In April 1644, as he was about to ascend the volcanic slopes of Mount Etna, the Danish doctor Thomas Bartholin put pen to paper and took stock of the situation. He was then halfway through the scientific grand tour that had brought him from Padua to the main studia of the Italian peninsula. The south of Italy had unfolded before him with surprising idiosyncrasies. Naples had been fascinating, providing chemical laboratories, furnaces and museums to visit, knowledgeable men to converse with, and renowned physicians who shared his interest in anatomy and Harveian physiology. Sicily struck an altogether different note. The beauty of its landscape did not compensate for the apparent lack of intellectual vitality. Virtuosi were scarce, and fewer still the physicians who, like him, could be said to have been committed to medical advances as well as to the life of the mind.
In Theatrum Naturae, Alessandro Ottaviani and Oreste Trabucco take their cue from Bartholin in attempting to shed new light on the scientific landscape of the Mezzogiorno spagnolo, the Aragonese kingdom of Naples and Sicily. As with much recent scholarship to do with the scientific culture of post-Renaissance Italy (for instance, the work of Giuseppe Olmi, David Freedberg, Luigi Guerrini and Irene Baldriga), the problem is examined through the activities of the Roman Accademia dei Lincei, founded by Prince Federico Cesi in 1603 to investigate the natural world through philosophy and experiment. Innovatively, Ottaviani and Trabucco choose to focus on the less well-known Neapolitan branch of the academy and its associates, thus illuminating the unsung successes in medicine and natural history of Fabio Colonna (1567–1640), Marco Aurelio Severino (1580–1656) and Pietro Castelli (1574–1662).
The early career of Colonna, a lawyer by profession and naturalist by choice, is reconstructed by Ottaviani in Chapter 1. True to his time, Colonna consulted Dioscorides in the convent of San Giovanni alla Carbonara and perfected his knowledge of simples under the apothecary Ferrante Imperato; he published on the local flora of Naples and engaged in the debate on the organic origin of fossils through his work on shells and glossopetrae (fossilized shark teeth commonly believed to be snake's fangs or stones with thaumaturgic properties). Chapter 2 is devoted to the Mexican Treasury, the chief collaborative endeavour of the first Linceans. Based on annotated drawings of naturalia from the Spanish New World, it was eventually published in 1651. Its editorial vicissitudes are widely known, its content much less so. In two cameos, we are told again of Colonna, a Lincean since 1612, who integrated the scanty botanical notes of Johannes Schreck after he left Cesi's coterie for China, and of the dissections conducted by Johann Faber and Pietro Castelli on the secretory glands of the civet in order to test the reputed hermaphroditism of the exotic animal. Trabucco pens the final chapter on the southern respublica medica, recalling the divergent histories of the friends Severino and Castelli. The former, a surgeon in Naples, established a European network of colleagues and correspondents, regularly printed his works abroad and became a referent for the German population studying medicine at Padua. The latter, conversely, after a successful start as a physician in Rome, moved to the studium of Messina. Here he founded a botanical garden and strove to reform the medical curriculum, only to find himself bogged down in petty disputes, lack of funds and, ultimately, intellectual exile. The volume ends with an appendix of five letters exchanged by Severino with Castelli and the Dutch anatomist Johann van Horne.
The book focuses on the period 1610 to 1640: a ‘transitional age’ (p. 13) in the south between the inherited encyclopedic humanism and a rigorous experimental science, a time when the eclectic and antiquarian erudition encouraged by Cesi prepared the ground for the ‘new science’ that later emerged from the Neapolitan Accademia degli Investiganti and the work of anatomist Marcello Malpighi and mathematician Giovanni Borelli in Messina. The authors' critical stand in this analysis is slightly conflicted. They refute Freedberg's reading of Lincean activity as a linear progress towards a science of taxa and geometrical truths directly inspired by the Galilean endeavours. Indeed, they side with current scholarship in the attempt to enfranchise the early Linceans from the role of mere supporters of the great man Galileo. While doing so, however, they fall too fullheartedly into a revisionist agenda, surrounding their southern Linceans with a similar aura of inevitable progress. Colonna becomes the objective observer ante litteram, fieldwork notebook and microscope in hand; Castelli, the embodiment of the disenchanted scholar ahead of his time. All play the parts of characters trapped in a cultural geography that does not allow their modernity.
From the start, the oft-neglected half of Italy is reclaimed as an important ‘geo-political sector of the respublica literaria of the seventeenth century’ (p. 14). The book, however, is for the most part descriptive, and rarely offers any explanation that may reconcile the intellectual isolation of the insular south with the ferment that characterized the mainland. Nor does it succeed in pinpointing what was Neapolitan about this science. It therefore does little to challenge the first assessment made by Giuseppe Olmi two decades ago as to the role of the Neapolitan Linceans in the scientific life of the city: its virtuosi continued to work and exchange knowledge in the same way before as well as after the Lynx. The book fails to place these figures within the broader contexts of Neapolitan scientific projects of the Scientific Revolution as a whole – a concept which itself is never questioned. The close reading of the texts in which the authors take pride is not complemented by historical analysis. We do not see the local world of literati, naturalists and curieux that surrounded these Linceans and made their work possible by circulating specimens and opinions. We do not see the political struggles or the intellectual uncertainties that came with foreign domination. The laudable attempt at bringing to life the scientific landscape of southern Italy translates into biographical sketches, worthy of praise for their wealth of information, but ultimately limited in their focus.
Promoted by the Istituto Italiano per gli Studi Filosofici of Naples, driving force since the 1980s behind a revival in studies of the intellectual history of the Italian south, the book will certainly find its niche among the blossoming literature on the role of the Mezzogiorno in science. Still, one would have hoped for a more ambitious project.
