In recent years, there have been a number of in-depth studies of the Algerian War of Independence (1954–62) and its main actors and events. Each of these studies consequently concluded their investigations in 1962. Moreover, their analyses often revolved around the relationship between France and Algeria, owing to the metropole's central role in Algeria's long fight for decolonization. In a significant departure from these historiographical practices, Jeffrey Byrne has chosen to go beyond 1962 in studying the Algerian actors as part of a broader spectrum that includes the different Cold War powers. Following Westad's approach,Footnote 1 Byrne underlines how Cold War dynamics fueled decolonization, and how decolonization, in turn, reshaped the Cold War by reproducing its patterns and provoking broader conflict on the national and international stages. His work demonstrates how adopting a southern-hemisphere-based perspective facilitates the addition of many further elements that enable us to understand the complexity of decolonization and the birth of the new state. Moreover, for the historian and the political scientist, Byrne's in-depth analysis of the Ben Bella government underscores the importance of carefully analyzing the course of events within their historical context, and not judging them from the benefit of hindsight.
Each of the book's five chapters focuses on a different historical sequence. The first chapter gives a general overview of the political involvements, ideological backgrounds, and strategic engagements of the various Algerian leaders since the interwar period. Accurately, it depicts the question of national independence as being predominant over all other issues, as nationalist leaders successfully rallied wide swaths of the public around the cause without stating what they wanted to achieve afterwards. Their struggle for independence received firm support on the diplomatic stage, giving them a strength that they could not sustain through military control over the territory. The following years – described in chapter 2 – witnessed the forging of close links between Algerian leaders and new activists emerging from the Cold War. The Algerians formed key alliances with the Cubans and then the Congolese, managing to juggle the inherent contradictions in these alliances.
On the eve of Algeria's national independence, the new leaders assigned much value to foreign issues, which Ben Bella believed would demonstrate revolutionary Algeria's clear commitment to the emerging Third World. The Algerian authorities became involved on various stages, either directly through their actions or through their public declarations, with the intention of building bridges between themselves and other political and cultural entities. As Algerian diplomats admitted, the geographical range of their involvement depended on their available skills, budgets, connections, and opportunities. Several embassies opened across Africa. This helped to build a strong institutional apparatus through the Organization of African Unity, which Algerian leaders hoped would lead the continent on the path to revolution – as defined by Algeria. Byrne gives a detailed treatment of the contradictions between the dream of unifying states, on the one hand, and the subversive activities undertaken by the Algerians to spread their own understanding of anti-imperialism, on the other.
The diplomatic path taken by the Algerian revolutionaries hit several obstacles. Issues of race were a constant source of tension between sub-Saharan and Northern African countries. Moreover, the increased activities of Algeria's communist allies, the USSR and the People's Republic of China, amplified their antagonisms with each other. Byrne provides a detailed analysis of unexpected outcomes, for example arguing that during the first years of independence the French authorities were less suspicious of the USSR's relations with Algeria than they were of America's support for the new regime, fearing that their ally's influence in the country would exceed their own. Consequently, internal policies and politics and external dynamics were closely interlinked in the narrative of Algeria's struggle to become an independent state. This narrative reveals how the arrival of foreign revolutionary activists shook up the actions of a country facing major challenges; how alliances came to exclude certain practices; and, finally, how local actors looked to a much broader spectrum for guidance in determining their own conduct. The Congolese civil war, the Angolan fight for independence, agrarian reform, industrial policies, skirmishes between the USSR and China – all came together to stimulate the Algerian revolutionaries into forging their own path. Byrne finally concludes by showing how Ben Bella's outlook on international conduct and his great dream of engaging with external powers precipitated the formation of other factions in support of Boumedienne and Bouteflika, which overturned the government in the wake of the “Bandung II” meeting. Fearing that congressmen would grant Ben Bella a new mandate to rule, the conspirators staged a coup that put a stop to all foreign enterprise.
This book marks a new milestone in the historiography of the Maghreb and Algeria by demonstrating the connection between internal and external dynamics, and by more firmly embedding this region in Cold War historiography. Byrne's extensive documentary research, mostly in the Algerian archives, gives force to his arguments. He cannot avoid, however, certain difficulties involved in moving between various regions, from Cuba to Congo to Angola, and the need to gather all the elements necessary to clearly demonstrate the real impact of the Algerian authorities, their actions, and the nature of their influence on these external factors, but this minor criticism should not detract from the sound value provided by Byrne's book.
