Stanlake's monograph is thoughtful and thoroughly researched, and successfully achieves the author's intension to develop ‘a critical methodology for reading the unique aspects of Native American dramaturgy’ (p. 15). Wisely, she narrows the scope of her analysis to what she defines as ‘a field of theater that focuses on plays authored by members of the indigenous nations of the American Western Hemisphere’ (p. 17). In order to get ‘at the heart’ of how we analyse and understand Native drama as separate from other types of drama, Stanlake grounds her dramaturgical analysis in ‘Native ways of knowing’ and seeks ‘points of contact between Native American intellectual traditions and existing theater theories’ (pp. 17, 25). She displays a keen understanding of both, and situates each theory and theatrical example in its historical, political and cultural context.
Another notable strength is her clear organizational pattern. The first chapter provides a concise historical background from the first half of the twentieth century onwards; the second outlines the methodology. The remaining six chapters are then organized in pairs: Stanlake first introduces a major discourse in Native dramaturgy (platial history, storytelling, tribalography and theories of survivance) and then discusses three plays accordingly. She effectively describes Native ‘theories of platiality’ (p. 29), recognizing the special relationship between Native peoples and concepts of place, landscape and home, and then illustrates how these platial theories create dramaturgical structures. The next section explores how Native dramatists work towards decolonization by embracing oral histories and rich tribal traditions of storytelling. Stanlake offers dynamic examples from contemporary Native plays of holistic communication, non-linear ‘storytime’ and the power of orality to transform communities. Although she bases much of her analysis on Native American intellectual traditions, she also draws on performance studies in order to elucidate connections between the fields, comparing, for example, multivocal authenticity in Native drama and Elin Diamond's feminist reading of Brecht's historicization. She thus demonstrates how both destabilize master narratives of universal truths.
The discourses Stanlake identifies meaningfully overlap, connecting Native dramaturgy and ways of knowing with issues of representation, identity and cultural endurance. Building on Gerald Vizenor's theory of survivance, the last section illustrates how plays such as Hanay Geiogamah's Foghorn and Marie Clement's Urban Tattoo simultaneously correct popular misconceptions of Native identity and ‘depict methods of Native resistance and survival through trickster transformations, deconstructions, and representations of Native American dynamism’ (p. 182). The concluding chapter succinctly articulates, by way of summary, how the previously discussed dramaturgical discourses might expand general theatre studies and link with future analyses of indigenous performance throughout the hemisphere.
Wilmer's edited collection is, in contrast to Stanlake's clear focus on Native dramaturgy, far-reaching in scope and style. Fourteen essays cover a range of topics and viewpoints on multiple modes of Native performance, as well as Native and non-Native representation of Native identity through performance. The first section explores how traditional stories and performance practices have survived and transformed over time and how non-Native cultural encounter has influenced Native performance and identity. Part Two considers the function and reception of the Native body in performance and explores the concepts of ‘blood memory’, authenticity, and the possibility of embodiment to transfer indigenous cultural knowledge and encourage healing. The third section addresses dramaturgy in plays by non-Native and Native playwrights that represent and grapple with Native American identity.
The grouping of the four essays in this section is somewhat baffling: Jaye Darby, in her dramaturgical exploration of two of Geiogamah's early plays, convincingly argues that Native dramatic works and aesthetics should not be evaluated by Western standards, but in terms of their specific cultural and historical contexts. Immediately following is David Krasner's essay which reads William S. Yellowrobe's play The Independence of Eddie Rose (1986) as a ‘Native American Bildungsroman’ in the tradition of this late eighteenth-century German ‘coming-of-age’ story (p. 173). Wilmer offers no editorial comment on this contradictory methodological approach. The other essays in this section are excellent, yet similarly add to the confused scope of the anthology.
The fourth and final section includes two interesting essays on how contemporary Native filmmakers work to destabilize historical misrepresentations of Native life and culture through their medium. Several of the essays Wilmer includes usefully contribute to discussions on representation, racialization, authenticity and (un)ethical cross-cultural research practices. Stanlake, however, offers a more cohesive analysis of, and investigation into, the important fields of Native American theatre studies.
