Paul Lim's book is part of a minor publishing wave of first books on Richard Baxter, a list which has also seen works from Tim Cooper, on Baxter and antinomianism (2001), and J. William Black, on Baxter and the pastoral ideal (2004). This scholarly resurgence is hardly surprising: Baxter is, as Lim claims, ‘arguably the most frequently cited Puritan’. While Lim's study omits any extended reflection on Baxter the man, it presents an assured study of the ecclesiology which cost so much in the seventeenth century and has done so much to puzzle historians ever since.
Lim argues cogently that ecclesiology is a central locus in the puritan imagination: more than 70 per cent of both the 1605 and 1640 editions of English Puritanism was taken up with discussions of ecclesiology. He also demonstrates that it is a central theme in Baxter's own writing, some 30 per cent of which is taken up with discussions of Christian unity. Lim's book – based on a University of Cambridge Ph.D. – presents a systematic analysis of Baxter's theology of conversion, baptism, confirmation and eucharistic thought before moving into the outworking of that ecclesiology in the Worcestershire Association, the debate about sola scriptura and the Socinian controversy, and Baxter's articulation of a ‘true’ history of Puritanism in the face of post-Restoration Grotian aggression.
Lim's strength is in his theological grasp, which he deploys carefully and to good effect in his historical analysis. His historiographical introduction demonstrates ‘a surprising lacuna in works devoted to [Baxter's] ecclesiology’ and claims that his text is ‘the first monograph-length study’ of the subject. But while Lim is consistently well-attuned to issues of theological interpretation, his use of the term ‘puritan’ is sometimes provoking. While Lim reflects on its contested definition, he also begins the first chapter by insisting that ‘the Puritans of both New and Old England’ shared an ecclesiological emphasis on liberty, unity and purity – a statement that is true enough in its own way, but perhaps open to a degree of misinterpretation, as his later descriptions of intra-puritan contests suggest. Additionally, in a period when more and more people were opting to live without baptism and when access to the eucharist was no longer guaranteed, a more extensive description of the competing analyses of the relationships between the visible and invisible churches would have been helpful.
It would also be useful to see Baxter's policy of liberty in a broader contemporary context. Baxter's preference for confessions of faith that were entirely composed in scriptural language has made him famous – inaccurately – for his defence of the heterodox. Nevertheless, Lim demonstrates Baxter's belief that ‘an explicit affirmation of the Deity of the Holy Spirit as a test of orthodoxy was a satanic strategy’, and parallels his lauding of the Westminster Assembly as a ‘Synod of as godly, judicious divines . . . as ever England saw’ with his insistence that their confession of faith or catechisms should not be used as a test of church membership. But perhaps Baxter was less of a maverick in this than Lim suggests.
There are a few proofreading issues in the published text, but these do not at all detract from what is otherwise a solid, scholarly and genuinely ground-breaking analysis of Baxter's complex and controversial ecclesiology. Lim's study demonstrates that Baxter's ecclesiology emerges from his polemical and political contexts and featured ideas that were often in tension with themselves.
