While Christian responses to Darwinism have gained much scholarly attention, Jewish responses have been little studied. In their introduction to Jewish Tradition and the Challenge of Darwinism, editors Geoffrey Cantor and Marc Swetlitz describe the general idea: to show how ‘the study of evolution can illuminate how modern science has been recruited both as an enemy and as an ally of Jews’ (p. 2). The essays are grouped into three sections, each organized in roughly chronological order, and each with a helpful introduction by the editors. The first and third sections mainly concern Jewish theological encounters with evolutionary theory. The middle section considers uses of evolution in the overlapping contexts of anti-Semitism, race and eugenics.
The three chapters of the first section deal with ‘historical perspectives on Jewish responses to evolution’, concentrating on Great Britain and the United States since the late nineteenth century. Cantor's chapter portrays Anglo-Jewish responses to evolution in the British Jewish periodical press around 1900. According to Cantor, Jews were on the whole less troubled by questions of materialism, the human soul and divine design than were their Christian counterparts – though challenges to the standard, conciliatory response from Jewish writers revealed deeper uncertainties within the Jewish community. Swetlitz's contribution traces the responses of reform, conservative and reconstructionist rabbis in twentieth-century America, dividing these responses into eight phases, from the Scopes trial up to new Jewish mysticism. Continuing in this taxonomic spirit, Ira Robinson, writing on Orthodox Jewish responses to evolution in the twentieth-century USA, differentiates four strategies: rejecting science, pointing to the weaknesses and limitations of science, integrating science and Torah and claiming the transcendence of science. Robinson convincingly shows that all four strategies have been employed by certain movements within the Jewish Orthodox community, mainly for the purpose of making Jewish Orthodoxy more attractive to Jews not raised Orthodox.
The third section complements the first with four chapters on contemporary Judaism, concentrating on Orthodox views. Shai Cherry portrays three Modern Orthodox physicists and describes their writings on evolution as ‘crisis management’. He claims that all three physicists, voting for a literal reading of Torah and especially Genesis, are to be seen as fundamentalists who founded their authority on their status as scientists. In her chapter, Reny Selya reports on her interviews with teachers and alumni of Orthodox Jewish schools regarding how evolution is integrated into science education. While preparing their students for secular university training, most of these schools find a way of teaching evolution that reconciles science and theology, evolution and Creation. One of the teachers interviewed by Selya, a trained microbiologist named Carl Feit, follows with a chapter of his own, examining two of the most influential Modern Orthodox philosophers and their quite unusual approaches to science and evolution, grounded in traditional Jewish sources. Feit then concentrates on interpretations of Genesis and concludes with personal remarks about his own positive attitude towards evolutionary theory, rejecting a literal reading of Genesis. In the last chapter, Lawrence Troster analyses which aspects of Darwinism are most problematic for the belief in divine action or providence, and how the physicist Paul Davies, the philosopher Hans Jonas and the Catholic theologian John Haught have responded to those challenges with a certain ‘neo-naturalism’.
In contrast to the above, the middle section focuses mainly on German contexts; on evolutionary ideas as applied to, and especially against, Jews; and on secular responses to social movements, including social Darwinism, racism and eugenics. Richard Weikart's chapter, concentrating on Germany until the Second World War, examines several well-known, non-Jewish biologists, anti-Semites and eugenicists, and in particular their attitudes towards Jews and how those attitudes incorporated some notion of (social) Darwinism. Although Weikart's overview is helpful, the employed terminology is hardly convincing. ‘Scientific racism’, ‘social Darwinism’, ‘biological racism’ and ‘Darwinism’ are used almost interchangeably, sometimes in contrast to ‘mystic’ and ‘irrational’ anti-Semitism and racism. The impact of major changes within evolutionary theory, such as the rise of Weismannism and neo-Lamarckism, remains unmentioned. More satisfying is Paul Weindling's portrayal of Ignaz Zollschan, a Jewish-Austrian physician and Zionist who wrote on the ‘Jewish race’ before the First World War. According to Weindling, Zollschan's views on Zionism changed after that war; his views on race changed while he became a leading activist in international antiracist campaigns during the Second World War. His neo-Lamarckian approach allowed him to focus on cultural instead of biological factors, and he criticized the assumption of immutable racial characteristics claimed by many neo-Darwinian writers. Zollschan, it turns out, had no connections to traditional Jewry, which throws an interesting light on the spectrum described by Cantor. Quite different again is Raphael Falk's chapter, which systematically examines the connections between Zionism, race and eugenics in the twentieth century. According to Falk, ‘many Zionist writers appealed to biological conceptions of race and nation and displayed an awareness of their responsibility not only to preserve this biologically circumscribed ethnic group but also to propagate and improve it’ (p. 140). Falk ends his account about Zionists, Jewish anthropologists and Jewish eugenicists with a look at interest in ‘genetics of the Jews’ in recent years, and with a provocative conclusion: ‘Zionism and race are as intertwined today as they were a century ago’ (p. 162).
Such a fascinating volume, so full of surprising insights into the reception of biological science in a specific religious context, should stimulate new perspectives and highlight many starting points for further inquiry. If eugenics can be considered a form of Darwinism, as this volume suggests, then Jewish (theological) responses to eugenics should be investigated in the same way that Jewish attitudes to evolution and Creation have been. The interactions and conflicts between various religious groups – Jewish movements, but also Jewish and Christian groups – with regard to evolution could be a further focus, as well as the debates between those groups and bioscientists who oppose any belief in God. Continued work along these lines might also engage more systemically with the problem of defining ‘Darwinism’, and also with uncovering the range of German-Jewish responses to evolution (many sources have so far gone unnoticed). A final interesting aspect would be the old question of how the personal beliefs of biologists influence their scientific work, not only their self-proclamations, and vice versa.
