Studies of industrialisation in Latin America have undergone significant changes since the 1970s. In broad terms there has been a shift from an interpretation that saw industrial development as being galvanised by the external shock of the Great Depression in the 1930s to an alternative viewpoint that stresses that, at least in the leading Latin American economies, industrialisation got under way in the latter decades of the nineteenth century, coinciding with a period of export-led growth. Although a series of studies produced in Argentina in the 1970s spearheaded the revision of traditional interpretations of the roots of industrialisation in Latin America, until recently there had been a dearth of general studies of industrialisation prior to 1930 in the country itself, in contrast to the cases of Mexico and Brazil. The publication of Fernando Rocchi's Chimneys in the Desert: Industrialization in Argentina during the Export Boom Years, 1870–1930 (Stanford University Press, 2006) represented a giant step forward, offering for the first time the results of exhaustive and original research on the process.
The objective of Yovanna Pineda's book, published a few years later, is to contribute to the study of Argentine industrialisation between 1890 and 1930, focusing primarily on its limitations. The author considers the reasons for Argentina's failure to become an industrial nation, even though it already possessed the prerequisites for achieving this by the beginning of the twentieth century. In order to explain this conundrum she turns to new macro- and micro-economic empirical evidence and uses econometric tools, aligning herself explicitly with the camp of the ‘New Economic History of Latin America’.
In order to explain the principal obstacles to industrialisation in Argentina, Pineda concentrates on a series of specific issues. She begins by examining productivity and the extent of industrial concentration between 1895 and 1933, using information from industrial censuses and focusing on 12 sectors and subsectors that produced consumer goods and inputs. Second, she reconstructs the process of technology incorporation by drawing up time series on machinery imports between 1890 and 1930, using both Argentine sources and those of the leading capital-goods-exporting countries. Third, she identifies economic groups engaged in industrial activity between 1890 and 1930, drawing upon a database of the directors and major shareholders of 59 companies in the 12 sectors selected. She then looks at the profitability and strategies of these companies between 1904 and 1930, on the basis of the annual reports and accounts and other documentation from these firms. Finally, she analyses industrial legislation between 1900 and 1930, using parliamentary debates and periodicals as source material.
Despite its ambitious scope, the book does not offer much that is new regarding the initial phase of Argentine industrialisation. Its main contribution lies in the information it provides on areas that had previously been unexplored, or had not been subjected to empirical research. It is worth highlighting the chapter on imports of machinery, parts and fuel, the result of painstaking reconstruction work, alongside the calculations of company productivity and profitability. But close reading reveals a series of problems that raise questions about the work as a whole.
The first relates to whether the sectors and subsectors selected are sufficiently representative of Argentine industry in the period. The author fails to explain her selection criteria, and although she states that these are consumer goods production sectors, some intermediate goods producers (iron and steel, cement, glass, burlap bags) and also capital goods producers (small-scale machine shops) are included. Another point to note is that Pineda calculates the level of concentration on the basis of data from the 1895 census, though at this point the development of a modern industrial sector in Argentina was only just beginning. This calls into doubt the appropriateness of the choice and the representative nature of the data obtained.
A second problem is the author's scant familiarity with the literature on the origins of industrialisation in Argentina, particularly the debates over the characteristics of the business class and the economic groups. This may be a problem that goes beyond this book, since it is related to the audience for which the book is written. If the principal intended readership is an audience of North American academics, it is understandable that the book should give precedence to references from US authors and that it should take an approach that is in sympathy with the predominant lines of research within their frame of reference. But this does not justify ignoring, or at least failing to emphasise sufficiently, long-standing controversies and recent contributions from Argentine historians. A few examples suffice. First, Pineda appears to be unaware of the intense polemics that began in the 1970s and continue today regarding the question of whether Argentine industrialists in the period before 1930 were ‘rent seekers’ or not. Second, she draws up a questionable list of the main economic groups according to her own criteria, apparently leaving to one side the abundant literature on this subject published since the 1980s. Third, she constantly reiterates the difficulties faced by industrial companies in gaining access to finance, whereas Fernando Rocchi's work offers a different picture, one based on exhaustive archival research and representing a perspective that deserves at least to be mentioned.
A third problematic aspect of Yovanna Pineda's work is that the conclusions she reaches do not appear to be based sufficiently on the empirical evidence she offers. In order to explain the weaknesses of the industrialisation process in Argentina, the author argues that local firms were not capable of satisfying domestic demand because entrepreneurs were not interested in making long-term investments and tried to dominate their markets by means of support from the state, lobbying for high import tariffs rather than establishing competitive advantages. It is not a question of whether the analysis is correct or not –in fact, it is one of the standard interpretations in the literature on the subject – but of the extent to which it is founded on the research data here. For example, in chapter 3 Pineda states that labour productivity grew between 1895 and 1935 in all the sectors and subsectors under review (p. 22), and in the following chapter she maintains that machinery imports grew consistently between 1890 and 1930 (p. 43). What is hard to fathom is why she affirms, in the light of these statements, that business owners were inefficient and risk-averse. An explanation is offered in terms of the level of industrial concentration, but other historical experiences show that such concentration is not necessarily an obstacle to industrialisation. The author states that local producers had limited knowledge of technology, but she does not substantiate this, nor does she pause to reflect on the different forms of innovation adopted in late-developing economies.
A fourth point to note is that the work contains several inaccuracies, which I shall not dwell upon, but which include the statements that state intervention began in 1914 (p. 1), that industry never spearheaded the growth of the economy during the twentieth century (p. 128), and that public policy after 1930 generally followed a similar course to that of the period between 1890 and 1930 (p. 132).
A general conclusion to be drawn from reading this work is that the deployment of abundant information and its subsequent processing by means of econometric techniques does not guarantee a good end product, in the sense of encouraging greater and more precise understanding of a historical process, if the data is not chosen and analysed adequately, and contextualised and measured against the historical and theoretical literature available. This is a subject beyond the scope of this review, and one which encompasses long-standing polemics about methodology and related debates regarding the strengths and weaknesses of the ‘New Economic History’. Yet, despite these criticisms of the approach, the book does offer abundant and useful information for readers interested in early Latin American industrialisation in general, and that of Argentina in particular, the results of intensive research in primary sources and the techniques used to process the data.
