The book Flora Tristán, Pensamiento económico y comunicación social en tiempos del Romanticismo (Flora Tristán, Economic thought and social communication in the times of Romanticism) examines the life and work of Flora Tristán (Paris 1803–Bordeaux 1844) in order to analyze her contributions to social sciences. The work is divided into five chapters spread over 180 pages, including a final reflection on the author’s contributions to economic and social thought.
Chapter I, entitled “Apuntes históricos sobre los primeros años de Flora Tristán” (Historical notes on the early years of Flora Tristán), depicts her life in the first half of the nineteenth century, a period that coincides with the second industrialization of France, leading to profound changes in industrial structures and the rapid development of social sciences. These may be accounted for by economic changes and all their resulting effects: class and gender inequalities that forged class consciousness and led to workers’ movements. Tristán was self-taught, and Pérez Calle portrays her as someone of great intellectual capacities, a mature social scientist dedicated to spreading her economic-social and feminist ideas from a personal perspective of associationist and revolutionary utopian socialism.
This chapter also provides a bibliographical review of the authors who have studied the figure and work of Flora Tristán, including Eleanor Blanc, Jules Puech, Dominique Desanti, Stéphane Michaud, Evelyne Bloch-Dano, Luis Alberto Sánchez, and Mario Vargas Llosa. It also reminds readers that her work has been studied from the perspective of feminism, politics, philosophy, and sociology but not economics, which constitutes Pérez Calle’s main contribution. Her research has been conducted within the Communication and Digital Information (GICID) research group at the University of Zaragoza.
The chapter then moves on to relevant details from Tristán’s biography, which were essential to understanding her intellectual development, with her childhood and adolescence scarred by poverty. Her mother was French and her father was a Peruvian military officer from a wealthy family. He died in 1807 and bequeathed all his goods to his brother instead of his family, leaving them completely destitute. Flora married in 1821. This unfortunate union ended in 1825 when she fled home with her children. Her dire economic situation and the fear of being discovered by her abusive husband brought home to her the degradation and vulnerability to which women were exposed. The book highlights the dramatic events of 1832 that led to the separation of her children (Alexandre, Ernest, and Alina), and which created two psychological profiles that have been analyzed by Pérez Calle: Flora Tristán, the outcast; and Flora Tristán, the scientist.
Chapter II, entitled “El viaje a Perú: un punto de inflexión en el itinerario de vida y ciencia de Flora Tristán” (Journey to Peru: A turning point in Flora Tristán’s life and scientific career), narrates how she embarked on a voyage to find her father’s family in 1833. Her life experiences are reflected in her work Peregrinaciones de una paria (Wanderings of an outcast), published in 1837. Pérez Calle considers these years to be essential to Tristán’s scientific development and social thought, together with a certain financial relief in the form of the pension granted by her uncle Pío Tristán, which she received for a number of years.
Flora Tristán was a strong woman and a believer in social justice and the Christian message. She was an observer who carried out informative and quantitative fieldwork on the indentured situation of workers—for example, the sailors on the ship Le Mexicain on which she had traveled to Peru. In the same book she also collected information on the oppression of women at home and in factories, subjected to laws, social customs, and prejudices, and compared their labor situation in France and Peru.
Pérez Calle demonstrates that Tristán criticized the economic and financial system of the times in her book Peregrinaciones de una paria. At the same time, she proposed remedial solutions together with descriptive and dialogue-based reflections, the latter including her conversations with her cousin Carmen. She was an abolitionist and, interestingly, she made economic arguments against slavery when attempting to convince slave owners, using Europe as a point of reference within the framework of an international fraternity of solidarity. It is believed that she became aware of her outcast status, and the need to actively participate in social transformation in order to counteract economic inequalities, during her trip to Peru. Pérez Calle demonstrates that this book represents the beginning of all her later work and scientific methodology: personal experience and informative fieldwork. The book’s success paved the way for further publications by Tristán in Parisian newspapers and magazines including Le Siècle, Journal des debats, and La Phalange.
Chapter III, entitled “La vuelta a Europa y los años de esplendor” (Return to Europe and the splendid years), delves into the years of her return to Paris, and emphasizes the process of intellectual maturity and social empowerment that she underwent. Pérez Calle highlights the reflexive drive, popularity, and social relations that shaped the core of her thought between 1835 and 1840.
Tristán was influenced by utopian socialism. The influence of Saint-Simonianism is presented in reference to the organization of labor and industrial progress focused on the drive of the working class, in the absence of class struggle. She knew and became friends with Charles Fourier, from whom she adopted her criticism of capitalist industrialization and the importance of a non-violent revolution, as well as the social and productive organizational cooperation of the Fourierian school. From Robert Owen, whom she also knew and admired personally, she took the importance of worker association in achieving goals, citing the case of profit maximization with labor and social welfare. She analyzed Owen’s thought in her next book Promenades dans Londres (Walks through London, 1840). Pérez Calle highlights Flora Tristán’s economic analysis in the debate on ideas, and discusses the opinion market that counteracts asymmetrical information and dangerous misinformation of the aristocracy which, in Tristán’s opinion, weakened the working class while empowering the bourgeoisie.
Pérez Calle shows the formative process of Tristán’s thought from her first publication, which was a short essay in 1835 entitled “La necessité de faire un bon acceuil aux femmes étrangèrs” (On the need to make foreign women welcome), where she outlined the innovative methodology of her fieldwork: aims, own experience, observation, developing hypotheses, theory building, and the creation of tools to put it into practice. In this case, the tool was designing the articles of an association to aid foreign women, La Societé pour les femmes étrangères (The foreign women’s society). Tristán believed that a successful woman was an educated woman, and that she would be conferred equal rights and duties, with the aim of projecting equality to all social classes.
In 1838 she published a novel entitled Méphis ou le Proletaire (Méphis or the proletarian) in the style of Harriet Martineau, whom she had probably read during her years in London. Pérez Calle comments on the romantic tragedy of its two protagonists: Méphis and Maréquita, French workers who show readers the economic inequalities arising from industrial commodification, and where, once again, access to education represents the workers’ salvation. Like Jane Marcet and Harriet Martineau, the aim of her book was to spread knowledge. Given that Marcet, Martineau, and Tristán had no access to a university education simply because they were women, the only way they could spread their ideas was through the popular success of their books. And it appears that all three succeeded in this regard.
In 1840 she published Promenades dans Londres and, as Tristán indicates in the quotations included by Pérez Calle, it is a book of facts and observations collected directly to be analyzed, and which seeks to reveal the flaws of the English system so they may be avoided. Tristán had traveled to England four times—in 1826, 1831, 1833, and 1839—and commented on the decline of the economic system, since misery and labor unrest were on the rise. In this work, Tristán called on workers to wage a great fight for social transformation, and gave the example of the Chartists as a workers’ association fighting to eradicate the inequalities and privileges that were being perpetuated in the British system. Interestingly, she examined real wages, with reference to basic necessities, workers’ working and living conditions, their labor rights, food, health, and longevity. Her comments on prostitution arising from the misery and exploitation of the working class are highly striking. Tristán estimated the population of prostitutes to be between 80,000 and 100,000 women. Her economic arguments are relevant; Promenades dans Londres is a book to bear in mind when studying nineteenth-century industrial expansion in Europe.
Chapter IV, entitled “El rumbo del apostolado” (The course of the campaign), takes us back to 1843 when she published La Unión Obrera (The workers’ union) by means of a public subscription a year before her death. The names of the 123 subscribers who raised the 1,538 francs for the publication are listed at the beginning of the book. It is a work of intellectual maturity based on the concept of achieving an organized, supportive, egalitarian, and productive society without gender discrimination, underpinned by a peaceful struggle for social justice, ownership of labor power, and the right to work. Her proposal called for the creation of centers, which she named “workers’ union palaces,” to establish a deep universal union among the workers. She also embarked on a tour that she called the “Tour de France” to disseminate her economic principles. Pérez Calle describes it as a great campaign to pass on her socio-economic model to seven million French workers.
Chapter V is postmortem and, fortunately, her friend Alphonse Constant takes up some of her unfinished works, such as her diary of the Tour de France and La emancipación de la mujer o el Testamento de una paria (The emancipation of the woman or declarations of an outcast, 1846). Constant defines this last work as a journey into spirituality, with deep reflections of life, which seeks to strengthen the workers’ union.
Pérez Calle’s book concludes with a beautiful reflection on Tristán’s model, which focuses on the proletarian labor power and its capacity to generate wealth as a group, with a discourse of universal justice and solidarity in gender equality. The author laments that it was overshadowed by the narrative on class struggle of scientific socialism.
It is an interesting, well-written, and enjoyable book that fulfils the author’s main objective of including the writer Flora Tristán and her scientific work, which is critical of nineteenth-century industrial capitalism, as well as her contributions to socialism and the labor movement, into the body of economic and social thought.
COMPETING INTERESTS
The author declares no competing interests exist.
