In June of 2017, the University of Pennsylvania Press published Deportation: The Origins of U.S. Policy, by Torrie Hester. Its treatment of an important state practice obviously connected to enduring questions of race, immigration, and labor asks scholarly questions that cannot help but inform our understanding of contemporary politics and society. As the book's jacket copy declares, “Deportation covers the uncertain beginnings of American deportation policy and recounts the halting and uncoordinated steps that were taken as it emerged from piecemeal actions in Congress and courtrooms across the country to become an established national policy by the 1920s. Usually viewed from within the nation, deportation policy also plays a part in geopolitics; deportees, after all, have to be sent somewhere. Studying deportations out of the United States as well as the deportation of U.S. citizens back to the United States from abroad, Torrie Hester illustrates that U.S. policy makers were part of a global trend that saw officials from nations around the world either revise older immigrant removal policies or create new ones.”
Based on what struck us as the provocative and generative nature of the book and its intersection with the present political moment, the journal's editors decided to make Deportation the subject of our second book roundtable (Our first roundtable, in the January 2017 issue, treated Michael Lansing's study of the Nonpartisan League, Insurgent Democracy). We invited Rachel Ida Buff, Aviva Chomsky, Grace Peña Delgado, Hidetaka Hirota, and Emily Pope-Obeda to share their assessments and reactions to the book's major arguments. We asked them not so much for book reviews, of the sort more or less obligated to cover the book's sweep, but rather for their take on the book from the vantage of their own expertise. What can we learn from Hester's book, either because she lays out convincing and important arguments, or because she gets things wrong or misses major issues? What other work—already published, ongoing, or prospective—ought scholars be aware of or put in dialogue with Hester's?
In her 1931 monograph on the deportation of immigrants from the United States to Europe, political scientist Jane Perry Clark wrote:
A fact too little appreciated by those anxious to rid the country of ‘undesirables’ with all possible speed is that the United States can deport no one unless some other country is willing to receive the deportee. No matter how deportable a foreigner may be under our laws or how entirely unwelcome here, we must keep him here unless some other country is willing to take him in, for he cannot eternally wander the seas.Footnote 1
Yet, it is not until Torrie Hester's 2017 Deportation: The Origins of U.S. Policy that a scholar of American deportation history has truly grappled with the ramifications of this seemingly self-evident fact. Hester traces the rise of the American deportation system through the federal courts, but stays constantly attuned to the international realities of a practice based on removing individuals from U.S. soil by arranging permission to land them on the soil of another nation. Arguably Hester's most critical and well-developed insight is that deportation, as a bilateral process of directed removal rather than a unilateral process of expulsion, has always been shaped by and shaped the international legal landscape. Hester's work takes seriously the diplomatic requirements of a modern deportation system, and in fact, contextualizes the rise of the American deportation regime within a broader international transition from expulsion to deportation under the modern nation-state systems of documentation and international law.
Historical scholarship on deportation emerged quite slowly until recent years, lagging behind work in other disciplines on the contemporary growth of deportation. From the time of Clark's publication until roughly fifteen years ago, there were remarkably few publications on the historical underpinnings of the modern deportation regime. Until recently, deportation history had been largely relegated to brief mentions in larger studies of immigration policy, rather than recognized as a policy, and furthermore, a social agenda of its own. But deportation, as a new wave of scholars, beginning with immigration historians like Mae Ngai and legal scholars like Daniel Kanstroom, have reminded us, exists to do far more than merely enforce growing immigration restrictions.Footnote 2 Kanstroom explains of deportation that “to be sure it part of our immigration control system, though it has worked remarkably poorly even in that realm. But it is also a powerful tool of discretionary social control, a key feature of the national security state, and a most tangible component of the recurrent episodes of xenophobia that have bedeviled our nation of immigrants.”Footnote 3 As contemporary events have urgently drawn attention to the centrality of deportation in American political life, so too have historians begun to explore its critical role in shaping the nation.
Historians have increasingly emphasized how deportation has reflected and reframed racial regimes, contributed to new forms of medical and moral boundary drawing, and helped constitute the modern carceral state. Scholars such as Susan Coutin, Nicholas De Genova, and Nathalie Peutz have debated where deportation studies sits as a field of scholarship—merely as a subset of immigration history, subsumed within security studies, as part of the growing literature on the carceral state; or as a field of its own, marked by elements of these topics, but representing a distinctive approach.Footnote 4 Hester's work presents a compelling claim to additionally locating deportation studies as part of the study of international law, and her coverage of both the international appeals procedure and extraterritorial jurisdiction are clear, groundbreaking, and enlightening.
As a judicial history of the deportation regime, Hester's work is exemplary. Hester provides an excellent, thoroughly researched, and painstakingly detailed account of how the nascent deportation regime came into being. The most marked strength of the work is in its careful and patient tracing of how the courts interpreted deportation legislation over a period of forty years. Rather than emphasize merely the congressional debates that drove national law incrementally toward a gatekeeping ideology, Hester joins scholars like Erika Lee and Lucy Salyer in emphasizing the significant impact of the judicial branch on the development of American immigration policy throughout the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.Footnote 5 In doing so, she highlights the role of immigrant agency in pushing their cases through the courts as they fought for less expansive interpretations of the federal power of deportation. Hester's work provides a powerful analysis of migration as something deeply shaped not only by individual states, but by the developing field of international law. While scholars have suggested the need to examine the state-building project enacting by deportation beyond American borders, none have so thoroughly reconceptualized its necessary integration of international law. Deirdre Moloney argued in her 2012 book that “deportation and related forms of immigration control arose as an important function of the modern, industrial state. Control over the composition of a nation's citizenry, its ideologies, and the shape of the industrial workforce increasingly became a transnational project, not simply one that occurred within national borders.”Footnote 6 But Hester goes even further, reframing deportation as both a facet and a result of developing international law.
Hester's work is divided into two halves—the first of which explores the construction of U.S. deportation as well as the international circumstances within which it emerged, and the second of which examines particular criteria for deportation. The first half of the book is highly innovative, impeccably detailed, and ambitiously argued. It critically disrupts many of the traditions of solely national-level explorations of deportation, and provides a refreshing example of how even histories of federal legal policy can be transnationally oriented. Perhaps among the most important interventions Hester pushes for is an acknowledgment that the United States was not only a sending nation of deportees, it was also a recipient of deportees. In doing so, she not only highlights an underexplored aspect of American immigration history, but undermines a long-standing and politically problematic tradition of representing the United States as a unidirectional receiver of immigrants who (in the national myth) all aspire to permanent residence and integration in the United States. By recognizing not only that not all immigrants were American bound, but that not all nations always wanted American citizens to immigrate, Hester sharpens our understanding of the growing immigration control regime. Furthermore, her discussion of how the system for Chinese deportations and that for all other immigrants emerged distinctly, but in parallel to one another, but eventually were folded back into a unified system is a masterful and tremendously useful integration of two accounts that are often told separately, to the detriment of a fuller understanding of the aims of the system as a whole.
The second half of the book, while still rigorously researched, nuanced, and effective in explaining the various deportation provisions that she selects, is somewhat less ambitious a departure from the existing scholarship. Hester addresses each of the provisions she selects (anarchism, prostitution, and economic dependency) from a distinctive angle. Perhaps this is most notable in the chapter on political radicalism where she sheds new light on a frequently covered topic by exploring the complicated diplomatic maneuverings needed to actually implement deportations to the Soviet Union during the period of the First Red Scare. However, Hester's work at times reinforces the pervasive tendency within the scholarship to emphasize those deportations that were striking, sensational, or scandalous as the expense of a deeper exploration of those that were both numerous and mundane. While the amount of attention, time, and staffing the Immigration Service may have devoted to criteria like prostitution and radicalism might demonstrate federal priorities, they neither sufficiently encapsulate local priorities nor the lived experiences of immigrants. Perhaps it is precisely because Hester's narrative is driven by court cases, rather than by case files, that her story tends to emphasize those provisions of the law that had the most complicated legal questions, rather than those that had the most numeric impact or reach across immigrant communities. While Hester acknowledges the relatively low numbers of deportees removed for political activism (only rising to a significant number for a span of two frenzied years in 1919 and 1920), she continues to reinforce the disproportionate power these uncommon stories have had in the narrative of deportation history.
Because these political deportees had powerful networks of advocates, and presented, in many cases, as compelling and sympathetic victims of the excesses of the state's power of removal, they have often overshadowed the masses of anonymous deportees of the period. Hester notes that the majority of deportation cases were actually people entangled in the state's machinery for much more pedestrian violations, such as the designation of “likely to become a public charge,” but at times, these accounts get lost behind the extensive coverage of more striking cases. Hester critically reveals the paternalistic aspects of anti-prostitution deportations while still recognizing that they were part of a project of enforcing normative sexual morality through the removal of suspected prostitutes and other women who deviated from the status quo of gendered expectations. However, except for a small number of years, far more women felt the power of the state as it policed their poverty, their physical or mental health, their unmarried status, or their perceived inability to support themselves.Footnote 7 What was perhaps most notable about the nascent deportation regime by the early twentieth century, I would argue, was not the spectacular violations of political liberties or free speech, or even the crackdown against prostitution. It was the deep and insidious forms of quotidian violence that the state wielded against the most unremarkable and unnoteworthy of victims.
Hester's final chapter provides a much-needed engagement with the economic dimensions of the deportation agenda. Much of her discussion of the much broader and more frequently implemented criteria of “likely to become a public charge” emphasizes how this provision was used to carry out a racial project of exclusion and expulsion of Indian immigrants in the years prior to their prohibition under the 1917 Immigration Act. Though a fascinating example of how the Immigration Service managed to “exclude Indians as a racial class by proxy,” this section diverges some from the overall exploration of post-entry deportations, and more generally, dominates the overly brief discussion of how the “likely to become a public charge” provision emerged as one of the most powerful elements of deportation law by the early twentieth century.Footnote 8 While Hester notes that “immigration agents used the LPC provision as a catchall category to restrict the immigration of single women, Jews, and many other groups,” and adds that “it was also used racially,” she does not provide an extensive analysis of how it came to be used to not only restrict the migration of immigrants into the country, but to remove those who had resided within the nation for some time.Footnote 9 In doing so, she fails to grapple with some of the ways in which the modern deportation apparatus functioned to policy immigrant dependency on state resources, and to punish not only those who violated the nation's moral codes through prostitution, but those who became financial burdens on the public.Footnote 10 Even the name of the chapter itself—”From Racial to Economic Grounds”—sets up what I would insist is a problematic dichotomy—marking racial and economic grounds as distinct and discrete entities, and failing to truly capture the extent to which they were interwoven in practice. Deportation facilitated the rise of powerful and persistent narratives about the racialized nature of poverty and dependency, which continue to shape the modern debates over migration today.
In her introduction, Hester makes the essential point that “immigrants defending against a deportation understood that the deportation policy they faced was shaped as much by the nature of enforcement as by the text of the law.”Footnote 11 One of the subjects that Hester's work thought provokingly introduces, but never fully develops, is what she calls the “mechanics” of deportations. She picks this subject up in her chapter entitled “From Protection to Punishment,” but devotes only a few pages to these mechanics (a topic rarely treated in depth upon in the literature on deportation) before moving on. Her treatment of the legal technicalities for the applicability of deportation is remarkably thorough, while her discussion of the technicalities of enforcing and carrying out these deportations is considerably more constrained. In general, this seems to speak to a broader need in the field to engage more seriously with the enforcement of the law, rather than merely the law itself.Footnote 12 Doing so will not only give us a better understanding of how the deportation regime operated on the ground and how immigrants experienced this growing apparatus of the state, but also how much it varied locally. Just as we understand today that contemporary deportation policy, while national and international in its legal scope, is not applied equally in Arizona as it is in New York City as it is in Alabama, we must recognize that it has never been enforced outside of specific local and regional contexts.
While deportation history is, necessarily, marked by a series of legislation and court cases further elaborating the reach of such legislation, it is also, at its core, about the localized policing of individuals. While Hester thoughtfully engages how the growing deportation state required coordination with international law and governments, she at times underemphasizes how much deportation relied upon local governments for enforcement, particularly in a period when the staff of the Immigration Service was still small and underfunded, though rapidly expanding. Hester notes in her conclusion that “state prison and local authorities seldom initiated deportation proceedings or sought federal involvement.”Footnote 13 However, by the 1920s, the period in which she ends her study, considerable (if locally and regionally inconsistent) communication and cooperation had arisen between on the ground law enforcement officials, local jails and hospitals, and immigration officials, which facilitated the sharp rise in deportation throughout the 1920s that Hester notes in her final pages. Without the assistance of a wide array of local figures, from random vigilantes who reported their neighbors on suspicion of their deportability to local police forces who carried out raids in immigrant neighborhoods and workplaces, the deportation agenda of the government would have struggled in its efforts. As contemporary debates rage over the extent to which local law enforcement should play a role in bolstering the work of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), and localities struggle over their rights to withhold participation in the deportation agenda of the federal government, it is critical to note how contingent deportation has always been on both law enforcement and local cooperation.
For many in the nation, the subject of deportation has only recently emerged as part of their political consciousness after months of it being splashed across headlines and uttered in public debates throughout the most recent presidential campaign. Others have been aware of its increasing impact for decades, particularly as immigrant rights’ activists have struggled to draw attention to the massive rise in deportations during the Obama administration. Hester's work rightly prompts us to recognize that not only is this policy not new or limited to the past few decades, but that it is has long been constitutive of both the nation and its international relations. Hester reminds us that deportation has not been an ever-present or inevitable facet of American law. Instead, it emerged and expanded at particular moments in history, prompted by particular national and international developments and agendas. Nor was it a smooth and steady advance, but instead, was one fiercely contested in the courts. Today, as the courts debate the president's power to restrict the entry of certain groups of immigrants, profiling and discrimination against particular groups of immigrants, indefinite detention of immigrants for whom deportation cannot be effected, the legality of expedited removal, and the grounds for criminal deportations, Hester's work could hardly be more timely or important.
Deportation is a relatively new subject in modern American immigration scholarship. Previous generations of historians hardly neglected regulatory immigration policy in their works, but it is in Asian American Studies and Latino Studies since the 1990s that immigrant deportation began to receive substantial scholarly attention. Highlighting the centrality of race in American immigration control, Asian American Studies and Latino Studies have led the historical study of American deportation policy. At the same time, as a natural consequence of this background, many works touching upon deportation policy have been framed along the lines of distinct national or racial groups certain group lines, and a limited number of studies provide a broader general history of deportation policy.Footnote 14 In Deportation: The Origins of U.S. Policy, Torrie Hester, who has already established herself in the field of American immigration history with her earlier articles on deportation, provides a rare study that focuses on the policy itself as the main subject for inquiry. The book chronicles the rise of a national deportation regime in the United States between the 1880s and the 1920s, with a masterful analysis of the roles of Congress, the Supreme Court, and the Bureau of Immigration in the process.Footnote 15 Two themes covered in the book stand out as particularly important to historians of American immigration policy: the integration of Chinese exclusion into general immigration policy and the international dimension of deportation.
One of the recent trends in American immigration scholarship is the reinterpretation of federal Chinese exclusion. As the first national legislation that restricted immigration on the basis of race and nationality, the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 has been thought by scholars to mark the closure of America's borders, which had supposedly been open until that point, and set the groundwork for American immigration control.Footnote 16 While recognizing the significance of Chinese exclusion, historians have recently begun to place it in new interpretive contexts. Moon-Ho Jung, for example, has argued that the federal Act of 1862, which prohibited the importation of “coolies” from China on the assumption that most Chinese subjects leaving the country were unfree, bound laborers, was not simply America's last slave-trade law but also “the first federal statute to restrict immigration into the United States.”Footnote 17 Jung thus suggests that restrictive legislation against Chinese immigration had existed at the federal level before the passage of the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. On the other hand, Beth Lew-Williams has warned against overestimating restrictive motives attached to the Act of 1882, going so far as to assert that “the 1882 Act did not intend to exclude all Chinese immigrants or even to exclude all Chinese laborers,” given the federal government's compelling interests in maintaining positive diplomatic relationship with China at that time. Lew-Williams thus calls the intent of the 1882 Act into question and demonstrates that the implementation of Chinese exclusion remained mild at best until 1888.Footnote 18 In my own work, I have challenged immigration scholars’ tendencies to describe the Chinese Exclusion Act as an abrupt and absolute turning point in American immigration policy and to overlook earlier state-level immigration control and its lingering influence on federal control.Footnote 19
Hester provides important new perspectives on Chinese exclusion by revealing how Bureau of Immigration officials folded it into general immigration policy applicable to all non-Chinese foreigners in order to deport as many Chinese as possible. From the perspectives of officials, the merit of applying general immigration law to Chinese was not simply to throw a wider net over them. Chinese exclusion law allowed immigrants to dispute deportation orders at federal courts, which often overturned them. Under general immigration law, by contrast, deportation appeals went to the Secretary of Commerce and Labor, a procedure that minimized judicial review for the removal orders and usually worked against the immigrants. Once the Supreme Court approved the application of general immigration law to Chinese in 1912, Bureau of Immigration agents began to arrest and deport Chinese for the infraction of the general law, such as unlawful entry without inspection. The officials heavily relied on this method to the extent that the number of deportation warrants for Chinese issued under general immigration law was nearly four times as large as those under Chinese exclusion law in 1914. The Immigration Act of 1917 formally made Chinese deportable under general immigration law. This process, Hester argues, took Chinese exclusion “largely out of the judicial system, making it almost entirely a separate administrative law.”Footnote 20
Historians have extensively analyzed the evolution of the two tracks of early federal immigration control. While some claim that Chinese exclusion laid the foundations for general immigration policy that developed from 1882 onward, others note how the making of general immigration law, including its earlier state-level precedents, shaped the context in which Chinese exclusion was introduced. Historians thus recognize how the two tracks influenced each other, but most tend to see them as ultimately separate systems of immigration control in terms of implementation. Hester's analysis of the use of general law for the deportation of Chinese illuminates the practical overlap of Chinese exclusion and general immigration policy. The deportation experience of Chinese was not simply shaped by Chinese exclusion law; general immigration law also played a vital role in their removal from the United States. Hester's study suggests that if the fundamental significance of Chinese exclusion lay in its injection of racism into the nation building of the United States during the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, the full understanding of this process requires historians to expand the scope of the investigation of Chinese exclusion to include its incorporation into general immigration policy. The point is to view the two tracks as parts of the single development of the U.S. deportation regime.
The second point of importance that Deportation raises is the international dimension of American immigration policy. Internationalization, or efforts to interpret U.S. history from international perspectives, has characterized American historical scholarship for the last two decades. As a field that has long adopted transnational methods, immigration history helped lead this intellectual trend. Ironically, however, immigration control—its subtheme—has remained decidedly domestic in approach, focusing largely on the development and implementation of regulatory laws within the United States. Some historians have nevertheless analyzed the international aspects of American nativism and immigration control. Kornel Chang, for example, has argued that local whites’ violence against Asian migrants in the state of Washington and the Canadian province of British Columbia at the turn of the twentieth century stemmed from common social and legal forces to exclude Asians from North America.Footnote 21 Likewise, Kelly Lytle Hernández has demonstrated that deportation at the southern borders in the twentieth century functioned on the basis of binational policing orchestrated by the United States and Mexico.Footnote 22 The integration of diplomatic and immigration policy history has also drawn increasing attention.Footnote 23
Deportation is a significant addition to this growing effort to internationalize the study of American immigration control. Hester traces how deportation began to follow bilateral proceedings between the United States and the country that would receive deportees in the early twentieth century. As nation-states tightened control over their jurisdictions, deportation became a subject of case-by-case diplomatic negotiations. A nation-state's ability to deport somebody depended on the receiving country's willingness to approve such an action and could be constrained by oppositions from it, which amounted to an international appeal. “By the early twentieth century,” Hester asserts, “the centrality of reception to carrying out a removal at all meant that the bilateral deportation, as opposed to the more unilateral expulsion, emerged as a dominant form of immigrant removal.”Footnote 24 Involving diplomats as well as immigration officials in the process, deportation therefore not only embodied domestic nativism or agendas of nation building, but also took shape in an international legal regime where layers of jurisdictions and diplomatic agreements determined the course of the policy.
The emergence of bilateral migrant removals seemed to mark a pivotal departure from the age of state-level immigration control in the nineteenth century. Before the introduction of federal immigration legislation in the 1880s, states administered immigration control and Massachusetts in particular actively implemented its policy for deporting destitute foreigners. One of the characteristics of Massachusetts removal policy was the unilateral decision of destination by state immigration officials. Massachusetts law provided that a foreign pauper could be sent to “any place beyond the sea, where he belongs,” and officials enjoyed complete freedom in deciding where the deportee belonged. As a result, Massachusetts officials routinely deported indigent Irish immigrants to Liverpool on the grounds that they were British subjects. This policy provoked heated protests from Liverpool authorities, who asked the United Kingdom Foreign Office to stop the deportation of the Irish from Massachusetts to Britain. The Foreign Office, however, ultimately concluded that it could do little with the practice, in part because a state government, not the federal government, implemented it and British diplomats could not exert any significant influence on state-level affairs. The unilateral approach also applied to exclusion, or policy for landing regulation. Massachusetts law restricted the landing of destitute foreigners unable to support themselves, just as later federal law did. After refusing the landing of Irish passengers coming from Ireland, officials in Massachusetts sometimes ordered the vessel captain to go to a Canadian port without securing any approval from Canadian authorities.Footnote 25
This quick look at state-level deportation and exclusion illuminates how the situation that surrounded American immigration control changed by the early twentieth century. The formation of the national deportation regime coincided with the solidification of border surveillance and claims to sovereignty in other nation-states. Unilateral removals, which had characterized state-level immigration control, became increasingly difficult to pursue. Hester carefully notes that the international legal regime was not made up of equal entities. Imperialism, including unequal extraterritorial agreements based on it, placed some countries in superior positions to others over the matters of deportation, and it was precisely with imperialist arrogance that the U.S. government deported Chinese nationals to China while denying the country the authority to remove American citizens. Nevertheless, by the early twentieth century, federal deportation policy increasingly needed to function within the confines of the international legal regime, especially among Western countries.
Torrie Hester's Deportation makes seminal contributions to historical scholarship on American immigration policy by placing Chinese exclusion in a new interpretive context and by incorporating international and diplomatic perspectives into the examination of deportation proceedings. A number of scholars have already noted the distinctiveness of Chinese exclusion in the history of American immigration policy. Future research, then, should be encouraged to follow Hester's lead to investigate Chinese exclusion's relationship with general immigration policy, especially how the two tracks of federal immigration control overlapped at the site of law enforcement. Hester's study also provokes new lines of inquiry into the international dimensions of deportation. Historians have paid much attention to the rise of the plenary power doctrine, which justified the United States’ unilateral right to exclude and deport undesirable foreigners over international treaties, as the backbone of modern American immigration policy. Future research may explore, among other themes, the relationship between the doctrine and the international legal regime that made deportation proceedings bilateral. The significance of this book, of course, is hardly limited to these two issues. The book as a whole provides a uniquely comprehensive analysis of the legal and administrative development of federal deportation policy during its formative period, and Hester's examination of the logic of deportation expands our understanding of the policy's central problems that still exist today, such as the abuse of deportation power under the cause of national security and the racist use of economic deportation. For its exceptional scholarly achievements and timely nature, Deportation deserves acclaim and a large readership.
Torrie Hester's important book challenges readers to unsettle truisms related to immigration that inform contemporary immigration debates and policies. Deportation complements recent works like Mae Ngai's Impossible Subjects, Ian Haney López's White by Law, Kelly Lytle Hernández's Migra!, and Daniel Kanstroom's Deportation Nation to reveal the historical construction of concepts and systems regarding immigration control that we have come to take for granted.Footnote 26 As deportation has become a household terror or a household word across many sectors of the United States in recent years, these urgent calls to turn to history to understand how we got to where we are could not be more timely.
Like some of the books cited above, Hester relies heavily on the making of law by Congress and through court decisions that step by step assembled the deportation edifice that we live within today. She highlights three interrelated areas: the intersections between criminal law and immigration law, the ways that border control evolved into interior enforcement to together create the roots of today's widespread deportation regime, and the global aspects of deportation.
The strength of Hester's work is in the depth and detail she provides for what she convincingly argues is the key period for the development of deportation law: from the 1880s until 1924. During these years the legal groundwork for the next century of deportation was laid. But it was not until the late twentieth century that the laws began to be implemented in full force. Although the first deportation policies were established in 1892, 95 percent of the fifty million people deported by the United States since that date were deported after 1970.Footnote 27
The issues Hester raises profoundly shape today's deportation debates, and a better understanding of the arbitrary and contingent nature of current realities can help us imagine better ways to conceptualize the rights of immigrants, and also to critique the optimistic notion espoused today by liberals that the United States is and has always been a “country of immigrants” that only needs to return to its welcoming, multicultural roots. A close reading of Hester, in the context of other recent works on settler colonialism, criminalization, and mass incarceration suggests that a much more profound challenge to American roots is in order.
Hester traces the chilling legal genealogies of forced removal from the United States. Deportation law and policy began with border exclusion from entry, then expanded from the border into retroactive exclusion through detention and deportation of those already inside the country. As the system metastasized, it intersected with criminal law in complicated ways. Immigration violations became defined as crimes, and criminal convictions had become grounds for deportation. Yet the immigration justice system, which included arrest, detention, and deportation, remained immune to the constitutional protections afforded by the criminal justice system.
Race, class, and gender played important roles in the elaboration of a national doctrine of admissibility and deportability. Deportation law and practice aimed initially at the Chinese, who were deemed racially ineligible to citizenship, and in particular Chinese laborers. Hester traces how deportations of other excludable categories like criminals and paupers, followed, then female prostitutes, who were deemed criminally undesirable. Later, the category “likely to become a public charge” (LPC) emerged as a major rationale for excludability and deportability. Once certain categories of people were forbidden from entry, “entry without inspection” also became grounds for deportation.Footnote 28
The expansion of deportation from the border to the interior, Hester shows, meant that the distinction between immigrants and citizens gained heightened significance in the early twentieth century. In 1891, Congress ruled that immigrants remained deportable for a year after entry. The time limit increased up to five years by 1917, and was removed altogether for certain crimes, including the vague category of crimes involving “moral turpitude.” This meant that “immigrants” became a new category of residents who could be permanently deportable.Footnote 29 (Under President Bill Clinton, retroactive deportability was expanded to apply to an increasing number of offenses not deemed deportable at the time they were committed—so individuals could become deportable not because they committed a new offense but because an old offense was re-categorized.)
The murky ground where immigration law intersects with criminal law took on renewed importance decades after the focus of Hester's study, when after 1965 numerical quotas were for the first time applied to Mexican migration, thus illegalizing the hundreds of thousands of Mexicans who crossed the border to work every year. This shift accompanied the racialized wars on crime and on drugs, and the ways that Democrats from Johnson to Clinton and Obama fused their wars on crime with wars on the poor, and Republicans fused their own wars on crime with national security.Footnote 30 Hester's book sheds a whole new light on President Trump's wars on the poor and people of color at home and abroad, his invoking of national security, and his obsession with the “criminal immigrant.”
While Hester offers abundant detail on the complex legal origins of the U.S. deportation regime during the key period she studies, reading her work in the context of emerging literatures on settler colonialism and on the carceral state can suggest further theoretical significance to her arguments. The detail in her in-depth case study can also help scholars in these fields to wrestle with questions that only a few are beginning to ask. Why is a settler colonial paradigm so much more widely accepted in Canada and Australia than in the United States? Why and how have settler colonial regimes evolved from glorifying and privileging immigrants, to despising and excluding them? How does the criminalization of immigrants relate to the growth and nature of the carceral state?
The immigrant holds a contradictory place in the American imagination. Liberals in favor of immigrant rights often invoke the notion that the United States is a country “founded by immigrants” or is a “country of immigrants.” Hester delves into the moment when the “immigrant” first came to be seen with suspicion and criminalized. Placing her study in the context of settler colonialism helps to illuminate these apparently contradictory cultural and political stances toward immigration, and also the exclusionary and racialized underpinnings of the exaltation of immigrants. Unless we can challenge these underpinnings, appeals to the country's immigrant history offer a compromised foundation on which to base calls for immigrant rights.
The settler colonial framework is only now being taken seriously in mainstream U.S. historiography, yet it provides an essential tool for understanding immigration history in the Americas. Patrick Wolfe's key theoretical work on settler colonialism emphasizes the “logic of elimination” and replacement by which colonizers imagine the creation of a nation that excludes the Native population.Footnote 31 This logic of elimination is not a temporal event located in the past but an ongoing process that permeates the history and culture of the polity. A settler colonial frame helps to reveal further nuances in the deportation policy Hester has uncovered.
Settler colonialism's “logic of elimination” took multiple forms, many of them echoed in the United Nations’ 1948 definition of genocide. Assertion of European rights to Native lands and the implementation of these rights through dispossession, enslavement, removal, massacre, and genocide; attempts at cultural, religious, and linguistic erasure through law, education, religious conversion, and force; attempts at racial elimination through coerced physical and cultural mestizaje, sterilization, and eugenics; child removal through enslavement and forced transport, missions, residential schools, prisons, foster care, and adoption; and racial whitening through immigration. They did not end with independence, and they continue to shadow U.S. culture, society, and policy.
Two recent studies situate immigrant detention and deportation in a settler colonial frame. Daniel Kanstroom takes his study of deportation law much further back in history than Hester, finding the origins of late nineteenth-century immigration restrictions and deportation in colonial-era removals of criminals, the poor, or religious dissidents and early nineteenth-century Indian removals. Kelly Lytle Hernández explicitly places settler colonialism at the roots of the carceral state in general and immigrant incarceration in particular.Footnote 32 Beginning with the expulsion, extermination, and caging of California's Natives she traces Los Angeles's carceral history through the incarceration of poor white transients, of Chinese immigrants, of Mexican revolutionaries in the 1910s, of Mexican immigrant workers in the 1920s, and of African Americans since the 1930s. All of these, she argues, reveal an intertwined settler colonial history through which Anglo (and later, white) elites imposed their dominance on the land and claimed their right to rule.”Footnote 33
The “country of immigrants” narrative takes on a different cast when viewed from a settler colonial perspective, as does the issue of citizenship and its relationship to deportation. In British North America, immigrants were the possessors of political and racial power. Among the causes of the American Revolution were the British Empire's halting attempts to reduce white settler power over racialized others, mostly in the interests of balancing American and other imperial interests. Gerald Horne points to British restrictions on slaveholder power as one source of settler discontent.Footnote 34 The Declaration of Independence names another source when it refers to the Proclamation of 1763, which halted white settlement west of the Appalachians. Among King George's crimes listed in the Declaration are the fact that “He has endeavoured to prevent the population of these States; for that purpose obstructing the Laws for Naturalization of Foreigners; refusing to pass others to encourage their migrations hither, and raising the conditions of new Appropriations of Lands…” Thus white supremacy was inherently embodied in immigrants, and immigration and the imperative of taking Native land were intimately linked.
State promotion of white immigration as a settler colonial means of racial whitening characterized the entire population replacement project of Manifest Destiny or Westward expansion in the nineteenth century. Indian policy swung back and forth between removal and assimilation, two poles on the same genocidal spectrum of elimination. U.S. immigration history, as it was traditionally conceived, ignored the other side of a settler colonial coin.Footnote 35
A settler colonial frame to the history of immigration reveals industrial society developing in deep symbiosis with Indian removals and Indian wars. Edward Baptist and Sven Beckert have recently brought arguments about the centrality of slavery in the development of American capitalism back to the fore.Footnote 36 But the cotton boom of the nineteenth century was predicated also on the removal of the Native peoples and the multiracial formations that had emerged in the U.S. Southeast under Native, Spanish, and French rule. Later in the century, the Homestead Act that offered Western land to white settlers was the other side of the Dawes Act, which broke up and privatized Native reservations. The railroads, mines, and agriculture that linked the industrial East to the West (and brought Mexican and Chinese immigrant labor as well) entailed the violent elimination of Native sovereignty and the daily subjugation of the region's Native peoples.
This process did not end with the Indian wars at the end of the nineteenth century but continued into the twenty-first with the post-WWII population, military and extraction boom in the sunbelt.Footnote 37 In fact Native peoples from Alaska to Tierra del Fuego have been the primary victims of twenty-first century neo-extractivism that has fueled First World digital revolution and overconsumption, just as the Native peoples displaced by the coffee, cotton, sugar, hides, lumber, tin, copper, and banana industries of the nineteenth century spanned North and South America.Footnote 38
Today's deportation policies, and their roots in the period Hester studies, take on a new logic when placed in the context of settler colonialism's project of creating a country of white people on Indigenous lands. Contemporary deportation policy could be seen as a logical unfolding of Indian removal policies, especially given the preponderance of Indigenous people among those being deported today. Mexican and Central American Indigenous people are today overrepresented among those uprooted by economic and physical violence in their home countries, among those migrating to the United States, and among those currently being deported. A visit to Streamline (immigration) court in Arizona reveals the horrifying spectacle of dozens of brown—primarily Indigenous—shackled people shepherded through show trials on the way to being forcibly removed. As I have written elsewhere, “the United States is still deporting Native people.”Footnote 39
The settler colonial frame coexists in symbiosis with the criminalization of immigrants in ways that reveal much about our current contradictions. For much of U.S. history the term “immigrant” was defined as applying to white settler colonials, and not to the many people of color who were incorporated as voluntary or coerced laborers and, by definition, not eligible for citizenship. Hester's focus on the roots of the deportation regime precisely during the period in which immigrants were supposedly being welcomed highlights the contradictory nature of the supposed “welcome.”
Birthright citizenship played a key role the new drive to control immigration after 1870. As Jacqueline Stevens, Martha Jones, and others have argued, while birthright citizenship was conceived as a progressive move to extend citizenship to African Americans after the Civil War, it left large gaps in rights for those living outside of the country of their birth. In the post-1965 context of massive forced and voluntary migrations, it has come to serve as a form of exclusion as arbitrary as earlier forms based on race.Footnote 40
The carceral state offers a second frame that can add to the significance of Hester's study. The 1960s War on Crime and the 1980s Drug Wars contributed to the contemporary growth of the carceral state, which coincided and intertwined with the upward spiral in the criminalization, detention, and deportation of immigrants.
A major frame in mass incarceration studies has been that of race. Michelle Alexander suggested in 2010 that mass incarceration had created a “New Jim Crow” that continued to legally and disproportionately exclude blacks from attributes of citizenship including voting, working, or receiving public benefits temporarily, and for many with felony records, permanently.Footnote 41 The Drug Wars played a role, as did changes in sentencing laws. Felony records, often the result of overworked public defenders who counseled clients to plea bargain in return for a reduced sentence, turned convicts into permanent outcasts.
Even without criminal records, noncitizens face the same systematic exclusions from rights, plus, in the age of mass incarceration the ever-increasing threat of deportation. If one assumes that noncitizens are simply travelers temporarily in the country, exclusions from the rights of citizenship contain a certain logic. But in fact the eleven to twelve million noncitizens in the United States are immigrants: people who came to settle, work, and make lives. Criminalization adds yet another layer to the accretion of laws, policies, and culture that over time justify their legal and physical exclusion.
While Hester's work outlines some of the roots of the criminalization of immigrants, mass deportation, like mass incarceration, is a post-civil rights era phenomenon. Interestingly, several scholars argue that the carceral state's roots may also lie in the period Hester studies.Footnote 42 Tracing the ways that contemporary realities of the carceral state and the criminalization of immigrants grew from these tangled roots is a task that awaits further scholarship.
Juliet Stumpf opened the conversation with “The Crimmigration Crisis” in 2006. Stumpf pointed out that immigration and criminal law share the conceptual characteristic of regulating individuals’ relationship to the state (rather than to other individuals), and claiming the right to determine who should be excluded from the community, either by limits on entry, deportation, or imprisonment. Criminal convictions have played a key role in the dramatic increase in deportation, especially since the creation of the category of “aggravated felony” in 1988 and its expansion in 1996. Likewise, immigration violations have been increasingly criminalized, since unauthorized entry became a misdemeanor and entry after removal, a felony, in 1929. A common punitive model began to replace the rehabilitation model in both criminal and immigration law in the 1970s. In the twenty-first century, the Department of Homeland Security's various immigration enforcement arms have become the largest armed federal law enforcement body, and immigration prosecutions the largest category of federal criminal prosecutions. Along with this has come a growing popular association of immigrants with criminality.Footnote 43
Although most studies of the carceral state have neglected the issue of immigrant detention and deportation, a few recent works emphasize the connection. In the Journal of American History's 2015 special issue on mass incarceration, Hester's “Deportability and the Carceral State” shows that immigration offenses have come to outnumber drug offenses in the federal prison system, and together these two make up the majority of those incarcerated in federal prisons. Seventy-five percent of incarcerated immigrants are there on immigration violations: entry without inspection or entry after removal. The massive use of incarceration, as opposed to voluntary removal, dated to the carceral movement of the 1980s and ‘90s. So did the deportation of increasingly large numbers of immigrants convicted of post-entry infractions that rendered them deportable. As more people were incarcerated in state or county jails, the immigrants among them became liable for deportation upon release. Because mass incarceration most targeted the poor, undocumented immigrants tended to be overrepresented in the prison populations vulnerable to deportation.Footnote 44
The Obama administration publicly prioritized immigration enforcement priorities that focused on criminals, strengthening public perceptions of immigrant criminality, even though most of those deported had no criminal record. Almost all of those criminalized and deported were people of color—Mexicans—caught in “New Jim Crow” dragnets similar to those described by Alexander. Patrica Macías-Rojas's From Deportation to Prison is really the only study thus far that delves into the multiple ways that mass incarceration has intertwined the immigrant detention and deportation system with the criminal justice system in the post-1965 era.Footnote 45
The “carceral turn” in “U.S. popular and political culture” stood out in the 2016 election campaign.Footnote 46 And it had a clear race and class inflection. It was not the first time, although in Trump's case, it was aimed more against Mexican immigrants than African Americans or even the poor more generally. Richard Nixon, in 1968, and George H. W. Bush, in 1988, appealed directly to racialized fears of black crime to appeal to white voters who felt threatened by moves toward greater political and social rights for people of color, and by their claims to these rights.Footnote 47 Anti-colonial revolutions, whether in Vietnam, Watts, Attica, or Nicaragua, spurred politicians to appeal to white workers’ class anxieties on the basis of a racial, white settler colonial, unity. Reading Torrie Hester's Deportation in the context of works on settler colonialism and on the carceral state can help us make sense of the present in light of our country's past.
Federal immigration law both imposes the responsibility and provides the means for the Federal Government, in cooperation with border States, to secure the Nation's southern border. Although Federal immigration law provides a robust framework for Federal-State partnership in enforcing our immigration laws—and the Congress has authorized and provided appropriations to secure our borders—the Federal Government has failed to discharge this basic sovereign responsibility.
-Executive Order: “Border Security and Immigration Enforcement Improvements” January 25, 2017I recently spoke at a Milwaukee church, as part of its decision-making process about whether or not to become a sanctuary congregation. Also included on the program was the coordinator of the local New Sanctuary Movement, a component of Voces de la Frontera, an immigrant rights and workers’ center with branches throughout Wisconsin. During the question and answer period, one congregant asked about the process by which “illegal immigrants” might legalize their status. After my colleague responded, I wondered aloud about the asker's use of the word “illegal.”
“That's just what they're called,” the congregant breezily responded.
I gently pointed out that immigration laws do not inhere in the existence of a nation, but are, instead, created by the slow and contradictory process of policymaking. Undocumented entry—crossing a U.S. national border without papers that are themselves an invention of the federal government—became a crime in 1929, resulting, as Mae Ngai explains, in the existence of “impossible subjects”: undocumented immigrants, who often abide in great tension with regimes such as the one articulated in the executive order quoted above. Such regimes derive much of their legitimacy by conflating the presence of “illegal immigrants” with threats to what the current presidential administration deems “national security and public safety.”Footnote 48
If I had a pocket version of Deportation: The Origins of U.S. Policy for such occasions, along with a dime for each time they occur, I would be a wealthy and satisfied immigration historian, indeed. In this book, Torrie Hester assembles a powerful account of the development of deportation as an instrument of immigration enforcement. As she explains it, “between 1882 and 1924, Congress, the Supreme Court and the Bureau of Immigration pieced together the policy and legal regime in which all deportations from the United States have occurred ever since.”Footnote 49 Hester points out that deportations during these years collectively amounted to fewer than those carried out during any one year since 1970. But her detailed and exceedingly well-researched account of the origins of deportation during the early twentieth century illuminates much that is useful in our current moment.
This book is policy history at its finest. Detailing the rise of the deportation regime, Hester deploys archival research in a multiplicity of federal archives: the Departments of State and Labor, the Bureau of Immigration, district and Supreme courts and the Foreign Service. She traces the rise of deportation as a technology of national law enforcement and notes the ways that federal officials interacted with foreign governments to deport and relocate deportees. While I was previously familiar with the broad trajectory of Hester's story, I learned a lot about the historical development and implications of law and policy from reading it.
What emerges in this book is not only a study of deportation, but an account of its implications for the development of federal power. As both Erika Lee and Anna Pegler-Gordon detail, the ascendance of immigration enforcement during the Progressive Era entailed federal investment in a vast bureaucracy for the surveillance and regulation of the foreign born.Footnote 50 Hester traces the development and implications of the plenary power legal doctrine, which holds that immigration law inheres in national sovereignty; noncitizen immigrants lack full access to the provisions of the Bill of Rights. The enduring significance of this emphasis resounds in the prose of the executive order quoted above.
Though she never cites Foucault, and in fact, abjures any and all discussion at the level of theory, Hester is in Foucauldian territory here. The central narrative of this book concerns the ways a deportation regime gained traction and power during the early twentieth century, becoming so normalized that an assertion such as the one above, of the presence of a “robust framework for a Federal-State partnership,” while almost entirely untrue, can present itself as legitimate. The use of the plenary power doctrine to create a system of immigration enforcement resembles precisely the transformation described in Discipline and Punish: “the most brilliant figure of sovereign power is joined to the emergence of rituals proper to disciplinary power.”Footnote 51
The strongest contributions here also carry a strong tincture of Foucault. Hester analyzes the jurisprudence that developed, starting with Fong Yue Ting v. United States (1893): because deportation was an aspect of national sovereignty, it did not constitute punishment for individuals, who therefore had limited rights and recourse. As immigration enforcement evolved, it created what Foucault would call a “disciplinary regime” that distinguished citizens from immigrants and lawful from unlawful entries, as well as categories of exclusion, such as prostitution, political radicalism, and likelihood of becoming a public charge (LPC). Ultimately, Hester argues, the deportation regime created the status of temporary worker through contract laborer and guest worker provisions. Then, as now, temporary workers possess far fewer rights than citizens or legal permanent residents, and thus are far more easily deported.
As the deportation regime elaborated categories of exclusion, Hester documents the ways that lawful immigrant became subject to what Daniel Kanstroom calls “post-entry social control”: time limits on deportation expanded to allow the removal of immigrants who had crossed lawfully into the nation, years after their arrival, for actions committed while on U.S. soil.Footnote 52 An exemplary chapter traces the ways that moral panic over a putative international “white slave trade” enhanced federal police power by expanding the grounds for deportation. The anti-white slavery regime established an enduring foothold in immigration enforcement, as Hester notes: “expansions in the anticrime mandate outlasted the humanitarian intent of the antiprostitution provision.”Footnote 53 Language from the 2017 executive order connecting unlawful entry to the operation of “transnational criminal organizations” could well have been lifted from the anti-trafficking campaigns of the early twentieth century.
The tendency of both Foucauldian and policy history scholarship to elide the significance of grassroots resistance is evident in this book. Because Hester is primarily concerned with the evolution of deportation law and policy, she tends to ignore the significance of social movements. She cites, for example, the extraordinary statistic of the 110,000 Chinese immigrants who refused to comply with the Geary Act and register their presence in the United States. But she is more interested in how the federal government exacted compliance than in the transnational complexities of how a fairly recently arrived cohort of immigrants staged this act of collective civil disobedience.Footnote 54 Grassroots movements for immigrant rights are a part of the story of policy formation. In the research for my book, Against the Deportation Terror: Organizing for Immigrant Rights in the Twentieth Century, I found that civil and immigrant rights activists both responded to and influenced immigration policy in the mid-twentieth century. Recent work on transnational immigrant radicalism by Seema Sohi and Christina Heatherton attests to the dialectical relationship between immigration policy and social movements, as well as the significance of immigrant transnational connections.Footnote 55
That Hester avoids engaging in theoretical discussion about questions of power and resistance is not a problem with this book; her analytical work is powerful on its merits. However, framing this book more broadly as a discussion of Progressive Era power and policy would facilitate important comparative conversations. Foucault points out that the ability to police and to incarcerate is central to the emergence of modern, disciplinary regimes.Footnote 56 The deportation regime that Hester documents so well in this book emerged at roughly the same time that, as Dennis Childs and Mary Farmer-Kaiser explain, vagrancy laws were deployed to create a regime of segregation and incarceration in the post-Reconstruction South.Footnote 57 Hester argues that the deportation regime produced police power; at the same time, similar federal regimes levied police power against non-foreign-born African Americans, American Indians, working people, and political dissidents. In her recent history of incarceration in Los Angeles, Kelly Lytle Hernández connects Indian removal, immigration enforcement, and African American displacement.Footnote 58 Such parallels point to some broad considerations for the fields of immigration history and migration studies.
Why not expand our framework, so that we consider foreign-born immigrants along with migrants, vagrants, fugitives, and other people compelled to move? Jasmine Nichole Cobb's compelling description of pre-emancipation African American fugitivity echoes the displacement created by the deportation regime: “Fugitivity meant trying to claim a cohesive Atlantic world as home when persons of African descent could not properly claim the nation and the nation did not properly claim fugitives.”Footnote 59
At this writing, the approximately eleven to twelve million undocumented people in the United States face an enhanced deportation regime that levies national security and a politicized discourse around “criminal aliens” against them, destroying communities and violating the public trust. But they do not face this alone. The same regime threatens the life-saving mobility of legal immigrants and refugees, enhances the violent power of law enforcement against aggrieved communities and protesters, undermines Indigenous sovereignty, seeks to deprive millions of people of basic health care coverage, and overturns hard-won LGBTQ legal protections, to name only a few of the initiatives perpetrated in the long months since the inauguration. To comprehend the ways that these threats are and have been entwined, we need to summon vagrant and comparative historical imaginations.
It is odd that the history of deportation is still largely confined to the nation-state. Deportation, after all, works in tandem with international law to guide the actions of nation-states to forcibly remove unwanted aliens from the body politic. Today, in democratic, liberal societies such as the United States, deportation is wielded as a bureaucratic-administrative tool to control immigration in the fulfillment of a vision of national membership. It acts, in the words of political scientist William Walters, as a “technology of citizenship that allocates [people] to their proper sovereigns”Footnote 60 But in the recent past, deportation in the United States has not worked in such stark ways. American deportation law contains considerable prosecutorial discretion allowing the government wide latitude in choosing or not choosing whom to expel from a vast array of possible violations. In near-reversal from policies in his first term as president, Barack Obama, in his second term and under political pressure from immigrant rights activists, based most deportation decisions or non-decisions on a recognition of the lived, transnational identities of immigrants.
Circumstances, though, have changed. Under the current presidential administration of Donald Trump, U.S. immigration policy is keeping company with its more restrictive trappings by vastly expanding the definition of “criminal aliens” and disregarding the international geopolitical terrain that acts to restrain nativist efforts. By eliminating much of Obama's immigration safety net, Trump has effectively placed most of the eleven to twelve million undocumented persons currently living in the United States on the verge of deportation, including those under temporary protective status. Take the recent case of Juan Manuel Montes Borórquez, the first DACA (Deferred Action of Childhood Arrivals) recipient to be deported by the Trump administration. Montes, who was among 750,000 undocumented immigrants granted DACA status under Obama's executive order in 2014, lived most of his twenty-three years in the United States until his arrest by a border patrol agent in early 2017. Within three hours of his apprehension, Montes, ostensibly protected under DACA until 2018, was deported to Mexico, his place of birth.Footnote 61 What of Montes's fate and the fate of many thousands of immigrants before him who were deported and remain banished from a nation they consider home? Do deportees like Montes have legal recourse in international courts of law to remedy removal? What of the role of the receiving government (Mexico, in this case) in protecting or advocating for those nationals who were deported from the United States? These are questions of history just as much as they are questions about geopolitics in the present day.
It is from this vantage of “what is past is prologue” that historians of immigration could bridge the conceptual chasm between cases like that of Juan Manuel Montes Borórquez and the many turn-of-the-twentieth-century immigrants who also confronted the weight of the American deportation regime. Their commonality, however, is not merely that they were forcibly removed from the United States, but rather they helped to make legible the fraught nature of state power to expel unwanted subjects. To be certain, deportation produced expelled and illegal bodies, but its discretionary authority also created a host of incongruities: victimization and protection; citizenship and statelessness; rightlessness and humanitarian flexibility; and precarity and predictability. Much of the best scholarship delves deeply into these paradoxes without losing track of the power of deportation to control the past, present, and future actions of others. The extraordinary edited volume of Nicholas De Genova and Nathalie Peutz, The Deportation Regime: Sovereignty, Space, and the Freedom of Movement is instructive here.Footnote 62 Deportation, they argued, produced the concept of “deportability,” a mode of constant fear that is instilled in immigrants given the strong likelihood of expulsion. Among many other salient points, De Genova and Peutz implicate deportation as a global-wide technique of human management that rationalizes state action to protect national borders over protecting the rights of noncitizens.
The latest contribution to the historical literature on the American deportation regime by Torrie Hester takes us to these important inflection points. Deportation: The Origins of U.S. Policy is a well-researched and carefully argued study of the formative decades of the American deportation regime.Footnote 63 To extend deportation beyond the nation, as Hester shows, foregrounds several dimensions of global immigration control that until recently have been unexplored by historians, including the treatment of American deportees brokered through diplomatic channels with European and Latin American countries.Footnote 64 This, I believe, is the most significant contribution Deportation makes to the study of American immigration because it compels scholars to think somewhat in reverse, which is from the vantage of America's expelled subjects and from the vantage of an oft-unequal geopolitical landscape. After 1925, for instance, the United States managed its deportees from Mexico through bilateral agreements except when it came to those deportees who were “ineligible for [American] citizenship”—a shorthand for Asian immigrants. Deported Americans from Mexico enjoyed U.S. protection even as they were removed from a nation where they had preferred to live.Footnote 65 In sharp relief, Mexicans deported from the United States did not experience a soft landing in their country of emigration. In 1931, for example, the United States unilaterally deported between five hundred thousand and one million Mexican-descent people to Mexico, several thousand of whom were naturalized and birthright American citizens.Footnote 66 Despite direct appeals to U.S. Consular agents in Mexico, deported Mexican Americans were left mostly to their own resources in reconfiguring their lives in a country that was not their own.
Deportation's budding cosmopolitanism, as Hester shows, was equally implicated in the racialization and immoralization of immigrants. The response to the international white slavery scare at the start of the twentieth century brought moral reform closer to immigration control by deporting suspected immigrant prostitutes and procurers for post-entry infractions. But deportation, alone, was not enough: moral reformers and immigration officials advocated for the imprisonment of prostitutes before deportation. After 1907, imprisonment or detention preceded the deportation of prostitutes. Take, for example, Hester's opening vignette of Ellen Costello in Chapter 4, “From Protection to Punishment.” Costello, a circus performer and erstwhile burlesque dancer, plied her trades across Canada and North America from the early age of seventeen to the age of thirty-one, when she was ordered deported from New York City on the charge of prostitution in 1915. Costello though was not immediately expelled, as this may have been the kinder recourse for the Dutch native. She was instead briefly imprisoned at New York City's notorious Blackwell Island and then deported to Holland, her country of emigration. As Hester correctly points out, Costello's case was not exceptional in terms of frequency and severity nor was imprisonment followed by immediate deportation the only course of action taken by reformers and immigration officials. At the turn of the twentieth century, when the United States passed its first set of restrictionist immigration laws aimed at deporting prostitutes, to the outbreak of World War I, prostitution was the second-largest deportable category followed by the Likely to Become a Public Charge (LPC) provision.Footnote 67 This fact, uncovered by Hester, is no small observation. If one also remembers historian Deidre Moloney's contention that the LPC charge served as a proxy to deport prostitutes because poverty charges were far easier to prove than an act of sex for money, it is clear that the early practice of deportation was a deeply sexualized and class-inflected one.Footnote 68 This may come as a surprise to scholars of immigration who have done much to show that an expressed racial agenda underlies the history of U.S. deportation.
In somewhat of a qualification, Hester contends that policy makers hoped to use the anti-prostitution provision not as a punishment for being poor or for exchanging sex for money or both, but rather as a form of humanitarian intervention to care for women after their deportation. Policy makers, it seemed, envisioned returning “victimized” white slaves to a type of rehabilitative safety net wherein, according to Hester, they would be met by “family, friends, and [religious] and women's organizations” aiding in the reform process.Footnote 69 Although Hester is silent about both the effectiveness and pervasiveness of this humanitarian project and not expansive in terms of the actual locations of reform homes or institutions, it is clear that the common bond among state makers and humanitarians (usually white, middle-class women) was to suppress sexual commerce and clarify what it meant to be a morally suitable immigrant deserving of citizenship in the United States.
It may be that scholars follow Hester's lead to begin rendering a transnational history of immigration control. In area of immigration studies, this would turn the conceptual tables somewhat. Over the last decade or so, critical legal scholars and immigration anthropologists and sociologists have mapped the manner in which modern-day deportation produced myriad nodes of interaction and possibilities of re-immigration even after expulsion.Footnote 70 Historians, though, have yet to explore these dynamics for the past. Again, Hester's work is instructive in that Deportation lays out, among several rich discursive points, the early relationship between deportation and the complex international systems of nation-states to expel and absorb returnees into the body politic. Might it be time to turn to the tools of spatial history or the digital humanities to map the physical and social spaces of deportation? I raise this because Hester's work on American deportees and the geopolitics of their forced return to the United States has largely gone unquestioned by historians. In other words, historians have yet to turn their gaze outwardly to the returns, reintegration, and re-immigration of deportees as Hester has begun to do.
This possible instance of the spatial turn in history may be worthwhile pursuing for scholars interested in the relationship between points of emigration, entry points, immigrant detainment, immigrant return, and the carceral spaces in between.Footnote 71 In mulling over ideas to map the geospatial movements of im/migration, I am reminded of Richard White's Railroaded: The Transcontinentals and the Making of Modern America. Under the auspices of The Spatial History Project at Stanford University, White created a new lens from which to view California's railroad industry as a landscape of commerce. To compete with shipping lines, railroad barons charged less to transport grain to the port of San Francisco, thereby effectively bringing faraway towns such as Delano and Tulare closer to the city. On the other side of the ledger, railroad barons recouped costs of shipping grain inexpensively by quadrupling the fees to transport manufactured goods from the same towns. In effect, low freight rates contracted space for wheat farmers while much higher shipping costs expanded space for producers of manufactured goods.Footnote 72
Returning to deportation, a new spatial history of im/migration may be influenced by White's mapping schema on the metalevel to foreground specific nodes that mediated movements and migrations. How might a spatiotemporal mapping of successful, stalled, significantly delayed, or altogether impeded entry shift scholars’ understanding of immigration itself? How would our built-in assumptions about deportation change if we chart its spatial messiness through network visualization methods? What may transpire from such an undertaking is unknown at this point, but if we take White's illuminating patterns for California railscapes and commerce as influential starting points, then historians may be on the way to map the geoscapes of entry, deportation, immigration detention, and re-immigration. Immigration files from various nations, local police documents, court depositions, personal letters, collections from women's reform homes, as well as a host of new methodological approaches (e.g., network mapping, Geographic Information Systems; 3D virtual reality models) may capture the nonlinear arrangements and the multigeographies of immigration control that Hester points to in Deportation. New spatial and discursive geographies of mobility/immobility may fundamentally shift our gaze about the nature of expulsion, and our questions thereof.
All good books raise new questions and Hester's Deportation is certainly in this category. In effect, Hester's outward historical lens on deportation draws into relief some of the precursors to the modern-day practices to expel and exclude. Clearly, though we know far too little about the lineages of criminalization of immigration if Chinese immigrants, the poor, and prostitutes spent significant time in prison before deportation. We know not enough about these early carceral spaces and the consequences they faced, if any, upon return. What of the rights of stateless subjects who did not have the privilege of powerful, watchful allies? Were rights, as Hester begs us to ask, solely the rights of the citizen and not those of the political refugee, the banished prostitute, or the deported Chinese laborer? Deportees, plainly stated, must go somewhere else and these outer places are frequently troubled spaces, and not always “from whence they came.” It may be that historians of immigration take as a starting point—following Hester—an earlier moment in the administrative development of expulsion where granular-level relationships help to make more visible the halting and uncoordinated steps to impede the freedom of movement. Ultimately, though, scholars must find ways to explain the commonalities between deportees such as Juan Manuel Montes Borórquez and Ellen Costello, two individuals who rejected the exclusionary nature of American citizenship and in whose names deportations were carried out. Hester's Deportation begins to do this work by orienting historians to a fresh and open-ended reading of expulsion and exclusion's past.
Many thanks to the Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era for organizing this roundtable on Deportation: Origins of U.S. Policy. I am exceedingly grateful to Emily Pope-Obeda, Hidetaka Hirota, Rachel Ida Buff, Grace Peña Delgado, and Aviva Chomsky for their thoughtful reviews. My response is organized thematically. I first engage with commentators’ remarks about sources. Discussions of race, methods and comparative approaches, diplomacy and bilateralism follow. Since the roundtable's primary purpose is to further the study of deportations, I have focused my discussion toward that end. It is a great honor to be part of this conversation; its timeliness is underscored by the fact that as I wrote my response, President Trump has ended DACA.
In order to give the reader a sense of the evidence available for researchers, I will first provide a short summary of sources used in Deportation. When I began my research so many years ago at the University of Oregon, it became clear that a paucity of sources was not going to be one of the challenges of the project. Take, for example, the paper trail that deportations left diplomatically. At one point during my first trip to the National Archives, a very helpful archivist took me into the stacks so I could see the immense size of relevant records from U.S. diplomatic and consular posts in Record Group (RG) 84. The files and consular records located in the Central Files in RG 59, which includes communiques, internal memorandums, and reports, turned out to be the most valuable of my diplomatic sources. Within these U.S. State Department records are paper trails leading to the national archives of other countries. Backing these diplomatic sources are the tens of thousands of pages from the Bureau of Immigration records, the federal courts, and the Congressional Record.
My book does not draw heavily on local and regional sources and one important consequence, as Pope-Obeda notes, is that it does provide insight into the sustained impact of deportation policy “across immigrant communities.” A growing body of historical research is focusing on just this, primarily for the years after 1924 when the government deported tens and then hundreds of thousands of people annually. Anthropologists, sociologists, and scholars of education are publishing widely on the contemporary context. For example, an outstanding newly published book is Roberto G. Gonzales's Lives in Limbo: Undocumented and Coming of Age in America, which is a longitudinal study of undocumented young people over the past twelve years.Footnote 73 Fewer scholars consider the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. Historians of Chinese exclusion like Erika Lee examine the deleterious effects of violent and aggressive enforcement of deportation policy on Chinese American communities. Grace Peña Delgado's award-winning article, “Border Control and Sexual Policing: White Slavery and Prostitution along the U.S.-Mexico Borderlands, 1903–1910?,” Kelly Lytle Hernández's Migra!: A History of the U.S. Border Patrol, and Natalia Molina's How Race is Made in America: Immigration, Citizenship, and the Historical Power of Racial Scripts are recent studies that provide insight into the impact of deportations on Mexican and Mexican American communities.Footnote 74 Pope-Obeda looks at the wider national impact in her forthcoming monograph. For information on the state policies that predated federal policy, Hirota's work is important.Footnote 75 The limits of my focus on the federal government became particularly clear when writing Chapter 4. In some ways this is one of my favorite chapters, because it tracks a critical expansion of federal jurisdiction into post-entry infractions and introduces the concept of a victim's rights program. My sources, though, did not provide insight into the regional impact of anti-prostitution policy. Consequently, as Peña Delgado observes, I could not make an argument “about both the effectiveness and pervasiveness of this humanitarian project.” Case files and other sources on local enforcement would fill out this picture. More investigation into regional enforcement would answer Hirota's call for more investigation of “how the two tracks of federal immigration control overlapped at the site of law enforcement.”
Another important source for researchers, as Rachel Buff notes, is the records of social movements. Buff knows from her own research that “civil and immigrant rights activists both responded to and influenced immigration policy in the mid-twentieth century.” Deportation’s coverage of social mobilizing primarily concentrates on when people made claims in the courts—in Fong Yue Ting, the 1893 case where the Chinese immigrant community tested the constitutionality of deportation, and In re Rhagat Singh, a 1913 lower court case where South Asians challenged their deportations, for example.Footnote 76 This means, as I think Buff rightly states, that my book, like other “Foucauldian and policy history scholarship,” does not tend to provide deep insight into the “significance of grassroots resistance.” Thinking through the implications of Buff's criticism made me reflect on the case of Marcus Garvey. Garvey is covered in my conclusion when I discuss the significance of post-entry infractions to the exportation of U.S. law abroad. Garvey's case could also be mined for insight into social movements. Not as a success story—the United Negro Improvement Association (UNIA) did not influence immigration policy to protect immigrants. Rather, following his case from this angle would tell us something about the difficulties social movements encountered when trying to influence policy and the ways that deportations have been used to undermine the social movements. Despite years of searching, I was unable to find Marcus Garvey's deportation case file. NARA archivists tried to help me track it down; it is listed in the finding aids in Record Group 85. One archivist thought that perhaps it had been removed to a central vault due to the significance of his case. It was not there. Future research will no doubt turn up this file; perhaps a researcher already has it. The transcripts and supporting documents could reveal a great deal about deportations and social movements.
The reviews contain an important discussion about race and U.S. deportation policy. Chomsky urges scholars in the future to use settler colonialism as a frame for deepening our understanding of the role immigration policy has played in white supremacy. I was struck by her thought that contemporary deportations “could be seen as a logical unfolding of Indian removal policies, especially given the preponderance of Indigenous people among those being deported today.” This is both a point that furthers an argument made by Daniel Kanstoom in Deportation Nation, and helps illustrate the changing, but continual process of racialization in U.S. history.Footnote 77 I do not use settler colonialism in Deportation, but I worked hard to analyze race and understand the racial impacts of deportation policy. A point raised by Peña Delgado in reference to my fourth chapter helped me rethink through how I explained the significance of race to the expansion of deportation into a form of post-entry social control. Peña Delgado writes that while Chapter 4 shows that the anti-prostitution provision was “equally implicated in the racialization and im-moralization of immigrants,” “in somewhat of a qualification” it argues that the anti-prostitution provision was seen as “a form of humanitarian intervention.” I did not intend this as a qualification. I wanted to show that they were part of the same process. Moving information from my conclusion into the text might have helped make this clearer. Near the end of my work I reference Angela Banks's “The Normative and Historical Cases for Proportional Deportation,” which documents difficulties Congress had in creating post-entry infractions under criminal status provisions before 1917. Divisions over whether or not deportations for offenses committed on U.S. soil represented a punishment was one of the most significant blocks to congressional efforts to create post-entry infractions.Footnote 78 In Chapter 4, I argue that Congress overcame its reluctance to deport for actions taken on U.S. soil because they framed the issue as a progressive program to protect white women. Once the government had the power to deport one group for post-entry infractions, lawmakers used it as a precedent to create broader criminal sanctions in 1917. Further discussion of congressional disagreement over creating post-entry social controls more might have highlighted the role discourses about protecting whiteness played in creating a new jurisdiction over immigrants in my book even more.
With an eye to contextualizing and bringing out power dynamics in future work, Buff and Peña Delgado call for comparative works of coercive regimes. The scholarship on coercive legal regimes is reaching a critical mass. To name just a few, in addition to the work already referenced, are Risa Goluboff's Vagrant Nation: Police Power, Constitutional Change, and the Making of the 1960s and Peggy Pascoe's What Comes Naturally: Miscegenation Law and the Making of Race in America examines miscegenation law. There is also a flourishing field on the carceral state.Footnote 79 Since these works have done much of the heavy lifting of understanding each regime, future studies can more easily take up comparisons and the ways the regimes worked together. The relatively new field of crimmigation is currently doing just this, examining the connections between the criminal justice and immigration system. The state of digital humanities, Peña Delgado suggests, is similarly opportune for expanding our knowledge of deportation and the intersections of multiple coercive regimes. Peña Delgado lists Richard White's digital humanities project to serve as a model for future scholarship. Three others quickly come to mind. Digital Harlem: Everyday Life 1915–1930 uses GIS and overlays newspapers, probation records, and district arrest records. Million Dollar Hoods is a tool that “maps how much the Los Angeles Sheriff's Department and the Los Angeles Police Department spent on incarceration between 2010 and 2015.” An even larger project, one that is transnational, is The Digital Panopticon: The Global Impact of London Punishments, 1780–1925. This enormous project includes “genealogical, biometric and criminal justice datasets held by different organizations in the UK and Australia” and explores “the impact of different types of punishments on the lives of 90,000 people sentenced at the Old Bailey between 1780 and 1875.”Footnote 80 Using with new tools of digital mapping, textual analysis, and network analysis will enable historians to uncover layers of data, often hidden between coercive legal regimes, and can lead us to new questions. This is an exciting opportunity, which will significantly further our historical understanding of governmental power, legal rights, race, class, sexuality and gender, as well as social movements.
It is gratifying that the reviewers praise my work on the international side of deportations. Examining the diplomacy and bilateral nature of deportations is relatively recent and much remains to be undertaken.Footnote 81 The reviews are extremely insightful, especially, I think their suggestions for two directions for future work. First, Hirota writes, “research may explore, among other themes, the relationship between the (plenary power) doctrine and the international legal regime that made deportation proceedings bilateral.” One direction that interests me is the degree to which trade and labor migration factor into the international nature of deportations. In 2017, for instance, the U.S. federal government ensured countries accept deportees by attaching strings to visas—countries must approve deportations if they also want employment visas for their citizens. At what point, then, does the bilateral process lose much of its meaning? Cindy Hahamovitch's award-winning No Man's Land: Jamaican Guestworkers in America and the Global History of Deportable Labor takes up this question, to some degree implicitly.Footnote 82 She studies the bilateralism of creating guest worker programs; she does not track bilateralism in immigrant removals. A second direction for future study raised in the reviews is, as Peña Delgado writes, to further our understanding of deportations from “the vantage of America's expelled subjects.” Where Deportation focuses mainly on initial deportee reception, a number of projects just out or in the pipeline are tracking the longer-term reintegration of deportees. Hirota's Expelling the Poor looks at the lives of people in Ireland and the United Kingdom in the nineteenth century, after their expulsion from Massachusetts and New York. Adam Goodman is researching people's experiences in Mexico following deportations. Daniel Kanstroom's book Aftermath: Deportation Law and the New American Diaspora studies people returned to countries like Guatemala, Cambodia, and Haiti.Footnote 83 I expect to see a future project that examines deportees in China during the Chinese exclusion era. Using digital mapping and visualization tools, as Peña Degado also notes, can enhance our knowledge of the international history even more.
In one final note, it is an honor to have Deportation serve as a starting point in this roundtable's reflection on the state of the field. The observations make clear that deportation will continue to be a significant topic of study, for the GAPE and beyond, for the foreseeable future.
