Historians and theologians often frame white evangelical political movements as a backlash against trends in secular culture. In God's Law and Order: The Politics of Punishment in Evangelical America, Aaron Griffith argues that evangelical engagement around crime and punishment after WWI aligned with that of the broader American public. President Roosevelt followed state and local governments that were expanding formal law enforcement efforts and enacted a large federal crime bill. The economic victory of the New Deal had to be protected. In exploring the rise of the carceral state alongside emerging trends in American evangelicalism, Griffith seeks to fill a lacuna in conversations regarding criminal justice reform by investigating religion's role in shaping the policies and practices that built mass incarceration through evangelical actors’ perspectives.
Griffith offers meticulous detail about the messages, methods, and significant figures in the evangelical effort to secure law and order. While the book's primary focus is on post–WWII politics, the first chapter, “Churchdom's War on Crime,” outlines the context that fostered the subsequent movements. Griffith notes that before the nineteenth century, American responses to criminal activity were “largely disorganized, decentralized, and regularly ineffective” (16). A more standardized approach slowly emerged in attempts to protect the young nation from disorder and chaos. Political leaders often utilized religious messaging to underscore the profoundly punitive and retributive nature of justice. In addition to the religious overtones, “crime and punishment” rhetoric became racialized through the legal practices of convict leasing and the illegal perpetration of lynching. Griffith presents this reality as the starting ground for national campaigns in support of professional law enforcement. The 1920s, 1930s, and 1940s saw the professionalization of policing, prisons, and chaplaincy with a Judeo-Christian sense of civic duty.
In chapter 2, “Jesus Christ Is the Only Control,” Griffith narrates the rise of evangelical conversionism as a response to criminality during the early post–WWII era (1945–1965). Billy Graham began his national ministry speaking through Youth for Christ about juvenile delinquency and lawlessness. Youth for Christ and Graham's later crusades represented evangelicals’ foray into the mainstream. They utilized large platforms (such as sports arenas), radio, and print media to spread a form of Christian patriotism that would protect godly American democracy from lawlessness and godless communism. Griffith offers data that the perceived increase in juvenile lawbreaking may have been a result of changing crime definitions rather than an increase in actual criminal behavior. Nevertheless, Graham, Youth for Christ, and others promoted “leading teens to Christ” (59) as the solution to juvenile delinquency, rather than a focus on law enforcement. Graham also showcased high-profile converted criminals who were now faithful disciples. Other evangelicals similarly represented these testimonies through bestselling novels and movies reaching the broader public. Eventually, many ministries began in urban centers, directly targeting gang members and drug dealers. Black and Puerto Rican neighborhoods became local mission fields. White evangelists glossed over the racial dynamics, arguing that these neighborhoods just happened to be predominately Black and Brown—in contrast to “orderly” rural areas and the newly emerging suburbs. Griffith suggests that the movement's commitment to utilizing what is now called the personal influence strategy for social change began to deteriorate in the late 1960s and into the 1970s. Crime began to spread closer to the sprawling suburbs, rather than being isolated to inner cities. White evangelicals began to acknowledge that social factors contributed to criminal activity, but they still enacted stricter punishments for individuals—as protections for their communities from those deviants.
Chapter 3, “Religion Is a Real Weapon,” outlines how, after the height of the Civil Rights Movement (late 1960s), evangelicals shifted to embrace a more punitive crime and punishment approach. Griffith again points readers to the broader American social context, which was marked by fear of rising crime rates. For evangelicals, the fear of rising crime was coupled with anxieties over the social disruptions of the civil rights movement. Although most mainstream evangelicals supported racial equality in principle, newly passed civil rights legislation had created a neutral or color-blind law and a handful of liberal Supreme Court decisions stoked fears that conservatives were losing political ground. Furthermore, many evangelicals felt that civil disobedience and protests threatened law and order. Racial uprisings, such as the Watts Riots, led evangelicals to double down on their arguments for the need for stricter laws. They rejected the arguments of civil rights activists who claimed the riots were rebellions against societal disenfranchisement. Finally, evangelicals in this period also linked their fear of crime with attacks on American family values and threats to the stability of the family. Government-backed efforts such as the Moynihan Report claimed Black people, in particular, were suffering under this new trend, thereby also centering these developments in Black, and primarily urban, communities. Thus, the political unrest of the 1960s pushed evangelicals from emphasizing personal conversions to establishing laws and punishments for those who lacked a changed pious heart. While evangelicals continued to emphasize spiritual transformation, the increase in unrepentant lawbreakers required a shift in strategy. They turned toward developing a strong police force and prison system to protect the public.
Chapter 4, “God's Law and Order,” marks the nation's dramatic shift to a law-and-order state. Evangelicals capitalized on the growing crime rates leading into the 1970s. Griffith argues that evangelicals may have overstated the impact of increasing crime rates and misconstrued the underlying causal factors. However, they effectively drew on public concerns and leveraged their evangelical identity as a powerful political mechanism. Richard Nixon benefited significantly from this evangelical block. Although Billy Graham never publicly endorsed Nixon, he evoked Nixon's concern for establishing law and order and the sanctification of strict policing and increased incarceration as methods to curb crime. White evangelicals felt racial justice required them to take crime in African American communities seriously, and this movement intensified racial tensions. Support from Black leaders (conservatives and progressives) concerned about increased crime in Black neighborhoods allowed white evangelicals to continue pushing for harsher sentences and increased policing as part of preaching an allegedly color-blind and race-neutral gospel.
Following chapter 4, Griffith shifts focus from the conditions leading to increased incarceration to evangelicals’ response to incarcerated people. Griffith frames chapter 5, “A Sermon in Your Cell,” with the claim that evangelical prison outreaches mirrored the common mission emphasis on evangelism and conversion. Prison ministries were grassroots and organic (led by laypeople and lacking organizational structure) and entangled in standard missionary tensions (questioning the relationship between themselves and other religious actors, the government, and the people they ministered to). Griffith highlights three prison ministers of that time who had considerable impact. Bill Simmer and Good News Jail and Prison Ministry expanded and professionalized independent evangelical chaplaincy work by combining “evangelism, discipleship, and pastoral care”—ministering to incarcerated souls and advocating for better conditions within the facilities (179). Bill Glass, a retired professional football player, combined sports and evangelism by leaning into the growing trend of “muscular Christianity” that promoted a “masculine gospel of athleticism, fatherhood, and manly fellowship” (188). Ray Hoekstra distinguished himself from others of his time by flooding prisons with evangelistic literature and radio messages. Griffith closes the chapter by examining the impact of these ministries, demonstrating that they attracted Christians of all kinds to prison ministry and increased general empathy for incarcerated people's plight.
Griffith's penultimate chapter, “There Are Better Ways,” charts the struggle between the prison reform work of Charles Colson and the new Christian Right of the 1980s. Colson converted to Christianity just before his incarceration for his involvement in Nixon's Watergate scandal. Although incarcerated at a minimum-security federal prison, Colson still experienced prison life's harsh conditions, which, he said, “eroded men's souls” (219). Once released, Colson utilized his political knowledge and influence to coax conservatives to support prison reforms. He made moral arguments against incarcerated men's moral and political disenfranchisement simultaneously with pragmatic ideas about the lessened costs of alternatives to incarceration. Colson's efforts were at odds with the rising Christian Right, led by Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, and the Moral Majority, who continued their rhetorical mobilization around crime and punishment as part of the attack on liberalism. The Moral Majority leveraged the public's concerns about crime, lobbied for stricter punishments, and became active in state and local politics and judicial appointments. Griffith argues that what distinguished this period from previous eras were new emphases among evangelicals on the influence of drugs on crime and the impact of crime on victims. Advocacy for victims’ rights opened doors for some unlikely coalitions, including with African Americans and women's rights groups. In response, Colson's Justice Fellowship called for “criminal justice” reform instead of “prison reform,” which allowed the messaging to include the concerns of victims of crimes and the need for reconciliation between the offender and the whole community (248). Nevertheless, politicians persisted in passing harsher laws with mandatory minimums. Griffith concludes that eventually, liberals and conservatives lost sight of restorative justice efforts. More straightforward (and punitive) solutions became the norm.
God's Law and Order provides an excellent history of the political movements that arose alongside shifts in evangelical thought and practice. Griffith does the meticulous work of combing through sermons, printed materials, and policies to ascertain some overlooked nuances in the evangelical preoccupation with crime and punishment. In doing so, Griffith undermines the assertion that evangelical politics are reactionary and demonstrates how they were deeply rooted in broader societal concerns. Another significant contribution is Griffith's emphasis on the evangelical struggle to address the racial undertones of their politics and the disparate impact their law and order theology had on Black people.
Griffith, however, notes this racial history in a very matter-of-fact way, which could lead evangelical ministers or activist readers to continue minimizing the movement's need to address whiteness. Griffith only briefly highlights the work of Black evangelical leaders who incorporated racial concerns into their work, such as Tom Skinner or Consuella York. The absence of white prison evangelists that attended to racial dynamics leaves readers questioning if there are any exemplary models, even if their influence and impact is less prolific. Similarly, Griffith critiques the evangelical preoccupation with individualism that neglects systemic factors yet the book tends to make the same mistake. For example, in chapter 4 Griffith introduces readers to the Nixon-era war-on-crime, but in chapter 5 he bypasses any explicit conversation on these policies’ correlation to the steep rise in incarceration rates. Griffith instead launches into discussing the actors, messages, and methods of evangelical prison ministries in the late 1970s and 1980s. Griffith's laser focus on prominent individuals and their ministries makes his argument susceptible to the same form of individualism that causes evangelicals to miss the import of analyzing systems and conditions. Additionally, Griffith fails to discuss the plight of incarcerated women and evangelical ministry to women. “A Sermon in Your Cell” highlights Tammy Faye Bakker's outreach and notes the move toward gendered prisons, and Griffith comments that male evangelists often overlooked the specific needs of incarcerated women. On the whole, however, Griffith seems inadvertently to dismiss incarcerated women rather than telling their stories because of his inattention to ministry in women's prisons and the specific impact of crime and punishment theology on women.
Griffith concludes God's Law and Order on an optimistically critical note. As a white evangelical Christian and a former prison ministry volunteer, Griffith acknowledges that evangelicals too often participate in uncritical support of law enforcement and the use of force. This practice alienates them from Black and Brown people who suffer at the hands of law enforcement and demonstrates their ongoing inability to address their whiteness. Griffith, however, emphasizes that despite their issues, evangelicals continue to be among the most committed and consistent volunteers within prisons. God's Law and Order paints a detailed picture of the social and political context from which evangelical law and order theology emerged and became intertwined with the broader American political landscape.
Theologians, criminologists, prison ministers and chaplains, and criminal justice activists will benefit from Griffith's research as it provides historical nuance, success stories, cautionary tales, and ultimately hope that evangelical preoccupation with crime, punishment, and “lawbreakers” can be converted into a powerful force that redeems the lives and communities affected by American mass incarceration.
