No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2004
In 1986, just when many were beginning to question the viability of the American union movement, Robert Zieger published a survey history of the American unions from 1920–1985. In American Workers, American Unions, Zieger sought to provide a “civic history” of American workers, or a history of workers' collective action in labor unions. As such, the book was a great success. In barely 200 pages, Zieger provided a survey of the organized labor movement suitable for undergraduate history classes that was also of value to graduate students and their professors.
The current third edition is an update of the classic Zieger text with two new chapters and some additional material added to a third. Written by Zieger, the first chapter reviews labor relations before World War I. He shows how competition and the imperative to reduce costs led employers to challenge the position of skilled craftsmen within American manufacturing and to recruit lower-wage immigrant workers from Southern and Eastern Europe. Behind employer anti-unionism, he argues, was a determination “to control the workplace free of restriction” (p. 21). New material added to the next chapter describing labor relations during World War I adds a useful review of that period's dramatic industrial changes as well as the entry of new workers, especially women and southern African-Americans, into the industrial labor force.
The second entirely new chapter is written by Gilbert Gall whose previous works include a superb biography of Lee Pressman, the lawyer associated with the Congress of Industrial Organizations of the 1930s and 1940s, and studies of the politics of “right to work” legislation. After reviewing the rise of the new “organizing model” for American unions in the 1990s, Gall's chapter discusses organized labor's growing political activism through the 1980s and the Clinton administration of the 1990s. Gall nearly reverses the earlier focus on employers and technology to emphasize union strategy and politics. In the new chapter 1, for example, Zieger says nothing about the AFL's campaign against the judicial injunction and for the Clayton Act (1914); Gall, by contrast, neglects recent technological changes and population shifts to focus on recent union political campaigns such as that against NAFTA.
The enhanced focus on politics and state policy rather than economics and technology in Gall's concluding chapter continues a trend in Zieger's own chapters where politics looms more important in the chapters covering the later twentieth century. Zieger and Gall may be suggesting that organized labor's recent problems may be more in the political than in the economic realm. If so, there may also be a lesson here for labor activists, and for historians.
American Workers, American Unions is a good book made better in its latest incarnation. Those looking for a course book for twentieth-century labor history should consider it. Those looking for their own enlightenment will find it a quick and useful read. Each edition has been better; I look forward to the next.