The paintings produced at the courts of South India during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries are for the most part much less well known than those associated with the Mughals and Rajputs. This lack of familiarity in no way reflects on the artistic quality of South Indian paintings, which manifest as much iconographic range and pictorial exuberance as their better known counterparts from North India and Rajasthan. One possible explanation is that collectors have been less attracted to materials from South India, with the consequence that there are fewer scholars who have made a particular study of the subject. There is every reason therefore to welcome the present volume, which showcases the extensive South Indian painting collection in The British Museum. It is perhaps no accident that this institution should have a particularly rich repository of such paintings on paper, often assembled as pages in albums, as well as on mica and cloth. After all, the Museum has for many years benefited from bequests from numerous colonial administrators and merchants who enjoyed careers in South India. Nonetheless, few of the materials that they donated, now in the Department of Asia (previously the Department of Oriental Antiquities), have previously been published, and then usually only as isolated images. The British Museum Press must be congratulated for issuing this handsomely produced volume, illustrated with colour plates throughout, and commissioning Dallapiccola, one of the very few specialists in the field, to write the text. Not only has she taken pains to describe all the paintings in the collection, she also provides translations of all the accompanying Tamil and Telugu captions.
Following the usual preliminaries of foreword, preface and acknowledgements, Anna L. Dallapiccola offers a broad introduction that situates South Indian paintings in their historical and artistic context. Here she outlines the careers of the principal courts of the region during the centuries to which most of the paintings in The British Museum collection belong: notably, Thanjavur under the Marathas, Mysore under the Wodeyars, Hyderabad under the Nizams, and the kingdom of Malabar in Kerala. The fact that many of these works are supplied with English labels indicates that they were made for European patrons. However, rather than cataloguing such paintings under the heading of ‘Company school’, which has been the usual practice of scholars, the author argues that such works are genuine products of indigenous ateliers. She underscores this approach by presenting a chronology of South Indian painting, beginning with the mural tradition that harks back to Vijayanagara times in the sixteenth century, and which then developed as distinct schools of miniature painting and painting on cloth at different centres in what is now Karnataka, Andhra, Tamil Nadu and Kerala. Her discussion includes a consideration of the artists themselves, based largely on English accounts, and the records of the Thanjavur court.
The catalogue that follows is divided accordingly by subject: thus Hindu myths; castes, trades and occupations; natural history; and legendary narratives. Dallapiccola introduces the first of these sections with a discussion on pictorial style and provenance, and the elements of iconography, costume and jewellery. Most of the mythological paintings in the collection are grouped in sets, one with no less than 99 compositions executed in pen-and-ink wash (Cat. 4), others with 61, 70 and 91 water colours (Cats. 3, 7 and 5 respectively). To the credit of The British Museum Press a generous selection of pages from these and other comparable sets are illustrated so as to give the best possible idea of the spectrum of gods and goddesses that populate the South Indian Hindu pantheon. Most of these divine personalities are familiar from pictorial traditions in other parts of the country, but others, such as the folk god Mailara (Cat. 3.63) and the 16-armed form of Vishnu known as Sudarshana (Cat. 3.12), are more characteristically South Indian. Interleaved into these pictorial series are occasional diversions, a scene of a Hindu wedding (Cat. 3.6) and a temple plan (Cat. 5.1), which afford a welcome insight into contemporary social life and urban settings. Most noticeable here are the stylistic variations between ateliers in the different centres of Tamil Nadu and Karnataka. But lesser familiar workshops such as those at Machilipatnam and Shorapur are also represented, the latter by a depiction of a celestial entertainment with female dancers in a garden palace, presided over by a trio of gods (Cat. 12.7).
In her second section of the catalogue Dallapiccola presents sets of drawings of different trades and occupations, most of them supplied with English captions. The paintings are of considerable sociological value, not only for the different types of peoples that are portrayed, but also for their depictions insight into the preoccupation of the English in South India at the time. The European connection is confirmed by one composition showing Sir John Dalling, Commander-in-Chief of Madras in the 1780s, together with his retinue, enjoying a nautch performance (Cat. 18.6). Of greater artistic interest, perhaps, are the natural history paintings in the next section of the catalogue. Some of these are executed with considerable skill and elegance, often with European inspired shading to enhance their realistic appearance, such as those in water colour on mica panels depicting gorgeous orchids and hibiscuses (Cat. 19.1–25 and 20.1).
The most important of the painted narratives that constitute the fourth section of Dallapiccola's catalogue are those on cotton scrolls, one of which is more than 9 metres long! Divided into panels, generally with red backgrounds, these scrolls illustrate local legends such as the story of Bhavana Rishi (Cats. 22 and 23), which seems to have been particularly popular in the Telangana region of Andhra. Other cloths, such as those with vigorous Ramayana compositions, were executed by Tamil artists resident in Sri Lanka (Cat. 27), or by South Indian artists for distant markets such as Sulawesi in the Indonesian islands (Cat. 26). Other paintings in this series belong to the kalamkari cloths associated with the great temple centre of Kalahasti in south-eastern Andhra Pradesh. Several of these cloths dating from no earlier than the 1950s are of huge dimensions, and are crammed with episodes from the Ramayana and Mahabharata epics, all identified by Telugu labels (Cats. 31 and 32). The section ends with two paper sets with strikingly bold paintings, supposedly from Paithan in Maharashtra (Cats. 33 and 34). These were produced by chitrakathis, or local storey-tellers, for use in public performances of sacred stories. In addition to this profusion of paintings, Dallapiccola also includes a model of a processional chariot with a cloth-canopy roof, presented to the Museum in 1793. Its interior shrine, with painted walls, is attended by painted, miniature wooden priests and musicians.
The volume concludes with a technical study by staff from the conservation department of the Museum who examine the restorations of two particular paintings (Cat. 18.5 and 6). Dallapiccola's glossary, bibliography and various indexes should satisfy the needs of the most demanding readers.
