Many music scholars and cultural activists are forging ideas on how to transgress the walls of universities and academia and make both music and research on music accessible to broader audiences. Despite great efforts in applied and engaged ethnomusicology and a nearly paradigmatic positioning of participatory and dialogical forms of research (see Hemetek, Kölbl, and Sağlam Reference Hemetek, Kölbl and Sağlam2019), ethnomusicology at large has yet to overcome the systemic hegemonies between the ones doing research and the ones being researched (see Sardo Reference Sardo, Martí and Gútiez2018). This unequal power relationship holds true especially for minorities, who often are structurally excluded from academic spheres and scholarly knowledge production.
RomArchive—Digital Archive of the Roma aims to counter these hegemonies that we so often find in academia, specifically the hegemonies surrounding the creation and maintenance of archives. Institutional archives that are invested in national, imperial, and colonial legacies generally fail to represent, let alone include, cultural expressions of ethnic minorities (see also Western Reference Western2019). Targeting academic audiences, institutional archives do not provide easy access to minority members. Further, their few representations of minorities often draw on non-minority positionalities based on historic ethnographies that draw on emic concepts, meanings, and values. In its promotion of self-representation and accessibility, RomArchive presents an alternative: an archive produced by minority members for minority members, as well as all others. Its maxim, as articulated by one of its founders, is “nothing about us without us” (Raabe Reference Raabe2020:88).
The ten topical sections of the website comprise around 5,000 audiovisual files, photographs, recorded art works, and articles by over 150 participants from 15 countries. This archive, magazine, and portal seeks to focus on all art forms and cultural expressions of Roma around the world. The objectives of the site are ambitious. When one enters the online space, sharp headers appear on the neatly structured site: “Creating visibility,” “Reclaiming culture,” “Decolonizing knowledge,” and “Deconstructing identities.” These slogans represent the website’s approach to showcasing the cultural expressions of the Roma—cultural expressions that have a history of stereotypical representation and exoticisation, positioning the Roma as “Other” from a Eurocentric perspective through music.
Central in facilitating visibility and accessibility is the archive’s (non-)locality: the Internet allows for low-threshold access—the website is designed for desktop and mobile devices, which adds to its accessibility, with the smartphone interface being of particular relevance in reaching the target communities. Another crucial feature is RomArchive’s language policy: next to German and English, the entire content is available in Romani. Funded by the German Federal Cultural Foundation with a grant of €3.75 million, this large-scale project is one of the biggest public foundations of its kind. Sixteen curators, almost all with Romani background, are responsible for ten sections that consistently foreground the principle of self-representation. Curator-in-chief of the music section is Petra Gelbert, a Romani musician, educator, and ethnomusicologist. She is supported by fellow music curators and ethnomusicologists Carol Silverman and Siv B. Lie, and a team of fifteen other researchers, musicians, and activists.
Surprisingly, RomArchive’s selection policy indicates that artistic excellence is a key criterion for selection, stressing the quality of well-known and lesser-known artists as a requirement. Although perhaps reasonable in the context of other art forms, the focus on “artists” may seem unusual to ethnomusicologists. While Roma musical traditions may indeed feature musical excellence and outstanding individual artists, they often also do not meet the standardised conceptualisation of singular artistry; rather, they tend to involve participatory expressive forms found in everyday settings, some of which are also featured on the website. Accordingly, the music section is divided into six chapters, two representing musical styles (classical music and jazz) and four based on regions (Balkan, Central Europe, Russia, and Northern and Western Europe). An additional chapter, “Introduction and Context,” features four texts by Petra Gelbert tackling basic questions regarding the definition and representation of Roma music (as of August 2020). Gelbert’s contributions also dominate the chapters on Central Europe and Russia—her perspective overall strongly shapes the music section, including political activist and feminist perspectives on Roma music.
The six chapters of the music section offer articles and interviews on individual artists as well as musical styles, phenomena, and practices. The Balkan chapter, for example, comprises descriptions of Manele urban ethno-pop in Romania, zourna and daouli instrumental music in Greece, and Romani brass bands in Serbia, as well as features on Macedonian singer Esma Redžepova, Manele performer Florin Salam, and Bulgarian saxophonist Yuri Yunakov, among others. This selection also points to a weakness of the project: certain styles and artists are featured while others remain out of the picture. Precisely this challenge, however, seems to inform RomArchive’s approach. In the present, first phase of arranging content, the archive intends to grow—although presenting an exhaustive overview on Roma music is neither possible nor intended. After all, it is the blog-archive’s expandability that makes it a valuable source of knowledge. The articles offer concise overviews of the respective topics, suitable for a broad public readership while simultaneously providing scholarly accuracy. In addition, all audio and video examples are not only playable while reading, but also available for download with all accompanying metadata.
Also relevant to readers of this journal, especially those interested in ethnochoreology, is RomArchive’s dance section (curated by Isaac Blake) and separate Flamenco section (curated by Gonzalo Montaño Peña). Both sections provide thorough information, but do not yet illustrate the diversity of voices in Roma dance and flamenco. Here again it becomes apparent that a well-balanced curation of content is yet to be achieved in regularly expanding content, a circumstance that constitutes RomArchive’s greatest challenge and potential strength.
RomArchive forms a resource for further inclusion and increased accessibility of various existing perspectives on Roma dances and musics. But the music section currently lacks references to several established and aspiring Roma music researchers, and it therefore misses an opportunity to transgress the Eastern- and Southeastern-European and German-centric predominance of its existing materials. This section would benefit from an expansion of the voices within the ethnomusicological network of Roma research. Since RomArchive explicitly serves “as a contact point for preserving material on Roma cultures and histories for the future,” the website welcomes proposals for material to be added (be it for common use on the website or restricted access within the internal archive). Providing this opportunity to contribute and participate will help RomArchive to further grow and foster its unique music-related minoritarian agency.
