The history of science has many gardens. Some impress by the sophistication of their plants and the absence of weeds. Such is the historiography of seventeenth-century science. Others are in prominent locations, widely seen but still untilled, impressing more by the potential of what could grow than by the beauty of the existing plants. Such is the historiography of twentieth-century science. Now a master gardener perhaps best known for his contributions to the first has moved to share the burdens and the opportunities of the second. In The Scientific Life, Steven Shapin looks at how ‘resources of personal virtue, familiarity and charisma’ have mattered where, he claims, we have least suspected them: in such ‘characteristically late modern configurations as the industrial research laboratory and the entrepreneurial network’ (p. 5).
His first three chapters deal with the fundamental drift of existing historiography and philosophy: that scientists, having once been seen as special, were normalized in the twentieth century. The view from a race across Western history in less than a hundred pages is bound to be slightly blurred. Interestingly the category of scientist is rarely differentiated here into ‘chemists’ or ‘physiologists’ or ‘physicists’. Instead, Shapin's concern is with the abstract category of ‘scientist’. The second part of the book deals in a more focused fashion with the industrial scientist, often treated as the unmentionable part of the scientific community. Following rarely quoted statistics of the 1950s, Shapin points out that in the postwar years the greatest number of man-hours devoted to scientific research came from researchers in industry rather than academe. Moreover, he shows that industry was an attractive context for good researchers, despite being at variance with Mertonian norms. With its emphasis on the reality of daily life as a scientist, this section is generously illustrated, with twelve photographs. Like much else here, however, these come from just two books: the two editions of The Organization of Industrial Scientific Research by the Kodak research boss C. E. Kenneth Mees (New York, 1920 and 1950); and C. C. Furnas's edited collection Research in Industry (New York, 1948). Those provide Shapin with an account of the scientist's life and work which he can contrast with the representation of science by Robert Merton and his contemporaries among sociologists of science, such as Warren Hagstrom. This contrast lies at the heart of the book and is both stimulating and timely. It does, however, prompt important questions.
Although Shapin launches us on a discussion to whose stimulus a new generation of researchers should be justly grateful, he is limited by the asymmetry in published knowledge and commentary about the partners in his dialectic. Sociologists of science have been reviewed and their work subjected to criticism, metacriticism and historical situation by scholars such as David Hollinger and the Edinburgh school (of which Shapin himself was a member). On the other hand, while the works of Mees and Furnas have occasionally been cited in recent years, they have not been subjected to anything like the same examination. To take just one example: as noted, Mees published his textbook on industrial research in two editions, one in 1920 at the start of the boom in industrial research, and the second, with his colleague John Leermakers, in 1950. Quotations from the two editions are used and both are cited, but the difference between the two is nowhere analysed. Nor do we know yet how ‘typical’ or generic were the views of Mees among managers of research. There are statistics available showing how much faster was the rise in numbers of engineers in industrial research than was the rise in numbers of chemists such as Mees (see A. Thackray et al., Chemistry in America, 1876–1976 (Dordrecht, 1985), p. 118). Mees was presumably unusual amongst the postwar research managers in being both older and British by training. Did that make him different? Such a question is a challenge to future research.
The third part of this book deals with a further transformation of the scientist, as entrepreneur. The sources for this part are quite different. Here there is a mass of journalism charting the progress particularly of the biotech start-up. Shapin has also conducted his own interviews with participants. Here he moves from a historian dependent on literature to an observer who attends breakfast meetings. The challenges of this mode of research are to get behind the presentation of information in public – which, of course, talking to Shapin constitutes. Money, relative incomes and mortgages are strikingly missing from scientists' accounts. So while Shapin does offer pioneering research on the relative income of researchers in larger companies in the interwar years, ‘remuneration packages’ in the academic and commercial sectors remain to be fleshed out. Again, future historians will be both stimulated and challenged by his arguments, such as on the nature of trust and how it is evoked and rationalized in twenty-first-century America. (In the wake of the Madoff affair, the subject is ripe for further inquiry.)
It is striking that whereas this review has taken as a matter of course the interest of future historians, where Shapin has found historians to cite their works were typically published about thirty years ago. The text of only one unpublished talk on industrial research is cited, by Jeff Sturchio in 1985 on Mees. At one level this is a testament to the foresight and imagination of the research schools at the time, particularly at the University of Pennsylvania and Johns Hopkins University. Writing in the year that Arnold Thackray retires, one should point out that Shapin was his first Ph.D. student, and that the works of four others of Thackray's students from just a few years later are cited. At the same time, the lack of later research works with which to drive the now generation-old texts into obscurity is disappointing. This book should serve as a wake-up call: there are big patches of fertile soil out there which attracted even a gardener of the seventeenth century. The opportunities his work highlights should tempt others to continue the job.
