Eric Selbin has written an excellent book about the way that stories animate and embolden revolutionaries, a thought-provoking book about types of revolution, and a problematic book that shoehorns disparate episodes of resistance into the category of lost and forgotten revolutions. In the course of advocating a “storied turn in the discipline” (p. 4), Selbin puts people and their thoughts and feelings at the heart of his account and highlights how myth, memory, and mimesis combine to make revolutions possible. Although he acknowledges that other factors come into play, including oppression, hunger, demographic pressure, and economic crisis, he believes that “the articulation of compelling stories may provide the key” (p. 191). Stories of possibility, though not always true in a simple factual sense, guide, warn, inspire, and make real what may well be unreal and impossible. They offer revolutionaries a practical ideology with which to confront inequity, povert, and disenfranchisement. Like frequent Che Guevera sightings, “mythopoetic” (p. 16) stories transcend time and space and are adopted (and adapted) by those seeking to transform their world.
The first half of the book, where Selbin lays out his case for the power of story, at times read like a brief, but does so in the way that important and lasting books often do. Occasional overstatement—“stories … can obviate economic disadvantage, surmount socio-cultural mores, and even triumph over military might” (p. 74); stories are perhaps “the primary form of socio-political struggle” (p. 187)—do not take away from his argument's significance. One might, nonetheless, question “the intrinisically subversive element” (p. 79) he locates in many stories and Ben Okri's claim that stories are “always a form of resistance” (p. 185). As Selbin acknowledges, but brushes over quickly, many stories resemble conservative fairy tales: They legitimate the status quo, reinforce prescribed behaviors, and impede the consideration of other possibilities. At the same time, this brief book, which covers some of the best-known revolutions in little more than five pages and scores of other incidents in as little as a sentence, has limited space to discuss how stories are transmitted. How and when does mimesis happen? How, for example, did 1917 Russia come to be seen as the child of 1789 France? What enables a particular story to become “the story of the moment” (p. 194)? Why has the story of the Cuban revolution been “the right story in the right place at the right time” (p. 186) for so many revolutionaries over the last half century?
The second half of the book sketches four revolutionary stories: 1) the civilizing and democratizing story, with the American Revolution as “the bright and shining example” (p. 106); 2) the social revolution, where the French Revolution has pride of place; 3) the freedom and liberation story, where anticolonial struggles and the 1791 Haitian slave revolt are examplars; and 4) the revolutions of the lost and forgotten, where the Paris Commune stands in for a variety of “smaller, more obscure, more local, narrower, and insular stories” (p. 21). Each of these stories is told simply and well, with more attention to legacies than facts. Tidy and often apocryphal tales may raise the hackles of students of particular revolutions, but Selbin has a ready retort to the charge that the stories are tendentious or based on questionable interpretations of history. He is recounting a revolution as it is remembered and used, not as it was. The prevailing story of the French revolution downplays the Terror. That October 1917 was less a social revolution than a pedestrian coup d'état is not the point. The myth matters more than the reality. More problematic, many of the revolutions he reviews appear in two or even three stories. So, France, for instance, is the archetypal story of social revolution, but a “good revolution gone bad” (p. 107) in the civilizing and democratizing story. This suggests that Selbin may not be classifying the French, Russian, or Mexican revolutions (or even stories about them) so much as clarifying tendencies or strands within them. Readers may also wonder why these particular four stories of revolution. As the author is the first to point out, his schema does not accommodate some revolutions, most notably the Chinese, which was too long and too nationalist to fit comfortably into any of his categories.
Finally, there is the issue of what counts as a revolutionary story. Although Selbin refers to the trio of revolution, rebellion, and resistance throughout, in the end the stories he tells are all presented as stories of revolution. Drawbacks associated with this categorization are most evident in the account of lost and forgotten revolutions, the least satisfying chapter in the book. Here, he discusses dozens of fleeting episodes of resistance, ranging from the Paris Commune to Hungary in 1956 to an antidraft rebellion in 1917 Oklahoma to riots in Berkeley's People's Park. He is correct that some readers may conclude that this category is a “grab bag” or an “island of misfit revolutionary and related moments of little or no importance” (p. 162), though the problem with considering such incidents together is not their lack of significance but their lack of connection. He needs to do what he eschews: to categorize by people, place, or type, and his acknowledgement that “any number of classifications are possible” (p. 165) raises questions about the coherence of the lost and forgotten category and whether it is wise to treat so many kinds of opposition to the powers-that-be as stories of revolution. Although he resists “corralling” (p. 169) these episodes, this is advisable if they are to be more than a list of loosely related incidents handled better by existing taxonomies of resistance. This tendency to group the unalike also appears in the freedom and liberation story, where a paradigmatic case (the Haitian slave revolt) is placed alongside English serfs' revolts, the American Civil Rights movement, the Irish war of independence, indigenous resistance to Spanish conquest, and elements of the American, French, Russian and Mexican revolutions.
Revolution, Rebellion, Resistance has many outstanding features. It is bold and gracefully written and will inspire readers to reconsider overly material and structural accounts of revolution. A subtle, self-aware voice is apparent on every page as Selbin shows himself to be interested in general laws, typologizing, and nomothetic explanations, and also attuned to minutia, idiographic accounts, and the perils of all classification schemes. Furthermore, despite his focus on narrative, he does not shy away from causal arguments, repeatedly posing a question that could scarcely be more central to the study of popular contention: “Why do revolutions happen here and not there, now and not then, among these people and not those” (pp. 6, 191)? His analysis at once looks back and forward; it helps us think creatively about the color revolutions of our era and whether a new story is replacing Cuba as “the modern avatar of revolution” (p. 133). This book is a real achievement and should win a wide readership.
