Academics, experts, and commentators on the Middle East explore the local, regional, global, political, ethical, and legal consequences of Israel's thirty-four-day war against Lebanon during the summer of 2006 in The War on Lebanon. Editor and coauthor Hovsepian and thirty-one contributors—including many renowned scholars of the Middle East—as well as foreword writer Rashid Khalidi, address a series of far-reaching questions and issues. The book's six parts chronologically trace the prewar contexts and causes and the experiences of those who lived through the war and outline its many implications.
Although much of the material here is perhaps familiar to anyone who has studied the politics of the modern Middle East, this is the first sweeping effort to amass the scholarship, commentaries, and reflections in one edited volume. It is certainly one of the more comprehensive analyses of war and politics in a post-9/11 Middle East, one that fittingly traces the current course to events long before the attack on the United States: the Palestinian–Israeli conflict, the Iranian Revolution, and the Soviet intervention in Afghanistan.
Hovsepian outlines the main thesis of the book as an examination of the historical, social, and political processes affecting Lebanon. He underlines that the war—indeed all major events in Lebanon (and certainly the region)—cannot be understood in isolation; people must consider the local, regional, and international (read U.S.) context. A regional framework in particular, and the U.S. vision of a new Middle East more specifically, is a point reinforced by many of the contributors to this book. As Khalidi's foreword makes clear, this is neither the first extension of the Arab–Israeli conflict into neighboring countries nor the first involvement by a world power in local politics and conflicts. It does mark, however, the further lumping together of otherwise separate and distinct conflicts in the Levant, the Gulf region, and other areas under the Bush administration's rubric of the “war on terror”: they are ultimately perceived and dealt with as one single enemy.
The War on Lebanon begins with a necessary and concise historical examination of Lebanon's development to lay the background for war, from the country's adaptation of a confessional system and the death of secularism to the rise of Hizbullah and the assassination of then prime minister Rafic Hariri. The five chapters in Part I outline the context of the prewar (both the civil war and 2006 war) eras.
Part II, a vital section for understanding not just Israel's war on Lebanon but also the current and future situation in the Middle East, reveals the collusion of Israeli and American interests in the region and suggests that the Israeli attack on Lebanon in the summer of 2006 can be simultaneously classified as the sixth Arab–Israeli conflict and the American–Israeli war on Lebanon. The extent of U.S. involvement in the war and its influence in determining the war's length and level of destruction are unquestionably established. For the United States, argues Stephen Zunes, Israel was its proxy, and its attack on Lebanon was a testing ground for a possible U.S. attack against Iran. Several contributions in this section also remind us that the 2006 summer war was not an act of self-defense, as was repeatedly asserted by both the United States and Israel and portrayed as such in much of the Western media, but had been in the planning long before Hizbullah's abduction of two Israeli soldiers, likely beginning after Israel withdrew its troops from South Lebanon in 2000.
In Part III, “Israel's War on Lebanon,” Hovsepian includes six chapters by those who experienced the war firsthand. These chapters, the majority in the first person and told through actual diary entries, contain detailed reflections of war as a lived experience. For readers who experienced the conflict firsthand, myself included, the explicit memories can be difficult to revisit.
Parts IV and V offer a glimpse into the international legal system and account for dissident voices from inside Israel, respectively. The former section addresses the role of international law and the United Nations during war. It demonstrates the ineffectiveness of the United Nations in general, and the Security Council in particular, in securing an early ceasefire and imposing international law—largely because of U.S. pressure. It also examines how American media coverage ignored history and context, making it easier for America to support Israel's self-defense claims and thereby rendering any U.N. verdict improbable and ineffectual. Part V examines the deconstruction of Israeli power and provides a space for the dissenting voices in Israel that challenge official orthodoxies.
The final, and arguably most significant, section of The War on Lebanon examines the economic and human costs of the conflict. It also sets out the local, regional, and global repercussions of the war in a multiplicity of ways: the (once unlikely) association of Hizbullah and Michel Aoun's Free Patriotic Movement in Lebanon, the intensification and solidification of the Sunni–Shiʿi split with its regional ramifications, the failure of Israel's unilateral policy in the face of the growing momentum of the resistance (Hamas in the occupied territories and Hizbullah in Lebanon), and the emergence of what Fred Halliday calls the “Greater West Asian Crisis,” which is characterized by a three-way conflict—Iran and its radical allies (Syria, Hizbullah, Hamas, and Iraqi Shiʿa) versus radical Sunni insurgency (in Iraq and Al-Qaʾida) versus the United States and its regional allies. As a result, to understand what is happening in Lebanon, or in Israel, or in Iraq, or anywhere in the region, requires an understanding of U.S. policy and of the shifting interests of new powers like Russia, India, and China.
This is one viewpoint put forward in this last section. The other, as advanced by authors like Rami Khouri, sees the war on Lebanon as an extension of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. The actual source of the war and just about every other issue plaguing the region—the war in Iraq, the rise of Iran, terrorism, and extremism, to name just a few—is the Arab–Israeli conflict. Khouri insists that the solution lies in dealing with the root cause and not the symptoms, as has been the practice of the last several decades. In other words, we must find a just resolution to the Arab–Israeli conflict. This is by no means a new plea but one that continues to go unheard and/or ignored in favor of other quick and short-term fixes.
What makes The War on Lebanon a worthwhile read is the contributors' insistence on a consideration of history, context, and a more global vision to understanding not just the 2006 summer war but also what is happening today in the Arab world as a whole. The book's contributors collectively uncover the true basis behind the war, in contrast to the cause readily conveyed, particularly in the West. The war against Lebanon is intricately connected to the wider issues of the Middle East, from the Palestinian–Israeli conflict to the Bush administration's quest to “bring democracy” to the region.
Hovsepian provides an indispensable resource both on recent events—including a clearer understanding of Israel's latest attack on Gaza—and what the immediate future is likely to bring. There is one question this book does not address, doubtless because its publication preceded the U.S. change in leadership. Will America's design for a “democratic Middle East” look any different under an Obama administration?
