Jennifer Lisa Koslow's exploration of municipal public health is set against the backdrop of Los Angeles during its boom years at the turn of the twentieth century, when the city lured new arrivals with the promise of health-uplifting sunshine. In this ostensibly health-infused locale, white middle-class women reformers' actions underwrote the expansion of municipal responsibility for citizens' health. First, these women established intellectual and bureaucratic frameworks ripe for government appropriation. They then deployed maternal and scientific arguments to compare the limitations of private endeavors to the advantages of governmental institutionalization. Patient-clients, a very different group of women who were impoverished, immigrant, or socially marginalized, negotiated for a version of public health that acknowledged some rights to privacy and private interests that might otherwise have been overwhelmed in the course of reformers' enthusiastic cleansing of individuals' bodies and homes. Although men—as officeholders, physicians, fellow reformers, and patients—are not without agency in Koslow's narrative, it is women to whom she attributes the greatest share of responsibility for the domain and shape of municipal intervention in public health.
In many ways, Koslow's argument resonates with those posed by other historians of women and reform during the Progressive Era. Readers familiar with the work of Robyn Muncy, Molly Ladd-Taylor, and William Chafe, among others, will not be surprised by the story of government appropriation of maternalists' agendas and endeavors, or by the idea that women were architects of state-building.Footnote 1 However, Koslow departs from these oft-cited narratives by foregrounding two points. First, she presents a narrative wherein women reformers' authority is not regretfully lost to men in government. It is instead offered up by women reformers who planned for such co-optation and deliberately sought to share their authority with male professionals and government officials. Second, she suggests that the relative activism of local government in the 1890s—in comparison to expanding state and federal governments—encouraged some women to begin their advocacy at the municipal level. The close look at Los Angeles therefore contributes some interesting nuances to classic interpretations.
Each chapter of Cultivating Health explores an individual program or policy advanced by women reformers, tracing the pathway by which it was eventually incorporated into municipal governance. Three of these reforms—public health nursing, housing codes and inspection, and maternity assistance—were advocated by the Los Angeles College Settlement Association (LACSA), which Koslow portrays as the embodiment of a “social milieu” in which educated women informed themselves about public and political issues (7). There are some wonderful details about how LACSA members acquired their extensive knowledge of poor people's lives: Women reformers read public health nurses' visitation reports, became embroiled in the rivalry between baseball-playing boys and grumpy local businessmen, met national reformers such as Jane Addams and Jacob Riis, read professional journals, and monitored infant mortality statistics. The LACSA women used this highly constructed knowledge to make the case for their programs' necessity. At stake in these reform movements was the matter of persuading fellow citizens that the city had responsibilities beyond responding to epidemics and that the city's health department should both educate the public and cure disease. LACSA women considered themselves successful when municipal government provided funding for their private programs, established commissions of private citizens to oversee government programs, and fused private with public endeavors in new municipal bureaus. For example, for LACSA women, the act of turning their public nursing program over to Los Angeles's Bureau of Municipal Nursing in 1913 “fulfill[ed] a long-cherished plan” (41). A perhaps unanticipated byproduct of the creation of knowledge about public health was the fastening of racial distinctions. Particularly in the process of crafting housing codes and conducting building inspections, reformers and public health officials came to judge not only types of dwellings, but types of people, as inherently deviant.
Clubwomen from various groups joined together to support two other reforms also investigated by Koslow: milk inspection and venereal disease treatment. Although each chapter references incidents in which the intended recipients of public health reforms negotiated aspects of its practice, it is in these two chapters that Koslow most clearly delineates the edges of clubwomen's authority. In the intriguingly titled chapter, “Bovines, Babies, and Bacteriology,” Koslow interprets the 1912 defeat of a city ordinance that would have provided for a tuberculin test of dairy cattle as evidence that reformers' claims of disease, rooted in difficult-to-understand scientific data, were ultimately checked by consumers' fears of a rise in milk prices. “The Challenge of Constructing Venereal Disease Programs” illuminates the protests of women who refused to be examined for venereal disease at the time of their arrests. Government officials who encountered these women often balked at using force, grudgingly accepting a middle ground wherein they quarantined arrested women until they would cooperate. Arrested women, in turn, sometimes pursued liberation by invoking habeas corpus or simply ran away from treatment centers.
This work will be enthusiastically greeted by anyone interested in municipal reforms, health care policy, gender and politics, or the relationship between various levels of governance. Koslow examined club minutes, nurses' reports, municipal reports, petitions, and local newspapers, and she reads these sources with thoughtful attention to the motivations of various actors. Tantalizingly introduced by her research, but ultimately under-analyzed, is the question of why so many public health programs expired within a decade or two of being institutionalized by government, especially if they were so carefully planned and secured. Here, municipal public health reforms seemingly stand in stark contrast to, for example, maternalists' pursuit of the mothers' pensions that evolved into modern welfare. By quickly passing over the demise of various commissions and bureaus, Koslow leaves open to speculation whether changes in state or federal authority, economy, population, political culture, or urban health best explain the systemic loss of a wide range of health programs (if not all of them), as well as government's later negligence about reinstating such programs.
