Christine Hamdoune's detailed study of the Mauretanian provinces of Tingitana, Caesariensis and (later) Sitifiensis is an important study of a region that has been too frequently neglected in modern scholarship. The study is founded on an equal mastery of the Latin epigraphy from the region, and the few textual sources that survive, often in fragmentary form. Ammianus Marcellinus’ account of the Firmus rebellion in the early 370s is unusual in its breadth and depth. More often, texts are knotty puzzles in themselves: the tantalising episcopal lists from the Carthaginian Councils of 411 or 484, or the frontier commands presented in the Notitia Dignitatum all require cautious scrutiny to be useful as sources, which they receive here.
The archaeological evidence is similarly lacunose. Although a handful of scholars undertook survey and excavation work in Algeria during the middle decades of the twentieth century, the vast majority of this data survives in cursory records from the early colonial period, much of it compiled in Stéphane Gsell's great Atlas Archéologique de l'Algérie (AAA) (1911). One of H.’s significant accomplishments within this work is to present the vast amount of information in the AAA in a way that is accessible to a modern audience. Scarcely less impressive is her insistence that the inevitable gaps in this material should not be filled through reference to the later Arabic historians, to modern anthropology or indeed to the works of Augustine and others relating to regions further east, however tempting such comparanda might seem. The result is a somewhat impressionistic account of changing provincial society between the first and the seventh centuries, but one that allows the Mauretanian material to speak for itself. This is no small accomplishment.
The study covers the history of the Mauretanian provinces from their incorporation in the Empire during the reign of Claudius to the arrival of Islam in the seventh century. As might be expected, the uneven nature of the evidence prevents a completely balanced coverage of this whole region, and Mauretania Tingitana in particular largely drops out of the discussion in the latter part of the book. The only comparable work of recent scholarship is Yves Modéran's monumental 2003 study Les Maures et l'Afrique romaine (IVe–VIIe siècle), which provides a similar perspective on changing rural society in the provinces between Numidia and Tripolitania, but which is much less satisfactory in its treatment of the archaeology.
H. argues persuasively that the different Mauretanian provinces followed distinct trajectories, which reflected the nature of their incorporation within the Empire. Mauretania Sitifiensis was the westernmost part of the African landscape of great estates, and consequently was drawn by currents similar to those in Numidia. On the fringes of this province, and in Caesariensis, the urban fabric and estate agriculture were less well established, and Roman presence was largely effected through local elites who often subscribed with enthusiasm to the cultural, political and economic opportunities on offer. These could be deep-rooted and often survived long after the formal disappearance of imperial rule, but represented a mode of political life that was very different from that visible closer to Carthage.
This general thesis is expounded through a number of exemplary case studies. H.’s discussion of the military crises of the mid-third century and of the Firmus revolt are measured surveys of the evidence and will be helpful points of reference for future scholarship. Her account of the development of Christian institutions across Mauretania is still better and represents an important contribution on a region that has been almost entirely neglected in recent work on the Church in Roman Africa. Here, the combination of conciliar records, papal correspondence, hagiography, epigraphy and archaeology works to impressive effect. Perhaps most important, however, are her closing chapters on the polities that replaced Roman power in the fifth and sixth centuries — certainly the most thorough treatment of this material to date. That this discussion is based upon very recent archaeological and epigraphic discoveries, as well as long-familiar evidence like the Masuna inscription and the archaeology of the Tiaret Djedars, adds particularly to its value.
This is a work of exceptional scholarship, and immensely rewarding, but is occasionally difficult to use. One particular regret is that the discussion is not better supported by maps. This is, after all, a region which will not be immediately familiar to many scholars outside the Maghreb, and where French, Arabic and Latin toponyms of rural sites are not always easy to track down in the Barrington Atlas (or on Google Earth). Although the book does include a handful of original maps, most are reproduced from earlier publications, and they are spread somewhat unevenly through the book. Neither the discussion of the third-century conflicts nor the account of the Firmus revolt (two sections likely to be read in isolation by interested readers) are supported with a map, which may make discussion difficult to follow. Similarly, following the thread of H.’s discussion of aristocratic fundi and (especially) rural Christianity demands more or less constant reference to the AAA and to the helpful maps provided in Serge Lancel's Budé editions of the Conciliar Acts of 411 and the Notitia Provinciarum of 484 (neither of which is reproduced here).
These caveats aside, this is a rewarding and important book. Much remains to be said about the history of the Mauretanian provinces in the Roman and (especially) post-Roman period. As systematic archaeological investigation returns to Algeria, our impression of this forgotten corner of the Roman world will doubtless change substantially. But the foundations for that work have been laid here.
