How were the British able to rule India at such a long distance? What forms of the modern state emerged, as a result, in the periphery? In order to assuage the concerns of the British public and Parliament, the East India Company government in India became especially concerned with producing documents for metropolitan oversight. In varied government practices, from land revenue settlement and the adjudication of legal cases to creating accountability for governance through petitioning, Document Raj locates the sinews of colonial power in a bureaucracy that privileged continuous writing. Employing an impressive array of multiple-language sources, Bhavani Raman makes a compelling case that to truly understand the nature of colonial governance we should peer inside its offices, courtrooms, and archives, attending to the micro-practices of this documentary regime and the new forms of power it produced.
In the early colonial period (the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries), the British encountered and depended upon previously existing, highly elaborate Indian writing cultures. Raman analyzes these scribal and pedagogic cultures, in the process drawing our attention to the different forms and genres that would have characterized this period. And yet, this is not just a story about how local actors and the British encountered one another, or how local scholars resisted or alternatively collaborated in the logic of British governance (pp. 24–25). Raman significantly reframes sometimes-vociferous debates about the production of colonial archives, knowledge, and their relationship to governance. Rather than focus on the epistemological underpinnings of colonial and modern disciplinary knowledge to assess the contribution of different players, Raman draws our attention to the transformations in textual practice that accompanied early colonial rule and the new forms of expertise and authenticity that underwrote the projects of the modern state. For example, certain forms, like the signature or the petition, had existed in India before, but now they were deliberately reoriented within a regime of “‘papereality,’ or the exclusive reliance on official written documents to represent the world” (p. 3). This regime, Raman artfully demonstrates, entailed peculiar ideas and demanded particular dispositions from the writing subject, from pedagogy, language, and even from writing itself—even as it rendered previous modes of writing and remembering suspect.
The language of transparency and impartiality that bureaucracy speaks about itself is here subjected to a withering critique. In Document Raj, utilitarianism and bureaucratic reform (the idea, for example, that public and private business need to be separated) are shown to have allowed the colonial state to expand territorially and subordinate native collaborators in a racialized hierarchy. In the process, the local was itself produced. So, to take one important theme threaded throughout the whole book, Raman argues that caste was reinvigorated and hardened through the practices of the colonial state: it took on renewed importance in the recruitment strategies of the East India Company, even as the functions of caste groups shifted. Upper-caste clerks, for example, were overrepresented in the offices of colonial Madras, where they “could no longer legitimately partake of the wider relationships of exchange and had their upward mobility restricted within the cutcherry” (p. 49). As a result, they ultimately came to place an even greater emphasis on their own caste- and language-based affiliations, to secure and maintain their privileged occupations (p. 50).
In one of its most forceful arguments, Document Raj details how the early colonial regime produced corruption. Even as it demanded and tried to create a continuous paper trail for metropolitan oversight, the colonial state also resorted to “selective documentation” (p. 139) at the local level, and especially for the sake of expanding its policing powers. The undermining of older regimes of verification and truth-telling resulted in a “diminished ability of inhabitants to tell a credible story” (p. 201). It is this process that led to a twinning of bureaucratic expansion with discretionary authority in the workings of government—tracks that have been mistakenly understood to be separate and conflicting. Police, judges, rural officers, and village headmen wielded a great deal of (sometimes violent) discretionary power, determining facts rather than simply administering the law. The product was a novel form of modern rule, unlike anything that had obtained before this encounter—in pre-colonial India or back home in the metropole.
An immensely valuable and original contribution to the study of colonialism and modern governance, Document Raj is especially significant for the novel and productive questions it provokes: Is the regime produced in India a perversion of an ideal type, or characteristic of modern bureaucracy more generally? What is the relationship between the documentary regime of the East India Company and religion, for example? Is this a form of secular governance that necessarily disqualifies older forms of truth-telling? And finally, given Raman's argument about the emergence of a specifically colonial form of power, how should we think about the relationship between this period of early colonial rule and the period that is commonly taken as the model for theories of colonialism (the late nineteenth century)?
