The Internet, smartphones, and social media have become indispensable and ubiquitous in our time, and consequently scholarly inquiries have attempted to understand the relationship between this new communicative technology and the mobilizing processes of political activism. There cannot be a better place to analyze the link between the digital world and mass protest than South Korea, widely acknowledged as having the fastest and broadest usage of online networking and a rich heritage of popular uprisings. Dal Yong Jin's Smartland Korea and Jiyeon Kang's Igniting the Internet offer a timely and complementary analysis of the political economy of digital technology and its connection to youth culture and political participation. The former work is focused on explicating the evolution and expansion of information and communication technology (ICT) and the changing communicative culture of South Korean youth, while the latter unearths the political dynamics that young South Koreans have created in cyberspace to generate mass street protests.
In Smartland Korea, Jin takes a political economy approach to the adoption and growth of ICT in Korea by examining its interaction with global market forces (chaps. 2–4). The initial growth of Korean ICT benefited from the government's planning and protection of domestic industries, which reflected the policy orientation of past developmental states. Yet, due to growing pressure for neoliberal deregulation, particularly by the United States, opening the ICT market was inevitable. Exposed to international competition against major American tech firms, Korean chaebols like Samsung pursued a survival strategy that Jin identifies as localization. As the government contributed to creating an advanced ICT infrastructure, South Korean firms rose to lead the international market with the help of Korean consumers, who exhibited a high level of technological sophistication and swiftly sent market signals to the industry.
South Korea's transformation into a “smartland” stems from a high volume of production and consumption of smartphone apps and mobile games (chap. 5). Here Jin cautions against the persistence of “platform imperialism” (e.g., the monopoly of US-based operating systems, p. 83) and the dominance of big players such as Google Play and the Apple App Store, as well as Naver, Daum, and Kakao. He further demonstrates that such hyper-digitality in South Korea does not preclude a digital divide, such as that between advanced users and limited users. Like in many other countries, elderly, blue-collar workers and the less educated are found to be the most disadvantaged groups in the ICT world (chap. 6). The communication culture of young South Koreans, the most avid users of apps and games, has reached a new turn as Kakao Talk and mobile gaming have deeply penetrated their everyday routines (chaps. 7 and 8). As an integral mechanism that generates both an individualizing and a socializing space, digital technology has changed how individuals communicate, manage interpersonal networks, and spend their leisure time.
Jin's examination of South Korea's rise to ICT powerhouse and of its changing communicative culture suggests that the legacies of the developmental state are still influential, as the government continues to play an important role in creating an industrial infrastructure for Korea's ICT firms. But the book also recognizes the country's persistent challenges from a competitive global market dominated by American tech corporations.
Igniting the Internet begins where Smartland Korea ends. Kang's analytical focus is on investigating how South Korea's hyper/digital space is appropriated by young Koreans in articulating their political causes and in mobilizing mass protests. Locating the case within South Korea's robust social movement tradition, Kang strives to demonstrate the differences between the mobilization dynamics of the young generation and those of previous activists who fought against military dictatorships. The study begins by identifying the current young South Koreans as those born from the mid-1980s to the mid-1990s. This generation grew up as digital natives in a liberal political environment, which exposed them to progressive knowledge and critical thinking (chap. 1). They matured in a distinctive political period when the Korean Teachers Union, which advocated for liberal education, was legalized; the Asian Financial Crisis of 1997–98 ushered in a neoliberal economy; the very first summit meeting between the political heads of the two Koreas took place in 2000; and the joint hosting of the 2002 World Cup raised national pride to new heights.
This generation took advantage of the advancement of ICT by using cyberspace as a new political arena for progressive alternatives, which had a direct impact on mainstream politics. These dynamics were most visible in 2002. The ascendance and electoral success of Roh Moo-hyun's presidential candidacy that year could not have taken place without the popular support formed through digital activism. It was also in cyberspace that the candlelight vigils protesting the killing of two teenage girls by an American military vehicle were mobilized (chaps. 2 and 3). It was this momentum, when on- and off-line vigils emerged as a new medium for envisioning a democratic alternative to the status quo, that most squarely marked a departure from the dominant repertoire of the Korean movement tradition. Igniting the Internet follows young individuals who participated in these spontaneous, festive, and cathartic digital and street protests (chap. 4).
Kang's next case study examines the online and mass demonstrations in 2008 against American beef imports and the participants’ remembrance of their activism (chaps. 5 and 6), a watershed of festive subversion and satirization of existing structures of authority and political repression. Kang finds that the participants recollect this experience as corporeal moments of belonging, creating an alternative community, and voicing independent thoughts.
These two volumes on digital technology, youth, and political activism are welcome additions to the scholarship on communication, youth culture, social movements, and Korean studies, but they are not without limitations. Jin's Smartland Korea offers a historical account of South Korea's rise to digital powerhouse and its impact on the communicative culture of young Koreans through a political economy approach that adds depth to the analysis by drawing on a wide range of empirical sources such as official statistics, surveys, and interviews. While it definitely covers the baseline of understanding how South Korea became a smartland, there are two facets of the phenomenon in which Jin could have undertaken more critical interventions. First, the formation of Korean chaebols’ dominance in ICT is examined in the context of international competition, but not in terms of domestic market-distorting practices. Big names like Samsung, Naver, and Kakao maneuvered themselves into monopoly positions, making it difficult for novel ideas and products by venture firms to gain acceptance. The hierarchical relations imposed by the big players may have posed a detrimental blow to further advancing South Korea's smartland economy. Another important missing discussion concerns the connection between the digital culture of young Koreans and their real material and social circumstances. The smartland was not necessarily a happy land for these hyper-digital youth, as their real world came to be defined by high rates of unemployment, a precarious labor market, and frequent and unabashed violations of basic labor rights. Today, young individuals are differently intersected with both the digital space and real-world material conditions, and investigating these two aspects in relation to each other could have added more complexity to the analysis.
In comparison, Igniting the Internet closely examines online communities as a new social space that generates distinctive communicative dynamics for expressing opinions, forging alliances, constructing formidable dissent, and establishing the youth as active political participants. The key concept Kang adopts to explain the cultural ignition of cyberspace is “captivation.” It is defined as a process through which a particular set of competing discourses grabs the user's attention, prompting the user to further circulate the material and activate its deep structures of belief (p. 75). This line of explanation triggers quite a few important questions, such as under what conditions this captivation operates. What kind of materials succeed or fail to enter the captivation process in the digital world? Is this purely a matter of contingency, under-articulated sentiment, and inadvertent judgment, as Kang claims? Contextualizing in a more nuanced way the sociopolitical conditions under which a specific discourse enters the captivation process might yield a better understanding of when and how digital space is ignited by a specific political cause.
In this study of the youth in political protest, Kang emphasizes how their activism is different from that of the older generations, whose activism was forged through a shared political identity in resistance to authoritarian regimes. By highlighting the differences between the two generations, Kang refutes the idea that shared identity or interest in a political cause is a precondition for protest participation. Instead, she suggests the workings of a contingent, unintended process of political mobilization. Obviously, the people, the mobilization processes, and the forms of protest now are different from those of thirty years ago. Yet, as much as captivation connects cyberspace with real-world street protests, the movement infrastructure and culture created by the earlier generation of activists continue to undergird the blooming of this new agency and modalities of activism. In other words, large-scale street demonstrations and direct confrontation with state authorities in 2002 and 2008 were a distinctive feature of South Korean politics that firmly inherited the movement tradition of the older generation. Kang could have discussed the youth's political activism more as a creative renovation built upon these earlier historical experiences than as a discrete development.
The Internet, smartphones, and social media have indeed created their own spaces and culture. Still, they do not stand completely on their own. These digital spaces and their users are inescapably embedded in and linked to real politics, economy, and social movements. The two monographs reviewed in this essay therefore could have done more to analyze these two interconnected spheres—the youth's digital culture, on the one hand, and their socioeconomic reality or the organizational conditions of protest mobilization in cyberspace, on the other. Further investigating both the connections and disconnections between these two realms in a systematic way could enrich our understanding of contemporary media, youth, and political activism in South Korea.
