews following the dissolution of DC*B, Crowder seems to continue to vacillate between these two poles. In a single interview, he'll suggest that DC*B “stumbled upon this little trail into the world of bluegrass music, and there was something about it that just burst to life in me,” referring to the events of 2004 and strongly emphasizing the spiritual power of the music, while simultaneously discussing his childhood in Texarkana, where
We had, in rotation, four different pieces of music. We had Elvis, Willie Nelson, Bill Gaither, and Olivia Newton John. That's everything I've ever done musically in one place. That's it. On equal footing is Bill Gaither! So this goes to the bottom of David Crowder.Footnote 47
In this interview, Crowder clearly authenticates southern gospel as a form of Christian worship as well as a marker of his own musical lineage, and is thusly authenticated by southern gospel, both as a worshipper and an artist. This strategic deployment of multiple forms of authentication is essential for an artist like Crowder. He must simultaneously vindicate himself as a recording artist as well as a worshipper and worship leader, something which requires a great deal of rhetorical dexterity.
Interestingly, this process of re-narration which Crowder undertakes using references to bluegrass-gospel is also the precise function that he believes this music provides to its listeners. Earlier in the same post-DC*B interview referenced above, Crowder posits the following function for southern religious music:
There's this sorrow beneath the surface, that “high lonesome sound,” and it turns out the whole thread goes back to the Appalachian Mountains … in the Appalachians, it was a hard life that they lived, and what was happening is they were singing themselves out of the present and into a future that they believed was real and tangible, and they felt like, “Maybe, if we sing hard enough, we could bring it into the here and now.”Footnote 48
If the ultimate function of southern music is its ability to “sing oneself out of the present” and into a new future, Crowder seems to have taken this advice to heart. Throughout this seven-year stretch of his career, he has consistently used bluegrass-gospel as a way to negotiate the tricky performance/worship divide, providing his fans with a music which promises the eschatological re-narration of worship and the artistic re-narration of southern music. One of the iTunes reviews for his first solo effort, simply titled iTunes Session and released November 9, 2012, demonstrates this clearly.
So, Mr. Crowder moves on from the DC*B to start his own little project known as “Crowder.”… If you loved the DC*B for their electronic kind of style, then this is not for you. There were two different parts of the David Crowder*Band: the organic bluegrass-like style and the pop/rock style. … If you're looking for the pop/rock awesomeness from the DC*B, then please check out The Digital Age [a band composed of all Crowder's other DC*B bandmates]. But if you want some more beard and some more acoustic, organic, and calm awesomeness, then you're definitely in the right place.Footnote 49
This seemingly simple review manages to demonstrate the far-reaching power of Crowder's authentications through bluegrass-gospel. Despite the fact that he was the lead singer and songwriter of the predominately pop/rock David Crowder*Band for more than two decades, for a host of his fans, he is primarily associated with the southern stylings of just a few tracks on A Collision, B Collision, and Give Us Rest. After years of selling out stadiums and producing densely constructed, computer-based music, David Crowder seems to promise that the simple man with the guitar from Texarkana always exists “somewhere between here and there,” somewhere in the middle voice.Footnote 50
