This beautifully written little book, by two of Britain's leading socio-legal scholars, takes a close look at the realities of the varied work of barristers in the common law adversarial family justice system of England and Wales. In so doing, it effectively dismantles a number of widely held myths which influenced the New Labour government's policy concerning the funding of legal aid and court services; myths which of course gained credence from the publicity given to high profile ‘celebrity’ divorce cases such as that of the McCartneys. Thus, in the popular British press we regularly encounter the perception that lawyers milk the system for all they can get and help to perpetuate an adversarial system of justice which aggravates family conflict.
The research revealed in this book shows how oversimplified such a view is. While it may be true of some ‘high net worth’ divorce cases in the High Court in which the parties' disputes about money, property and the care of children cannot otherwise be settled, it is certainly not so for the bulk of child-related public and private law proceedings which make up the every day hurly-burly of work in local family courts. When barristers are brought into such cases, quite often at very short notice, they may well be confronted by a complex mess of human distress and conflicting interests. The task of representation in such emotionally hot cases, where the interests of children are supposedly paramount, is too often aggravated by having to get to grips with a muddled bundle of unfamiliar documents and a court administration working under severe pressure. Such a task calls not only for legal knowledge but a high degree of human relationship skill and understanding with the ability to negotiate diplomatically on a number of fronts simultaneously. When one considers the restricted remuneration provided by the Legal Aid Fund (likely to get worse as a result of the current economic downturn) and often the prospect of late payment, one can only wonder why so many able barristers have so far been willing to undertake such a public service.
Like much other British family law research, this study was funded by the Nuffield Foundation. It was intended to complement the authors' earlier investigation of the divorce work of solicitors (see Eekelaar, Maclean and Beinhart, Reference Eekelaar, Maclean and Beinhart2000). Both studies outline the rapidly evolving policy background against which to set the research findings. This more recent study occurred during a period in which government had already embarked on legal aid reform and had introduced a transitional system based on standardised fees for advice as well as a graduated system for various stages in the litigation process: all measures aimed at curbing major increases in the public costs of representation which rose by 12 per cent between 2004/2005 and 2005/2006 compared with a 2.6 per cent rise in the volume of cases.
The research methods started from a qualitative sampling frame aimed at providing a broadly representative profile of barristers undertaking family litigation work. This was drawn from various sources such as professional directories and websites. These provided information about age, length of experience since qualification, and the practitioner's degree of specialisation. It is worth noting that while there have been a number of studies of solicitors undertaking family law work in the UK, this study of barristers breaks new ground in focusing specifically on their family court work. In all, it was discovered that there are just over two hundred chambers (i.e. sets of offices run as commercial businesses) where family law work is carried out, the vast majority (126) on the South Eastern Circuit, mostly London based. Whereas, according to a 2002 Family Law Bar Association Survey, in the profession as a whole, women comprise only 32 per cent, 51 per cent of these undertake family law work. There is a fairly even age distribution with the majority (74 per cent) having practised for more than four years and most (77 per cent) specialising in family law to the extent of spending more than half their time on it.
The next stage of the study provided a more detailed picture of the range and nature of barristers' representation work in family courts. This information was acquired in two ways: the first through a telephone survey, supplemented by email, of barristers who were willing to provide information about their role in their most recent case. The second consisted of an observation study of a number of barristers ‘on the job’ in court.
The telephone survey highlighted the wide range of cases in which barristers were called upon to represent one of the parties. It provided quite detailed information about time spent on both preparation and attendance at court in fourteen disputed financial cases, fourteen ‘public law’ cases of alleged child neglect and abuse, and seven private law domestic children's cases mostly concerning contact with the non-resident parent. Levels of remuneration range from £55 to £200 per hour depending on the nature and complexity of the case and the level of experience and seniority of the barrister concerned. With respect to those involved with the fourteen public law children's cases, the authors observed that all were experienced and committed practitioners ‘[w]ho did not appear to be dissatisfied with their remuneration though they were inconvenienced by the time taken for bills to be paid’ (pp. 34–35).
Turning to the last three chapters dealing with the 20-day observation study, in a number of respects these give the most vivid picture of the barrister's role – certainly any aspiring young lawyer wishing to enter this field ought to read them. On each occasion the researcher accompanied the practitioner to the court and took full notes of what transpired, only altering the resulting data to anonymise it before publication. Each chapter deals with a separate area – financial cases, private law and public law children's cases. As the authors point out, the aim was not to discuss or evaluate the legal framework but rather to describe the variety of skills and knowledge employed by barristers in their handling of a wide range of cases. On the day, these could throw up all kinds of challenging problems apart from the demands of advocacy. They range from grappling with financial matters and accountancy; engaging in diplomatic people management with distressed and confused litigants in often crowded public corridors when court interview rooms were unavailable; trying to strike settlements and bargains with solicitors and counsel from ‘the other side’; and of course dealing with the idiosyncrasies of local family court staff and judges who themselves were working under pressure.
This reviewer found this part of the study the most gripping read, with each chapter portraying a vivid moving picture of a number of unpredictable human dramas into which, on the day, these barristers were in effect parachuted and expected to respond with quick wits, no little skill or knowledge, realistic human compassion and professional objectivity.
At the beginning of the book the authors claim that the information they present enables them to address a range of questions:
‘Do we have an excessively adversarial system? Are the financial rewards excessive in big money cases and inadequate in child protection cases? Is the Family Bar a well rewarded group profiting unduly from ancillary relief divorce work? Is there a problem of recruitment for a poorly rewarded, beleaguered, but essential workforce protecting children at risk of harm? Is it still possible to talk of the Family Bar as a single profession? What common ground is there between a provider of luxury services for the rich and jobbing fixers for troubled families which have no resources?’ (p. 9)
Yet, how in their conclusion do the authors deal with these vitally important questions? Their tactic seems to be to let the material speak for itself and not to permit themselves to be drawn into taking what could be a contentious policy position. In the conclusion therefore they simply limit themselves to a brief statement that the barrister in family law is ‘a mentor and guide to the client’ (p. 118) – a role which society should appreciate more. This is disappointing given that in the final days before the 2010 election, the Gordon Brown government published Support for All: The Families and Relationships Green Paper in which it announced a comprehensive review of the family justice system (2010, pp. 87–88). This was intended to critically examine the shortcomings of the British adversarial system and to see what could be done to bolster mediation skills. However, following the change of government in May 2010, the fate of this review is unclear. But as the new Conservative/Liberal coalition is committed to finding major cuts in non-frontline public services after 2011, there may well be further reductions in resources available to the Civil Legal Aid Fund and other family court-related support services which will adversely impact on the services of barristers. With hindsight therefore, it is a pity that Maclean and Eekelaar did not address more fully the policy and practice implications of the questions they posed so pertinently at the beginning of the book.Footnote 1
In particular this reviewer saw in this material ample evidence of a family justice system which is splitting at the seams: solicitors who only get documents to the barrister advocate at the last moment, overcrowded courts unable to provide sufficient private space in which the barrister can meet and consult with the client, difficult problems about listing in order to ensure judicial continuity, and a host of other administrative complications. As far as this particular study is concerned, it is a pity too that we did not learn much more about the reasons that solicitors find it necessary to bring a barrister into the case, especially in those courts in which solicitors have a right of audience and could presumably act as advocate themselves. Does it save money or make things more expensive? Does it contribute to delay and does it confuse the litigants?
The authors report that this was just a preliminary, relatively small, pioneering study of the barrister's role in British family law proceedings. Therefore one hopes that more will follow which will broaden the focus to consider the vital relationship between solicitor and barrister, and perhaps to investigate their roles from the perspective of their clients – parents and children alike. Nevertheless for the time being this clear, graphically written, little book deserves to be widely read by all with an interest in the family justice system of England and Wales.
