The consecration of the American loyalist Samuel Seabury by bishops of the Scottish Episcopal Church in November 1784 “may make a new Era in the History of Religion,” the former governor of Seabury's native Connecticut wrote to the radical English nonconformist minister Richard Price.Footnote 1 Of all the various configurations of church-state relations throughout the Atlantic world, the prospect of Christian episcopacy disconnected from government struck observers as a genuinely profound historical moment. Just a few months earlier, Price's own pamphlet, Observations on the Importance of the American Revolution, had celebrated the revolutionary birth of “a confederation of States, prosperous and happy, without Lords—without Bishops—and without Kings.”Footnote 2 Of course, America was not, strictly speaking, a land without bishops. The Moravian Brethren had subsisted under a missionary episcopate in America since the 1740s.Footnote 3 The Anglican minister John Wesley's uncanonical elevations of Thomas Coke and Francis Asbury as quasiepiscopal “Joint Superintendents over our brethren in North America,” which consummated the rupture of the Methodists from the Church of England, had occurred mere weeks before the appearance of Price's Observations.Footnote 4 And Seabury's consecration in Aberdeen as bishop of the Protestant Episcopal Church in Connecticut proceeded just weeks later. But none of these would have controverted Price's claims about America. For by bishops, Price did not mean “any Officers among Christians merely Spiritual,” for these the new nation might indeed possess without any diminution of liberty. He merely extolled the absence in the United States of “clergyman raised to preeminence, and invested with civil honors and authority, by State establishment.”Footnote 5 In other words, these free episcopates portended something genuinely revolutionary in the American religious landscape, something that Price hailed as contributing inestimably to “the improvement of the world”: the separation of church from state.Footnote 6
The historiography of the founding of the Protestant Episcopal Church has seldom deviated from this framing of the Seabury consecration as an act of liberalization. The perennial imperial project of imposing an episcopal form of ecclesiastical polity on the British colonies in North America, culminating in the Anglican agitations for an imperial bishop in the decade before the Revolution, had come to naught.Footnote 7 And now, with the securing of independence, an episcopacy stripped of its pretensions to establishment could be safely domesticated within a free and pluralistic American religious ecology. “A quiet revolution had been wrought in the tradition of Anglican episcopacy,” writes the preeminent American religious historian Sydney Ahlstrom, “as monarchical institutions gave way to those of a democracy.”Footnote 8 Historian Frederick Mills similarly hails the consecration as “an ecclesiastical revolution.” And in an instance of hyperbole, which bafflingly overlooks the Scottish episcopate from which Seabury received his orders, Mills exults, “The office of a bishop in a major denomination was completely separated from the state for the first time since Emperor Constantine officially recognized Christianity in A.D. 313.”Footnote 9 The American consecration, John Frederick Woolverton writes, “changed radically the inherited ideas about episcopacy by dismantling the medieval, hierarchical pretensions of that office.”Footnote 10 And the British historian Jonathan Clark, echoing Woolverton, writes of the most monarchical and magisterial of Protestant churches adapting itself “to the west's first secular republic.”Footnote 11 That the loyalist Seabury himself had once been among the most vocal advocates of those monarchical pretensions only adds to the impression of a chastened Toryism acquiescing before what Mark Noll dubs the novus ordo ecclesiasticorum of the new republic.Footnote 12 In light of this historiographical consensus, one might be forgiven for imagining that a new era in the history of religion had indeed commenced—that the threshold of religious modernity ran through the makeshift upper-floor house chapel of a Scottish bishop's private residence in Aberdeen.
The narrative framework of a thwarted establishmentarianism yielding to the American denominational order, however, requires serious interrogation. The Church of England, such readings insist, was royalist and establishmentarian at its core; its political ideal in the eighteenth century was what would come to be known as the “confessional state.”Footnote 13 Any alternative arrangement that weakened the ties that bound throne to altar or placed the established Church on a level with its sectarian rivals was a fundamental threat to its existence, to be defied at every turn with the perennial cries of the Church in danger. Footnote 14 The eventual Anglican acquiescence before American denominationalism was thus a concession to an ecclesiological tradition that was theologically and intellectually alien to it—namely, the voluntarism of the Protestant nonconformist tradition. The Americanization of the Church of England, as Woolverton writes, entailed submission to “a thoroughly reformed [Protestant] and sectarian tradition which was foreign and inimical to Anglicanism.”Footnote 15 In other words, because Anglicanism had no native conception of the separation of church from state, any accommodation thereto must certainly have been forced upon it from without—generally, under the duress of revolutionary crises: the civil wars of the mid-seventeenth century; the reign of the Roman Catholic James II and its aftermath; and, now, in the fallout from American independence. But such an interpretation dramatically misunderstands the theological and intellectual premises upon which the American episcopate was erected. Worse, it renders the abstemiously antipolitical character of later-American high churchmanship virtually inexplicable.
The consecration of Samuel Seabury was secured and defended in an Atlantic milieu permeated by the tenets of what we might call Anglican catholicity.Footnote 16 The imperatives of catholicity—the robust identification with the historic (or primitive) Church and its sacraments, liturgy and ecclesiology that characterized various strains of Anglican and Episcopalian churchmanship throughout the Protestant Atlantic world—subsisted in often unrelieved tension with monarchical elements of the high church tradition.Footnote 17 Idealizing the primitive and apostolic church in the age prior to its establishment, the catholic tendency in Anglicanism demanded a clearer distinction between the ecclesial and civil spheres than confessional states of eighteenth-century Europe typically permitted. In fact, the transatlantic community that rallied around Seabury's consecration was already in possession of an alternative conception of the “separation of church and state,” one that owed virtually nothing to either the enlightenment or nonconformist strains of liberal thought commonly associated with the development of the notion of “religious liberty” in the Atlantic world.Footnote 18 This antiestablishmentarian tendency in Anglicanism runs like a subterranean stream beneath the age of revolutions.Footnote 19
Indeed, Anglican catholicity is inseparable from the Atlantic revolutionary tradition. The Church of England's identification with the primitive, pre-Constantinian Christianity of the first four centuries, of course, had long fostered a due sense of ecclesial autonomy from the state.Footnote 20 But it was, above all, the dynastic and confessional shocks of the seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries—the British civil wars, the Glorious Revolution, the Hanoverian succession—that impelled the development of an Anglicanism not organized around the Reformation doctrine of the royal supremacy.Footnote 21 The series of early modern political and religious crises that delivered the English state into the hands, successively, of Puritans, Roman Catholics, continental Calvinists, and Lutherans, catalyzed within Anglicanism a real skepticism about the reliability of the state as the guarantor of orthodoxy. The waves of revolutionary crises in this period impelled the need to locate the being of the Church of England beyond the impermanent fact of its political establishment. American independence was thus another in a series of periodic political traumas across the long eighteenth century that effectively reactivated the sense of catholicity in the Anglican tradition. In the following decades, the events of the French Revolution and the stirrings of democratization in the age of reform would catalyze similar movements toward ecclesiastical autonomy.Footnote 22
The Church, wrote the future archbishop of Canterbury John Potter in his influential 1707 Discourse of Church-Government, was no “meer Voluntary Society,” to which “men are permitted to come in, and to go out [of] when they please.” On the contrary, the Church was an “outward and visible society,” of which “Men are obliged to be Members” as they value their eternal happiness and well-being. But this obligatoriness, this necessity of ecclesiastical communion, Potter took pains to stress, stemmed not from any civil establishment or penal sanctions that prohibited nonconformity. “The Kingdom or Church of Christ,” he wrote, “was, by the design of its Foundation, to be distinct from all earthly Kingdoms.” And just as the privileges secured by ecclesiastical communion “are of a quite different sort from our Civil Rights and Liberties,” so the penalties attached to religious nonconformity were understood as purely spiritual. This conception of the Church as neither purely voluntary, on the one hand, nor compulsory in a governmental sense, on the other, required a theory of ecclesiastical government in which authority was not conceived as borrowed from the magistrate or derived from the congregation. Episcopacy, as established by Christ and his apostles, thus served as the guarantor of ecclesiastical autonomy. The bishops’ exclusive prerogative of ordaining priests and consecrating new bishops thus preserved an independent and putatively uninterrupted succession of officers from the apostolic age until, presumably, the end of time.Footnote 23 For Potter and the Anglican ecclesiological tradition that drew on his works throughout the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, episcopacy was no mere matter of ecclesiastical organization.Footnote 24 The apostolic succession of bishops was the only reliable sanction for Christian ministry and, hence, the only available guarantor of sacramental efficacy. “Communion could not be maintain'd with Christ,” Potter wrote, “without adhering to the Communion of the Bishop.”Footnote 25 For this tradition, episcopacy was the sine qua non of religious life. Moreover, an apostolic episcopacy, which conveyed ecclesiastical authority in a direct succession from Christ, preserved the church as a corporate society visibly distinct and autonomous from both the political state and the gathered sect.
The divine and apostolic foundations of the episcopal Church thus underpinned an alternative, sacerdotalist conception of the separation of church and state, what this tradition often referred to as “the independency of Church power.”Footnote 26 The form of Christian life that was to be insulated from political interference was neither the individual conscience nor the gathered congregation, but rather the canonical priesthood and its offices. The difference between this alternative conception of the separation of church and state and either the enlightenment or Protestant nonconformist strains in American ecclesiastical thought was profound.Footnote 27 Anglican catholicity mandated ecclesiastical independence from state interference, without, however, accepting either of what historians Chris Beneke and Christopher Grenda deem the bedrock principles of religious liberty in the new republic: “the essential interiority of belief and the inevitability of religious difference.”Footnote 28 The claim to catholicity, with its externalization of religion exclusively in historically transmitted forms and orders, could not abide either of these precepts. The catholic identification with the historical church, and its unbroken succession of officers and the sacramental prerogatives that the priesthood alone possessed, precluded the conception of religion as either an interior state of belief or a voluntary association of likeminded souls. The Church, this tradition affirmed, was not of the civil state. But neither was it, as in the voluntarist ecclesiologies derived from Protestant nonconformity and Lockean liberalism, a gathered sect or denomination, to be consigned amid the commercial and associational sphere that was coming to be known as civil society.Footnote 29 Seabury himself explicitly denied the core tenet of Protestant denominationalism that “the discordant sects and denominations of christians, differing in their government, doctrine, sacraments, were all parts of the one church of Christ.”Footnote 30 Seabury's loyalist Anglican friend Jonathan Boucher similarly deemed denominationalism in the republic “utopian Projects, respecting Universal Equality on the Subject of Religious Establishments,” as both “disgusting & dangerous.”Footnote 31 Seabury and his allies, then, were heirs to the double-sidedness of Anglican ecclesiology: opposition to what was known in the early modern period as Erastianism, state superintendence of the Church, was complemented by an unrelieved hatred of schism and sectarianism that militated against the logic of the denominational order.Footnote 32 As the Canterbury prebendary George Berkeley, son of the famed philosopher and a long-time advocate of an American episcopate, described his ecclesiological principles in 1782, he was “as far removed from Erastianism and from democracy as ever any man was. I do heartily abominate both of these anti-scriptural systems.”Footnote 33 Anglican catholicity, then, was marked by its dual differentiation of the Church from both the heavy hand of the sovereign state, on the one hand, and the voluntarism of civil society, on the other. Both were aspects of lay encroachment on a divinely constituted ecclesial life.
By understanding the ecclesiological foundations of the Seabury consecration, we may gain a clearer understanding of the critical cultural resources bequeathed to high church Episcopalianism in the antebellum United States. Early nineteenth-century Episcopalianism, particularly in the high church form emanating out of the General Theological Seminary in New York City, was the “ecclesiastical-” (or ritualist-) type denomination par excellence in the early republic.Footnote 34 Possessed not only of an eminently clear sense of the distinction between civil and ecclesial spheres, high church Episcopalianism in America was also extremely skeptical of the ersatz establishmentarianism of the so-called “benevolent empire” in civil society.Footnote 35 A number of historians have suggested that the overlapping and interdenominational Bible, missionary, and temperance societies that composed the vaunted “benevolent empire” coalesced into something of a shadow establishment in the early decades of the nineteenth century.Footnote 36 For all their supposed ambition for ecclesiastical preeminence, American high churchmen were conspicuously reticent to engage in such public endeavors. They similarly refrained from pulpit exchanges with ministers of other denominations and looked askance at virtually the entire practice of Protestant revivalism. They infamously eschewed abolitionism as an illegitimate mixing of religion with politics.Footnote 37 All of these stances suggest an overriding concern not with religious primacy but with the preservation of the distinctiveness of ecclesial life.Footnote 38 Accusations of Episcopalian “illiberality” by rival denominations had nothing whatsoever to do with the Protestant Episcopal Church's covetousness after some lost establishment but rather with its uneasiness with the American denominational order as a whole.Footnote 39 The Episcopal Church derived this critical posture—this sense of itself as a counterbalance, in historian Robert Bruce Mullin's words, to the “centrifugal tendency” of American commercial and religious life—from its founding ecclesiological premises.Footnote 40 These have far less to do with some residual royalism and more to do with the catholic sense of the Church as a tertium quid distinct from both state and society. Indeed, as recent scholarship has shown, some of the most trenchant non-Episcopalian critics of the institutional deficiencies of antebellum American Protestantism—Orestes Brownson, the Mercersburg theologians, Horace Bushnell, Henry Bellows, among others—developed their ecclesiologies in dialogue with this Anglican tradition.Footnote 41 Thus its most consequential interjection into American life bears revisiting.
The reconstruction of Anglicanism in the newly independent United States of America can reasonably be said to have commenced with the appearance of Philadelphia rector William White's extraordinary pamphlet The Case of the Episcopal Churches in the United States Considered in August 1782.Footnote 42 White's pamphlet, published just a few months after the commencement of peace negotiations in Paris, was certainly the first work to consider substantively the ecclesiological implications of American independence.Footnote 43 White, a prominent patriot among the Anglican clergy and a former chaplain to the Continental Congress, set about the task of conceptualizing an ecclesiastical polity for Anglicans in America “that would contain the constituent principles of the church of England, and yet be independent of foreign jurisdiction and influence.”Footnote 44 Given the enmity still persisting between the republic and Great Britain, White could not imagine any successful application to the English episcopate to consecrate bishops for an independent United States.Footnote 45 The question, then, was how might worship be maintained and the severe attrition of the ministry from death and expatriation during the Revolution be reversed.Footnote 46 White believed the worship of God and the moral reformation of the people to be the supreme objectives of ecclesiastical life; “to relinquish them from a scrupulous adherence to episcopacy,” he affirmed, “is sacrificing the substance to the ceremony.” And delaying positive action to ensure the continuity of worship, he warned, hazarded the very existence of episcopal Protestantism in America.Footnote 47
White purported to solve the problem of American independence by reconceptualizing the meaning of ecclesiastical establishment in the Anglican tradition. State countenance of the Church was incidental, he reasoned. In White's view, the English ecclesiastical establishment—as manifest in the doctrine of the royal supremacy, the necessity of statutory confirmation of church canons, and instances of parliamentary deprivation of bishops—was nothing more than a national institutionalization of the principle of lay participation in church governance. Such participation could take other forms. An American Church simply had to reproduce this collaborative dimension of ecclesial polity in an environment “where all denominations of christians are on a level, and no church is farther known to the public, than as a voluntary association of individuals.” In other words, the cooperation of clergy and laity in England was institutionalized in the constitutional relations of crown, parliament, and Church. But in America, he wrote, “it will be necessary to deviate from the practice (though not from the principles) of that church, by convening the clergy and laity in one body” subsisting outside the civil state.Footnote 48 With such a hybrid ecclesiastical assembly effectively taking the place, in part, of both the royal supremacy and parliamentary oversight, White was willing to endow it with the power of admitting candidates to the ministry, electing what he called “a superior order of ministers,” and exercising discipline over the clergy. “The primitive churches,” he attested, “were generally supplied by popular elections.” The later usurpation by monarchs of the Christian people's right of nominating their bishops had simply altered the organ through which the indispensable will of the laity was expressed. White was effectively transferring it back again. There was, in fact, nothing “anti-republican” about the institution of episcopacy, White affirmed: “This supposed relation between episcopacy and monarchy arises from confounding English episcopacy with the subject at large.” Episcopacy might be peaceably settled in a free republic by shifting the mechanisms by which bishops were installed from state to civil society.Footnote 49
The supposition of an emergency undermined somewhat the radicalism of White's proposals. Though he had equipped his lay and clerical conventions with the power of electing an order of superior clergymen or superintendents, he considered his plan for what was essentially synodal governance as nothing more than a “temporary departure from episcopacy.” White entertained the possibility that traditional consecration might be procured at some future date, which could retroactively legitimate “any supposed imperfections” in the ordinations and reforms undertaken in the interim.Footnote 50 But this framing invited disagreement over whether, in fact, just such a state of emergency was indeed still in place.
Most of the respondents to the pamphlet, it seems, did not encounter its proposals until after news of the peace had circulated. “The supposed Necessity, on which your Scheme is founded,” the loyalist clergyman Charles Inglis wrote White from New York, “does not now really exist.”Footnote 51 And the expatriate clergymen in London were sanguine about the ease with which consecration by the English episcopate would proceed once American independence had been formally recognized. “The Episcopal Clergy have only to wait with Patience,” the former Society for the Propagation of the Gospel (SPG) missionary Jacob Duché informed White from Lambeth parish, “and they may have, if they are unanimous, a Church in each State, with a Bishop at its head, chosen by themselves, and regularly consecrated.”Footnote 52 Of course, invoking the newly favorable geopolitical situation often saved friendly respondents from reckoning substantively with the magnitude of White's ecclesiological deviation. Still, several pointed out quite forthrightly that White's plan effectively amounted to presbyterianism; as Inglis put it, “if adopted and adhered to, our Church would cease to be an Episcopal Church.”Footnote 53 From St. Andrews in Scotland, George Berkeley, a keen observer of the American Church, fretted, “In a short time, we must expect all Protestant Episcopalian principles to be lost in America.”Footnote 54
These were certainly the sentiments of the ten Connecticut clergymen who assembled at the parsonage of John Rutgers Marshall in Woodbury on March 25, 1783. This convention of quondam loyalists undertook two tasks: a formal response to William White's Case of the Episcopal Churches and the election of a candidate to seek episcopal orders abroad. Under the hand of their secretary, Abraham Jarvis of Middletown, the assembled clergy assailed White's proposals. Episcopacy, they held, was of divine ordinance and, therefore, indispensable to any reconstruction of Anglicanism in the United States. “Really, sir, we think an Episcopal Church without Episcopacy, if it be not a contradiction in terms would, however, be a new thing under the sun.” They also rejected White's plea of necessity, as no effort to obtain consecration had been undertaken since the cessation of hostilities.Footnote 55 Interestingly, perhaps out of mistrust of White's political or ecclesiological principles, the Connecticut clergy did not bother to inform him of the formal steps they then took toward that end.Footnote 56 They nominated the sixty-five-year-old Jeremiah Leaming, an SPG missionary formerly of St. Paul's, Norwalk, but since 1779 a refugee in British-occupied New York, to travel abroad to seek consecration. In mind of Leaming's advanced age, the clergy selected the Connecticut-born Samuel Seabury, lately of St. Peter's, Westchester, but now also a loyalist refugee in Manhattan, as an alternate.
There was evidently some debate about the potential sources of consecration. The Church of England was undoubtedly the overwhelming preference, but the prospect of pursuing consecration from the “foreign” episcopates of either the Moravians or the Lutherans of Scandinavia was reportedly considered as well.Footnote 57 And at least one attendant subsequently claimed that the convention had instructed the nominee “to go down to Scotland and receive ordination from a nonjuring Bishop,” that is, from one or more of the remaining bishops from the proscribed Scottish Episcopal Church, should the English prelates prove disobliging.Footnote 58 Pleading debility, Leaming declined. And Seabury was thus dispatched bearing letters and testimonials from the clergy of both Connecticut and New York.
The Connecticut clergy's application to England was, it is not unfair to say, positively haunted by White's Case of the Episcopal Churches. The clergy were impelled to seek consecration, they informed the archbishops of Canterbury and York, expressly “to prevent the carrying into execution a plan of very extraordinary nature, lately come to our knowledge, formed and published in Philadelphia.” The Americans considered it their duty, they told the primates, “to reject such a spurious substitute for episcopacy.”Footnote 59 The New York clergy who wrote in support of the application also warned that miscarriage would leave Americans with the unpalatable alternatives of seeking “foreign” consecrations or acquiescing to “the pernicious scheme” outlined in the Case of the Episcopal Churches. Footnote 60 To their minds, White's plan seemed to acquiesce before the democratic and voluntaristic impulses of denominationalism, what they called “the rage for popular right, as the fountain of all institutions civil and ecclesiastical.” As such, it was incompatible with their conception of catholicity, which required some external linkage with the historic Church that could serve as a guarantor of orthodoxy.Footnote 61 Only apostolic episcopacy provided such a warranty.Footnote 62 At least two of the alternatives considered at Woodbury, the sui generis episcopacy proposed by White or the prospect of “foreign” consecration by an episcopate of less than apostolic pedigree, seemed to fall well short of catholicity, as understood within the high church tradition.Footnote 63
Samuel Seabury's long sojourn in England was an object lesson in the inertia of ecclesiastical establishment. At every turn, Seabury found the prelates of the Church of England not only politically incapacitated from consecrating him, but virtually incapable of conceiving of an episcopate truly disentangled from the state.Footnote 64 Seabury arrived in London on July 7, 1783, and waited on the ailing bishop of London, Robert Lowth, a week later. Lowth voiced his support for the plan and his willingness to concur with the actions of the two archbishops in its furtherance, but pointedly declined to take the lead in the matter. The bishop of London believed that a dispensation from the king would be sufficient to discharge Seabury from the statutory oaths of allegiance to the crown. The new archbishop of Canterbury, John Moore, however, disagreed, conceiving that nothing short of an act of parliament could facilitate such an irregular consecration.Footnote 65 Seabury's consultation with Archbishop William Markham at York the following month was similarly fruitless. “Both the Archbishops are convinced of the necessity of supplying the States of America with Bishops,” he reported home, “if it be intended to preserve the Episcopal Church there.” Nevertheless, they remain “exceedingly embarrassed” by a number of difficulties. They found they had no right to send a bishop to Connecticut without the express consent of the state and that, absent such consent, no bishop was likely to be allowed to exercise his spiritual function within the state. The archbishops further fretted that the absence of adequate financial support for a bishop in Connecticut would bring the office into disrepute. “Unless Matters can be put on a different Footing,” Seabury had already concluded by mid-August, “the Business will not succeed.”Footnote 66
Faced with invincible establishmentarianism among the fathers of the Church of England, Seabury believed that only an explicit endorsement from the state government in Connecticut could avail.Footnote 67 His Connecticut brethren counseled discretion. Upon treating with the members of the state assembly convening at New Haven regarding the episcopate, Jeremiah Leaming and Bela Hubbard were told “that a formal application to the Assembly would be improper, if not highly imprudent.” While the congregationalist establishment in the state would quietly “connive at a Bishop's residence in this State,” formal recognition was likely to incite opposition.Footnote 68
In place of an explicit endorsement by the state, the Connecticut clergy could only produce the still unpublished “Act for securing the Rights of conscience, in Matters of Religion,” ratified in January 1784 amid a broader overhaul of the Connecticut law code.Footnote 69 “The lowest construction [of the act], which is all we expect,” the clergy reassured Seabury, “must amount to a permission that the Episcopal Church enjoy all the requisites of her polity and have a Bishop to reside among them.” As for material support, a bishop in the United States could not expect more than what could be gleaned from voluntary contributions and subscriptions. “A Bishop in Connecticut must in some degree,” they confessed, “be of the primitive style.”Footnote 70 The English prelates were fairly unimpressed with these merely denominational accommodations.Footnote 71 John Butler, bishop of Oxford, “said he hardly thought it sufficient ground to proceed upon.” And Archbishop Moore's response, Seabury reported, “though polite, I thought, was cool & restrained.” He complained that the clergy in Connecticut had only procured “the permission of individuals & not of the Legislature,” and even raised a fresh objection that the initial application had proceeded without the concurrence of the laity.Footnote 72 Seabury's frustration was curdling into disgust. “This is certainly the worst country in the world to do business in,” he fumed.Footnote 73
The project of an American episcopate was, from its inception, shadowed by the dream of a British imperial bishop. At the request of Sir Guy Carleton, the commander in chief of the British forces in America, a convention of refugee clergy in New York, including both Seabury and Leaming, had devised a plan to establish a bishop of the Church of England in Nova Scotia mere days before the Woodbury meeting in Connecticut.Footnote 74 On March 26, 1783, the clergy proposed Thomas Bradbury Chandler, a loyalist American refugee in London, as a suitable candidate.Footnote 75 And after Seabury's own election, it had been suggested that he might himself reside in Canada, should he be barred from exercising his office in the United States.Footnote 76 Seabury used his time in London to lobby the ecclesiastical hierarchy on behalf of the Nova Scotia episcopate.Footnote 77 Seabury believed that his friend Chandler's consecration would eventually proceed, but as his own frustrations mounted, he began to harbor doubts about its utility for America. A Canadian bishop, Seabury grumbled, “will do no good in the States of America. His hands will be as much tied as the Bishops of England.”Footnote 78 An imperial episcopate as seemingly circumscribed by the British state as that of the metropole would be similarly ill-suited to ordain and superintend the clergy of an independent republic.
Archbishop Moore's renewed application to the infant ministry of William Pitt the Younger in the summer of 1784 only elicited additional cavils. Having never consecrated bishops for America while subject to British imperial authority, “it would have a very suspicious appearance to do it now & would probably create or augment ill will in that country.” And only an explicit request, or at least formal acquiescence from Congress, would alleviate these misgivings. Moreover, it was reasoned than an expansion of episcopacy within the British empire must take precedence over any foreign consecrations; hence, nothing could be done “till the Nova Scotia Episcopate be settled.”Footnote 79 Seabury was apoplectic, accusing the ministry of “a total ignorance of the State & temper of the Americans in general & of the Episcopalians in particular.” Seabury found himself practically lecturing the archbishop of Canterbury on the relatively limited cognizance governments had over religion in the United States. Congress, he explained, was positively barred from such an infringement on the sovereignty of Connecticut, and the state was sufficiently “liberal in their sentiments” to forswear interference either way. The precedence of the Canadian bishopric was particularly galling, as “they had it in their power to complete that business whenever they pleased. This week as well as next year.” The interview with Archbishop Moore was so heated that Seabury was three times called upon to apologize for his “hard expressions” to the primate. “The Am[erica]n Episcopalians must now look to some other country for a valid & clear Episcopate,” Seabury concluded, “& I hoped they would find, in some corner of the world, that attention to the common interest of Christianity which they had here sought in vain.”Footnote 80
Samuel Seabury was now caught, so to speak, between democracy and Erastianism—in the younger George Berkeley's formulation. The heterodoxy of a sui generis episcopacy had impelled Seabury across the Atlantic. There he found consecration unduly subordinated to the interests of the British state. He pleaded that the matter belonged not to the civic sphere, but rather to “the general laws of the Christian Church.”Footnote 81 But it was not readily apparent where such a purely spiritual regime actually obtained. The indifference of the American governments and the aversion of the British effectively set Seabury adrift amid the various episcopates of Christendom. The historian Katherine Carté is surely correct to attribute the stalled consecration to the breakdown of imperial Protestantism in the aftermath of American independence. But she overstates the extent to which the deadlock spurred a reversion to strictly “national” religious institutions.Footnote 82 The imperative of catholicity persisted in defiance of national borders and governmental inertia alike. And advocates of American episcopalianism pointedly refused to accept the binary that the British state and American society were the only available foundations for the new church.
Contemporaneous with Seabury's own sojourn in London, two Americans from Maryland, Mason Locke Weems and Edward Gannt, made a similar odyssey to seek ordination in England. A series of conferences with Bishop Lowth of London, Bishop Watson of Llandaff, and Archbishop Moore could not circumvent the statutory requirement of the state oaths. Weems therefore appealed to John Adams, the American ambassador at the Hague, to discern whether “the Bishops in Holland, Sweden, or Germany would ordain me without requiring the Oaths of Allegiance.”Footnote 83 Disabusing Weems of the existence of bishops in the Netherlands, Adams politely offered to introduce him to the Swedish ambassadors there or at the court of St. James, and recommended consulting with Benjamin Franklin about the amenability of the Swedish and Danish ministers at Versailles.Footnote 84 Adams subsequently approached the Danish ambassador at the Hague, St. Saphorin, who relayed the opinion of the Danish secretary of state and the theological faculty at Copenhagen that ordination could be obtained, according to the Danish rite, in which “nothing will be exacted from the Candidates, but a Profession conformable to the Articles of the English Church.”Footnote 85 Weems and Gantt subsequently wrote to Franklin, astonishingly, about the possibility of procuring “Romish orders” in France, which they considered apostolic and, hence, of more validity than those of Denmark. In the spirit of his friend and fellow Philadelphian William White, Franklin advised some form of presbyterian or congregational ordination back home. “An hundred years hence, when People are more enlightened,” he wrote, bemusedly, “it will be wondered at, that Men in America, qualified by their Learning and Piety to pray for and instruct their Neighbours, should not be permitted to do it until they had a made a Voyage of six thousand miles out and home, to ask leave of a cross old Gentleman at Canterbury.”Footnote 86
There is some debate over whether Seabury seriously entertained the prospect of consecration at the hands of a Lutheran bishop.Footnote 87 The Anglican high church tradition with which Seabury identified, although by no means uniform in its sentiments, had evinced a steadily dimmer view of the validity of Lutheran orders since the later seventeenth century.Footnote 88 But Seabury mentioned the option of application to a “foreign bishop” as late as October 1783.Footnote 89 And both he and Thomas Bradbury Chandler were certainly aware of the travails of Weems and Gantt, citing it as further evidence of the paralysis of the English hierarchy.Footnote 90 The need for a foreign consecration was preempted by the passage of a bill introduced on August 5, 1784, by Archbishop Moore, which allowed the bishop of London to confer holy orders on “Subjects or Citizens of Countries outside of His Majesty's Dominions.”Footnote 91 In Seabury's rather jaundiced estimation, the bill “was evidently calculated to preclude the necessity of resident Bishops in America, as far as ordination was concerned,” further evidence of what he considered the Pitt ministry's implacable hostility to the idea of an American episcopate.Footnote 92
Seabury and his allies began casting about for sources of catholicity unmediated by the confessional states of Europe. In late 1783, George Berkeley considered the revival of suffragan or coadjutor bishops, a medieval Norman office briefly resurrected during the English Reformation, which he believed (erroneously, it would seem) might be consecrated immediately by a diocesan bishop without royal license.Footnote 93 Interestingly, the only claimants to the title of suffragan bishop since the office fell into abeyance at the turn of the seventeenth century were the first bishops consecrated in the schismatic communion of the English nonjurors George Hickes and Thomas Wagstaffe, who claimed the suffragan episcopal titles of Thetford and Ipswich, respectively, in early 1694.Footnote 94 In summer 1784, Seabury's friend Jonathan Boucher approached one of that succession, the nonjuring bishop Kenrick Price of Manchester, about consecrating Seabury. Price, in turn, consulted the other remaining nonjuring bishop—or, as they now styled themselves, bishop of the Orthodox British Church—William Cartwright, an apothecary in Shrewsbury.Footnote 95 Like their own remnant communion, Boucher assured Price, Seabury “is, and expects to remain, independent of any control from any State.” Cartwright heartily approved of this posture. In a letter to Thomas Bradbury Chandler, he clarified the nature of their political ecclesiology. “I may submit to the Civil State under which I live, in temporals,” he told Chandler, “but in spirituals, I acknowledge no allegiance or obedience to any State, but according to the laws of the Church Catholic in the three first centuries.” Cartwright was deeply sympathetic to Seabury's impasse, and evinced the antiestablishmentarianism that had long characterized the nonjuring movement in Great Britain. “If I should be any way instrumental in planting an orthodox Episcopacy in the Western World,” he told Chandler, “I shall think it the happiest event of my life.” But he warned not to expect the revival of catholicity from the state Church. “For as the Church was not first planted, so I think it never will be restored to its purity by any lay-power, or mere civil establishment whatever.”Footnote 96 Seabury did not learn of these exchanges until later in autumn 1784, by which time he was already negotiating with a church whose fate had long been intertwined with that of the schismatic communion of English nonjurors, the Scottish Episcopal Church.Footnote 97
The Scottish Episcopal Church had been formally disestablished at the Revolution of 1689, and effectively driven underground by the ruthless penal laws imposed upon it after the failed Jacobite Rebellion of 1745.Footnote 98 For their adherence to the deposed house of Stuart, Scottish episcopal ministers were strictly forbidden in 1746 from ministering in any religious meeting or conventicle; worshipers could be fined, imprisoned, and disqualified for public office for merely attending a service where the minister had not taken the oaths of allegiance to the Hanoverian monarchs or where George II and the royal family were not prayed for by name. Further penal laws prohibited the remaining Scottish bishops from ordaining any new clergy and confined virtually all episcopal worship to private homes or open-air services in the forests and mountains.Footnote 99 This was the dilapidated communion the celebrated novelist Sir Walter Scott famously described as reduced to “the shadow of a shade.”Footnote 100
Consecration by the remaining bishops of the Scottish Episcopal Church had been tentatively explored by Seabury's allies in late 1783, but negotiations resumed in earnest in August 1784 shortly after his contentious interview with Archbishop Moore.Footnote 101 Seabury's network in England was composed not only of American loyalists but also of the clique of advanced high churchmen surrounding George Horne, dean of Canterbury—many of whom had been most solicitous for the welfare of the persecuted Scottish Episcopalians.Footnote 102 It was almost certainly members of these circles whom Seabury credits with insisting upon his “duty to obtain Episcopal consecration wherever it can be had,” and directing him toward Scotland.Footnote 103 Seabury wrote his friend Myles Cooper, an expatriate New Yorker officiating at an Episcopal chapel in Edinburgh, to renew on his behalf an application to the Scottish bishops. The request was laced with bitterness regarding the morbid Erastianism of the Church of England. But perhaps, Seabury reflected, divine providence had preserved the disestablished, persecuted, and proscribed Scottish Church in the north, “that a free, valid and purely Ecclesiastical Episcopacy may, from them, pass into the Western world.”Footnote 104
The college of bishops had been divided on the question of the consecration since it was first broached in late 1783. The ardent Jacobite Charles Rose, bishop of Dunkeld, for one, could not abide Seabury's ordination and communion with “the schismatical Church of England” that had abandoned the house of Stuart in the Glorious Revolution a century earlier.Footnote 105 Bishop William Falconer of Edinburgh wanted no part of the proceedings, and died in the summer of 1784.Footnote 106 The remaining three bishops—the primus Robert Kilgour; Arthur Petrie, bishop of Ross and Moray; and John Skinner, coadjutor bishop of Aberdeen—acquiesced and together made up the canonical number for consecration.Footnote 107
In the fall, the bishops drew up a concordat, outlining the terms of the consecration and what they hoped would be a “Bond of Union, between the Catholic remainder of the antient Church of Scotland, and the now rising Church in the State of Connecticut.” The concordat committed Seabury to an especially “high” view of the Church as “the mystical Body of Christ,” governed by Christ and “under him, the chief ministers, or Managers of the affairs of this spiritual society, are those called Bishops.” It is especially noteworthy, in light of White's Case of the Episcopal Churches and Seabury's own frustrations in England, not to mention the precarious existence of the Scottish Episcopal Church since the Revolution of 1688–1689, that the compact explicitly declared the sacred function of episcopacy “independent on all Lay powers.”Footnote 108
Samuel Seabury was consecrated by Bishops Kilgour, Petrie, and Skinner on the upper-floor chapel of Skinner's private residence at Longacre in Aberdeen on November 14, 1784.Footnote 109 The ceremony proceeded, reportedly, “in the presence of a considerable number of respectable clergymen, and a great number of laity.”Footnote 110 Bishop Skinner preached on Christ's “great commission” to the apostles described in the twenty-eighth chapter of the gospel of Matthew. The sermon was an extraordinary distillation of the ecclesiological principles upon which the consecration proceeded. The commission to the apostles, “go therefore and teach all nations,” transformed what had been only a group of Christ's “personal attendants” into officers of “a regular, well formed society,” entrusted exclusively with distinct powers of preaching, administering the sacraments, and governance. The Church, then, was divinely founded, as a distinct “spiritual society,” which must be sharply differentiated from both the state, on the one hand, and the mere sect or voluntary association, “distinguished only by their adherence to some particular system,” on the other. The echoes of John Potter's Discourse on Church-Government were unmistakable. Mindful, no doubt, of the events that had brought Seabury to Aberdeen, Skinner expostulated at some length on the evils of Erastianism and its negligence of what he called the “manifest distinction established by our holy religion, between the spiritual kingdom of our Redeemer, and the temporal sovereignties of this world.” The Church was founded by Christ as “a society entirely distinct by itself, without being incorporated into, or any way defended or supported by the state.” Skinner's critique of the failure of the British establishment to permit an American episcopate was scathing and virtually undisguised. Indeed, Skinner conceived of British establishmentarianism and American denominationalism as reciprocal heterodoxies: the Erastian premise of “making the exercise of all spiritual authority, to depend entirely on the will and pleasure of temporal governors,” creates the conditions for “endless schisms and divisions” proliferating beyond the ambit of the state. Lay domination from above bred lay deviations from below.Footnote 111
The consecration of Samuel Seabury in Aberdeen sent shockwaves throughout the Atlantic world. Some sixteen months after arriving in Great Britain, he reported to his brethren in Connecticut, he had finally received the sacred office “freed from all incumbrance, arising from connections with civil establishment and human policy.”Footnote 112 The Scottish Episcopal clergy spoke rapturously of “the glorious work of the 14th,” and the role its execrated communion had played in the making of American episcopacy.Footnote 113 The English establishment, by contrast, responded mostly with mild embarrassment, if not dismay. Upon his return to London, Seabury felt himself “looked on coldly” for his actions.Footnote 114 “There is some uneasiness about it I find, since it is done,” his friend Dean Horne reported. “It is said you have been precipitate.”Footnote 115 Archbishop Moore was apprehensive that the Scottish consecration would now open the floodgates to a host of irregular plans of episcopacy, that American clergymen would begin applying to the Moravian bishops, and “the Philadelphia Clergy would be encouraged to carry into effect their plan of constituting a nominal Episcopacy by the joint suffrages of Clergymen and Laymen.”Footnote 116 But other clergymen were quietly sympathetic. Thomas Thurlow, bishop of Lincoln and brother of the powerful Lord Chancellor, was openly supportive of the Scottish consecration and considered Seabury's disappointment in England a black mark on the establishment.Footnote 117 Even the aged Charles Wesley, still more firmly attached to the constitution of the Church of England than his brother, took the occasion to lament the rupture of John Wesley's irregular Methodist consecrations the previous fall.Footnote 118 Seabury, for his part, was unapologetic. He professed “a sincere veneration for the Church of England,” but he was profoundly disheartened “to see the power of her Bishops so restrained by her connection with the State.”Footnote 119
The general public beyond clerical circles did not learn of the consecration until notice of it appeared in the newspapers in early 1785. The Gentleman's Magazine, for instance, was initially uncertain quite what to make of the obscure event.Footnote 120 But the London publication in early spring of Bishop John Skinner's consecration sermon, The Nature and Extent of the Apostolical Commission, swiftly polarized public opinion.Footnote 121 The sermon was printed with extensive notes drawing on the writings of the English and Scottish eighteenth-century high church and nonjuring ecclesiological traditions. And one note, in a perhaps needless provocation of the English hierarchy, praised the Scottish Episcopal Church for showing “more regard to the acts of the apostles, than to the acts of the British parliament.”Footnote 122 The English Review bristled at the persistent illiberalism of Scottish Episcopal ecclesiology; the claims of its episcopate and ministry to an apostolic pedigree evinced a want of the “liberality of sentiment” that supposedly characterized the present age.Footnote 123
A lengthy debate soon followed in the pages of the Gentleman's Magazine. “Bishop Seabury is gone thither,” one English supporter wrote, “unfettered with any of our English laws, either ecclesiastical or secular, many of which are derogatory, even destructive . . . of the unalienable rights of episcopacy, and of the Church as a spiritual society.” The shameful incapacity of the English bishops, like the proscription of Scottish Episcopalianism, were the fruit of an overweening British state, “interfering in matters purely spiritual, as to interdict and annihilate, as far as they can, the very essential and unalienable rights and powers of the Christian Church.” Though this letter appeared only under the signature “W. C.,” this apologist was plainly William Cartwright, the nonjuring bishop with whom Seabury had corresponded in the previous year.Footnote 124 The response from a low church Anglican, “L. L.,” clearly articulated the real source of offense: that though the Scottish Episcopal Church had renounced any former affiliation with the British state, it nevertheless refused to comport itself like other tolerated sects. It was, it might be said, no longer of the state, but refused to consign itself unassumingly among the voluntary associations that composed civil society. The respondent's lengthy comparison between Protestant nonconformists in England and Episcopalians in Scotland all but names catholicity as the truly unassimilable element of the latter's ecclesiology. Both communions were “equally Dissenters.” But the nonconformists in England “strive not to distinguish themselves by any claims to superior rank,” while Episcopalians in Scotland grasped after “the united privileges both of the crown and the crozier, not only affect[ing] to possess, but even to confer, the highest ecclesiastical jurisdiction.”Footnote 125 The Scottish Episcopal priest (and future primus) George Gleig, minister at Pittenweem, was incredulous at the animosity directed toward his Church. “What then,” he wondered, “is the enormous crime which has excited against them this outrageous clamour?” He could not comprehend the anger “that 30,000 American Episcopalians have received a bishop.”Footnote 126 This public debate ground on, in unremitting and anonymous hostility, well into 1786.Footnote 127 It is difficult to evade the impression that there was, to a segment of establishment Anglicans, simply something monstrous about the claims of a church that refused to locate itself in either state or society, as these forms were coming to be understood.Footnote 128
The opposition to the consecration was almost immediately joined by the influential English abolitionist Granville Sharp, a man possessed of a formidably wide and religiously pluralistic network of correspondents throughout the Atlantic world. The lay scion of an Anglican clerical dynasty, Sharp was a zealous advocate of an American episcopate.Footnote 129 In fall 1784, Sharp was promoting a tract he had written on the popular election of bishops as a potential blueprint for episcopacy in America. Though it is not clear whether Sharp was familiar with White's Case of the Episcopal Churches, his own pamphlet similarly argued for the historical right of lay and clerical congregations to nominate bishops but denied their authority to formally consecrate them. Indeed, he told Bishop Hincliffe of Peterborough that he believed his reclamation of a popular right from the putative usurpation of popes and kings would reconcile episcopacy to American republicanism, while at the same time “cut off all excuse for the vain pretensions of mere Presbyters to exercise the Episcopal Function.”Footnote 130 Reassuring the archbishop of Canterbury that his tract was not intended as a reflection on the royally appointed English hierarchy, Sharp digressed into the question of the Scottish consecration. He desired that the primate take some measures “to prevent the Congregations of the Church of England in Connecticut from being imposed upon by these pretenders to Episcopacy who cannot be said to be Bishops of any visible Church,” suggesting that the extension of their “spurious” orders to the new world would doom episcopacy in America.Footnote 131
Sharp's argument against the validity of Seabury's orders was, frankly, ill-considered, and seemingly predicated on an unreflective antipathy toward Jacobitism. But it also reflected the same narrowing social field of religion as the debate in the Gentleman's Magazine. Footnote 132 The Scottish Episcopal Church, Sharp charged, was but an “invisible Church,” rooted neither in a vibrant diocesan communion nor in a legitimate establishment. Instead, he imagined, its polity flitted amid a scattering of wan congregations below and the nominal oversight of the Pretender Charles Edward Stuart above, “a foreign Prince who has no Authority in these Kingdoms.” Being of neither society nor the state, it was nothing, a ghostly communion, and, therefore, to Sharp, ineligible as a source for American episcopacy.Footnote 133 Several of Sharp's British correspondents tried to disabuse him of his mistaken understanding of the Scottish Episcopal Church. Robert Findlay, professor of divinity at the University of Glasgow, found Sharp “much more unacquainted with the State of Episcopacy in Scotland that I would have expected,” informing him of the five episcopal meetings in Glasgow alone, and considerably more in the north.Footnote 134 And the aged founder of Georgia, James Oglethorpe, who came from a Jacobite family, reassured Sharp of the continuity of Scottish orders throughout the eighteenth century.Footnote 135 A tour of Scotland in the summer of 1785 only confirmed Sharp in his prejudices. He believed that the mediation of the Stuart pretender had fatally compromised their episcopal succession. And, perhaps more significantly, he believed that the Church's liturgical excesses—the so-called “usages” derived from the English nonjurors, the living embodiments of the Church's claims to catholicity and primitiveness—to be inconsistent with a Protestant church.Footnote 136 Charles Inglis tried in vain to remove Sharp's prejudices against what he insisted remained a valid succession, finding him “very whimsical & impudent, though zealous for the Church of England.”Footnote 137 Whether it genuinely made up a deficit of knowledge in America about Scottish Episcopalianism or it simply gave a handle to Seabury's enemies, Sharp's letters circulated widely in the infant republic.Footnote 138 Sharp cited the mounting reservations about the legitimacy of Scottish orders, alongside the “pretensions of Mr. Wesley and other Methodists” in urging Archbishop Moore to renew his efforts to legalize English consecration. The proliferation of spurious episcopacies, he told the metropolitan, was evidence of “an increasing inclination towards Episcopal Government” among the Americans, which could only be reliably secured through the Church of England.Footnote 139
During Seabury's final months in Great Britain, the accomplishment of his consecration was undermined not only by the first stirrings of controversy, but by news that the Protestant Episcopal Church of the United States of America was organizing without the presence of a bishop. A series of state conventions had culminated in a meeting in New York of lay and clerical representatives from seven states in early October 1784, where some basic principles of ecclesiastical union were recommended. In an endorsement of episcopal polity, the representatives proposed that “in every state there shall be a bishop duly consecrated and settled.” But this traditionalism was undercut somewhat by the mandate that the laity be included in a planned general convention, and their concurrence as a body distinct from the clergy would be necessary to give any adopted measures validity.Footnote 140 News of these developments reached the British Isles not long after Seabury's elevation. Like William White's original proposal in The Case of the Episcopal Churches, the program adopted in New York (in which White had been a moving spirit) seemed to reproduce Erastianism, or lay superintendence, at the level of the denomination. The plan, Seabury complained to Bishop Skinner in Aberdeen, “will bring the clergy into abject bondage to the Laity.”Footnote 141 Andrew Macfarlane, minister of Strathnairn, considered the resolutions “much unlike what might be expected from men calling themselves ‘the Episcopal Church.’” Indeed, he considered the New York program a glorified form of presbyterianism.Footnote 142 Seabury realized that he would be returning to America to do battle not only with the traditional enemies of Anglicanism, but now with the defective episcopacies of the Methodists and, perhaps, with that of the low churchmen of his own communion. He requested books from his allies in Britain to arm him against ecclesiological heterodoxy. The Scots responded with one hundred copies of Skinner's newly published consecration sermon and a grab bag of apologetical works by the first and second generation of English and Scottish nonjurors, whose bitter experience of revolution, disestablishment, and proscription had bred in them an acute regard for the preservation of ecclesiastical independence.Footnote 143
Samuel Seabury arrived in Connecticut in June 1785 to find an American Church already divided against itself.Footnote 144 William White and the representatives of the Pennsylvania clergy promptly dispatched a letter of congratulations to Seabury, inviting him to participate in the general convention scheduled for September in Philadelphia.Footnote 145 But New York publisher James Rivington urged Seabury and his brethren to have nothing to do with “the Southern Bastards” organizing in his absence.Footnote 146 The Connecticut clergy formally received Seabury at a convention at Middletown on August 3. Their formal address hoped that Seabury would govern after the model of the primitive church, “while in her native purity, she was unconnected with, and uncontrolled by, any secular power.” The clergy's acrimony toward the English hierarchy had not abated, and their address was laced with recriminations that their “begging for an officer so absolutely necessary in the church of Christ, as they and we believe a bishop to be” was refused. Seabury was diplomatic, suggesting that the good dispositions of pious and concerned churchmen were liable to be rendered ineffectual “where the ecclesiastical and civil constitutions are so closely woven together as they are in that country.”Footnote 147 This exchange was soon published in both New Haven and Edinburgh, with a list of the succession of Scottish bishops since the Glorious Revolution appended.Footnote 148 In Britain, the Connecticut addresses inflamed the still simmering controversy over the consecration in the pages of the Gentleman's Magazine, where the anonymous low churchman “L .L.” mocked the list of Scottish bishops as a “long muster-roll of names, truly obscure and unedifying,” and pointless besides, as it was “universally known that all legal episcopacy terminated in Scotland” after the Glorious Revolution.Footnote 149 From Epsom, Jonathan Boucher told Seabury that the Connecticut clergy “make some little Noise among us” in Britain, but that he thought “upon the whole the world is with you.”Footnote 150
In fact, a transatlantic consensus was emerging in late 1785 that held the Scottish consecration valid, but sufficiently controversial that it threatened schism. In England, Archbishop Moore's misgivings over what he considered Seabury's “hasty and ill judged” expedition to Aberdeen persisted, no doubt exacerbated by Granville Sharp's relentless campaign on behalf of an English consecration.Footnote 151 In the United States, Seabury's decision to refrain from participating in the general convention at Philadelphia only bred additional ill will. Indeed, the only cognizance the general convention, which began on September 27, 1785, took of the new bishop was to hear the lengthy letter Seabury had written to the clergyman William Smith, president of Washington College in Maryland. In the letter, Seabury inveighed against the program adopted the previous year in New York, particularly the undue share of power it accorded the laity in the ecclesiastical constitution. “The rights of the Christian Church,” Seabury warned Smith, “arise not from nature or compact, but from the institution of Christ & we ought not to alter them, but to receive & maintain them, as holy Apostles left them.”Footnote 152 The letter was reportedly quite poorly received, particularly among the laity in attendance.Footnote 153 Granville Sharp's letter to James Manning denying the validity of the Scottish orders was also apparently laid before the convention.Footnote 154 Seabury's abstention from the assembly, his rejection of the ecclesiastical constitution and the mounting doubts about the Scottish episcopate likely influenced the convention's resolution to request consecration exclusively from the archbishops and bishops of the Church of England for American candidates elected in the state conventions.Footnote 155
There was some irony in the general convention's resolution to seek an episcopacy exclusively from England. In the new denominational order of the United States, where “there is a separation between the concerns of policy and the concerns of religion,” the only reliable imprimatur for a valid episcopate was that of the British establishment.Footnote 156 Granville Sharp was surely exaggerating when he marveled “that Presbyterians, Socinians, Methodists, Anabaptists & almost all the Sectaries from one end of the United States to the other, even to Boston, should agree in calling themselves Episcopal Churches,” but there were now multiple episcopacies in the new republic. Alongside the episcopal claims of the Moravians and the Mennonites was now what Seabury called the “impudence” of John Wesley and his American superintendents.Footnote 157 And in protest of Seabury's pretensions in the state, the General Association of Connecticut recommended that all congregationalist ministers “adopt & use the Appellation or Scripture Title of Bishop.”Footnote 158 In an environment where, as John Locke had famously put it, “everyone is Orthodox to himself,” the claims of Seabury and his allies to catholicity and to a pure episcopate “unshackled by Presbyterian & Un-Christian usurpations” barely registered.Footnote 159 Ironically, there was more legitimacy to be gleaned from the vestiges of an abrogated imperial establishment.
The transatlantic negotiations that ultimately secured the consecration of William White of Pennsylvania and Samuel Provoost of New York at Lambeth Palace on February 4, 1787, lie outside the scope of this article, as does the process by which the rival American episcopates were finally reconciled in late 1789.Footnote 160 What is important to note is that the subsumption of Episcopalianism within the American denominational order did not extinguish the claim to catholicity. Indeed, as Dan Handschy points out, the imperative of catholicity was largely channeled into Seabury's influential sacramental theology.Footnote 161 The conceit of an apostolic commission to ordain and administer the sacraments, transmitted from Christ exclusively through an uninterrupted succession of bishops, would continue to roil the broadly Protestant ecumene of the early republic.Footnote 162 And, indeed, one might usefully compare the narrow exclusivity cherished by high church Episcopalians (and their allies throughout the Anglican communion) with the sentiments that prevailed among American Presbyterians at the time, who were reconstructing their communion to maximize interdenominational cooperation with the various branches of Reformed Protestantism.Footnote 163 By contrast, Episcopalians, particularly those of Seabury's high church stamp, would continue to cultivate ecclesiastical distinctiveness.
“The Incorporation of the Church with the state,” lamented the Scottish Episcopal priest Andrew Macfarlane to Bishop Seabury in early 1785, “necessarily involves the Church in the revolutions of the State.” More than a century of political upheaval in the British Atlantic world testified to what Macfarlane deemed “the evils arising from civil establishments of Christianity.” Indeed, the examples were so numerous, Macfarlane observed, “it is surprising they are not seen.”Footnote 164 Like Richard Price's Observations on the Importance of the American Revolution a few months earlier, Macfarlane's conception of the separation of church and state was born of an age of revolutions. But the political cataclysms of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries imparted to adherents of the catholic tendency in Anglicanism a sense of the threat ecclesiastical establishments posed not to individual consciences and right of private judgment, but to the apostolic Church and its exclusive spiritual powers and prerogatives. In an age when the polities of the Atlantic world were exposed to periodic social and political turbulence, the Church was safer without state establishment. There was nothing particularly American or democratic about this ecclesiology. Its tenets were not gleaned from an experience of religious pluralism in the new world.Footnote 165 It was not predicated on a belief in the interiority of faith. And its mistrust of established religion did not, like that of Price, translate into any generalized sentiment of religious liberalism.
For the proponents of Seabury's episcopate, the Church's renunciation of state establishment in no way mitigated its claims to preeminence, its obligatory character, or the exclusivity of its sacramental authority. Relinquishing the primacy that came from political establishment, Seabury and his allies nevertheless resisted the parity that denominationalism imposed. The result was what Diana Butler Bass describes as the high church Episcopalian tendency “to insulate themselves from American culture.”Footnote 166 As critics in the early United States soon noted, there was something deeply “illiberal” in this ecclesiology. Even from London, Richard Price lambasted Bishop Seabury's pride and haughtiness “as a man who thinks he belongs to a higher order and considers himself as elevated above the other ministers in the state.”Footnote 167 And if these critics were not wrong, it is vital that we distinguish this illiberality from that of the old-world confessional state, which mandated religious conformity by force. High church Episcopalians in the United States were not clamoring for the restoration of ecclesiastical establishment or the resumption of coercive powers. But they were vigilant in maintaining the separation of church from the broader space of civic life. And this continued to inform this tradition's hostility to interdenominational movements such as temperance and Bible societies, pulpit exchange, prayer groups, and revivals.Footnote 168 Unlike other Protestant denominations, Episcopalianism was decidedly wary of redressing its loss of political establishment with the psuedoestablishment of the benevolent empire.Footnote 169 This imperative of separateness was not limited to the state. The consecration of Samuel Seabury bequeathed to American Episcopalianism an ideal of catholicity that might be realized in studied isolation from all the institutional forms of public life.
